-RSB Usry v. Clarke, No. 7:2012cv00090 - Document 16 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 11/1/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
dQ :OFFI U. DI C/lr ERK' CC 5. :X l A?DANVI E. LL VA cI ( (. F DG j v I TH E UN I N TED STA TES DI STR I CO UR T CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DISTRIC T O F V IR G INIA RO AN O K E D I SI N VI O G R EG O R Y D O NN ELL U SR Y , Pet toner, ii H A R O LD W .CLA R K E , R espondent. JbL . ' t DO E c ERK x :; s - à v/ Ci lA c i N o.7: 2- vvi t on 1 c 00090 ) ) ) ) ) ) ) M EM O M N DU M O PI I N N O By: H on.Jacks L.K i on ser Seni U nied St es Di tri Judge or t at s ct tton or i G r gor D onnel U s y,a V i gi a i a e pr ee ng pr y tl a pe ii f a w rtof e y l r r ni nm t oc di o q, i ed - habe sc pus purua t 28U. C.j2254.Res a or , s nt o S. ponde fldamoin t dimis a nt ie to o s s , nd peii rr ponded a a s fld a moton t a e hi r pc e, a ng t m a trrpe f r ttone es nd lo ie i o m nd s es ms m ki he te i o diposton. A f e r vi w i t r or 1gr ntt m o i t a end a di m i st pe ii a s ii t r e e ng he ec d, a he ton o m nd s s he tton s tmeba r i red. 1. The Cic tCour oft Ciy ofLync r ui t he t hbur s nt e pe ii ne on Fe ua y 1 2009,t g e enc d tt o r br r 3, o a a i t nu ofs ve ye r a s x m ont 'i a c r ton f r pos es i a Sc dul 1 n ctve e e n a s nd i hs nc r e a i o s s ng he e 1 cont l s ance. Pettonerappeal t t CourtofAppeal ofV i ni and t t Supr e roled ubst ii ed o he s rgi a o he em Cour ofV igi a, hi h r us t a alon M a c 1 201 Pe ii r di nottl a petton t r ni w c ef ed he ppe r h 9, 0. ttone d ie ii f a w rtofc r i a iw ih t Unie St t Su e e Cour . or i e tor r t he t d a es pr m t On J nua y 4,20 11 pe ii ne fl d a pe ii f a w rtofha s c pus w ih t a r , tt o r ie tton or i bea or t he Su e e Co tofV igi a, hi h di m i s d t pe ii on J m e 21 2011 Pe ii rf l d t pr m ur r ni w c s s e he tton t , . ttone ie he i tntf rlha speii noeale t nFe uar 21 201 Se R.Go j225 Cas s3( nsa edea bea tton rir ha br y , 2. e v. 4 e d) ( s i ngt prs mal r e . decrbi he ion- ibox ul) I I. Ha e spei o fldu d rj2 5 a es j c t ao - e r ro o l tto 28 b a tt ns i n e 2 4 r ube t o ney a pei d f i ain. i e mi U s. j2244( ( )' Ge r1y,t sp ro b g n t r nfo t d t o wh c tej d me t c. d)l. nea1 hi eid e i s o u r m he ae n ih h u g n . ofconvitonbec ci omesfnal2 28I. . .j2244( ()A) A c ci be i . Js c d) 1( . onviton come fna oncet si l he a alb l yo dr c r ve i e h u td ie Sttsv. a 5 7U. 5 2 5 4( 0 3 .The v ia ii f ie t e iw s x a se .Untd ae Cly, 3 S. 2 , 2 2 0 ) t one ye flngpe i i t l whie ac c ' ipr ry fl a ia i f St t - ar ii rod s oled l onvits ç ope l ied pplc ton or a e pos-onvitonorot c l ealrviw'i ' ndi ' 28U. C.j2244( ( .SeeW alv. tc ci her olatr e e 's k ng.' pe S. d)2) l Khol, i U. S. ,1 S.Ct 1 1 - 9( )( susi pr edi t tquaiya 31 . 278, 288 8 2011 dic sng oce ngs ha lf s colatr rviw) l eal e e . Pei o e ' j2 5 peiini u tmeyu d rj2 4 d ()A) Peiin rsc n ito tt n rs 2 4 t o s n i l n e 2 4() 1( . tto e ' o v cin i t bec me fnalon J 1 201 whe t tm ee r d f pe ii rt fl apeii f am i of a i une 7, 0, n he i xpie or ttone o ie tton or t c ri aiwiht Supr meCour oft Unie Stts SeeU. Sup.Ct R.1 1 (ttng e torr t he e t he td ae . S. . 3( ) sai a p la t s tl apeiin f rawrto c rir r wihnn n t d y o j d me t en p eln mu t ie tt o o i f e t ai t i i ey a s f u g n b i g o a ld) Peii rfl hi saehabe peii o J r 4,2011, da a trhi ppeae . ttone ied s tt as tton n anuay 200 ys fe s c onvi ton bec m e f na . ci a i l 1The one- y a p rodo lmia in f rfln ah be sp tto u d rj2 5 be i st r no t eIt s o f u d t s e r e i f i tto o i g a a eiin n e 2 4 g n o u n h ae t f o r a e : i ( t d t o whc tej d me t e a f a b tec ncu ino drc rve o tee prto o te A)he ae n ih h u g n b c me i l y h o lso f ie t e iw r h x iain fh n tm e f s ki s h r vi ; i or ee ng uc e ew ( ted t o whihtei e i n t Gln a a pl aince tdb Stt a t ni voaino te B)h ae n c h mp dme t o ig n p i to rae y ae ci n ilto f h c o Consiuton orl oft Unie Stt i r ove i t a ia waspr nt fom flngby s h tt i aws he td aes s em d, f he pplc nt eve ed r ii uc St t a i a e cton; ( ted t o whihtec nsi to a rg tasre wa i tal rc nie b teS pe Co r,fh C)h ae n c h o tuin l ih setd s ni ly eog z d y h u rme u tite t i rgh ha be ne yr ogni d b t Supr m eCour a m a r toaci y a iabl t ca e on i t s en wl ec ze y he e t nd de er tvel pplc e o s s colaealr viw ;or ltr e e ( t d t o wh c t e fc u l r dc t o t ecam o camsp e e t d c u dha eb e d s o e e D) he a e n ih h a t a p e iae f h li r li r s n e o l v e n ic v r d t ough t e r s ofduedii nce. hr he xe cie lge 2 S. j 2 4d ()A)( . 28U. C. 2 4 ()1( -D) P tin rddn tag etmeie su d rs b eto s( tru h( . eio e i o r u i l s n e u scin B) ho g D) t n The sat e oflmia i wa t ld f l da be wee J nua y 4 a J 21 2011 t ut i ttons s ole or 6# ys t n a r nd une , , du i t pe ncy ofpe ii ' pr pery- ie s a e ha spe ii A not r244 d pas e r ng he nde ttoner s o l fl d t t bea tton. he ays s d bewe J 22,2011 whe t Supr m eCour ofVigi adim is d t sa ehabe speii t en une , n he e t r ni s s e he tt a tton, a Fe ua y 21 201 w he pe ii rfl t f er lha aspe ii Eve afe t lng t nd br r , 2, n ttone ied he ed a be tton. n t r oli he l da peii rspr l tlda i tonf c ltr lr e waspendi peii rfld 68 ys ttone ' opery-ie pplcai or olae a eviw ng, ttone ie t i t ntha spe ii m or t n 440 daysafe hi co c i be m e fna . he ns a bea tton e ha t r s nvi ton ca i l Equia e t lng i a ia e onl i t hos r r i t nce whe e - due t cic sa es t bl oli s va l bl y n û e a e ns a s t r o r um t nc e e na t t pa t sow n co xt r l o he r y' nduc - i w oul be unc c ona e t e or t lm ia i pe i t t d ons i bl o nf ce he i t ton rod a ns t parya gr sij tc woul rs t' gai t he t nd os nusie d eul. 'Rous v.Le 339F. 238,246(t Ci. e e, 3d 4h r 2003)(nba (ntr quottonmaksomitd)( tngHarsv. t ns 209F. 325, e nc) i enal ai r te cii ri Huchi on, 3d 330( hCi.2000).Thus ape iine mus ha ûbe npurui hi rght dii nty,a ... 4t r ) , tto r t ve û e s ng s i s lge l nd s e e r or na y c r um s a e s ood i hi w a ' o pr ve tm e y flng. H ola v. o i , om xt a di r ic t nc t n s y' t e nt i l ii l nd Fl r da U. S. ,1 S. . 49,2560( 0) 30 Ct25 201 . Pe ii r sl k ofknowldge a tl ga pr s ort sa ut r de dlne f rf r l ttone ' ac e bou e l oce s he tt o y a i o ede a ha sr le doesnots bea e i f uppor gr ntng s h extao di r r lef Hq rs 209 F. a 330. t a i uc r r na y e i . r i, 3d t Fur he m o e Ido notfnd a e r or na y c r um s a i t s r c d t tpr ve e pe ii ne t r r, i ny xt a di r ic t nce n hi e oz ha e nt d tto r f om flng a tm el pe ii See. u. U nie S a e v.Sos , 3 4 F.d 5 7 51 ( t Ci. 0 4 r ii i y tton. e. , t d t t s a 6 3 0 , 2 4h r 2 0 ) (r y sau a di n rnc of h lw d e n t usiye uia l t lig ; r e v. o ns n 1 7 p o . tts n g o a e t e a o s o j tf q tbe oln ) Tu n r J h o , 7 q . F. 390,392( hCi.1 )( tngt tunfmiirt wiht lw duet iltrc orpr > 3d 5t r 999 noi ha a laiy t he a o liea y oç . . sausdoe nott llmiai pei .Acc di y, ttone tl hi f rlha aspeiin tt s ol i ttons rod) or ngl peii r ied s edea be tto beyond t onehe yearlm iatonsperi , pettoneri notentted t equiabl t lng, and t i ti od ii s il o t e oli he petton m us be di m i ed. ii t s ss 1 11. Fo t f e ng r ons 1gr pettoner' m ot On t a e , gr ntr ponde ' r he or goi eas , ant ii nt s s i o m nd 3 a es m oton t di m i s deny pettoner sm oton t gr nt4and di m i st pe ii f a w rto i o s s, i o a , s s he tton or i f ii ' ha s c us Ba e upon m y tndi t tpe ii nerha notm a t r st s t n i l bea om . s d i ng ha tto s de he equi ie ubs a t a s o n o ad n a o ac n ttto l ih a rq ie b 2 U. C. 2 3 c, c ri c t o h wi g f e il f o si ina rg t s e urd y 8 S. j 25 () a ett ae f u i a ppea a lt i de e l biiy s ni d. The Cl r i die t t s nd a c oft sM e or ndum Opi on a t a om pa ng e k s r c ed o e opy hi m a ni nd he cc nyi Or rt pe ii ne a c de o tt o r nd ouns lofr co d f rr s nde . e e r o e po nt E E T i) NT R: hs dyo Noe e,02 a f vmbr2 1. î t4 = .. S ni Unie St t s i t i tJ or t d a e sr c udge - 3Thc m o i t amend s kst i ude t o par gr phsofcia i a a gum ent i peii rsr po et ton o ee o ncl w a a t tons nd r s n ttone ' es ns o rs e ponde ' moton t di m i s S eFo nv Da s 3 1U..l 8 1 2(9 2 (oigac u th l fe l gie nts i o s s . e ma . vi, 7 S 7 , 8 1 6 ) n tn o r soud rey v la et a n wh nj sies rq ie) ev o me d e u tc o e urs. 4Pettone ' m oto t gr ntas m et gr t pe ii f a wrtofha ascor ii r s i n o a ks o ant he tton or i be pus. 4 N
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
