-RSB Wolters v. Holder et al, No. 7:2012cv00056 - Document 17 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 7/3/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
cŠ- ' OFFt u. nl . s CE s. r tour AT M NM L VA LE, ) Fl I TH E U N I D STATE S D I N TE STR I CO UR T CT FO R T H E W E STER N D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O A N O K E D I ISIO N V JL JUL BY: AN DR EW W O LTER S, Pl ntif ai f , By: , ,. E M EM O R AN D U M O PINIO N ERI HOLDER,M A , C . C i lA cton N o.7: cvvi i 12- 00056 V. ' H on.Jacls L.K i t on ser Seni Uni StatesD i t ctJudge or ted s ri D ef endant s. And e W ole s a f de a i a e pr ee ng pr K ,fl d a c vi r ght c pl i rw t r , e r l nm t oc di o ie i l i s om a nt . pur ua t B i nsv.Si Unknow n N a e A ge sofFe r lBur au ofN a co i , U . 388 s nt o ve x m d nt de a e r tcs 403 S. ( 9 ) wi j rs ito vetd i 28U. C. 1 31 Plitf ddn t yt $ 0fl gfea 1 71, t u idcin se n h S. j 3 . an if i o pa he 35 ii e nd n a kst pr e L f mapaupei.See28U. C.jj191 a ,1 5.Thec tgrnt pli if s o oc ed q or rs S. 4() 91 our a ed antf t o runiyt s ppor hi a iai t pr e t f mapa rswihani t ac ount he ppo t t o u t s pplc ton o oc ed q or upe i t nmae c r por and s a e en ofas e s The c tw a ne pl i ift tpr o di m i s s f f i iy o e t t tm t st. our r d a ntf ha i r s s al or rvolt r fii t saeacam woul lmihi a lt t pr ee t f mapaupei. alng o tt li d i t s biiy o oc d q or rs The c tfndst tpl ntf ha a l s t eenon- bea c vi com pl i sora our i ha ai if d t ea t hr ha s i l a nt ppea s l pr vi usy di m i s d asf i ous asm a i i ,orf f ii t s a e a cl i upon w hi h r i f e o l s se r vol , lc ous or a lng o t t am c ele ma beg a ed.W ole sv. rlBura ofPrs , 10- 7,si op. 12( h Ci. a y r nt tr Fedea e u ions No. 3071 lp at - 5t rJ n. 11 2011 (ppe dimis dasfi ous;W ole sv. dea BurauofPrs , 08c 08 , ) a al s se rvol ) tr Fe rl e ions No. -v- 37, si o a 1( . La J l 5 2 0 ( cind s se wihp eu iea fi oo a df rfiig lp p. t W D. . u y , 01 ) a to imis d t rj dc s rv lus n o aln t saeacam uponwhihrle ma beg a e ;W ole sv.Hune , 1: c 02290,si op. o tt li c eif y r ntdl tr tr No. 07-vlp a 4( Col M a . , 00 )(cind s se wihp eu ief rfiigt saeacam up n t D. o. r 2 2 9 a to imis d t rj d c o aln o tt li o whihr ifma begrntd) SeeHe l v.KelrNo.11 6707,si op.a 1 ( h Ci.J ne5, c ele y a e . nsee le, lp t 0 4t r u 201 ( o bii adititcour dimis lt bec i r at r srkewhiet dimis i 2) pr hi tng src t s sa o onsdeed hid ti l he s sal s benga ae .l ac r nc wiht t e -ti pr sonof28U. C. 1 5( ,heCour i ppe ld) n co da e t he hr esrkes ovii S. j 91 g)t t ofAppe l f t Fit Cic tpr vi l a s d pl i ift henee t s i t $35 0 a s or he fh r ui e ousy dvie antf hat ded o ubm t he 0.0 flng f or es ablsh an i m i t eatofserousphysi har t pr ii ee t i m nent hr i cal m o oceed w ih a ci ls tonce t vi ui hea umultst eeC ti ,' s ntt 28U. C.j 1 5() W ole sv. de a Bur uof cc ae hr û rkes'purua o s S. 9l g . tr Fe r l ea Pri sons,N o.1030717,slp op.at2. i Pl i ifnam esas de e nt Er c H ol r t Ator y Ge r oft Unied St t s a a ntf f nda s i de , he t ne ne al he t a e , nd C.Zyc W ade oft UniedSttsPe tntayi Le Count Vigi a(C Lee'.Plitf h, r n he t ae nie ir n e y, r ni I USP ' anif ) c pl i t tc r c i om a ns ha or e tonals af r t i t d aga ns hi by e erng a l ge y f l e i i ntr por s t f e ala e i t m nt i le dl a s nc de e t a di c plna y c nd s i i r onvi tonst i r as hi s urt l vela housng c as ii a i n a t rpl ntf ci o nc e e s ec iy e nd i l s tc t o fe ai i f c pl i a om a ned boutt e t ofs xuala physca as a t 1 Pl ntf a s alege t ts a fa hr a s e nd i l s ul . ai i f l o l s ha t f t a he f r pr s r t i t a i thi by X - a ng hi m out a an t s a c f not r ede al i on e ala ed ga ns m r yi s h nd us o e r h or weapons dur ng a pri tans er i son r f . Ahe r vi w i pl i if scom pl i i t sc vi ac i n,i i c ea t pl i ifdoe not r e e ng a nt f a nt n hi i l to t s l r hat a ntf s etb iht a h i c re tyt e a yi n n tra o a y s ro sp y ia ij r wihnte sa ls h t e s u rn l md r n mmie t h e t f n e iu h sc l nu y ti h me ni of28U. C.j 1 5( .Furher e pli ifwa ho eda afderlpe tnir i a ng S. 91 g) t mor, antf s us t e a nie tay n Pen yl ni w he he i tt ed t sa ton, t , a ntf c d notha bee i i m i n ns va a n ns iut hi c i and hus pl i if oul ve n n m ne t da rofs rousphys c lha m i Pe yl ni a nge ei i a r n nns va a boutt co tonspr vi l e r e ed i he ndii e ous y xpe i nc n Vigna Ac o dngy ld s s t ea to wih u p eu iefrplitf sfiu et p yt e r ii. c r i l, imis h ci n t o t rj dc o an if al r o a h tlng f a t tm e off lng t c pl i . Se e c. Dupr e v. m e ,284 F. 1 i i ee t he i ii he om a nt e, . , e Pal r 3d 234,1 237 ( 1h Ci.2002)(ea o ngt tt tlngf i dueuponflngacvi a tonwhe L f ma 1t r r s ni ha he ii ee s ii i l ci n q or pa r spr vi i do nota y t pl i i fa t tt c ti no r uie t pe m i pl i if a upe i o s ons ppl o a ntf nd ha he our s t eq r d o r t a ntf n opporuniyt payt flngf i pli ifi i ii et pr e t f mapa rs. t t o he ii ee f antf s nelgbl o oc ed q or upei) 'Pl ntf a knowldge t t saci doe notltgaet r aedis soft ale uns iid s xuala ai if c e s hat hi ton s ii t he elt sue he lged pecfe e nd p y ia a s u t.( mpl5 ) h sc l s a ls Co . . 2 The Cl r i di e t d t s c e oft s M em or ndum O pi on a t a om pa ng e k s r c e o end opi s hi a ni nd he cc nyi Or t pl ntff der o ai i . )W( w. ENTER :Thi da of y > 01 2. 4 Sen rU nied St es i rctJudge t at sti