-RSB Watson v. Garman et al, No. 7:2012cv00037 - Document 14 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 02/29/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CL ERK' OF/I U. Dl 'COURT S CE S. S1 . A M F$ L V J N E. A V I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R T H E W E STER N D I STR I O F V I G I A CT R NI RO AN O K E D IVISI N O < EB JUL BK M A RL O N G .W A TSO N , Pl ntf ai if, M EM O M ND U M O PI I N N O JO H N S.G A R M A N ,e aI, t . D ef endant s. By: Ex c RK . DEP 'Y cLE 1 ' C i lA cton N o.7: cvvi i 12- 00037 V. . t t? r to gt 21 22 H on. ks L .K i e Jac on sr Se or U nie St e Di t i tJudg ni t d at s s r c e M a l G .W a s a V igi a i a e pr e ng pr K ,f l d a c vi r g s a ton ron t on, r ni nm t oc edi o ie i l i ht c i . purua t 42U. C.j 1 s nt o S. 983.Pl ntf na asdee ant J S.Gama t W esen ai if mes fnd s ohn r n,he tz Re ina Die trf rteVigni De a t n o Co rcin ($ g o l r co o h r i a p rme t f re to s E VDOC', ndHaol W . ake 'a ) r d Clr , t VD O C Di e t . Pl i ifa l s i hi c pl i t tprs of i i s a e de i r t l he r c or a ntf lege n s om a nt ha i on f c al r lbe a e y i f e e t a s i r s ofde t i pl ntf i m ove f om s e ton t t ge r ndif r nt o erous i k a h f ai i f s d r egr ga i o he ne al popul to ofa V D OC f iiy. ai n ac lt Prs n l b fr tec u tspan ifsmoinf rap ei nayij n to , ihl e e ty eo e h o r i litf' t o r l r n u cin whc o mi c t ea aTe r yResri ngOr r(; 'be a et dee t ha no ye bee onsnz s mpoar tani de ( TRO') c us he fndan s ve t t n s r d. Pl ntf r ques s pr lm i r eq t bl r le t ha m e or rpl ntf st a f rt e ve ai if e t e i na y uia e e i f o ve de ai if r ns e o pr ec i c t y f om s gr ga i ot tve us od r e e ton. Th pupo eo aTRO i t p e ev t sausq oa d a odpo sbl irp rbl ij r e r s f s o r s r e he tt u n v i si e re aa e n u y t apa t pe ng ltgai untlahe rng ma be c o ry ndi ii ton i ai y onduc e Se St n t d. e e khous .l v. t of e nc. Ciy Raeg ,1 6F.d6 4 63 (t Ci.1 9 )(; ega to itrm (n u cie rle i a lih 6 3 3 , 7 4 h r 9 9 $ Th r n f n ei ij n tv j eif s n e r or na y r edy i vi t e r i e ofa ve y f r r c ng pow e , hi h i t be a i xt a di r em nvol ng he xe c s r a - ea hi rw c so ppled onl i t lmie cic tnc swhihcl ryde ndi.) Imayis aTRO wihout y n he i td rumsa e c eal ma t' . ' sue t pr di notc w he e :s c fc f t i a a fdavi o a ve ii d c pl i c e r y s ovi ng i e r ipe ii ac s n n f i t r r fe om a nt l a l how t t ha i dit a ir paabl ij y,l s orda ewilr ul t t mova beor t a re mme ae nd re r e nur os , mag l es t o he nt f e he dves pat c beheadi o ii .' Fed.R.Ci P.65( .Themova mus aloesa ih() ry an r n ppostonll' v. b) nt t s tbls 1 t thei lkeyt s c dont meis ( t tt baa ofe te tpsi hi fvor a ( ha s i l o uc ee he rt,2) ha he lnce quiis i n s a , nd 3) t a a ij n to i i t ep bl itrs.W itrv. tl s Dee eCo n i.n .5 5U. h t n n u ci n s n h u i n ee t ne Na' Re . fns u clI c, 5 S. c 7,20- ( 24 2008) Themovi pa t mus c tf i wrtnga ef tma t gi notc a t . ng ry t eriy n ii ny for de o ve ie nd he r a onswhynotc s dnotber rd.Fe R.Ci P.65( . es ie houl equie d. v. b) Pli ifdoesnotde c i a e f t m a t gi notc ofhi moton f pr lmi r antf s rbe ny for he de o ve i e s i or e i na y e t bl r i fa t r s why no i s ul notbe r quied. Pl i i fdoe notes a i h quia e ele nd he ea ons tce ho d e r a ntf s t bls t the i lke y t s c d on t m e isbec us i a e do no ha a cons iutona rghtt ha s i l o uc ee he rt a e nm t s t ve tt i l i o c hoos t i c a s tc t on l ve sorhousng. Se e g. Sandi v.Conne ,51 U . 472,486e he r l s ii a i e l i e, . , n r 5 S. 87 ( 9 ) Furhemor pl ntf ac 1 95 . t r e, ai if knowldgest tt theha no ye be hame a t the e ha ha s t t en r d nd ha r a ns s gr ga e a ay f om t i a e w ho ale dl w ilha m hi . Pl ntf d not em i e e t d w r he nm t s l ge y l r m ai if oes es a i h t tt bal nce ofequii tps i hi f vorbe us he a know l dgest he i t bls ha he a tes i n s a ca e c e hat s pr e t d f om phys c lha m i s ega i Efk i nta ef e tve pe la i sr ton ot c e r i a r n egr ton. t e nd f c i na dm ni t a i f t r t publc' i e e t and i vi a f r lc ti t day-o- y a i sr t o ofa ur he s he i s nt r s , nvol ng ede a our n he t da dm ni t a i n p io i ac u s t j iir g n rlyd sp r ve o tkn S e1 U. . j3 2 4)2 rs n s o re he udcay e eal ia p o s f a ig. e 8 SC. 6 6 a( ) (ç co ts l gi s tntalweghtt a a s i tonpublcs ft ort o r ton $The ur hal ve ubsa i i o ny dvere mpac i aey he pe ai o ac i na j sies se c us db tep ei n t r l fa d s al e p c t ep i ilso f rmi l u tc y tm a e y h r l a' ei n h l r s e t h rncp e f mi y e c mi . .) Bel W o fs , 41U. 5 0 5 01. , 481. ( 9 9 (x anigta o t .'; lv. lih 4 y. ' S. 2 , 4 1 5 1 1 7 ) e pli n h t 23 29 m ai ai ng s c iy a or ra oper tng i tt ton i m a ge bl f s on a e nt ni e urt nd de nd a i ns iu i n na a e a hi r l onsder tons ... c i dy w ihi t pr nce a pr es i lexpe ts ofco r c i ns t i ai c pe ula t n he ovi nd of sona rie r e to ofi as'.Acc di y,pli iff l t esa iht rquie sf aTRO,a lde hi tcil' ) or ngl antf ais o tbls he e rment or nd ny s r equest . The Cl r i die ed t s nd copi oft sM e o a e k s r ct o e es hi m r ndum Opi on a t a com pa ng ni nd he c nyi Or t pl i if der o a ntf . ENTER :Thi x. da ofFe ua y, 2. y br r 201 ' > J t . Se 1 r Unie St t D i t i J o td a sr d udge 3
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
