-RSB Wolters v. Holder et al, No. 7:2012cv00096 - Document 13 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 7/3/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
cu s o- mzu : :I O Q tR A A Ms l iv T vl ,A k FI I T EU IE SA E DSRC C R N H NT D T T S IT IT OU T FO R TH E W E STER N D ISTR ICT O F V I G I IA R N R O A N O K E D I ISIO N V J - é 1 J% BK # . E AN DR EW W O LTER S, Pl nt f , ai i f L Ci lA ct on N o.7: vi i 12-cv00096 M EM O M ND U M O PIN IO N ERI HOLDER, V , C 1 By: H on.Jaclson L.K i er t s Seni U nied St esD i ri Judge or t at st ct Defendant s. Andr W ole s a f r li a e pr e ng pr K ,fl d a c vi r gh s c pl i ew t r , ede a nm t oc edi o ie i l i t om a nt . pur ua t Bi ns v.Si U nknow n N a ed A c nt ofFede a Bur a ofN a c i ,403 U . 388 s nt o ve x m e s rl e u r otcs S. ( 971, t urs ci vese i 28U. C.j1 1 ) wihj iditon td n S. 331.Plitf di notpa t $350flngfea anif d y he ii e nd akst pr e L f mapa rs e28U. C.j 1 4() 1 s o oc ed q or upei.Se S. j 91 a, 915.Thecour gr tdpl ntf t ane ai if t opporuniyt s r hi a iai t pr ee L f mapa rswiha imaea co he t t o uppo t s pplc ton o oc d q or upei t n n t c unt r po ta s a e e ofas e s The c tw a ne pl ntf t tpr ordi m i s l f f i iy or e r nd t t m nt s t. our r d ai i f ha i s s a s or ' volt r f lngt saeacl m woul lmi hi a lt t pr e t f mapa i. aii o tt ai d i t s biiy o oc ed q or upers The c ttnds t tpl i ifhad a l as t e non- be s c vi c pl i t ora a s our i ha a ntf t e t hr e ha a i l om a n s ppe l pr vi l di m i s a f i ous a m alci ,o f f ii t s a e a c a m upo whi h r le e ous y s s ed s rvol , s i ous r or a lng o t t l i n c ei f ma begrntd.W olesv. de a Bur uofPrs , 1 30717,si op. t12(t Ci. a y a e tr Fe r l ea ions No. 0lp a - 5h r J n. 11, 1 (ppe ldimis a fi ous;W olesv.Fed a Bura ofPrs ns No. c 0837, 201 ) a a s sed s rvol ) tr erl e u io , 08-v- si o a 1( . La J l 5 2 0 (cind s se wihp eudc a fiolu a df rfiig l p. t W D. . u y , 01 ) a to imisd t rj ie s rv o s n o aln p t saeacam upo whihr ifma begrntdl W olesv. e , 1: c 02290,si o o tt li n c ele y a e ; tr Huntr No. 07-vlp p. a 4( Col M a.2,2009)(ci dimis wihprj c f fii t saeacli u n t D. o. r a ton s sed t eudie or alng o tt am po whihrle ma beg a e .Se He lev. le , 116707,si o a 1 ( hCi. une5, c eif y r ntd) e nse Kelr No. lp p. t 0 4t r J 201 )( ohi tngadititco tdimis t bec i rdat r srkewhiet dimisli 2 pr bii src ur s salo onsdee hid ti l he s sa s benga ae .l a or i ppe ld) n cc dmwewiht t eesrkespr so of28U. C j 1 5() t Cour t he hr -ti oviin S. 91 g ,he t . ' ofAppe sf t Fit Cic tpr vi l a s d pli ift the ne ded t s i t $350. al or he fh r ui e ousy dvie antf ha e o ubm t he 00 tlng f e ores a ih a i m i ntt e ofs rousphys c ha m t pr e w ih a c vi s tonc ii e t bls n m ne hr at e i i al r o oc ed t i l ui e hea tmult t e ç ti ,' s ntt 28U. C.j 1 5() ole sv. derlBur uQf ccl aes hre û rkes'purua o s S. 91 g .W tr Fe a ea Prsons,N o.10i 30717,s i op.at2. lp Pl i i fna es a de e nt t t s a ton Er c H ol r t A tor y Ge r loft a ntf m s f nda s o hi c i i de , he t ne ne a he Unied St t s a C . h,t W ar n oft U nied St esPe t nta y i Lee Count V igi a t a e , nd Zyc he de he t at nie i r n y, r ni (t Le ' .Pli ifcompli t tac lmaei ge rlpopulto a USP Le ti t rpe I USP e' antf ) ans ha el t n nea ain t e red o a pl ntf o J ai i f n anua y 31 20l1 a l gedl a t r que tofc r t o ls a fasr t la i f flng r , , le y t he e s or ec i na t f e a i ton or ii gre nc a co pl i sa iva es nd m ant boutUSP Leesa f A c r c i lofi e deni d pl ntf sr ques t f . ore tona fc r e ai if e t t be m ove i o pr ec i cus ody.O nc pl i ifs gne a a t da ta o d nt ot tve t e a ntf i d n fi vi boutt s he exua as a t a l s ul, c r to lof i e t d pl n i ft tt afi vi w o d be pas e a ound t o he i a e . A or ec i na f c r ol ai t f ha he fda t ul sd r o t r nm t s c lm a e as a t d pl i i fi s r ton on Fe ua y 4,2011 a t s r e r s t i e l t s ule a ntf n eg ega i br r , nd he t uggl e uled n plitf b e kigafng ra d ij rn hi e e Plitf i u aife wi me ia saf' anif ra n i e n nu i g s y . anif s nstsid t d c l tfs h di gnos s a t e t e ofpl i if s fnge . Bur a ofPr s 's a fr us t r pond t a e nd r a m nt a ntf i r eu i ons t f ef e o es o pl ntf s grevances. ai if' i A fe r vi w i pl i i f sco pl nti t sa ton,i i c e rt tpl i i fdoe no tr e e ng a ntf m ai n hi c i t s l a ha a ntf s t esa iht thei c rnty unde anyi ne t e tofa s rousphysc ij ywihi t tbls ha s ure l r mmi nt hra ny ei ialn ur t n he mea ngof28U. C.j1 5( .See e. , a tnv.Shetm,31 F. 1 1 0( t Ci. ni S. 91 g) , g.M ri ll 9 3d 048, 05 8h r 2 0 )(e urn p o fo a o g i s ro sp ysc l nt yo apatr o mic n u 0 3 rq ii g r o f n n ong e iu h ia ijl r ten f so d d r e dencngt lkelhoodofi nen s rousph ia ij y ;As e v. l lh,1 F.d 715, vi i he i i mmi t ei ysc l nur l hlv Diwo 47 3 71 ( hCi.l Cç lgato t tt prs rhasf e i ne da eri t pa tae 7 8t r 998) Ale ins ha he ione ac d mmi nt ng n he s r i ufiintt ti rt e e e i t j l 5( .....Pl ntf' algainsofs tmi ns fce o rgge hlj xc pton o 91 g) ) ai ifs le to yse c r t la i wihi t Bur a ofPrs ha alea be c i r d by a f de a c r,whi h e ai ton t n he e u i ons ve r dy en onsde e e r l ou t c r ule i one ofpl i i fs tz e s r ke . Furhe m or pl i i fw ashous a a f de al es t d n a ntf lr e ti s t r e, a ntf ed t e r pe t n i r i Pe yl ni w he he i tt e t s a ton,a t , a nt f coul notha be n nie t a y n nns va a n ns iut d hi c i nd hus pl i if d ve e i i m i ntda e ofs r ousphys c lha m i Pe m s va a aboutt co tonspr vi l n m ne ng r e i i a r n z yl ni he ndii e ous y expe i nc d i Vi gi a. M or r e e n r ni eove ,a pr s r sdi ag e m entw ih m edi alper onnelove t r i one ' s r e t c s r he c ls ofte t doe notsaeaj 1 cai Wrqhtv.Coli ,766F. 8 ,8 ( h Ci. otre rament s tt 983 l m. i lns 2d 41 49 4t r 1 ) Se Esel v.Gambl,429U. 97,1 06( 976)( tngcai ofme c lmapr tce 985 . e tle e S. 05- 1 noi l ms dia l aci andne i ntdignossar notc za ei acvi rght acin) Ac or ngl 1dimist glge a i e ogni bl n i l i s to . c di y, s s he a to wih u p eu c frplitf sfi r t p yt etl gf ea tetmeo tln te cin to t rj die o anif al e o a h ii e t h i f iig h u n c ant Se e. , eev. l r 28 F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci. 2)(eas ngt tt ompli . e, c.Dupr Pame , 4 3d 234, 237 1 t r 200 r oni ha he flngf i dueuponflngacviacin whe j f m;paupei pr sonsdonota yt ii ee s ii i l to n . or q rs ovii ppl o pl i ifa t tt cour i notr uie t pe m i pl i tf an o a ntf nd ha he ts eq r d o r t a n i f pporuniy t pa t tlng f i t t o y he i i ee f pli ifi i i bl t pr ee j f mapa rs. antf s nelgi e o oc d - or q upei) The Cl r i die ed t s nd co esoft sM e o a e k s r ct o e pi hi m r ndum Opi on a t a c pa ng ni nd he c om nyi O r rt pl ntf . de o ai if ET R Ti N E :h s dyf'n 012. aoJaj .l . tw , Se rU nie St t D i ti tJ ni t d a es sr c udge