Howard v. Messer et al, No. 7:2012cv00079 - Document 213 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 02/21/2014. (kab)

Download PDF
CL ERK' OFFI U.S. ST. S CE DI COURT AT RM NOKE, VA FI LED I TI E UM TED STATES DI N I STRI CO URT G FO R TI W ESTERN DISTRI OF VIRGINI IE G A ROANOU DI SI VI ON FEB 2 12 1 24 J ULK . DL ex BY' A BD UL H AM ZA W A LIM I H AM M AD J ( .Ro d Phaoa Ho mka be r h wae) , C A SE N O .7: 2W 00079 1 Pl ntf , ai if G M O R AND UM O PN ON LORIBETH PHI G SSEK e a. PPSt 1, By:GlnE. nmd e Co Chi fU nie St t s Di t i tJudge e t a e s rc D ef endnnt . s Pr K pli if AbdulHa o antf, mzaW aiMuhammad tt thn d' ,a. a.Robe tPhaoah l û l mma ' k. M l r r . Ho r ,mo sf rG n ij n to ( r p c l e r l g' i t sco e c s ,ba e o alg d wad ve o t n u cin p os e ti ) ei ' n hi l s d a e s d n le e a v e v r a tr asa d d r g tr c mme t b p io of asatrt ej r tilc n u td i t i eb l h e t n e o ao y o n s y rs n t l fe h u y ra o d ce n hs ki c s o Fe r ay 6 7 2 4. Thejly f t f rt ed fnd ns Afe M u a dr t e t ae n b u r - , 01 t omd o h ee a t. tr h mma e= d o r Re On o S aePrsm,s p r io y s r e n sHala d Me sr( h b n ofad fn a ti d i n tt it u e vs r e g a t l n se t us a d he ee d n n t s cae) algedl t e tned t be t up Mthn hi s le y hrae o a l mmad i he fls a a al i t s c s . f ie n ppe n hi a e1 M u n d a k t c u tf ra i daeijmcin dr cigt a s r e n sHala dM e s r h mma s s he o r o n mme it nt to ie tn h t eg a t l n s e ha no c ac wih M uhn a ve ont t t mm d. The c u tc n tu sMu a d' s b sin a a moi n fr itro u o y ijmci o r o sr e h mma s u miso s to o ne lc t r nt tve r i ,whih mus be de ed i t sc e,asi c e sa lge c elef c t ni n hi as t onc m le d onduc by ofi i swho a e no t fcal r t pa test t s c os d c e. How e r t c tal o co t es M thnm m a s s i s on as a ne r i o hi l e as ve , he our s nsnz l d' ubm s i w and s par t cvi aci n a wildie tt clr t docke i ass h. W hie a prs n ofk e ' e a e i l to nd l r c he e k o t t uc l i o t rs ver ltleas o di rl do notrs t c tt i lpr to s ast be a tonabl unde 42 ba lr t r na iy ie o onsi ona opori ns o o m ci e r 1 Specii l , M uham mad alegest tt e s vi y of i s s d i M uhnmm ad purs an fcaly l ha hes uper sor fcer ai f ues a e l ash itnd t d h i ç i t r c ie t e s me tè t n t t(n t e qo f n rdd on pp a , e ne s o o, e s û ng o e ev h a r ame t ha a o h r fe de i go 1 / 4 1 ' ( No.21 p.3. M u mma alge t t a o fnd r wa a s ule a s x l 2 1 / 3. ECF 5 2, ) ha d le s ha n fe e s sa t d nd e ual y s odom i by prs ofk i son December14,2013,and s ed a br zed ion t al uFer oken eye s ke and f s hed oc t our mas teh s ngoh rij i . et, mo te nures RK U. C.j1 3,ofki s ma nott eae a i t wih physc ha m f e rii hi S. 98 t al y hr tn n nmae t ial r or xecsng s c tt ina rgh t ac es t co t. Se Huds t v. Rgi ,584 F. 1 45,1 ( hCi. onsiuto l i t o c s he urs e peh Fi ns 2d 3 348 4t r 1 7 )Cç t ra o ph sc l n m t ap io e i h p rit i hi p ruto j dca rle i a 9 8 A h e t f y ia h r o rs n r f e e sss n s u s i f u iil eif s s i r sil a amo edr c me nso r srci gterg to a c s t t c t t. mpemisb e s r ie t a f e titn h ih f c e s o he ol s' r l. EA)p ei n r ij n to ma ne e is et p e e ta ij r o h nn wh c n te e G r l ay nu cin y v r su o rv n n nu y r a I mi ih o v n t movi pa t c endswa ca e by t wr c am e i t unde l ng a ton. Om eg he ng ry ont s us d he ong l i d n he ryi c i ' ' a W o l Trve v. A,1 1F.d 1 ,1 ( t Ci.1 9 ) l r M ir o t tt s Li g, 3 F.d rd a l TW 1 3 4 6 4h r 9 7 ; n e cos f An i t t .3 3 3 m i 51 5 ( hCi.2003) uha ddoesnotalget tt potntalhar hes e t prve 7, 26 4t r .M mma le ha he e i m e ks o e nt t r u h a itro u o y ij ncin aie dr cl fo tepatwr n sh h scame a ans h o g n ne lc t r nu to rs s ie t ' m h s o g e a li d g i t yr t de e he f ndant i t sca e. Ra he ,he a lgesa ne c am - t tlnname ofk i l i e t s n hi s t r le w l i - ha l d t a s nt nd o r t lae a ns hi f e r ii hi rgh t a c st c t The ef e whiehi m o i f e ai t gai t m or xe c sng s i t o c es he our. r or , l s ton or i eroc o y r le mus be d e i t sca e t c t l die tt cer t fl t m oto a nt l ut r e if t enid n hi s , he our wil r c he l k o ie he i n s a ne a s pa a e c vi ac i n. A n a o i t or rw ili s t sda w nd e r t i l to ppr pr a e de l s ue hi y. The Clr i dr c e t s nd copis of t s m e a m opi on a a c e k s ie t d o e e hi mor ndu ni nd c ompa ng nyi or rt pl i if de o antf . E NTER:Ths J l d yo Fe r ay 2 4 i A a f b u r, 01 . / P ChifUnie St t sDititJ e t d a e src udge 2

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.