Fenton v. United States Of America, No. 7:2012cv00106 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 06/26/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
eLER> OFFI 0. . sm O URT CE s Df ATR- ou l VA FI LED JUN 26 2 1 92 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A J C, DLEK Qt ? , C U NI TED STA TES O F A M ER I A , C CA SE N O . 07 R 00025 5: C VS. PERCW AL NORM AN FENTON Dee f ndant . PER CI A L NO RM AN FEN TO N , V CA SE N O .7: 2C V 00106 1 Pe ii r, ttone VS . M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N N O U NI TED STA TES O F A M ER I A, C By: G l n E.C onr e ad Chi Unied St es Di tri Judge ef t at s ct R espondent. Pe c va N or a Fe on ha fl d a pr K lte t tt c tc t e a a m o i n r i l m n nt s ie o e tr ha he our ons nz s s to as ngt c t o r vi a c r e tt or rofr siuton e e e agans hi i a c danc ki he our t e ew nd o r c he de e tt i nt r d i t m n c or e wih hi pla a r e e .Thec tc ude t tFe on' moton t r consde t or rof t s e g e m nt our oncl s ha nt s i o e i r he de r tt i m us bedenid. esiuton t e Th ci n l u g n ,n ld n t ersiuino d rdr cigta F no p y $ 00 0 e rmia j d me t icu i g h e t t r e ie tn h t e t n a 40 ,0 t o i r tt i t t vi tm sofhi c i es w a e e ed o Se e be 1 2007. Fe on di no n es iuton o he c i s rm , s nt r n pt m r 3, nt d t a p a tej d me t F ntnn w sae ta i 2 1 atrt c u t a d ne hi iiil to p e l h u g n . e o o tts h t n 01 , fe he o r h d e id s nta mo in t va t sta i orco rc t s ntnceunde 28U. C.j2255,hedico e ceti e s o cae, e sde re t he e e r S. s verd ran nor i t gove n e ' m e hod ofc l ul tng t a ountofl s e c vi tm s f r d and i n he r m nt s t a c a i he m os a h c i uf e e n det ni t am ountofres iuton Fent w asr r t pay. Fent ass t t hi ti enni ng he tt i on equied o on ers hat s r al RK c ouns lga hi bad a c a e ve m dvi e boutac e i t plaag e me ,i udi t r tt i or r c ptng he e r e nt ncl ng he esiuton de , a t tt c ts dnow rviw t ode ofr tt i t r1 U. C.jj3651,3 4, nd ha he our houl e e he r r esiuton mde 8 S. 66 and 37 2) an c rc t er r . 424 , d ore t he ro s A sn e c t a i o e a o d ro rsi to i atn lu g n .S e 1 U. C. e tn e h t mp s s n r e f ett in s q a j d me t e 8 S. u j366 ( Thesamor pr sonst tFe onct a es t pr dur f s hmatr as 4(9. tt y ovii ha nt ies ddr s he oce es or uc tes p e ai a da j t a o d ro rsiuinb fr sn e cn ,o c n igt s h d ef r r p rng n dusi n r e f ettto e oe e tn i g fr ha gn he c e ul o ng pa e oft r s i i orf c le ng s h a or ron di e ta a t t Cour of ym nt he e tt on, or ha l ngi uc n de m r c ppe l o he t Appe s 1N oneoft ciedpr viinsa horz t d src c tt r storr s t al. he t o so ut ies he itit our o evii evie he j d me to t eo d rof ettto s ma yy a sa tri o i o .Th r f r,ot ee tn t a u g n r h r e r si in o n e r fe mp st n ee o e t h x e t h t u i Fe o s ks die tr vi w by t scou toft or r o r tt i hi m oton f r c i r to nt n ee rc e e hi r he de f es iuton, s i or e onsde a i n i de e .2 s ni d Som e ofFe on' c r n a l ga i m i gi r s t cl i snor a l a tona e i a nt s ur e t le tons ght ve i e o a m m ly c i bl n j2255moi s hascli ofi fci a ssa eofco e rgadi t g lyplaor ton, uc ams nefe tve s itnc unsl e r ng he uit e sntncngmatr.Be aus Fe onha ar dyfldaj2 moi howe r hemus a y e e i tes c e nt s lea ie 255 ton, ve , t ppl f c tfc ton fom t Unie Stt Co tofAppe sf rt Fo t Cic tbef r flng a or erii a i r he td aes ur al o he urh r ui o e ii sco o s e svej2255moton.Seej2255(9.Fe ondoesnotpr enta s h e nd r ucc s i i 1 nt es ny uc c rii a i wih hi c r nts e ttc ton t s ur e ubmison. The ef e, hec t l no c tuet ss si r or t our wil t onsr hi ubmi son si a aj225 moton. s 5 i 1 Thec ur no e t a ones on Fe on cies 1 U. C. 3651 wa r p ae i 1 4. edi nt t , 8 S. 9 o t ts h t , s e e ld n 98 Onteohe h nd,h c u teai c ni i jrs cint modiyar tmto or rb sd h t r a te o r rt ns o tnung uidito o f esi in de ae on changed cicum s a r t ncesoft def he endant Unied St esv.M cM ahon,225 F. 656,2000 W L . t at 3d 1 9 ,a * ( t Ci. 0 ( rc ra t pu ihe tbl d cso .Thus i adee a te e in e 03 473 t 3 4h r 20 0)pe u imlun bls d a e e iin) ,f fnd n xp re c s cha nged fnanci cic t i al r umsances pettonermay s k m odiiaton ast t am ountofhi m ont y , ii ee fc i o he s hl pa nts u no s mer d to i t et tla un ofter siu i o d.1 U. C.j3 4( ;se yme s b t t o e ucin n h oa mo t h e ttton we 8 S. 66 k) e as M c a n, 000W L 1 9 3, t* (ie .Si eFe t smoto s e sardu tono lo M ho 2 03 47 a 3. ct) nc non' in e k e c i r r c a i oft amountoft r tt i t moton i untmel and mus be deni 1 U S. j ecalulton he he esiuton, he i s i y t ed. 8 C. 36 (9( ) 64 c 1. . 2 Fen on pr e e smia l lc am si hi r ce pe ii f rawrtofco a nobi , t es nt d i lr ega l i n s e nt tton o i rm s whi h t c t ni d by opi o a o de e e e A prl30,201 The cou Z s co ûue c he our de e ni n nd r r nt r d i 2. h o ns d a de e t tpeiin a as e svej2255moi nd nid ha tto s ucc si ton.Ot rt nc a nobi a j2255 t he ha orm s nd ,he c u tsn t waeo a yme h n s b whc Fe tnma s e u iil o r cin o t e o r i o a r f n c a im y ih n o y e kj d ca c re to f h j d me to t er si to o d ra t i t , a e o hi alg to o s b tn ielg ler r u g n r h e tt in r e t hs i b s d n s le ains f u sa tv e a ro s u me i c a tng t o de ofr s it o The e o e t c r c t ue Fe on' c r ntm oton a n r f i he r r e ttdi n. r f r , he ou t ons r s nt s ur e i s s e ng r co i r ton oft A prl30,201 di m i s lor r Be us Fe o f l t e ki e nsde a i he i 2 s s a de . ca e nt n ais o de onsr t a gr m ta e ny ound on whih t cour' r lng o Aprl30 s d bea tr ora nde c he ts u i n i houl le ed me d, howe r hi moton m us bede ed.An a oprat or rwile e t sda ve , s i t ni ppr i e de l ntr hi y. The Clr i diecedt s nd c esoft sme or ndum opi on a ac ompanyi e k s r t o e opi hi m a ni nd c ng or rt Pe ci lNor a Fe on a t couns lofr c d f t Unie St t s de o r va m n nt nd o e e or or he t d a e . ENTER:Th s 7$a d yo J n , 201 i a f u e 2. k ChifUnied St esDititJ e t at src udge 3