-RSB Wadley v. Zych, No. 7:2012cv00105 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 4/30/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CL ERK8 OFFI U. ,31 fokurt C: $ ! $ . p t ATROANOO , VA FIED L L #P 32 2 1 q 22 F RTEU IEETDE RSRC IGRA I TH WET SAIS ITO TC U T O H ENTDR T T C IVR II N S N SD F O N J I C. $ ' , ER ULA DU% CL K BY: l s jrp( , c g g j ROANOK E DIVI O N SI LODISE W ADLEY, Pe ii ttoner, VS. C.ZYCH ,W ARDEN, Res pondent . ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) CASE N O.7: 12CV00105 M EM ORANDUM OPI ON NI By:Jame C.Tur s k Se o Unie St t sDit itJudge nir td a e s rc Lodie W adly,af r i a epr s e ede al nm t oceedi pr K ,fl t spetton f awrtofhabeascor , ng o ied hi ii or i pus pu s ntt 28U. C.j2 41 c l gi t ma e i whiht Fe r lBura o Prs ns($ ' i rua o S. 2 , hal ng he nn r n c he dea e u f io ç en BOP' s ) colec i m one t l tng y owar s ts ac i ofhi c i i monetr penali . Fort r as sat t court d a if ton s rm nal ay tes he e ons t ed, he s marl dimi est pe ii um iy s ss he tton. W adl wasconvit i t Unied St t D iti Cour f t Easer Diti ofPe yl a ey c ed n he t a es srct t or he t n srct nns vani on dr t a fcki , pos essng afr m and body annorasaconvit f on,and r at cha ges1 see ug r f i ng s i iear c ed el el ed r . Unie Sae v. a e Ca eNo. 0 td tts W dly, s 2:3CR00 49 M AM- ( D. . a 27 2 5) TheCo t e tnc d 2 1 E. Pa J n. , 00 . ur s n e e W a e t att l em of622monhsi io n a d i os da$ 00Gn a d s ca a s sme t dly o o a tr t mprs nme t n mp e 20 e n pe il s e s n s ttlng$ 0. Th u me tore sae ta Wa e sci n lmoneaype alisweed ea a oai 70 2 ej dg n d r ttd h t dly' rmia tr n te r u s 1 Becaus W adl i c r l i cer ed att Unied St esPenie i y LeeCount i e ey s urenty ncar at he t at t ntar yn J ne vle Vigii, hi c r ha j rs c i o rhi c tdina rqur df rrviw o aj22 1 o s il, r na t s ou t s u iditon ve s uso a s e ie o e e f 4 peion.Se l r J ne ,2 F. 3 3 ( t Ci. 00 ) tti e n e o s 26 3d 28, 32 4h r 2 0 . 2 A f d r lc u t yt k j iiln tc o fcu lif mainl ae i p tng o e e a o r ma a e udca o ie f a ta n or to oc t d n osi s n gover ent webst i t Unied St es. Se I Re Kati CanalBr nm al ies n he t at e n rna eachesCons .Lii ,533 F. ol tg. Su 2d61 ,6 - 3 & n 1 1 ( D. 200 (ol ci c s sidiai t a f d r c rsma pp. 5 313 n. 4- 5 E. La. 8) c l tng a e n c tng h t e eal ou t y e tkej iiln tc ofgo m me a we ie,icl igc r rc r l W ila v. ng 5 F.S pp. a udca o ie ve ntl bsts n udn ou t e o ds; lims Lo , 85 u 2d67 ,68 - & n. ( M d. 08 (ole tn c s sidia i t tposigso go r me we ie 9 6 88 4 D. 20 ) c lc ig a e n c tng ha tn n vv n nt bsts a ei e e l a t e tco s l- uhe tc tng . r nh rnty u h n i r efa t n iai ) çgq s m pa me tof$2, 0 d ei ditl . . ( 41Pe. t1 l p. ) Th s e vs drla e çlump u y n 70 u mme aey. .' 22 t a - , 5.3 e up r ie ee s ' tr sae i tej g n i tuce ems ttd n h ud me tnsr td; The def nts lm akefne payment fom any w ageshe may eanzi prson i enda hal i sr n i n a c ra c wi teBue uo P io sFia ca Rep n iit P o rm.An p rino c od n e t h ra f rs n n n il so sbly r ga h i y ot f o t 5ne t ti notpai i f latt tm eoft def he ha s d n ul he i he endant sr eas fom i prs e ' el e r m lonm nt s l be m ea c ndii n o s pe vii n, ya e a t r t of$1 00 pe mon h. ha l co o to f u r so pa bl t he a e 00. r t ( 241Pe . t1 1 p. ) 2 t a - , 6. W a e sj22 p tto a lge t a BOP o fcas ()a eilg lya yi t Bura of dly' 41 e iin le s h t fiil: a r le al ppl ng he e u Prs Fi ions nanci Res i lt Pr r m (( al ponsbii.y og a IFRP' t W a e ( )a ei op rywih l n mon y 1 ' o dly; b r mpr e l t hodig e ) u e t el'. fo wh tve i o W a lyrc ie ,n u i g fs a ( )h vei r e l nd r h flp r m ae r nc me de e ev s icldng it; nd c a mp op ry l cole ed m oni fom W adly' i ome I rt t sat or fve- rlm i f s c l tons lct es r e s nc onge han he t ut y, i yea i t or uch olec i . Wa e s dly eeksa cour- derdiec i t BOP t desgna ehi astI exempt. tor r tng he o i t m GFRP ' ' The Unied St esCour ofAppeal f t Fourh Cicui hasdet m i t a s nt ng cour t at t s or he t r t er ned hat e enci t may notdel t t t BO P ort pr ton ofk et cour' sat or aut iy under l U . C. ega e o he he oba i f he ts t ut y hort 8 S. j3 2 d t s tt a nta tmi f rfnepa n s Unie S ae v. ilr 7 F.d7l 7 78(t 57 ( ) o e he mou nd i ng o i yme t . td tt s M le, 7 3 , 7- 4 h Ci.1 6 (i i o a pe lhaj dg nti op ryd lg tdt teBOPorpobai of rte r 99 ) fndng n p a t tu me mpr el ee ae o h r ton t h ke c r' a t rt t fx tr f rfn p y ns .A j2 peiin i tep o rr me f ra imae ou ts uho iy o i ems o ie a me t) 241 tto s h r pe e dy o n n t cami ta t sntncngc r ma s c a i op rd lg to i hijdg n.Colma v. li ng h the e e i out de u h n mpr e ee ain n s u me t e n Br ok ,1 3F. p' 51 5 ( t Ci. 05 .W heet i t sfneorot rfn nca ob iaini du o s 3 Ap x , 3 4h r 20 ) r he nmae' i he ia il lg to s e i ditl un rt j dg nt h we rt BOP' u eo t eI pr grm t c lc a i t s mme aey de he u me , o ve ,he s s f h FRP o a o ole t n nmae' c ur-mpo e fn i c nsse wihM ilr 1 ( tngMahe yv. o rs ,3 F.d 7 ,71 ( t o ti s d ie s o itnt t le . d.cii t n M rion 07 3 09 2 8h Ci. 02 ( l n t t( h t eds rto t pa ea imaei teI whe t s n e cn c ur r 20 ) hodig ha ' BOP as h icein o lc n n t n h FRP n he e t n ig o t h so dee i dit pa n oft c r-mpos dfne') (l i daepa n die tvei a r r d mme ae yme t he ou ti e i ' . s- mme it yme t r ci s ) -he 3 Th j dg n or e i W a e sc i na pr c e i si n ta ia eont ee to cdo k t e u me t d r n dly' rmi l o e dng s o valbl he lcr ni c e oft s ntn i c ur.W a e s mist pa e o t j g n a a atc n t hi j2 1 he e e cng o t dly ub t wo g s f he ud me t s n ta hme t o s 24 pe ii howeve . tton, r 2 ge aly i er et t r r paym entt t e entt t def ndantca make i i good f t ner l nt pr ed o equie o he xt hat he e n tn aih, be ini i daey. l (ne n lq tto makso te ) gn ng mme itl ' d. itr a uoain r mitd . ' l Cli ()W a lyasrsta t ln ua eo hij dg ntode i o ryd lg tdt n am a, de set h the a g g n s u me r r mprpel ee ae he cour' excl ve a hort t s tpaym e s dul f W adl sfnest t BOP.W adl i m it ts usi ut iy o e nt che es or ey' i o he ey s saken. Thes enci courtor ed t W adly' fneand s alass s e swer due i medit y. ent ng der hat e si peci es m nt e m a el The ef e,t BOP had t dicr ton t em pl t I r or he he s e i o oy he FRP pr sonst e ovii o ncour W adl y t make age e o pr es t d m e i hi fna aloblgatons a i s doi di notusur t se enci cour ' ogr s owar etng s i nci i i , nd n o ng, d p he nt ng ts a t i i volto o t er ei M ilr W a ly' Cl m ( )ha nome ia mus bedimis d. uhort n i ain f h ul n le . de s ai a s y rt nd t s se I Cli ( lW a e a srst tal ug heha no h dprs e o nti sveal e r, n am b p dly s e t ha t h ho s t el ion mplyme n e r y a s BOP ofi al havecontnued t wihhol money unde t l l f om wha e i fci s i o t d r he Fl. r p t ver ncom e he hasr ei ec ved fom f i and f iy. W adl as erst s wihhol ngvi aest courtsdie i on hi r rends am l 4 ey s t hat uch t di olt he ' r ctve s j g n.Thec r c n ta re ud me t out a no ge . TheI FRP i avol ar pr am t ough whi i t wor wih saf t devel apl t s unt y ogr hr ch nma es k t t f o op an o meett rfnanci oblga i i exc hei i al i tons, n hangef anumberofi or ncentvesofer t onl t complantI i f ed o y o i FRP pa t i nt.28C. R.j5 1 ;BOP Pr r m Sttme t53 08 W he ofiil i tal ca sf a ri pa s c F. 45.1 og a ae n 80. . n fcas niil lsiy y BOP i a e,t uni t r ewswih t i at al ofhi fnanci oblga i and hel hi de op nm t he t eam evi t hat nm e l s i al i tons ps m vel aplyt ma es tsa t y p og e stwa dme tngt e eo iai swhiei a c r td.j5 11a a a o k aifcor r r s o r e i h s blg ton l nc re ae 45, () nd ( ) Pa nt un rj5 1 ( )ç y b ma fo i t u i r s ure orno i tt ton(ommuniy b . yme s de 45.1 b d e de r m nsi ton e o c s ma t n-nsiui c t) r s ure . Th , h rgulto û u h ieg)t Bu e ut c n ie f dsrc i dfo s r e ohe e o c s' us t e e ain d t orz s he r a o o sd r un e eve r m ou c s t r ' a t prs w or i de er i ng whe heran i e i a et pari pat i t I han ion k n t m ni t nmat s bl o tci e n he FRP.' Pi s v. ori, ' er on M rs 28 F. x347 348( t Ci. 08 ( np ls d .Net e j5 1 no Pr grm S ae n 538 0 2 App' , 5h r 20 ) u ubihe ) ih r 45.1 r o a t tme t 0.8 e l egfsfom fmiy o fin fom t ec t g r o E o i tt in ( o xcud it r a l r re ds r h ae o y f t n-nsi o c mmuni r s r e . n ut t e ou c s y) Th rt v. se , 6F App' 7 ,7 2( 0hCi. 0 ( npu ih d) An imaewhoc oo esno u son Che tr 38 x 59 6 1 t r 201 ) u bls e . n t h s t 4 W ad1 y doesnots i any document i oft pa e ubm t aton he yments chedul BOP ofi al have e fci s i mpos on hi undert I ed m he FRP ort amount wihhel undert spr a . he s t d hi ogr m t compl wih t condii oft I pr am alo choos t f ego t i o y t he tons he FRP ogr s es o or he ncentvescondii i toned on pa t i ton,n u n s c prvi ge a p ione l me a f rou hs j5 1 ri pai icldig u h i l s s rs mpoy nt nd u l g . 45. 1 c e Un rt s prn pls W a e sCli ( )lc mei.Thesntncngc ts u me to d r de he e ici e , dly' am b a ks rt e e i our'j dg n r e die ed W a ey t m ake pa e st r hi monet y penali f om hi prson wagest ough t r ct dl o ym nt owa d s ar tes r s i hr he I FRP.Thi diec i howe ,di notlm i t m anne i whi BOP ofi al coul utlzet I t s r tve, ver d i t he r n ch fci s d ii he FRP o encour W adly t m e hi m one a y oblgatonse when hei notempl age e o et s tr i i ven s oyed. W adly' e s pa i pa i i t I rtci ton n he FRP r ai vol a y. W adl doesnotale t he hasnotfed BOP ofi al em ns unt r ey lge hat ii fci s t thedoesnotwantt pari pat i t pr am,ashemay choos t do i he want t e pet ha o tci e n he ogr eo f s o sca he pa e oblgatonst whi he agr ed w hen he ent edt I ym nt i i o ch e er he FRP. So l asW adly choos t r n ong e es o emai it I n he FRP,howe ,BOP of i al ma wihhol hi pa ver fci s y t d s yment fom any i sr ncom ehe r vesf om Snonecei r t i ttto ( o niy)r s r e ,'n ldig gfs Cli ( )mus b dimis d. nsiu in c mmu t e ou c s'icu n it. am b t e s se l Cli ( ) W a e r fr t l U. C.j36 3( Til 1 j3 ,whihc c r sr siu i n am c , dly e es o 8 S. 6 9. te 8, 663 c on e n e ttton o des d sno i l eas bs cin ( W a e as p e e t n e de et a teCo r o dee hi t r r , oe t ncud u e to 9. dly lo r s ns o vi nc h t h u t r r d m o pa r tt i Accor ngl t cour c y es iuton. di y, he t annotfnd t W adl hasesa ihed any gr i hat ey t bls ound f r i or elef un rj2 rgadigr siu i c l ton a dimis sCli ( ) de 241 e r n e tt ton ol i , nd s s e am c . ec I1 I Fort r onssat t cour fndsno gr he eas t ed, he ti ound on whi W adl i entted t t r i he s eks ch ey s il o he elef e u e j2 a dimis shi p tto Be a et c r Gnd t tW a lyha noa to becli t nd r 241 nd s se s eii n. c us he ou t s ha de s cina l am,he cour alo de eshi moton f a nt t s ni s i or ppoi mentofcouns .An appr i e or rwilisuet sda el oprat de l s hi y. TheClr i diect t s nd copi oft sm e or e k s r ed o e es hi m andum opi on and accompanyi or t ni ng der o pettoner ii . ENTE Thsho & dyo Api 2 2 R: i ' a f rl 01. , cq -f s Se ' Unied St t DititJu e or t a es src
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
