-RSB Haga v. Director, Va. Dept. of Corrections, No. 7:2012cv00023 - Document 15 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 12/3/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
CLERK' OFFI t . . Dl :cOtr B CE J: S1 ) AT DANVI E. LL VA ' FI 2 - I TH E UN ITED STA TES D ISTR ICT C O U R T N FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI O F VI NI CT RGI A R O A N O K E DI I O N V SI R ALPH E . A G A , . H JR , Pet toner, ii V. DI ECTO R ,V A.D EPT O F R CO RR ECTI N S, O R espondent . JULI BY A ; . Du Ex cusax L Ci lAc i No.7: 2- v- 23 vi ton 1 c 000 ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) M EM OM NPVM O PI ON NI By: H on. ls L.K i e Jac t on sr Se or Unied St e D i t i tJudge ni t at s s r c Ral E.Ha J .aVigi a i aepr ee ng pr K ,fld a pe ii f awrtof ph ga, r, r ni nm t oc di o ie tton or i ha a c pus pu s ntt 28U. C.j2254.Re ponde fldamotont ds s , t tme be s or , rua o S. s nt ie i o imis and he i f pe iinert r s or tto o e pond e r m a ngt ma trrpef diposton.Aferr viwi t xpied, ki he te i or s ii t e e ng he r cor lg an t m oton t di m i s a di m i s t pe ii be us pe ii ri note il d t e d, r t he i o s s nd s s he tton ca e ttone s ntte o r le . e if 1. TheCic tCour ofGr ys Count s nt nc pe ii ro M a c 1 2008,o m o e r ui t a on y e e ed ttone n r h 4, t r t neg te y as i rs n n atra u yc n itdh m o fv c u t o a g a ae sx l ha ih e n e r' mp io me t fe j r o v ce i f ie o n s f g rv td e ua t ye t he a e pe a e t ttone ' ba t r 1on m i sw ho sa d a t dayc r o r t d a pe ii r s hom e Pe ii ' a al te y nor . ttoner s ppe s t t Cour ofAppe l ofVigi aa t t Supr meCour ofVigi awe et s ce s u,a o he t as r ni nd o he e t r ni r m uc s f l nd pe ii ne fl a s a e ha a pe ii i t Cic tCour,a gui t f l w i g cl m s: tto r ied t t be s tton n he r ui t r ng he olo n ai ( A) Thepr e ut fiedt e tbls t taci ha ne i Gr ys Comt os c or al o sa ih ha rme ppe d n a on t y, Vigi a,a t r cor doe nots r ni nd he e d s how t tt Comm onweat a fnnai l ha he 1h fi tvey etb ih djlidcin; sa ls e t s ito r 1 eio e h doiial b e i itda Rap Ha afro ec u to sdo ( . d j1 .-7.)t c t s P tt n r a rgn l e n ndce s lh g o n o n f o my Va Co e 826 1,wo omt i y o a i t oj c sx a pe erto ( . d j1 .- .)a t c u t o i e e tl e t swi ac i ( . f nmae be t e u l n tain Va Co e 82672, nd wo o ns fnd c n i ri t hl Va b e h d Co e93 0 1.Up nmoinb teCo n at,h Cic iCo r od rdteidcme t a n e p ru n d 7 .) o to y h mmo we l te rut u t ree h n it ns me d d, u sa t h t Vi ii Co ej1 .- 1 t fv c u t o a ga ae sx a b tey( . d j 1 .- 73 .Th a n e o r na d 9223 ,o ie o ns f g rv td e u l atr Va Co e 82 6 .) e me d d g i ct e si vedt s m ealege a t a ns t s m em i rchidr n du i t s m er lvan tm esa t ndi m nt nvol he a l d cs gai t he a no l e rng he a ee t i t he s m eplc ast orgi li cm ens. a a e he i na ndit t ( B) Co n e wa i efciefrfiigt o j c t t elc o j rs ito , u s l s n fe t o aln o be t o h a k f u idcin' v ( C) Pei o e ' rg t weeviltdwh nt etil o r a n e teidcme t ta tt n rs ihs r oae e h ra c u t me d d h n it n s h t i we ert r e b t g a dj r wih u rp e e tngt e t teg a dj r , n r eu n d y he rn u y t o t e r sn i h m o h rn u y a d t n ndme sc ngedt na ur oft ac us d c i e ;a he me nt ha he t e he c e rm s nd ( D) Co n e wa i fe tv frf ingt o jc t t ea n e idcme t. u s l s nefcie o al o be t o h me d d n it n s i The Cic tCou tdimi s d t ha a pe ii n afe co i rng t mert oft c am s a r ui r s s e he be s tto tr nsde i he is he l i , nd t Supr m eCour ofVigi ar u e pe ii ' s e nta al Pe ii rtmey tld t he e t r ni ef s d ttoners ubs que ppe . ttone i l ie he i tntpeii , a gui t s cli r ie i t sa eha spe ii 2 nsa tton r ng he nme a ms a s d n he tt bea tton. I I. A pe ii rpr dur ly de a t af r lha a c am whe : sa ec t sd lned ttone oce a l f uls ede a be s l i n i t t our hm eci a t c i rt c am ' m e isont basso a ade t a i pe o onsde he l i s rt he i f n qua e nd nde ndents aepr d a r l ' t t oce ur l ue. ' Hedrc v. ue, F. 342,359( hCi.2006 .A saec tsfndi ofpr edurldea t ik Tr 443 3d 4t r ) tt our' i ng oc a ful i e ild t apr umpton ofco r cne s pr de t f s ntte o es i r e t s , ovi d wo oundai na r r m e sa e me .28 to l equie nt r t U. C.j2 5 4 Cln o v. u c 8 F.d 1 3 ,1 41(t Ci.1 8 ) Frtt esaec u t S. 2 4 *; a t n M n y, 45 2 2 8 2 4h r 9 8 . is,h tt o r mus e i il r l o t pr e a gr t xplcty ey n he oc dur l oundt de pe ii rr i . Y1tv. o ny ttone elef s Nmm e ke ,5 ma r 01 U. 797,802- ( 991;Harsv. d,489U. 255,259- ( 989) Se S. 03 1 ) ri Ree S. 61 1 . cond,hesae t tt pr dur lr l us d t de a tpe ii rscai mus b a i pe nta a qua esae oce a u e e o f ul ttone ' l m t e n nde nde nd de t t t go n frd n i grle .Fo dv. o ca 4 8U. 41 , 2 - 4( 9 ) Hars 48 U. a r u d o e y n eif r Ge r i, 9 S. 1 4 3 2 1 91 ; ri, 9 S. t 260.A sa epr ed a r ei ii pende ' i i doesnotde nd upon a f der lco tt i l tt oc ur l ul s çnde nt' f t pe e a nsiutona r i a t qua e 'i i i tr l e t bls d a r ul ry or c it nty a i d by t s a e ulng nd d ade t ' f t s i m y s a ihe nd eg a l ons s e l pple he t t c u t Ye tsv. eo e 1 6F.d2 5 2 3 6 ( t Ci.1 9 ) o r. at Anc ln , 6 3 5 , 6 - 4 4h r 9 8 . Pei o e ag e i Cli ( t th Cic i Co r u lwf l n n e teidcme t. tt n r r u s n am C) ha te rut u t n a ul me d d h n it ns i y TheSu e Cour ofVigi arj ce t scli purua tt Slyt v. ri n, 5Va 27, pr me t r ni ee td hi am s n o a on Paraa 21 . 2Peii radde a e e ae cl m i t f r ha spetton, butt cl m m eel r sae Cl m sB a D . ttone d n num r td ai n he edeal bea ii he ai r y e tts ai nd 2 2 5S. 2 6 0( 9 4 , e a et ecam c u dha eb e , twa n tr ie dzigtil r 0 E.d 8 1 7 ) b c us h li o l v e n bu s o ,a sd l n ra o r die ta ala di notconc r aj iditona is o i feci asitnc ofc e.The rc ppe nd d en urs ci l sue r nef tve ssa e ounsl Unie St t s Cour ofA ppe s f t Fourh Ci c tha tr pe t dl r c ni ed t tt td a e t al or he t r ui s te a e y e og z ha he pr e a de a tnze s f t i Slvt n c tt e a a quae a i oc dur l f ul l et orh n a o onsiut s n de t nd ndepe ntsae 1w nde t t a g o n frd cso ' F s rv Anc ln ,1 3F.d8 5 8 4( t Ci.1 9 )(n en lq o ain ru d o e iin. ihe . eo e 6 3 3 , 4 4h r 9 8 itr a u tto s ' omitd) Therf e,heSuprmeCour ofVigi adimisdCli ( purua t a te . eor t e t r ni s se am C) s nt o n i pe nta a nde nde nd dequa esa epr edur lr l ,a pe ii rpr ed a l def ule t scai . t t t oc a u e nd ttone oc ur ly a t d hi l m A c t a notr vi a pr edzal def uled c am a e a s wi ofa our m y e ew oc lr ly a t l i bs nt ho ng f n n na mic rig o j tc o c u ea dp eu ie Ha rs 4 9U. a 26 The u d me tl s ara e f usie r a s n rj dc . ri, 8 S. t 2. e s e ofc us or na iy t ns upon a s i ofi f ec i as i t e ofcouns ,a f c or xi t nce a e di r l ur how ng ne f tve s s mw el a t e e nal o t de e et ti xt r t he f ns ha mpede c d ompla wih t sa epr e a r e ort no t of ince t he t t oc dur l ul, he vely t ecam.Co e nv. o s n, 01U. 7 2, 5 - 4( 9 ) Clz av. u rv, 3F.d h li lma Th mp o 5 S. 2 7 3 5 1 91 ; o z M ra 91 2 1 2,11 ( h Ci.1 .Se Kor hrnsv. t,66F. 1 1 9 ( hCi.1 09 04 4t r 990) e na e Evat 3d 350, 35 4t r 995) (e o nzn ac u t o sn t e t c n i e teis eo p eu iei t ea snc o c u e . r c g ii g o r d e o ne d o o sd r h su f rj dc n h b e e f a s ) Pe ii ra guesco elwa i f e tvef no a gui t t ti lcour t ta e ng ttone r uns s ne f ci or t r ng o he ra t ha m ndi t i cme swasunlwf , a dic s i r ,pe ii ne f l t sae avibl i f tve he ndit nt a ul but s s us ed nfa tto r ais o tt a e nefeci asitnc cam a t a nde i cme s Ac r ngl 1dimisCl m ( as ssa e li bouthe me d ndit nt. codi y, s s ai C) pr edu a l def ule oc r ly a t d. 1 11. A fd rlc u t yg a th b a rle fo asaec urj g n E ny o t eg o n e ea o r ma r n a e s eif r m tt o tud me t t l n h r u d o t tEhepeii )i i c t yi vi ain o t Consiuin o lwsorteaisoft Unie ha t ttoner s n usod n olto f he ttto r a r te he td Stt . 28U. C.j22544 Afe asaec ta es dt mert ofacai as rie i a aes' ' S. *. tr tt our ddr se he is l m lo as d n 3 f de a ha speii n,af de a co tmayno gr ntt pe ii unl st sae c ts e r l bea tto e r l ur t a he tton es he t t our' a j dc to so acam i c n rr t , ra u r a o a l a plc to olce rye tb ih d du iain f li s o tay o o n n e s n be p iain t lal sa ls e fd r la o b s do a l e s n bed tr n to o tefcs U. C. 2 5 ( e e a lw r a e n n mr ao a l eemiain f h a t.28 S. j 2 4 *. Thee ua i ofwhehe a saeco tde ii i t onta y t ' f 'l e ona e val ton t r t t ur c son s t r r o'or t lmr as bl c al a i a i of'f der l1 w i bas on a i pende r vi w ofe h sa r W ila v. pplc ton e a a s ed n nde nt e e ac t nda d. li ms Ta or 5 U. 362,41 1 ( yl , 29 S. 2- 3 2000) A saec tdeemi toni t ontayt 'e r l1w i . tt our tr nai s i rr o'fde a a f c içarvesa ac usonoppost t t tr c by (heUnie SttsSupr mejCo tona t'ri t oncl i ie o ha ea hed t td ae e ur q eto o 1w o i t esaec u t e ie ac s dfee tyt a gh UntdS ae S p e l u sin f a r f h tt o r d cd s a e ifrn l h n t e ie tts u rme Cour ha on as tofm a e i l i si uiha ef t . l a 41 t s e t raly nditng s bl acs' d. t 3. ' A f de a c tm ay a s i s t wr tt de t t m r s na e a i a i 'c a e i t e r l our l o s ue he i m r he l ea o bl pplc ton' l us f he l fdea c r fndst tt saec tGde iist cor c go mi lga prnci efom ghe e rl ou t i ha he tt our û ntfe he re t ve ng e l i pl ' t i r S p e )Co r' d cso sb t n e s n bya p ista p icpet tefcso t ep io rs u rme u ts e iin u u r ao a l p le h t rn i l o h a t f h rs ne ' c s . J Thi r a o a ln s sa d r i a o j cieo e 1 . t 0 A Vigni c u ts a e' Z ' s e s n b e e s tn a d s n b e tv n . d a 41 . r i a o r' fndi c nnotbe de m e unr s bl me el be us i doesno c t e t bls d Unie i ngs a e d ea ona e r y ca e t t ie sa ihe td St t Su em e C o tpr ce nton a i s i t r s tr c i no co r r t t t a es pr ur e de n s ue f he e ul ea hed s t nt a y o ha etbih dp e e e t M ic el Es az , 4 U. 1 1 (0 ) Fu te mo e ta sa ls e r c d n . th lv. p r a 5 0 S. 2, 6 2 03 . rh r r ,t ! l sae co tf cua de e na i i no t e ona eme el bec us t f de a ha asc t t t- ur a t l t nni ton s t mr as bl r y a e he e r l be our woul ha r a d adif r ntc l i i t fr ti t nc ' W ood v. ln,558U. 290, d ve e che fe e oncuson n he is nsa e. ' Ale S. 1 0S. . 41 8 9( 01 ) 3 Ct 8 , 4 2 0 . A fd r l o r r ve n ah b a p tt n ç r sl l)t (ttlc r' f cu l e ea c u t e iwig a e s eio t e l s he sae ou ts a ta i p me fndi t bes unl s( ttonelrbusûheprsl i ofc r t s bycla and ngs o ound es peii r e t t e lmpton orecne s e r co ncnge de .' M ilrElv. eke 545U. 231 240( nvi i vi nce'' le - Drt , S. , 2005)( i 28U. C. quotng S. 4 j2 5 ()1) Se . . , n v W a hngo , 4 F.d2 5 3 0 01( t Ci. 0 ) Fial, 2 4 e( ). e eg,Le z . s i t n 4 4 3 9 , 0 - 4 h r 20 6 . n ly ûe iw u d rj2 5 ( )1 i l tdt t erc r t a wa b f r t esaec u t h t i v e n e 2 4 d ( ) s i e o h e od h t s eo e h tt o r t a r mi a j d c tdt ecam o t me is' Cu lnv. n o se , 6 U. du iae h li n he rt. le Pih ltr 5 3 S. ,1 S. .1 8 , 3 8 ' 31 Ct 3 8 1 9 ( 1. 201 ) A. P tto e a g e i Cli ( t th Cic i Co r ddno h v j s ito o e t e eiin r r u s n am A) ha te rut u t i t a e mi dcin v r h c i est toc r d i Gr on Cot y. The Ci c tCo tde e ne t s c ai had no m ert rm ha cur e n ays mt r ui ur t nni d hi l m i. Se Y1tv Nume k r 5 U. 7 7 8 3( 9 )( odngt a afdea c u t a rl o a e s . r ma e , 01 S. 9 , 0 1 91 h li h t e rl o r c n ey n r a o e saec u tud me t e ltru e li dsaec u t r r u odt tud me t. e s n d tt o rj g n wh n ae n xpane tt o r odes ph l ha j g n) Pe ii rwasac us d and c ttone c e onvi t ofc m itng a a t d s xua ba t r a a da a e he c ed om ti ggr va e e l t e y t yc r a hi w ie r n outoft i hous Tralt tm ony e t bls d t tt hous w asi Gr ys n nd s f a he r e. i esi s a i he ha he e n a o Co y a no wihi t t unt nd t t n he own ofI pe nc ,Vigi a Ac or ngl t Cicui Cour had nde nde e r ni . c di y, he r t t j rs ito o e t ci n l r c e i s a dt eCic tCo r' r ln wa n t o tayt, r u idcin v r he rmia p o e dng , n h rui u ts uig s o c nrr o o a unr a o bl a i a i of clary esabls d f r ll w orbas d on a unr as bl n e s na e pplc ton , e l t ihe ede a a e n e ona e de e m i ton oft f c s t r na i he a t . B. Pei o e ag e i Cli ( a d( t a c u s l e ee i ef ci a ssa c b tt n r r u s n ams B) n D) h t o n e rnd rd n fe t s itn e y i ve no o j cigt t alg dlc o j rs ito o t ten n e id cme t. TheCic i t be tn o he le e a k f u id ci n r o h me d d n it n s rut Cou tdee ne t s cli ha no m e i, ch wasnotc r yt oran ulr a ona e r tnni d he e a ms d rt whi ontar o, ze s bl a i ton of cla l e t bls f de allw orbas d on an un e onabl dee na i oft pplcai , e ry s a ihed e r a e r as e tnni ton he f s. act A pe ii rcli i i feci a ssa e ofc ttone am ng ne f tve s it nc ouns lmus s tsy t t pr dt t e t aif he wo- onge es stf rhi Src ln v W a h n t n 4 6U. 6 ( 9 4 .Th frtp o g o Src ln e o t n tika d . s i co , 6 S. 68 1 8 ) e is r n f tika d r quiesa pe ii rt s w G ha c e r ttone o ho t t ouns lm ade e r s s s r oust tc t e r or o e i ha ouns lwasnot e f to nga t C uncini s he couns l gua a ee t dee ntbyt Si hAme e' r nt d he fnda he xt ndme ll'mea ngt t nt,' ni ha c u s lsrprs n ai nfl b lw a o j ciesa a do ra o a e e s Src ln 4 6U. o n e ' e e e tto el eo n b e tv tnd r f e s n bln s . tika d, 6 S. a 68 88. The s ond pr ofSti klndr r ape ii rt s w t tco ms lsdeki n t 7ec ong rc a equies ttone o ho ha t e ' t e t pef r n eprj d c dhi b d mo srtn at e s n bep o a iiyta, u frc u e' roma c eu ie m y e n taig d a o a l r b b l h t b t o o nsl r t s er o s t r s toft pr e ng w oul ha be dif r nt' I a 694. CA r s na e r r , he e ul he oce di d ve en f e e .' d. t é ea o bl pr biiy i apr biiy s t intt unde mi t c ntde oft out ome. I oba lt s oba lt ufk e o r ne he o i nce he c ' d. ' l a pe ii rha no s ts i d one pr oft St i kl nd t s ,a c tdoesnotnee t f ttone s t a i fe ong he rc a e t our do i uiewhehe heha s tsidt ot pr nq r tr s aife he her ong.I a 697.ç( nat ney' a t oromisons d. t GA1 tor s cs si t tar no unc tt i li vi ly c nnotbea d t t t c e t a c tt i l ha e t onsiutona ndi dua l a dde ogeher o r a e onsiutona vi ai ' Fihe v. l ,1 F. 835,852- ( h Ci.1 ) Stiklnde tbls a olton.' s r Anceone 63 3d 53 4t r 998 . rc a sa ihed l tongpr um p i n t tc tr s es to ha ouns lsco uc f lswihi t wi r ngeofr s na e e ' nd t a l t n he de a ea o bl p o e so a a ssa c l ' Src ln , 6 U. a 6 9 tudca sr tn o c u e ' r f sin l sitn e .' tik a d 4 6 S. t 8 .d iil c uiy f o nsls l l pef r n emu tb hihyd frn il a di v r ef r ( t b ma et ei n t te roma c s e g l e ee ta' n t ey fo t mus) e d o l ae h ' e mi dit tngef t ofhi iht... ndt e l t t (halnge co tfom c e' sori fecs ndsg a o vauae he c le dl nduc r ouns ls pes tvea t tme. l Sglfe tverprs ai i nots rpeci t he i ' d. tE fci e eentton s ynonymouswiher l s ' t rores rprs nain. S rng rv. li , 6F.d3 , 3 ( t Ci. 9 ) e e e tto ' p i e Co l 58 2 29 3 2 4 h r 1 78 . ' ns Asd s u s ds p a peii n rs u idcin lag me th dn mei.Th s c u s l ic se u r , t o e 'j rs ito a r u n a o rt u , o n e t c d notbe dei e f notr sng afi ousa gume ,a pe ii rcoul notha be n oul fcint or aii rvol r nt nd ttone d ve e 6 prj dc db c u s l t r uigtecam.Se s ..Src ln , 6 U. a 68 . a tnv. eu ie y o n e no a g n h li e ec, tika d 4 6 S. t 9, no Cl Bar 8 6F.d 1 5 1 5 ( t Ci.1 8 ) i, 2 2 3 4, 3 9 4h r 9 7 . Ast t ecam c t e wa ief cief rn to j ci gt tea n e i dcme t,h o h li o ms l s n fe t o o be tn o h me d d n it n s te v Cic i Co r d tnnie c u s lwa n t e iin f rn t kngt i fi oo so j cin Th rut u t ee n d o n e s o d fce t o o ma i hs rv lu be t . e o i cm e swe en e ndit nt r m nded t upda epe ii rsna fom Raph Hagat Raph Edwa dHa o t ttone ' me r l o l r ga, J. n tec r e fo o c u to s o ,woc u t o a i t o j c sxu l e tain r a d h hag s r m ne o n f od my t o ns f nmae be t e a p nerto , a t c nd wo ount ofi ce lbe tesw ih a c l t fve co t ofa ava e s xua ba t y. The s nde nt i r i t hid o i un s ggr t d e l ter Cic tCour dee mi dt tVigi aCodej 1 2- pemit it a ndt i cme s rui t tr nt ha r ni 9. 231 r ted t o me he ndit nt be us t a e e sdi no c ca e he m ndm nt d t hanget natr o c r c e oft c r d ofens , nd t he tle r ha a t r he ha ge f es a he Supr meCour ofVigi a f e t r ni ound no r veri ee r ri t Cic tCour' a yssofVig ni e sbl r o n he r ui ts nal i ri a l . aw Theorg na i c ment i onned peii roft na ur a c r t roft i i l ndit s nf ttone he t e nd ha ac e he a c a i f t over acshecomm itd on s ii c l e durng as cik tm ea a c us tons or he t t te pecfc hidr n i pe t i t s c fcpl e.The Cicui Cou ta e d a1 t i c men sf t s m eac st agg a td pe ii ac r t r m nde 1 he ndit t or he n t o r vae s lba tr andt ame d i cm e sr t i d t s m ec r c e oft orgi lc r ed exua te y, he nde ndit nt e ane he a ha a t r he i na ha g s xua c i agans t s m emi s Ame ngt i cm e st mor a cur t y r fec e l rmes i t he n nor . ndi he ndi t nt o e c ael e l t pe ii ne ' l ga nam e a t a hor z a g ea e punihm e t n t of e esc ge i t tt o r s e l nd o ut i e r t r s nt ha he f ns har d n he orgnali cm e sdi notc ng t naur orcha a t roft orgi lc r .Kel v v. i i ndit nt d ha e he t e rce he i na ha ges le Co n at,1 0Va 5 2, 3 1 S. 43 , 4 ( 9 4 .Fu te mo e iwa n t e K mmo we 1h 4 . 2 5 2, 25 E. 7 4 0 1 2 ) rh r r ,t s o p r p eu iilta tea nd n so c re s v r l a sb f r til S eBr o ma v. rj d ca h t h me me t c u r d e ea d y eo e ra . e o k n Co n at,1 Va 5 2, 2 1 S. 3 8 3 9( 9 )( od n n n me t nd yo til mmo we 1h 51 . 2 5 4, 45 E. 5 , 5 1 28 h li g me d n o a f ra wasnotprj cil.Mor r Vigi aco t ha ra fnne t ta a ndme t a eudi a) eove, r ni urs ve e fi d ha n me nt o n i c me t tdoe no c ndit nt ha s t hanget naur orc r troft c r d ofens s a oc ure i he t e ha ace he ha ge f e , s c r d n peiine ' c s i pemitdbyVigi aCodej1 2tto rs a e,s r te r ni 9. 231.Se e. ,Edwadsv. e. g. r Co n at , 8Va 9 4 2 3 SE.d 8 4( 9 8 , a k o v Co n at No. 38 - 1 mmo we lh 21 . 9 , 4 . 2 3 1 7 ) J c s n . mmo we 1 h, 0 5 1 1 201 Va Ap LEXI 2 4 2 2W L 2 2 4 (uy 1 , 01 )( n u ih d ; ula v , 2 . p. S 2 , 01 7 8 41 J 1 0 2 2 u p bl e ) P l m . s i Co n at 5 Va Ap 71 , 5 1 , 8 S. 2 9 0, 3 1 ( 0 .Se as S ap v. mmo we 1 5 . p. 0 71 - 7 6 8 E.d 1 91 -4 201 ) e lo h r e h, Bel5 3F.d 3 2, 8 (t Ci. 01 )(e esn ad src c u tsç s ud d' o cu int a l 9 3 7 3 3 4h r 2 0 r v rig itit o r' û g ie 'c n l so h t , mi i c dde e m i a sae c ti orecl decded asa elw is whe g a i r le f ra t oul t r ne t t our nc r ty i t t a s ue n r ntng ei f o n ie fciea ssa c o c u e cam) Ac o dn l c u e d dn trnd rief ci e n fe tv s itn e f o ns l li . c r igy, o ns l i o e e n fe tv as it nc a t Cic tCour ' r lng w a notc r r t ora unr a ona e a i a i of s s a e, nd he r ui ts u i s onta y o, n e s bl pplc ton , c e ry esa ihe f de al1 w o ba ed on a unr as bl de e mi ton oft f c s l a l t bls d e r a r s n e ona e t r na i he a t . IV . Fort f e ngr as ,Igr ntr s he or goi e ons a e ponde ' moton t dim isand dimist pe ii n nts i o s s s s he tto f awrtofha a c pus Bas d upo m y fndi t tpe ii rhasno madet r st or i be s or . e n i ng ha ttone t he equiie s b tnil h wigo ad nilo ac n t ui n l ih a r q ie by2 U. C. 2 5 () a u sa ta s o n f e a f o si to a rg t s e ur d 8 S. j 2 3c , t c rii t ofa albiiy i de ed. e ttcae ppe a lt s ni TheCl r i dieced t s nd a c oft sM e a um Opi on a t a co pa ng ek s r t o e opy hi mor nd ni nd he c m nyi Or t peii ne a co elofr cor f rr s der o tto r nd uns e d o e ponde . nt gf dyoDee e,02 a f cmbr21. ENTER : s Thi - / Se ' Unie St t s Di t i tJ or t d a e sr c udge 8