Howard v. Statzer et al, No. 7:2012cv00079 - Document 64 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 09/26/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
CL S OFFI EU.S. ST COURT ERK' C DI . AT ROM OKE,VA FI LED SEP ï 2 1 22 I TH E U NI N TED STA TES D I STR I T CO UR T C FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STR I T O F V I I I C RG N A RO A N O K E D I I O N V SI R O BER T PH AR O AH H O W A RD , JULI BY: A C E ? etrsrr p. lr CA SE N O .7: 2CV 00079 1 Pl ntf ai if, M EM O R AN D UM O PIN I N O V S. J.STATZER, AL. c , cL,' '.! , ' ' By:Gln E.Conrad e Chi U nied St esD i t ctJudge ef t at s ri Defendant s. Pr #q pl i if Robe tPha oa H owa d,tl d t sci lr ght a ton pur ua t 42 o .. a ntf , r r h r i e hi vi i s c i s nt o U. C.j1 algi t tofki sa Re Oni Stt Prs vi ae hi c tt ona rg s S. 983, le ng ha t al t d on ae ion oltd s onsimi l iht i va i usw a . How a d i now c i a W ale Ri St t Pr s a ha m ove f a n ro ys r s onfned t l ns dge a e i on nd s d or pr i nayij ton( No.5 ,dieci W alnsRi ofi ast r nsaeHowadt elmi r n unci ECF 9) r tng le dge fcil o ei tt r o t Comm o Fa e Di t and f re ty ofat mpor r r ta ni or ragans c ran ofi e sa he n r e, o nr e a y esr i ng de i t e ti fc r t W alnsRi ( No.63) whos a tonsa veba t e t ha c us Howadt fa f le dge ECF , e ci nd r l hras ve a ed r o e r or hi lf a t ti tt i n. U pon r vi w oft r c d, he c tde e How a d' m o i f s ie t ha ns iuto e e he e or t our ni s r s tons or itro uo yij n tv r l f n el c t r n u ci e ei . e I hi frtmoi ( No.59 , n s is ton ECF ) Howar cai t tbe a eo a tonstkenby d l ms ha c us f ci a W a l nsRi of i r , ha be n pe m a nty r m ove f om t Com m on Fa e di tand m us le dge fce s he s e r ne l e d r he r e t e tt r a i a e m enu,whi h i l spor pr a he egul r nm t c nc ude k oduc s H owar a s cl i st tt r ul r t. d l o a m ha he eg a ditdoe no i l s fcintc l i sa ha c us d hi t s frs ve eco tpa i The e s t ncude ufi e aore nd s a e m o ufe e r nsi ton. de e f ndant i t sl w s ta e ofi e sa Re Oni n and ha no r pons biiy f H ow a d' s n hi a ui r fc r t d o ve es i lt or r s r lgi di t r a om m oda i nsorm e c lpr e sa W a l ns Ri e i ous e a y cc to di a obl m t le dge. Be us H ow a d' ca e r s de ndf aprlmi r ij toni notr aedt t damsi t slws t hei note il ma or ei nay nunci s elt o he i n hi a ui, s ntted t t ijmci r le hes e i t scvi a ton,rgadi r nsae ntt hi r i ousdita o he nt tve eif e ks n hi i l ci e r ng ei ttme o s elgi e t ' W alnsRi e S eOme aW o l Trv l . A,1 1F.d 1 ,1 ( t Ci. 9 7 ;nr le dg . e c rd a e v TW 1 3 4 6 4h r 1 9 ) l e Mir of Anttus Lii ,333F. 51 526(t Ci. cos t ir t tg. 3d 7, 4h r 2003) . How a d' c r nts i s on doe no i ca e t the hase us e ad i s r tve r s ur e ubm s i s t ndi t ha xha t d m ni t a i rmedis s e42U. C.j 1 () a t hi camst tW ale Ri ofi il c us hi t e e, e S. 997ea, s o s li ha lns dge tcas a ed m o be ba nned f om t Co m on Fa e di ta t t r gul rdi ttays d notpr de s f c e r he m r e nd hat he e a e r o ovi uf i i nt nutii a c us hi med c lpr bl ms The ef e whieHowa dm a tl a ne cvi aci n rton nd a e m i a o e . r or , l r y ie w i l to r i i s h cl i s a a sng uc a m boutW a l nsR i c e nsa trhe fr tc pl t st gr e nce le dge onc r fe is om e e he i va pr e e, heco twilno fl hi c r s m ison a ane lws t oc dur t ur l t ie s urent ub s i s w a ui. Howadha fldaspart moton f e r ofatmpor yr sr ni or ( No. r s ie e ae i or nty e ar e tai ng der ECF 63) Howadsaest thefa sf hi lf,ba e onveba t e t ce t nW alnsRi . r tt ha e r or s ie s d r l hras rai le dge ofi e sm a a i thi a t he c pl i d t tt we e c w i t c o a t ki t tc r de ga ns m fer om a ne ha hey r he ng oba c nd a ng he ldsof t f d ta ,i vi ai n ofvarousprs r gultons Howa d a s a lgest tt of i f he oo r ys n olto i ion e a i . r lo le ha wo t s of i r t ho d' hi a t nked' hi a w hie e c tng hi t a f om r r a i o he e fce s ç ve ' m nd d s ya ' s nn l s ori m o nd ' r ec e ton n Se e r1 201 a t eae t be thi up.Upon r viw oft r c d,hec tde es pt mbe 4, 2, nd hr t ned o a m e e he e or t our ni Ho r ' moin f ritro uo yij n tv rle. wad s to o ne lc tr n u ci e eif Te por r r s r i ng o de sa e i s d, ihou notce onl r r l w he t m o nt m a y e t a ni r r r s ue w t t i , y a e yn he va p o e t t ewil u frij r i rle i n t rn e b f r t a v rep ryc ul b n tfe r v s ha h ls fe nu y f eif s o g a td eo e he d es a t o d e o iid a havea o rt t t rs nd n ppo tmiy o epond.Se Fe rlRul ofCi lPr dtr 65( .I s ppor of e dea e vi oce le b) n u t s h am o i t pl ntf m us pr s n 4 pe fc f t i a afi vi orave iid compl nt uc ton, he ai if t e e t û cii acs n n fda t s rfe ai ce rys i t ti lal howlngj ha mmedit a irpaa eij y,l s ordn gewilr ul t t mo nt ae nd re rbl nur os , ma l es t o he va beor t a s pa t ca beheadi opposton'a mus k e ttyji wrtnga ef t f e he dvere ry n r n ii ' nd t t ril n ii ny fors c ma t gi notc a d t r a ot whyi s dnotber quie ' Rut 65( () de o ve ie n he e s u t houl e rd. e b) 1. ' 2 Howa d' c e nsa r s onc r boutt a tonsa t e t b ofi e sa W a lnsRi a enot he c i nd hr a s y fc r t le dge r r a e t t c a m s i t unde l ng c vi a ton aga ns Re O ni ofi a s The e o e,no el t d o he l i n he r yi i l c i i t d on tci l . rf r t m por r r s r i ng or rw ili s i t sci la ton. Om e W ord Tr ve ,111 F. a 1 e a y e t a ni de l s ue n hi vi c i ga l a l 3d t 6. M or ove , he c twilno c t ue H o a d' s i s on a a ne c vi ac i s ki e r t our l t onsr w r s ubm s i s w i l ton ee ng a t m por r r s r i ng or raga ns t W a l ns Ri ofi r he na es H ow a d f is t e a y e ta ni de i t he le dge fce s m . r al o pr de a afi vi s t i f r h s ii f c sc e ni t m n ovi n f da t e t o t pec f c a t onc r ng he nneri w hi h he wils f r ng n c l uf e ti tmmedit a ir paa eij y'wihouta i dit c tntr e i Howadalof l ae nd re rbl nur ' t n mme ae our i e v nton. r s ais t ce tf a r as t tt de e ntprs n ofi i l s d notbe notfe oft l s ta o riy ny e on ha he f nda i o f c a s houl i i d he aw ui nd gr nt d t o r unii s i r nti t no m a ltga i n pr s t r po t hi a l ga i a a e he ppo t te nhe e n he r l ii t o oce s o es nd o s le tons s rquie byRul 65( (1. Ana opraeor rde ngHowad' motonf tmporr e rd e b) ) ppr it de nyi r s i or e ay r s r i ng or rw ili s t sday. e t a ni de l s ue hi The C l r i diec e t s co esoft sm em or ndum opi on a ac om pa ng e k s r t d o end pi hi a ni nd c nyi or rt pl ntf . de o ai if EX TER : Thi s A&M d y otse em ber 201 a - pt , 2. Chi fUnied St t D it i tJ e t a es s rc udge 3