-RSB Garn v. Duffield Regional Jail, No. 7:2012cv00007 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 01/11/2012. (kab)

Download PDF
r FRKS OFFI U.. SX COURT d CE S DI A R0A)i KE, T ') VA : ' , A 1i f9 2':: 7 -7 , I TH E U NI N TED STATE S DISTR I C O U RT CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O A NO K E D I ISIO N V JA M ES C UR TI G AR N , S J A a -z b, k. sv; 21 22 // ,ua 1 CuK , o cus- CA SE N O .7: 12CV 00007 Pl ntif ai f , M EM O R AN D UM O PI O N M V S. DU FFI LD R EG I N A L JAI E O L, By: G l n E.C onr e ad Chi Unied St es D i ri Judge ef t at st ct D ef endant . ie hi vi i s c i J m esCuri Gn n, Vi gi a i a e pr e di pr K ,fl d t sci lrght a ton a ts r a r ni nm t oc e ng o . purua t 42U. C.j 1 al i t tat s nt o S. 983 legng ha lhoughherc ty dic r dt theha He tts e enl s ove e ha s paii C, eh sn t e p o i dte t n a teDufil Re in lJ i (t ej i' ,nvolto o h s h a o be n r vde r ame t t h fed go a al th al) i i ain f i t ' c tt i na rg s Upon r viw oft r co d, hec tfndst tt a ton m us be onsiuto l i ht . e e he e r t our i ha he c i t s ma iy dim is um rl s s ed. G n n a l st f l i s r e f t r l t t hi c a m s A f e l ar ng ofhi r lege he olow ng pa s ac s e a ed o s l i . t r e ni s He ttsdignosson De e be 25,2011 Ga n a ke t nur esaboutge tng te m e f t pa ii a i cm r , r s d he s ti r at nt or he die s .A n retl hm t a heé o dn tg tte t n'a teji b c us Cti t o sae u s o d i h t t ul o e r ame t' th al e a e t s oll c i expe i ' The docorl trga Ga n t s me i or ton. Ga n t l d t t c pt n and nsve. ' t ae ve r he n nf ma i r ake o he a ai ohe ofie s t noaval Hea s rs &( 1 isdoi i getngworee r t r fc r,o i. s e t,1A11t ng s ti s veyday (ilwihoutme sc t getng team e t t1ne d and de e v ' Ga n doe no sa ewha f nn ofr le hes e ti r t nt ha e s r e. r ' s t tt to e if e ks t ough t s l w s t hr hi a ui. 1 1 The c ti r qui e t di m i s a a ton orc a m fl by a pr s our s e r d o s s ny c i l i ied i onera ns a gai t gove m e a e iy orof i eri t c tde e m i t a ton orcl m i f i ous m alci , nl nt l ntt fc f he our t r nes he c i ai s rvol , i ous o fist saeacam o wh c rle ma b g a td.28U. C. 1 5 b)1.l o d rt r al o tt li n ih eif y e rn e S. j 91 A( ( ) n r e o saeacam i a yf d rlcv l cin,h panifsk ta t l l g to smu t ee o g t tt li n n e ea ii a to t e litf ll cua al ai n s b n u h o g e r i e a r ghtt r le a a s i o e i f bove t s ul tve l vel' t one t ti l a i e on isf c ' r t r he pec a i e ,' o ha s l us bl pl t a es a he ' t nmeeyC onceva e.'BelAt.Cop . Twombl 550U. 5 570( ha rl t i bl ' l l c v. y, S. 44, 2007) . û- a g toc l ovemi bodis... a bes diecl unde j 1 f mo tr de aaor l ng e c n ued r ty r 983 or nea y, clrt y, o ijmci er l f e e. .h a to ta i alg dt b u o si to l mp e n so r n t tv ei wh r . t e cin h t s l e o e nc n tt ina i lme t r e e u e ut s apolc s a e ent or na e, egul ton,orde s on of i i l a ed a xec e i y t t m , di nc r a i ci i f c aly dopt nd pr omul t d by t tbody' ofi r a M o l v. w Yor Civ De .ofSoc a Se vies 436 ga e ha s fce s' nel Ne ' k t pt il r c , U.. 5 , 9 ( 9 8 .Top o ta ag v rme tl n iy s c a alc l ali la l f r S 6 8 6 0 17 ) r ve h t o e n n a e tt , u h s o a j i, s ib e o c tt tonalvi a i c m it d by isem pl s pl i tf m us s ons iu i ol tons om te t oyee , a n if t how t tt e iy' polc ha he ntt s i y wasç hem o ng f ceoft c tt i na vi ai ' Pol Count v.Dods 45 U . 31 û t vi or he onsiuto l ol ton.' k y on, 4 S. 2, 3 (1 ) 26 981. Th o l d fn n t tGanha na d i ti c s i tej i.Hi c mpli t o sn t e n y ee da tha r s me n h s a e s h al s o an d e o o fra idc to h we e, h thealg dvilto c mmitd a ans hm byj i fe ny n iain, o v r t a t le e oains o te g i t i al e o e sweei f rh rn eo j ip lc Th rf r , sc mp an d e n t l g f cs mply e r n u te a c f al o iy. eeo e hi o lit o s o al e a t e saiga ya to a l cam a an t h j i. ttn n ci n be li g i s t e al M or over e n i t c t l e G a n t n e t na e i vi e , ve f he our alow d r o m nd o m ndi dualof i i s a f c al s def nt ,he doe notalege f c s s a i a c tt i na cl i a ns a enda s s l a t t tng onsiuto l a m gai t nyone A pr s . i on ofk i ' dei r t i fe e et a i ae' s ro m e ca nee vi a e t Ei ht t als lbe a e ndif r nc o n nm t s e i us di l d olt s he g h Ame nt Se Esel v. mbl 429U. 97,1 2 ( 976) A co tt i vi ai i t s ndme . e tle Gn e, S. 0 1 . nsiutonal olton n hi c ne tiv l e b t a o j ciea das be t c mp n n .Theo j ci ec mp n n i me o tx n o v s oh n b e tv n u j ci o o e t ve be tv o o e t s t i t de i toni çs fce l srous'Fame v. e n,511U. 825,8 ( 994 .A f he prvai s lufiinty e i . r r Brnna ' S. 34 1 ) s tcen l s rousm e c lne d i çonet thasbe n dignos d by aphyscin asm a tng ufi i ty e i di a e s l ha e a e ia nda i te t ntoronet ti s obvi t teve a1 pe s wo d e iy r cogni t ne s iy r a me ha s o ous ha n ay r on ul asl e ze he ce st frad co ' a tnin. l ov S e e 5 5F.d2 5 2 ( t Ci. 0 ) Thes be tve o o trs te to ' k . hrv , 3 3 2 , 41 4h r 2 08 . ' u j ci c ompo nti m e i aprs ofi ili û i r t y i fer nt't ti i he t ne s t f ion fca s t be a el ndif e ' ha s f t del knowsofa nd di r ga dsa e es i r s t i a e he t o s f t ' Fn r 511 U . a 837. s e r n xc sve i k o nm t alh r a e y.' nne , S. t A c am c er ng a dia e ntbewe n a i ae a m e c pe s l i onc ni s gr eme t e n nm t nd dial r onne r r ng l ega di di gnos s a co l s oft e t en doesnotge r ly i plca e t Ei h Am e a i nd tr e r a m t ne a l m i t he ght ndm e . W rght nt i v. l n , 6 F.d 8 , 4 (t Ci. 98 ) eto o me ia j g n aeno s be t o Col s 7 6 2 41 8 9 4 h r 1 5 .Qu sins f dc lud me t r t u j c t i j cilrviw underj 1 3.Rus elv.Shefe,528F. 318( hCi.1975) M o e r udi a e e 98 sl fr 2d 4t r . r ove , me c mal a tcedoesnotsae af de a c am ,Ese l 429U . a 1 1 nordoesm e e di al pr c i tt e r l li tle, S. t 05- 06, r ne i nc i dignoss Sos be v. ur hv, F. 1 ( hCi.1 . glge e n a i. e e M p 797 2d 79 4t r 986) G n n m a be a e t pr t he hasa s rous m edi alc ton, e tt sC , f r y bl o ove hat ei c ondii H pa ii and or pur e oft sopi on,t c t ilas um e w ihou tndi t the s f r f om t sdi ea e pos s hi ni he our w l s t t i ng ha uf e s ' r hi s s . Gand e n tho ve, l g fcsidc tngt a j i o t as f i r t p o i ehm wi r o s o , we r al e a t n iai h t al f l' al e o r v d i t e ki u h te t n o ti d s a ed rngh si c r eaina t ej i i ce tnga e c s iers t h s rame t f h s ie s u i i n ac rto t h al s rai n x e sv ik o i h at o s ft .Ga nsae nofcss g e tn t a a yme ia p o e so a , ttej io a e lh r aey r tts a t u g sig h t n dc l r f sin la h al r t a o he me c lf c lt ha i onne hi t thi die er uieste t e a t stme. ny t r di a a iiy, s nf d m ha s s as eq r r am nt t hi i M o eove ,Gn ndoesnota lget thei e re i a s c fc s r r r le ha s xpe inc ng ny pe ii ympt swhi h c us hi om c a e m dic f r orpan.Nordoe hepr de a a lga i ordoc e ai i c tng t ta s om o t i s ovi ny le ton um nt ton ndi a i ha ny pa tc a team e f rt diea eis fi a l eora o it i hi pr s ntsa oft riul r r t nt o he s s tel s vaiabl ppr pra e n s e e t ge he il s Fort e r s , s c r nta l ga i f i t s a e a cl i t the ha a s r ous lnes . hes ea ons hi ur e le tons a l o t t a m ha s ei m e ca nee f team e a t stm e. di l d or r t nt t hi i Mor i tnty, doesnotalgef t i c tngt tj lofi il know ofa e mpora l he le acs ndiai ha ai tcas ny s cii tea m e m a t d by hi c r ntc pe tc r t nt nda e s ur e ondii M e c ofk i sha i onned hi , ton. di al t al ve nf m g n r ly t a He aii C te t n saee pe sv a dwil o b p o ie t j i imae . e e al ,h t p tts rame t r x n i e n l n t e r vd d o al n ts U nl s G n n de o t a est tt s ofk i l know t the hasa s rousm edi lnee f t s es r m ns r t ha he e t a s ha ei ca d or hi e nsvete t e rghtno , we r hef ist sa eacli t tt i f l et pr vi t s xpe i r am nt i w ho ve , a l o t t am ha her aiur o o de hi t e t e c tt esdelber t i f er nce i vi a i oft Ei h A m e r a m nt ons iut i a e ndi f e n ol ton he ght ndm e . nt Fort ras sae t c tdimis sGa n' c antwihoutprj e purua he e ons ttd,he our s s e r s ompli t eudie, s nt t j1 5A( ( ) f fiur t saeacli TheClr i diecedt sndcopi oft s o 91 b)1, or al e o tt am. ek s r t o e es hi m e or ndum opi on a a com pa ng or rt pl i if m a ni nd c nyi de o a ntf . ExvsR:Thi tl s / d yo a u r , 201 a rln ay 2. ChifUnie Stt Diti tJ e t d a es src udge 4

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.