-RSB McLean v. McBride et al, No. 7:2011cv00597 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 12/21/2011. (tvt)

Download PDF

r FRK' OFFI U,. SX COUA d S CE S DI AT RCANOKE, VA rlir 7d -. ) . I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STRI T O F V I G I I C R N A R O AN O K E DI I O N V SI QUENTI M CLEAN, N Pl nt f , ai i f V. DR.M CBRI e c/, DE, t . D e e nt . f nda s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) DE2 2 1 2 1 21 J A fI-' u 'T ULI > ' Ã»' CLERK e f BY; Ci lA c i N o.7: v00597 vi t on 11c M EM O M N D U M O PI O N NI By: Sam ue G . is l W lon U ni e St e Di t i Judge t d at s s r ct Pl ntf Quentn M c n,a Vigi a prs r pr e ng pr s brngs t s a ton ai if i Lea r ni ione oce di o e, i hi ci purua t 42 U. C.j 1 a i tDr M c i a t nuresa RedOni Stt Prs he s nt o S. 983 gans . Brde nd wo s t on ae ion i ntfeso y asJ Does M cLe n alege t the hasa s n c ton and t tDr M cBrde de ii nl ohn . a l s ha ki ondii ha . i ha ia s s d' hi s n c ton but ha f ied t pr de a s is es e ' s ki ondii s al o ovi dequae medi lteam e f i, t ca r t nt or t a r nty r l ng i t d on a towe lve nur e'f te t t M cLe a gue t the ne ds ppa e l eyi nsea s r e l s ' or r a men . l an r s ha e i me ae a a opra e m edialca e f r hi die e whih,ac di t M cLe n,bec m di t nd ppr it c r o s s as c cor ng o a omes tll lrbl patt rquie tmerme' Att s metme M cx n c de t ta trhi Ã§incza e s he e rd i fa .' he n i , lea once s ha fe s i ta appoi m e wih D r M cBrde,1 b w o k wasdone a M cLe m etw ih t nlr e w hos nii l nt nt t . i a r nd an t he z s e c s ofte t tM cea a r ntybe ive t be i de t oure r a men l n ppa e l le s o na quae. Fe a Co t ha dim is d a las tle ofM cle n' pr vi prs der l urs ve s s e t e t ir e aa s e ous ionerc ompli s ant e or wi p eu ief rf i et saeacam p rua tt 2 U. C.j 1 5 e( )B)i . Ther f e, t rj d c o al o tt li u s n o 8 S. h ur 91 ()2 ( (i 1 ) M c a n m a notpr ed wih t s a ton unl she eiherpa t $350. flng f ors lea y oce t hi c i es t ys he 00 ii ee hows t th i t n e i ne tda g ro s ro ph sc lij r ' 2 U. C.j 1 5g . Th c u t ha e s t d r mmi n n e f eius y ia n u y. 8 S. u ' 91 ( ) e o r fnd a t sjmcl e h we e , h tM c a salg to saen tS ufiin l s e i c' o t i i s t hi t tr , o v r t a Le n' le ain r o t fce ty p ct 'fr hs z s i c u t oe au t ide e de tyth i n n eo d n eo n s o t tr a (e fc s' S e o r t v lae n p n nl t e mmie c r a g r us e s f he h e t h ) a e , e t ' 1 See M c ae n v.Fa s,No 2: c 6 ( D.Va Jn 2 1 9 )(imisd wi p eudc f rfi r t saea t a u t . 99 v 25 E. . u e 9 9 ds se t rj ie o al e o tt h u cam) Mcaa v. liz No 799 v 41( . . . uy2 1 9 )( imisdwihpeu iefrfi r t saea li ; le n Bol , . : c 3 W D Va J l 6, 9 9 ds se t rj dc o al e o tt n u cam) Mcaa v Untd Sae , . 0 c 4 7( D. . p.1 2 0 )(imisdwi p eu iefrfi r t li ; le n . i tts No 2:6 v 4 E. Va Se t 2, 0 6 ds se t rj dc o al e o e h u saeacam) Th c utnoe t ti Mcxa v Untd Sae,5 6 F.d 3 ( t Ci. 0 ) t UntdSae tt li . e o r ts ha n l n . ie tts 6 3 91 4h r 2 09,he i tts e Cour ofAppe l f t Fourh Cic t satd t M c n w a no a t e srke . Howeve ,a r t c t t as or he t r ui t e hat Lea s t hr e-ti r r Ae he our atr t dititc tsdim is ofM c aa sca ef f iur t saeacli ,M cLe r ceve hi t r srke. fimed he src our' s s al te n' s or al e o tt am an e i d s hid ti Asnoe b tedisn i ta c s ,tg ie ta temao i a re ta Mc a h sa latwop e iu srk s td y h se t n h t ae Ã§ lv n h t h j rt g e s h t Le n a te s t rvo s tie , l y M c aans dheea bedee e at ee srker' le houl r Aer m d hr -ti . ' M ic elv. d r lBu e u o Prs ns 5 7 F.d 41 , 21( C.Ci.2 0 )2 A c o di y, t th l Fe e a ra f io , 8 3 5 4 D. r 0 9 . c r ngl he c u td nish smoi n t p o e d i f r pa pe i pls a tt 28 U. C.j 1 5 g ,a d o r e e i to o r c e n o ma u rs t u n o r S. 91 ( ) n ds se h sc mp an wih u p eu ie p r tig M cua t r fl wih u p e a me to imiss i o lit t o t rj dc , e mit n le n o eie t o t r p y n f t flng f e s d he s y s tcint s c fc de he ii e houl uppl ufi e pe ii s monsr tng t t he i i da r of ta i ha s n nge . i m i nt s rous phys ca i l y. m ne , e i , i l n ur 3 ENTER:Thi 21s da ofDe mber 2011 s t y ce , . z ' M IQ TED S J TATESDl rm c'J sr r UDGE 2Thought pladi sa dsm i ae byt Supr Cour i As r t .lba,1 9S. .1 3 (0 9 he e ng tndar cultd he eme tn hc of v q l 2 Ct 9 7 2 0 ) r quii ac e rng ompl ntt c t n s fci f t matrt saeacl m t r ift ti plusbl o isf ea yt ai o onai ufi ent acual te o tt ai o ele ha s a i e n t ac ppl o teu d ryn c mpan i I sa i g a td,i e c n iei I eiiii ,( ec u tc niu l) igte h n elig o litf FP tms s rne f n o sd rng FP l bly t o r) o tn es usn h wh g t h ta tonalsanda dsa i bl t pladi bypr s prs r . M ic l 587F. a 420.Bute nunde t e r dii t r pplca e o e ngs o e ione s' thel, ' 3d t ve r hos sa ds tndar , t prs rsf malalgato mus bes fci l s cii f ust i e t tt prs rhasa he ione ' ac le ins t ufi enty pe fc or o nfr ha he ione srousdie ea t tprs ofk i sha f ie t te i.Abs nts h alegai ,weha no ei s as nd ha ion t al ve ald o r at t e uc l tons ve bai fre au tn t i n nc o d n ru n s o tetra tep io rfc s ( neswe ss o v laig he mmie e r a geo s es fh he th rsne a e . Ulls rquieprs ner t demo taet a ua e senc ofa i ne t r at ot m iediqualfed e r io s o nsr t he ct l xit e n mmi nt h e , he s s ii fl sc d o ai l sa ussmpl by a ngge alale insofe nge me . ier oul bt n FP tt i y ddi ner lgato nda r nt l He c M cle n ha alged as rousdie ebuti doe no a rt tprs n ofki sha r f edt tea i. d. r , aa s le ei s as t s t ppea ha io t al ve e us o r t t Rahe ,i a r t tt y haveteae i i ama r f und t bea opra eby heat ca epr e sonal t ugh t r t ppeas ha he r td t n nne o o ppr it lh r of s i s ho notby McLea M clea sltga i hit r dicl csanumbe ofs h diput .Se e. ,M c nv. ila , n. a n' ii ton so y s os r uc s es e. g. Lea W lims 7:4CV 5 ( D. . 0 5 ( c t nr #1 , pi o n tn afd vto n reta Mc a s u h me ia 0 81 W. Va 2 0 ) Do ke e ty 5 o nin oig fia i f us h t Len o g t dc l team e f ac ablse ,orr dnes whih hewr y beivedt beher a t ta t etm eshediag e r t nt or ne, itr e s c ongl le o pes nd ha t hos i s r ed wi teisi to a p ysca r g r i hste t n)Mc a v. mi , 0 CV 5 4( . . . 0 ) Do k t t h n tuin l h iin e adng i rame t; Le n S t 7:7 h t h 8 W D Va 20 7 ( c e e ty#5 o iinn tn ta Mc a c mpan dta h h sat t ,he maoddsae , e dij re, n te nr , pno oig h t Le n o lie h t e a rl i r u ti ie s s h a nuis a d h ui s hepesviusandt twhe he s htteame t defndantteae hi butt k ta e i a ls efi ci r r ha n oug r t nt he e r td m, oo Ã§n aser nd e s fca ous r ue' frame t; Le nv. de 7:0CV 3 ( . Va 2 0 ( c e e ty#1 , piinn tn ta Mc a o t'o te t n) Mc a Wa , 1 2 W D. . 01 ) Do k t nr 2 o no oig h t Le n c ai ofs r he da he ,lght ade s s rnes ofbr t s n br ko s we s ,a gr dua wegh ompl ned eve e a c s i he dnes , ho t s eah, ki ea ut, akne s nd a l i t ls) Mcaa v. lis 7:1CV 1 4( . Va 2 1 ( c e e ty#5 o ninn t ta Mc a c mpan d os; le n Muln , 1 7 W D, . 01 ) Do k t nr , pi o oi h t Le n o lie ng a o t p rp it me c lcr frateij r) b u a po rae dia ae o o nuy . 3Ev ni Mc a weet s p ys fce ts e iisp r ti hi t p o e d i o mapa pe i,ia per fo e f Le n r o u pl ufiin p cfc emit m o r c e nf r ng u rs t p as rm hsc re talg to st tMcaa smpydsg eswi teme ia j d me sof sd co a dn re, c i i urn l ain ha len i l ia re t h dc lu g nt hi o tr n u ss whih s e h n tato a l u d rteEihhAme d n . S eWrg tv Coln ,7 6F.d 8 ,8 9(t Ci.1 5 ;Harsv o cin be n e h g t n me t e ih . lis 6 2 41 4 4h r 98 ) ri . Murv 7 F.S p 4 9 41 ( D. .1 9 ) I ta weetec s ,h c u two l dimishsc mplitfr ra , 61 up . 0 , 4 E. Va 9 0 . f h t r h ae te o r ud s s i o an o f lngt sa eapl i ecli f rr i . aii o tt ausbl am o elef 2

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.