Howard v. Statzer et al, No. 7:2012cv00079 - Document 64 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 09/26/2012. (kab)

Download PDF
CL S OFFI EU.S. ST COURT ERK' C DI . AT ROM OKE,VA FI LED SEP ï 2 1 22 I TH E U NI N TED STA TES D I STR I T CO UR T C FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STR I T O F V I I I C RG N A RO A N O K E D I I O N V SI R O BER T PH AR O AH H O W A RD , JULI BY: A C E ? etrsrr p. lr CA SE N O .7: 2CV 00079 1 Pl ntf ai if, M EM O R AN D UM O PIN I N O V S. J.STATZER, AL. c , cL,' '.! , ' ' By:Gln E.Conrad e Chi U nied St esD i t ctJudge ef t at s ri Defendant s. Pr #q pl i if Robe tPha oa H owa d,tl d t sci lr ght a ton pur ua t 42 o .. a ntf , r r h r i e hi vi i s c i s nt o U. C.j1 algi t tofki sa Re Oni Stt Prs vi ae hi c tt ona rg s S. 983, le ng ha t al t d on ae ion oltd s onsimi l iht i va i usw a . How a d i now c i a W ale Ri St t Pr s a ha m ove f a n ro ys r s onfned t l ns dge a e i on nd s d or pr i nayij ton( No.5 ,dieci W alnsRi ofi ast r nsaeHowadt elmi r n unci ECF 9) r tng le dge fcil o ei tt r o t Comm o Fa e Di t and f re ty ofat mpor r r ta ni or ragans c ran ofi e sa he n r e, o nr e a y esr i ng de i t e ti fc r t W alnsRi ( No.63) whos a tonsa veba t e t ha c us Howadt fa f le dge ECF , e ci nd r l hras ve a ed r o e r or hi lf a t ti tt i n. U pon r vi w oft r c d, he c tde e How a d' m o i f s ie t ha ns iuto e e he e or t our ni s r s tons or itro uo yij n tv r l f n el c t r n u ci e ei . e I hi frtmoi ( No.59 , n s is ton ECF ) Howar cai t tbe a eo a tonstkenby d l ms ha c us f ci a W a l nsRi of i r , ha be n pe m a nty r m ove f om t Com m on Fa e di tand m us le dge fce s he s e r ne l e d r he r e t e tt r a i a e m enu,whi h i l spor pr a he egul r nm t c nc ude k oduc s H owar a s cl i st tt r ul r t. d l o a m ha he eg a ditdoe no i l s fcintc l i sa ha c us d hi t s frs ve eco tpa i The e s t ncude ufi e aore nd s a e m o ufe e r nsi ton. de e f ndant i t sl w s ta e ofi e sa Re Oni n and ha no r pons biiy f H ow a d' s n hi a ui r fc r t d o ve es i lt or r s r lgi di t r a om m oda i nsorm e c lpr e sa W a l ns Ri e i ous e a y cc to di a obl m t le dge. Be us H ow a d' ca e r s de ndf aprlmi r ij toni notr aedt t damsi t slws t hei note il ma or ei nay nunci s elt o he i n hi a ui, s ntted t t ijmci r le hes e i t scvi a ton,rgadi r nsae ntt hi r i ousdita o he nt tve eif e ks n hi i l ci e r ng ei ttme o s elgi e t ' W alnsRi e S eOme aW o l Trv l . A,1 1F.d 1 ,1 ( t Ci. 9 7 ;nr le dg . e c rd a e v TW 1 3 4 6 4h r 1 9 ) l e Mir of Anttus Lii ,333F. 51 526(t Ci. cos t ir t tg. 3d 7, 4h r 2003) . How a d' c r nts i s on doe no i ca e t the hase us e ad i s r tve r s ur e ubm s i s t ndi t ha xha t d m ni t a i rmedis s e42U. C.j 1 () a t hi camst tW ale Ri ofi il c us hi t e e, e S. 997ea, s o s li ha lns dge tcas a ed m o be ba nned f om t Co m on Fa e di ta t t r gul rdi ttays d notpr de s f c e r he m r e nd hat he e a e r o ovi uf i i nt nutii a c us hi med c lpr bl ms The ef e whieHowa dm a tl a ne cvi aci n rton nd a e m i a o e . r or , l r y ie w i l to r i i s h cl i s a a sng uc a m boutW a l nsR i c e nsa trhe fr tc pl t st gr e nce le dge onc r fe is om e e he i va pr e e, heco twilno fl hi c r s m ison a ane lws t oc dur t ur l t ie s urent ub s i s w a ui. Howadha fldaspart moton f e r ofatmpor yr sr ni or ( No. r s ie e ae i or nty e ar e tai ng der ECF 63) Howadsaest thefa sf hi lf,ba e onveba t e t ce t nW alnsRi . r tt ha e r or s ie s d r l hras rai le dge ofi e sm a a i thi a t he c pl i d t tt we e c w i t c o a t ki t tc r de ga ns m fer om a ne ha hey r he ng oba c nd a ng he ldsof t f d ta ,i vi ai n ofvarousprs r gultons Howa d a s a lgest tt of i f he oo r ys n olto i ion e a i . r lo le ha wo t s of i r t ho d' hi a t nked' hi a w hie e c tng hi t a f om r r a i o he e fce s ç ve ' m nd d s ya ' s nn l s ori m o nd ' r ec e ton n Se e r1 201 a t eae t be thi up.Upon r viw oft r c d,hec tde es pt mbe 4, 2, nd hr t ned o a m e e he e or t our ni Ho r ' moin f ritro uo yij n tv rle. wad s to o ne lc tr n u ci e eif Te por r r s r i ng o de sa e i s d, ihou notce onl r r l w he t m o nt m a y e t a ni r r r s ue w t t i , y a e yn he va p o e t t ewil u frij r i rle i n t rn e b f r t a v rep ryc ul b n tfe r v s ha h ls fe nu y f eif s o g a td eo e he d es a t o d e o iid a havea o rt t t rs nd n ppo tmiy o epond.Se Fe rlRul ofCi lPr dtr 65( .I s ppor of e dea e vi oce le b) n u t s h am o i t pl ntf m us pr s n 4 pe fc f t i a afi vi orave iid compl nt uc ton, he ai if t e e t û cii acs n n fda t s rfe ai ce rys i t ti lal howlngj ha mmedit a irpaa eij y,l s ordn gewilr ul t t mo nt ae nd re rbl nur os , ma l es t o he va beor t a s pa t ca beheadi opposton'a mus k e ttyji wrtnga ef t f e he dvere ry n r n ii ' nd t t ril n ii ny fors c ma t gi notc a d t r a ot whyi s dnotber quie ' Rut 65( () de o ve ie n he e s u t houl e rd. e b) 1. ' 2 Howa d' c e nsa r s onc r boutt a tonsa t e t b ofi e sa W a lnsRi a enot he c i nd hr a s y fc r t le dge r r a e t t c a m s i t unde l ng c vi a ton aga ns Re O ni ofi a s The e o e,no el t d o he l i n he r yi i l c i i t d on tci l . rf r t m por r r s r i ng or rw ili s i t sci la ton. Om e W ord Tr ve ,111 F. a 1 e a y e t a ni de l s ue n hi vi c i ga l a l 3d t 6. M or ove , he c twilno c t ue H o a d' s i s on a a ne c vi ac i s ki e r t our l t onsr w r s ubm s i s w i l ton ee ng a t m por r r s r i ng or raga ns t W a l ns Ri ofi r he na es H ow a d f is t e a y e ta ni de i t he le dge fce s m . r al o pr de a afi vi s t i f r h s ii f c sc e ni t m n ovi n f da t e t o t pec f c a t onc r ng he nneri w hi h he wils f r ng n c l uf e ti tmmedit a ir paa eij y'wihouta i dit c tntr e i Howadalof l ae nd re rbl nur ' t n mme ae our i e v nton. r s ais t ce tf a r as t tt de e ntprs n ofi i l s d notbe notfe oft l s ta o riy ny e on ha he f nda i o f c a s houl i i d he aw ui nd gr nt d t o r unii s i r nti t no m a ltga i n pr s t r po t hi a l ga i a a e he ppo t te nhe e n he r l ii t o oce s o es nd o s le tons s rquie byRul 65( (1. Ana opraeor rde ngHowad' motonf tmporr e rd e b) ) ppr it de nyi r s i or e ay r s r i ng or rw ili s t sday. e t a ni de l s ue hi The C l r i diec e t s co esoft sm em or ndum opi on a ac om pa ng e k s r t d o end pi hi a ni nd c nyi or rt pl ntf . de o ai if EX TER : Thi s A&M d y otse em ber 201 a - pt , 2. Chi fUnied St t D it i tJ e t a es s rc udge 3

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.