-RSB Atkins v. Farley et al, No. 7:2011cv00592 - Document 24 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 8/3/2012. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OFFCE U., 8% COUA 8 / 8 Dl ATM NVILE, L VA ) F! * I THE UNI N TED STATE S D I STR I T C O U R T C FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI GI A CT R NI R O A N O K E DIV ISIO N D A VI A TK I S, D N JuL - ,D L cL RK Ac E% E . B: m . Y DEp cL CA SE N O .7: V 00592 11C Pl ntf , ai if 5S r. M EM O M N D UM O PI I N N O D O N A LD W .FA R LEY ,SH ER I FF, U K , By:GlnE. nr d e Co a Chi U ni e St t sD i t i Judge ef t d a e s r ct D ef endant s. Thi pr K ci lrg sa ton,fld i t Roc ngha Count Cic tCour a s o vi i ht c i ie n he ki m y r ui t nd r move t t scour puruantt 28U. C.j1 ,i befr t c 'on dee nt'dipostve e d o hi t s o S. 441 s oe he oul t fnda s s ii motonsunderRul 1 b)6 a 1 c oft Fedea RulsofCi lPr ed ea s veal i es 2( () nd 2() he rl e vi oc ur nd e r m otonsfom t pl i if Da d At ns i r he antf , vi ki .Fort r as saedhe ei t c tc tue he e ons t t r n, he our onsr s At ns co ai a algi c tt i lcamsa tona eunde 42U. C.j 1 o r ki ' mpl nt s le ng onsiutona li ci bl r S. 983, ve whc t i e u t sjlidito p ru n t 28U. C. 1 43 Up nrviw o t rc r a d ih hs o r ha t s cin, u s a t o r S. j 3 . o e e f he e o d n t pa te 'motons t c tde e At ns motonf j he ris i ,he our nis ki ' i or udgme ont pla ngs moi f nt he e di , ton or j d me t samatro lw, n ohe p n i moins a g a t d fnd n s moinss e ig ug na te f a a d t r e dng t , nd r ns ee a t' to e kn o di m i s loft ac i f f l et s a e a c a m . s sa he ton or aiur o t t l i ProceduralBackzround At ns i taly f l t sci lrght a ton i t Cic tCour f Roc ng ki nii l ied hi vi i s c i n he r ui t or ki ham Coun y, t c s num ber 1 ae 65CL11001 394- c le ng t m edi altea m e he r ce ve f 00, ha l ngi he c r t nt e i d or hypogl e i w hie he w a i ce a e a t Roc ng m Cot y J i f om Se e be 2011 t yc m a l s ncr r t d t he ki ha mt a l ' r pt m r o D e m be 2011 1 Ati ss sS e ifDo adF. re 'h j i' h a n re K. h rz ce r . k n ue h rf n l Faly te als e d u s , Sc wat; , Cl s ii aton Of i er K .Se s a Sha a Lt St ve Shorel. l hi c pl i ,At ns a s fc i fc s ar nd nk; nd . e n t l n s om a nt ki alege ,a l s mongot rt ngs t tNureSc rzû hole t bedei rt l i feentt he hi , ha s hwa t d sq o c lbeaegyl ndifr o At nl' srousmedialnee 'r r nghi alege hy yce a'a t tot rdee nt' ki sl ei c ds' egadi s l d pogl mi , nd ha he fnda s aci r ae t hi bt asinme vi aedhi dduepr s . ( ke Enty (( ' 1 1a tons eltd o s mk sg nt olt s d oce s' Doc t r &DE' - t ' ) p.1 15. 2, ) N ur e Sc a t w ass r d w ih A t ns s a e co tc pl nto N ovem be 28, 1 s hw r z e ve t ki ' t t ur om ai n r 201 , andonDec mbe 1 201 fldanoiet r move, s ntt 28U. C.jj1 a 1 e r 4, 2, ie tc o e purua o S. 441 nd 446, atac ng A t ns s a e cour co pl nta e bis s alo tl a c t hi ki ' t t t m ai nd xhi t ' he s i ed opy oft notc i t , he i e n he sa eco t Ast gr tt ur . he ound f t r m ova ,Sc rza s rst tdelbe ae i fe e t a or he e l hwa t s e t ha i r t ndif r nce o s r ousm e ca ne a a l ged i A t ns com pl nt i a Ei ht Am e ei di l ed, s le n ki ' ai , s n g h ndm e c ai o r nt l m ve whc t i c u t a jlidcinu e 2 U. C. 1 31 S h rzt nfldamoinf r ih hs o r h s t s ito nd r 8 S. j 3 . c wa t he ie r to o j dg n o t epla ig i t i e u ts e i d s s a o t a o u e Rue 1 ()t u me t n h e dn s n h s o r, e kng imis l f he din nd r l 2 c,o w hi h A t nsr s c ki e ponde d. 1 At nshad ea i fl a ci lrght acton under42 U .S. j 1 3a i tNure S h rz ki rler ied vi i s i C. 98 gans s c wat a S rf Faly, asngne ry i n ial li r g r nghi me c lc r a t ej i i S ptmb r nd he if re r ii a l de tc cams e a di s dia ae t h al n e e e 2011 Se At nsv. h rz Ca eNo. 11 . e ki Sc wa t, s 7: CV00 3( . Va Oc.31 20l1 .Thec r s mma iy 49 W D. . t , ) ou t u rl dimis dt a to wiho tprj die pu s n t 2 U. C. 1 5 b ( ) f rf iu et saeacam. s se he cin t u eu c , rua t o 8 S. j 9l A( ) 1, o alr o tt li On D e e be 1 201 def nda sFa ly,Se r ,Sha a Shoreltl d anotc of c m r 6, 2, e nt re as nk, nd tl ie ie 2 i o s s j i e i t ermo a, ao gwih am oton t dim i s Th c u t tte plitf o ond r n h e v l 1 n t e o r noi d an if f i . dee nt motont dimisa r quie byRos bor v. rion,528F. 309( hCi'1 ) fnda s' i o s s s e r d e o Gars 2d 4t l 975 . a dwan dpli tf ta j g n mih beg a tdfrt edee d n si h ddn trs o dt n r e anif h t ud me t g t rne o h fn a t f e i o e p n o t emoin.At nsfldamo inf rj d me ta amatro lw a damo inf r u me t n h t o ki ie to o u g n s te f a n to o j dg n o t ep e d n s(mo insf j d me f) c n etn d fn a t'ag me t.Th c u t e u se , h la i g t to or u g n ', o tsig e e d n s r u n s e o r rq e td t and ha r ceved, t s a e cour , r or . se i he t t ts ec d 3 A letatons l i At ns c pl nta lgest thei s ng t de e nt i ki ' om ai le ha s ui he f nda s l rcol ofs ae lw' unde or tt a ' conc r ng e e ni vent t toc ur e a t rhe w a r c ve a t Roc nghn Count J lon s ha c r d f e s e ei d t he ki m y ai Se e pt mber7,2011. The c ompli s t o ana r tver t rt anum be ed s tofcli s a nt e s ut r ai ahe han r e am . A t ns a l gest the t d N ur e Sc a t t tw hie he had pr vi l be i ar e a e ki le ha ol s hw r z ha l e ous y en nc c r t d a teji i 20 3 t j ido t r a ds cait h dda n e hm wihh p glc mi a dha t h aln 0 ,he al co s n pe ilss a ig osd i t y o y e a n d p a e hm o as ca t o bepo to ' it ( 1 1 p. 2. At n 's miso as lc d i n pe il4 u l rin'de . DE - , 1 ) kis ub sins lo d 2 At nshass it whathe syl asmotonst deny t r ki ubm ted t es i o he emovalofhi cas t t scourt s e o hi . See DE 1 .DE 23- pp.1 1 At nshasnotfl am oton t r and t cas t t sat cour under 2, 6, 2, 9. ki ied i o em he e o he t e t 28U. C. 1 ( ) ho ve , ndha n g o so whiht d s Thefc ofAt ns c mplit S. j 447 c , we r a s o r und n c o o o. ae ki ' o an alegesa Ei h Am endm entcl m r di Nur e Schwarz'ale delber e i f e enc t hi l n ght ai egar ng s t lged i at ndif r e o s m edi ne ,a hi a l i agai tt ot def nt --concer ng hi need f abotom bunk, cal eds nd s legatons ns he her enda s ni s or t f medi r ds,and gri or cal ecor evancef m s al i i t consiutonalis ,s asdelbe t or so mplca e tt i s ues uch i rae i fer ncet medi ne de alofacces t t courtand de alofdue pr s. M or over At ns ndif e o cal eds, ni s o he , ni oces e , ki doesnots f any sat l bassf any ofhi cl ms. Accor ngl t courtlbe l consr peciy t e aw i or s ai di y, he i raly tues At ns'cl ms agai ta1 oft def ki ai ns l he endant asale ng cli sundert U nied St esCons iuton and s lgi am he t at tt i j 1 3.Asaj 1 3c an , h a to wa pr pel r mo d u rj 1 4la . Lo zv. r 41 98 98 omplit t e cin s o ry e ve nde 4 () nt Thap, 3 F. 4 43 ( t Ci. 05 (sllmo li a pr it i t fc o t ec an r iesaf d rl 3d 35, 9 4 h r 20 ) C ke va s p oprae f he a e f h omplit as e ea g qu sin.) e to ' . ' 3 At nst ed anum be ofm otonsi t s ae cour, bef eand afert notce ofr ki sl r i n he t t t or t he i emovalwas fl Her ied onl aporton oft ied. efl y i heses ame motonsi t scour. Theses a e c flngsi uded a i n hi t t t ourt ii ncl moton f appoi mentofcouns ,a moton t amend t add t cl m sand hvo new def i or nt el i o o wo ai endant, and s mo insf r udg n a amatro lw, t a to a do ume tto r a e t hi me c lcai . to o j me t s te f a wih ddiin l c n ain elt d o s dia l ms Becaus At ns i pr e ki s oceedi pr K ,t c hasnevert essconsde ed al ofAt ns's ng o he ourt hel i r l ki ubmi i i ssons n as es ng hi cl m s Forr onsdicus ed her n,t c tdeni hi motons. s si s ai . eas s s ei he our es s i i c t t tw hie he w a i r r t d a Cof e w ood Cor e tonalCen e i 2007,m ed c ls a f ndi a e ha l s nca ce a e t f e rci tr n ia tf ac omm oda e hi hypogl m i by pr vi ng t dou epori di tand t e s c dal c td s yce a o di he bl ton e hr e na ks iy. A lhoug N ur e Sc a t obt ned m e c lr c dsf At ns r t e tng t s pa tm e c t h s hw rz ai di a e or or ki e l c i hi s di al te t n ,h j i safddno p o iehm t ed u l po t nsd e a h rq e td At is rame tt e al t f i t r vd i h o be ri it s e e u se . kn o be n t ge hea ches col s a s di zi s a bl r vii whi he bei ve we eca ed ga o t da , d we t , z nes , nd ury son, ch le d r us by a dr p i hi bl s rl vel Hefl d gre nc ,s o n s ood uga e . ie iva es ome a es e t t s if whoi d ddr s d o he herf, s di not ng.'(d. hi ' l ) OnSe tmb r1 , 01 ,al fi il mo e At i t t eme ia d p rme twh r p e e 5 2 1 j i o tcas v d kns o h dc l e a t n , ee saf c d m oniorhi co ton.At nstid t r f et sm o be us hi r c e i a t f oul t s ndii ki re o eus hi ve, ca e s e r aton nd s howe prvieg we enott s r i l es r he ame a i t g r po a i a e ,a t r m wasdit s n he ene al pulton r as nd he oo ry, butsa fc i d housng hi i t m e ca uni f s ve alda .At nsc t f ontnue i m n he di l t or e r ys ki ompl i t tsa f ans ha t f onl che ked hi t per t e a bl pr s e durng t s tm e. Bas on t s a l ga i , y c s em a ur nd ood es ur i hi i ed he e le tons At nsase t t tNureSc t E hoge t bedei rt l i ferntt At ns s rous ki s rs ha s hwarz t s ) o c lbeaelyq ndif e o ki ' ei me c ne ds'ega di hi alge hypogyc mi (d. dial e 'r r ng s le d l e a. 1 ) At nsalege t tLt Shorelç ga t i e fle wiht g iva epr dur a ... ki l s ha . t l' n o ntrerj t he re nc oce e nd be de edAt nsc e ofbot me c rcor a g iva s' (d.p.13. ni ki opis h dial e ds nd re nce . l , ' ) A t ns a l gest tO fi rSha on N o m be 11 2011 ç ol i a e At ns t m ove ki le ha tce nk, ve r , , t d nm t ki o t of t botom bunk bec us s nee d i f a he i aewih no hit r a alofbeng diz f he t a e he de t or not r nm t t so y t 1 i zy o havi s i es' (d.p.1 ) Theot ri t s i hedi notne d abotom bunka t d r ng ezur . I , 4. ' he nmae ad d e t nd ol A t nst ke p i . ki o e t At nsa l st tCl s i i t o Of i e Se r s w At nson t botom bunk, t l hi ki lege ha a s fca i n f c r a s a ki he t od m t pa hi t ngs m o d hi t a he c l and a s g hi t a t bunk. A t nsaleges: o ck s hi , ve m o not r el, s i ned m o op ki l $ . knsif r dSg . aewh sae Ofie S asmlls d u (il lsae n , h dd û At i n ome t S l o ttd fc r e r e se - p sc. ttd o s e i Mr not She' doi t son ret i i t m y grevance. Because m edi never cl ed m e ort d . s ng hi alaton o i cal ear ol he t tkemeof t botom bunk,'(d. ar s toft move At nss ntt e da i a ro a f he t ' l )As e ul he , ki pe hre ys n dcasiiai ' twihfwerprvie (d phonec l,noT. , s r') (d. At ns sl sfc ton'uni t e i lges t no als V.no howe s'. 1 ) ki ase t t tSeas'a tonsvi aedhi t pr s . (d. At ns s si i iaet the srs ha r ci olt s ç due oce s' 1 ) ki ' ubmisons ndc t ha ' wa ta se rdt a o h r al o tmei De e e 201 . s r n fre o n t e j i s mei n c mb r 1 Li r l c tu At ns alegai r s t f l ngdai :( )NureSc rz bealy onsr ed, ki ' l tons aie he olowi ms 1 s hwat wa dei r t l i fe entt At ns doc e e ne d f adoubl pori di tr a e t hi s lbe a e y ndif r o ki ' um ntd e or e tons e elt d o s hypogl e a;( Lt Shoreli e frdwihAt ns us oft gre nc pr ce e;( Lt yc mi 2) . t l ntree t ki ' e he iva e o dur 3) . Shorel de e At nsc e ofm e ca r or a gre t l nid ki opi s di l ec ds nd ivanc hene d f hi c t es ede or s our pr e ngs ( Ofier Shat a Se r wer dei rtl i fe e t At ns me c ne d oce di ;4) fc s rk nd as e lbeaey ndifr nt o ki ' dial e f abotom bunk;( Ofie Seasmica sfe At nsf at burkasinme ,i vi ai or t 5) fc r r slsiid ki or op l sg nt n olton ofhi duepr s rght'a ( SheifFa yknew fom At ns'gre nce a a1oft s oce s i s nd 6) rf de , r ki iva s bout 1 he ot rdef nda s c tt i vi a i ,bu di nothep At ns Asr le i t saci n, he e nt ' onsiutonal oltons t d l ki . e if n hi to At issae t a h i se i t b mo e t a oh r ala dt r c iemo e d ma e . (d. kn tts h t e s e kng o e v d o n te j i n o e ev n y a g s4 I , p.1 ) 5. D i si seus on A. St andar ofRevi w d e Pli ifscai ca s vi amoto t dimisunde Rul 1 b)6)unls h antf' l ms nnot ur ve in o s s r e 2( ( es e S ea f c ua c e t ta l t cou tt dr w t r a ona ei e e et tt de e nt i ds a t l ont nt ha lows he r o a he e s bl nf r nc ha he f nda pl 4 I t s ae cour ac i , n he t t t ton At isas mo e fra q it n o c u s l Be a s tec ut kn lo v d o p onme t f o n e. c u e h o r d e n t a efn igt g yatre st rp ee tn ie t lilia t,h c ut laka atre o s o h v u dn o a ton y o e rsn idg n cvlig ns te o r wi s n t n y t l o t t on r es aton l s cas onl upon fndi t s a pl ntf demonsr t a vibl cl m o ake epr ent i n uch es y i ng hat uch ai if taes a e ai a e ptonalcicum sancesham pe i hi a lt t pr enthi cas . Gor v.Lee 574 F. nd xce i r t rng s biiy o es s e don ke, 2d l1 ,11 4( t Ci.1 8) Co v. 47 5 4h r 97 ; ok Boun ,51 F.d 7 9 (t Ci.1 ) Thec ur heei fnd t t ds 8 2 7 4 h r 975 . o t r n i s ha At nsf l t sat avi econsiutonalcl m agai tany oft def nda s, and t r or t cour ki ais o t e abl tt i ai ns he e nt he ef e, he t de e hi moto f ra pont ntofc uns l DE 2 6, 1 ) nis s in o p i me o e ( 3- p. 2 . i la ef t mico s ibl or he s nduc al ed.'As r tv. nbal 556 U. 66 1 S.Ct 1 t leg ' hc of l , S. 2, 29 . 937,1 949 ( ) BelAtani Cor v. 2009 ; l l tc p. Twombl 55 U. 544,570( v, 0 S. 2007)(i ngmotont ds s fndi i o imis p o el g a tdwh r plitf' fcu lalg to sd n tsaeç lu il'cam f rrle r p ry r n e ee anifs a t a l ai n o o tt ç a sb e' li o eig. e p The c pl i m us a l ge f c s s fc en Eso r i e a r ghtt r le above t s c a i l vel' om a nt t le a t uf i i t it a s i o e i f he pe ul tve e , t rby û i t )camsa r st lnefo c ei bl t plusbl ''Azi v. colc. hee nudggngj heg li cos he i r m onc va e o a i e.' z Al a 1 , F. 388,391(t Ci. 1 (is atrtoni orgna)( tngTwombl 55 U. ne.658 3d 4h r 201 ) frt leai n ii l quoi v, 0 S. a 5 5 5 0 .A Rue 1 ()moin fr u g n o tepla ig ta a s rst d fns o t 5 , 7) l 2 c to o j d me t n h e dn s h t set he ee e f fiur t saeacl m i g r byt smesa ar a i bl t a 1 b)6)moton. al e o tt ai s ovened he a tnd ds pplca e o 2( ( i Bur c Br dca tncCo.ofDea r v. ki Ra oCom.278F. 401, - ( h Ci. ba h oa si lwae El ns di , 3d 40506 4t r 2 0 )(iigEd r sv Civo Gods o o 1 8F.d2 ,43( t Ci.1 9 ). 0 2 ctn wad . t f l b r , 7 3 312 4h r 9 9 ) I a es i whehe t pl ntf ha pld s fcintf c st sa ea cai , hec t t n ddr sng t r he ai if s e ufi e a t o tt l m t our mus vi w t f c s i t lghtm os f vor bl t t pl i tf ,buttne no ac eptt l al e he a t n he i t a a e o he a n if t ed t c he eg c us onsdr wn f om t f t a ... e nota ce ast' e unw a r t i e enc s oncl i a r he ac s nd ne d c pt t u r an ed nf r e , u e s na ec usons oragument.'Giraan v. ohns 521F. 298 302 ( h Ci. nr a o bl oncl i , r s' ar t o J on, 3d , 4t r 2008)(nt lquottonsomit . Thec t ta e f t lconcusonst pl ntf i ema ai ted) our mus cc pt acua l i he ai if dr w sçonl t t e e t y a e pl usbl ba ed on t f c ualalega i . Bt z te v. he a ç y o he xt nt he r a i e s he a t l tons ' m e t Fa v, ' F.d , 1 - 3 4, 01 W L 2 9 8 4 * ( t Ci. uy9 2 2 .W h nd s si a 3 No. 1 1 2 2 2 6 5 5 , 6 4h r J l , 01 ) e imisng c pl i f f iur t s a e a c a m upon whi h r le m a be gr t c t m a c i r om a nt or a l e o t t l i c e if y an ed, our s y ons de e bis s m it i s por oft com pl nt a wher a co lcte s sbe wee d he ba e xhi t ub ted n up t he ai , nd e nfi xi t t n E t r alega i oft com pl i ' a a oft pl ntf se bis l he e bi pr is ' U nie l tons he a nt' nd ny he ai i f xhi t , s xhi t eva l . t ' td Sttse rl Consr t s l v. fl .Co.31 F.Supp.2d593,596( D.Va 200 ae x e. tucore nc. Gul ns , 3 E. . 4) (ii Fa te leI sor v.Comme calBuides I ,936F. 1 1 ( h Ci.1 ) ctng vetvil nve t s ri l r.nc. 2d 462, 465 4t r 991; s alo Anhe erBus v.Sc ee s us - ch hmoke,63F. 1 131 ( h Ci.1 ) 3d 305, 2 4t r 995 . 6 Summayj me i pr rwheet r i noge neis a t a maeilfc a r udg nt s ope r hee s nui sue s o ny tra a t nd t emo n p ryi e tte t j d me ta amatro lw.F d R. v. 5 . l 5 () A h vig a t s n ild o u g n s te f a e . Ci P. 6 Ru e 6 c . g n ieis eo maeilfc e it i ra o a l j rr c u dfn byap e o e a c o t e e un su f tra a t x ss f e s n b e uo s o l id rp nd rn e f h e de et tt nonm ovi pa t i e il t ave diti hi f vo .Ande s n v. be t vi nc ha he ng ry s ntted o r c n sa r r o Li ry Lobbv. I , U. 242, ( 986)5 nc.477 S. 252 1 . B. Aledi N eeds cal To sat ac eofa i unde j 1 3, pli ifmus e tbls t heha be n t e aus cton r 98 a antf t sa ih hat s e de i d ofrg sgua ant d by t Consiuto orl wsoft Unied Stt sa t tt s prve i ht r ee he tt i n a he t a e nd ha hi de i to r s t d fom c uc comm itd by ape s a tng underc orofsa el W es prva in e ule r ond t te r on c i ol t t aw. t v. ki , U. 42 (988) Topr t tt co s o me c lteame herc ve At ns 487 S. 1 . ove ha he m e f dia r t nt e ei d am ount t a c tt i lvi a i a i a e m us s ed o ons iutona ol ton, n nm t t how t tpe s ha r onne t w hos c r he w as lo e ae del s ca ds '6 t le co mit d e bied t i a e i f e e ' t hi ç e i m edi lnee .' Es e l v. m te xhi t t ber t ndi f r nce ' o s û rous Ga e 429U. 97,1 1 ( 976) A c tt i lvi ain i t sc e i ve bot a mbl, S. 04- 05 1 . onsiutona olto n hi ontxt nvol s h n o j ciea das be tv c mp e t Theo j ci ec mpo e t sme i ted p i to i b e tv n u j cie o on n . be tv o n n i t f h e rvain s Ss fcenl srous'Fame v.Brnna 51 U. 825,834( 994) A s fce tysrous Eufii ty e i .' r r e n, 1 S. 1 . ufiinl ei m e ca nee i çonet tha be di nos d by aphysca a ma tng team e oronet t di l d s û ha s en ag e i in s ndai r t nt ha 5 l hi pr yt pl di At nsf e n s o ea ngs, ki r quenty r er t hi exhi t aspar ofhi s a e entofhi l ef s o s bis t s ttm s cl m s;wihouts h r er nce,hi alegatonsar concl or and difcul t under t ai t uc ef e s l i e us y fi t o sand.Ther or t ef e, he courtlbe aly consr At ns's isonsasa whol ashi com pl ntand ass r i on hi i rl t ues ki ubm s i e s ai uch, eles s . . e bis i pa ti a r s i d f nd n s mo i t dimisa d mo i f r u me o tepla n xhi t,n r,n dd e sng e e a t ' ton o s s n ton o j dg nt n h e digs und rRul 1 At nss misa iina do ume t i s poto hsmoinfrj gme o t e e 2. ki ub t ddto l c ns n up r f i to o ud nt n he pe di a mo i f j gme ta ama tro lw.Thee o e t c ur mus a e st s mo ins la ngs nd ton or ud n s te f a rf r ,he o t t ddrs he e to u e t smmayj me tsa dadstf t i Rul 5 Se Rul 1 ( . nd rhe u r udg n tn r e orh n e 6. e e 2d) 6 Esele applest Ei h Am endmentt medi cl m sby convi ed prs s l i notcl tl i he ght o cal ai ct ioner . t s ear f om At ns'pl ngswhet he wasapr raldet nee ora c ct f on a t tme oft aleged r ki eadi her eti ai onvi ed el t he i he l vi a i . Cl msconcer ng contnementcondii i pos upon pr raldet neesa e t be oltons ai ni i tons m ed eti ai r o eval ed unde t Due Pr uat r he ocessCl e,r hert n undert Ei h A mendm e .Bel v.W olis 44l aus at ha he ght nt l t h, U. 5 ,5 - 38( 979 .Duepr e spr c i spuns nto adean ebeor prpe a j diainof S. 20 35 5 1 ) oc s os rbe ihme f tie f e o r d u c to guithasbeen accom pls d.1 Asa pr tcalmater however t cont soft Due Pr es Cl e l ihe d. ac i t, , he our hc oc s aus i t j l o e ttndt b c xtnsvewi t es bsa tv c nsiuto lp i i e a idvi t e n he aic ntx e o e oe e i t h u tn ie o tt ina rncpls ppl a h h e Eih hAme me tt c nvit di ts Se Hilv. c de ,9 F. 98 9919 ( t Ci.1 2) gt nd n o o ce nmae . e l Nio mus 79 2d 7, -2 4h r 99 . 7 i s ob oust te a l y per o w oul e iy r c s o vi ha ven a sn d as l e ogni e t ne s t f a doc o ' z he ces iy or trs atn in. l v S e e 5 5F.d2 5 2 (t Ci. 0 8 .Th s b e tv c mp n n i me i te to ' ko . hrv , 3 3 2 , 41 4h r 2 0 ) e u j cie o o e t s t f ' a pr s of i i i Cde i r t y i f e e ,' ha i i he (t s ofa di r r a e s i i on fc al s s lbe a el ndif r nt' t t s f t now l nd s ega ds n xce sve r s t i a e hea t ors f t ' Far e ,51 U . a 837. i k o nm t lh a e y. ' m r 1 S. t Qu si n o me c lud me taeno s b e t oj iil e e u de j1 8 , selv eto s f dia j g n r t u j c t udca rviw n r 9 3 Ru sl . Shefr 528F. 31 ( t Ci.1 ,a neglge di noss i dve tntfiur t pr de fe, 2d 8 4h r 975) nd i nt ag i,na re al e o ovi tea m e , m edi alm a pr c i do notpr e c tt i na de i tons Es e l ,429 U . r t nt and c l a tce es nt ons iuto l prva i . t le S. a 1 -1 t 05 06. A cc di y,a c a m c er ng a di a r e e be w e a i a e a m e c or ngl l i onc ni s g e m nt t en n nm t nd di al pe s me r r ng di r or l ega di agnos sa c s ofteam e doesnotge r ly i i aet Eiht i nd our e r t nt ne al mplc t he g h Ame ndme .W ra v. lns 766F. 8 8 ( hCi.1 . nt iht Coli , 2d 41, 49 4t r 985) 1. N urse Schw art z At nsr i e s t ntaly t s m e a l ga i a ns N ur e Sc a t i hi pr vi us ki a s d ubs a i l he a le tons gai t s hw rz n s e o c e, t nsv.Sc a t Cas N o.7: 1 0 3. Bas o A t ns a l ato a t as A ki hw rz, e 1 CV 049 ed n ki ' leg i ns nd he gre nc a doc e sa t c t hi co pl i t t c t ot d t tN ur e Sc i va es nd um nt t a hed o s m a n , he our f m ha s hwarz a t nd ohe alme c pe s t rj i dial ronnelddeer nedt tAt ns c ton a t yobsr idi no s t mi ha ki ' ondii s he eved t d t w ar nt... ovi nghi t do epo ton dit' nd i t a de i d t ti wa a opra e ra pr di m he ubl ri e 'a nse d c de ha t s ppr it û o contne hi i t m edi aluni f c os obs v ton ofhi s pt s ' I ,M e .Op.4t t i m n he c t or l e er a i s ym om .' d. m 5, Oc .31 2011 The c tr ed t e n i A t nsco d de onsr t t thi hypogl m i t , . our ul hat ve f ki ul m t a e ha s yce a cons iut d a s r ous m e ca ne hi s i s o di no s tt e ei di l ed, s ubm s i ns d t uppor a c ai t tN ur e Sc t l m ha s hwarz t ac ed w ih de i r t i f e enc t t tne 1 at5. t t lbe a e ndif r e o ha ed. d. Nur eSc rzas e t t tAt ns a lga i a i the i t i t nta ton a e s hwa t s rs ha ki ' le tons ga ns r n he nsa c i r s antaly t sam e asi Cas N o.7: lCV 00493,and are si iarl i uf i entt s ubst i l he n e 1 m l y ns f ci o uppor a t c a m t ts w a de i r t l i f e e t A t ns m edi lne . The c tagr es At ns' l i ha he s lbe a e y ndif r nt o ki ' ca eds our e . ki 8 s b sin a awho e i t sa to a di Ca eNo. 1 CV0 4 , idc t ta tej i' u miso s s l,n hi cin n n s 7:1 0 937 n iae h t h als m ed c s a fw a w e la a e ofA t ns hy i al t f s l w r ki ' pogl e i m o t ed hi c yc m a, nior s ondii a pr de ton, nd ovi d c r.Vaiu s bmiso si t rc r idc t t a tej i' me ia saf b s do t er a e ro s u si n n he e o d n iae h t h als d c l tf, a e n h i a s s m e ofAt ns'c r ntco ton a s s e s nt ki ure ndii nd ympt i t f l of2011, ovi d teame oms n he al pr de r t nt a ac m m oda i f A t ns hypogl ce i ,i udi r gul rt s s ofhi bl s zl ve nd co tons or ki ' y m a ncl ng e a e t s ood uga e l a a omm oda i ofhi dit r ne dswih d l s c .8 At ns a lga i r fe thi belef nd cc ton s eay e t aiy na ks ki ' le tons e l c s i t tN ure Sc ha s hwarz s d ha pr de hi t doubl pori dit ba ed o t team e t houl ve ovi d m he e ton e , s n he r t nt or r f A t ns by doc or i 2003 a 2007,r t r t n w aii t r e ve A t ns c r nt de ed or ki t sn nd a he ha tng o ec i ki ' ur e medialr co dsand te t tor r fom aphysc a whohad r vi we hi c r nts c e r r a men de s r ii n e e d s ure ympt m s o . At nsa s di a e wih t medi lsaf sdecson t ho ehi i t me c uni t ki lo s gr es t he ca t f ii o us m n he dial t o moniorhi c ton a w ih t m e c as e s e ssa fpe f m ed whiehewa t r t s ondii nd t he dial s s m nt tf r or l s he e. Suc di a e e s be w e n m e c lpe s h s gr em nt t e di a r onne and t patentove t appr i t co s of l he i r he opr a e ur e team e tdo nots r t n uppo tafndi ofdei r t i fe e e unde Fa m e a Esele.9 Because r i ng lbe a e ndif r nc r r r nd t l At ns s isonsf i t s ki ' ubm s i a l o how t tNur eSc rzacedwih delbe ae i fe e t hi ha s hwa t t t i r t ndif r nce o s me ia ne d ,h c u t rn st en re' moinf r u g n o t epla ig .F rt sme d c l e s te o r g a t h u s s to o j d me t n h e dn s o he n 7 l addr si t pa i m oton t dim i underRul 1 , t coul m a t notce ofiem s n es ng he rtes' i o s ss e 2 he ' y ake i t t i t publcr d,such ast document s n he i ecor he s ubmit i At ns'pr ouslw s t Cas No. ted n ki evi a ui, e 7:1 049 wiho tc nv ri t pe i moinsit moi sfrs 1 CV0 3, t u o etng he ndng to no ton o ummayj dg n.Se Phii r u me t e l ps v. t Cou yM e Hos 5 F. 1 6,l 0( t Ci. 0 ( ii ohe c s s; a tn- nc av. Pit nt m. p. 72 3d 7 8 4h r 20 9) ctng t r a e l M ri Ba ur ' Vigi aDept.ofM ent Healh, 64 F.S p. 72 73 n. ( D. . 09 (a ngno ieofsae r ni al t 0 up 2d 9, 2 1 E. Va 20 ) tki tc tt - he rngo f rsde so saec ur b if a o d r a data c ito saea mi sr tvehe rng . ai fke ' ciin, tt o t res nd r e, n rns rp f t t d nitai a i ) 8 I At ns'r n ki espons t Schw a z' moton, eo rt s i hea t t a tej i saft se At n 'bl d dmis h t h al t f e td kis oo s ugarand sari on Sept m be 16,2011 pr ded hi wih daiy snacksa a extam ealon da t tng e r , ovi m t l nd n r ys wh nt al y s r e t me s ( 1 pp. - l - , 3. e hej ionl e v d ' wo al. DE 8, 24; 8 1 p. ) At nspr desdocum ent i i ca i t ton Ja y 14, 201 t Page Count J l ki ovi aton ndi tng ha nuar 2, he y ai m edi saf began pr di At nsw ih a doubl pori dit ( 1 ,p. ) Co tayt At n ' cal t f ovi ng ki t e tons e . DE 8 5. n rr o kis b lelt sfc do sno s pp ta if rnc t a Nu s Sc wa t o ot r a l ia sa fkn ngy eit hi a t e t u or n n e e e h t re h rz r he j i medc l tf owi l pr ded At nsw ih tea mentt twas notappr i e f hi condii ast obs ved i, s as t ovi ki t r t ha oprat or s ton hey er t o o s ae a cl m ofdelber t i fer e underEsele. tt ai i a e ndif enc tl - 9 ra o s At isfist de nsrt t a h i e tte t j d me ta amatro lw.Th rf r , e s n , kn al o mo tae h t e s nild o u g n s te f a eeo e t cour de e At ns motonsf j he t nis ki ' i or udgme tast t sdee an . n o hi fnd t 2. O f cers Shank and Sears fi At nss sOfi r Sha a Se r f as i ni hi t mpor rl t at bunk, ki ue fce s nk nd a s or sg ng m e a iy o op at lhough t m e c saf ha notl e e ' m media l f t sc he di al t f d G ar d'hi cl c ly or hi hange.I s por oft s n up t hi cl i ,At nsr leson t o i a e r ques f m sda e O c obe 1 2011, r s e f o At ns am ki e i w nm t e t or t d t r 9, add e s d r m ki t Se s ( 1 1 pp.1 1 ) Ononefr makeda tlda 8: a. ,At nsi o d o ar. DE 3- , 2- 3. o m, r s ie t 45 m. ki nfnne Se r t thewoul lket qua iy asatusy t e n g tm ef cla ng t pod;Se r ' a s ha d i o lf r t o ar ood i or e ni he as r pons sa e C Iexpl i atusym us ge a ova t ough Ofk er ... es e t t d: t As aned r t t t ppr l hr t s You a ebo t r tom e yt ng- Nose al d.Sopl s donlj goupt se onmybe f' (d.p.1 ) On ver hi tps lowe ea e 't he tps hal ' l , 2. t s ond f m ,fl a 3: p. . he s m e da A t ns a gue t Se r t thi m e ca he ec or ied t 45 m t a y, ki r d o a s ha s di l c ton s d no pr ve hi f o be ng a tus y;Se sr s nde t s m e da ondii houl t e nt m r m i r t ar e po d he a y: Yourtusy a i ton i i t pr ce sofbei c i r d.M e c ha c e r d r t pplca i s n he o s ng onsde e di al s l a e you fom al housng r titonss t ti t ke ca eof You ar no l nge r 1 i esrc i o ha s a n r . e o r r quie t haveabotom bt o sarr srci .Thi i good. So now lc c e rd o t mk r t i e titons ss he k wih ofk e sf a oval. t t r or ppr s (#= p.1 ) At nsase t t tSe r 'rs e ont s f mspr t Sha a Se r kne J . 2. ki s rs ha a s e pons s he e or ove hat nk nd a s w , t tmedia ha notc e r d At nsf at bunk a sgnme . ha cl d l a e ki or op si nt Theco tfndsnoevi nc ofde i r t i fe e e he e.Se r 'r pons si c t ur i de e lbe a e ndif r nc r a s es e ndi ae t tt sofierha r ei dif rng a ount ofAt ns'me c r srci on t s m eda ha hi fc d ec ved fe i cc s ki di al e ti tons he a y i Oc obe ,a At nsof e sno e a ton oft sdic é nc At nsf ist ofe a ot r n t r nd ki f r xpl nai hi s r pa y. ki a l o f r ny he i o m a i s i t t Sea s o Sha k w on N ovem be 11 a 1 , 2011, ha At nsha a nf r ton how ng ha r r nk ne r nd 4 t t ki d ser ousm edi need t be ass gned t a botom bt k. l t m er y f l t ver f A t ns' i cal o i o t m f hey el aied o i y ki s at w ih m edi bef changi hi bunk as gnm ent such neglgentm i t t us t cal ore ng s si , i sakesar not e s t i tt s a e a c tt i lcl i . Se Bow rnc v. odw i 551 F .2d44, ( h Ci. ufk en o t t ons iutona a m e i G n, 48 4t r 10 1 7 )(i dngt a ( le ai n o me en g ie c , sa eo d fee c ofo no 'a e 9 7 fn i h t û lg to s f r e lg n e mitk r ifrn e piin' r a i ufi e t saeEi hAme ns fcint o tt ght ndme cli . nt am) A t ns a s pr ent no f c s s ki l o es s a t ugge tng t thi m i c as i i ato t a t bunk a t aly s i ha s s l s fc i n o op cu l pl c hi atr s or c us hi a s r ousphys ca ha m . 1 A fer shank t a a At ns a ed m ik a ed m ny e i i l r 0 t ook w y ki ' bo t m bt a sgnment anot i ae lthi see on t bo t bunk a to mk s i , her nm t e m l p he tom nyway. Ass on as o At nsla e t tSea sha r c a s/e hi t at bunk, ki t d s e a uthe ki e m d ha r d e l s i d m o op At ns ol om one bo r e r ,a At nswasr l s ii Alho At nsc pl ne aboutt lm ie prvieg i ror nd ki ec a sfed. t ugh ki om ai d he i td i l es n t eca stc to t t h do sn t l g ta h s fee a yij z d rnghi b ifsa i ta h ls i ain mi, e e o al e h t e u frd n n u y u i s re ty n h t i e uni. Fi ng t tAt ns s t ndi ha ki ' ubm i s ons do notpr s ntf ss a i a c tt i lc a m si e e ad t tng ny onsiutona l i a i tOf i r Sha and Se s ' t e c r gr nt def nda s m o i t di m i s Fort s m e ga ns fce s nk ar , 1 h ou t a s e nt ' ton o s s . he a r a o s At n fist d mo taet a hei e tte t j d me ta amatro lw.Theeo e e s n , kis al o e nsrt h t s n i d o u g n s te f a l rf r, t c u t e isAt n ' to f r u g n a t te ed fn a s he o r d ne kis mo ins o j d me t s o h s ee d nt. 3. Sherif Farl f ey At ns s e t hol t s r f la e f N m s So a t s f iur t m o de hi ki e ks o d he he i f i bl o< e hw rz' a l e o vi m a o it m e ca ca e. Thi cai hasnom e i. Thes rf rghtuly r le on t o ni of ppr pra e di l r s lm rt he if i f l ei d he pi on tej i' me ia safa t t p o e c u s o te t nt o At i ' ure tme ia h als d c l tf s o he r p r o re f rame f r kns c rn d c l s oms.M ite v. or 896F. 8 85 ( hCi.199 .M orove,ast c t ympt lir Be n, 2d 48, 4 4t r 0) e r he our 1 sC st i erv. W ae s 9 F. 1 , 38 - 381( hCi. 993 ( saeacam 0 e rckl tr, 89 2d 375 1 0 1 4t r 1 ) To tt li concer ng hazar ni dousprson lvi condii ,i a emus show t he hass t ned a s i or i i ng tons nm t t hat usai erous sg fc n me t l ph ialij r a ar s to t c le ge c ndiins. iniia t n a or ysc n u y s e ul f he haln d o to ) 1 At nsalegest Sear r ssgned hi t at bunk i realaton f a grevance. Beca e 1 ki l hat s ea i m o op n t i i or i us At nsofer no f st s ki f s act o upportt schar t i i ofSear motves he f l t s ae an actonabl hi ac erzaton s' i , ais o t t i e r t iton cl m agai tagans Se s. SeeAdamsv.Ri ,40 F.3d72, 4 ( hCi.1 9 (i igt t e ala i ai ns i t ar ce 7 4t r 9 4) fndn ha c ncus y alg to o rt ito aeno s fce tt saej 1 3cl m) o l or le a ins f ealain r t ufiin o tt 98 ai . ' At nsalo hasno due pr scl m bas on hi t por r l ofprviegesi t m edi uni ki s oces ai ed s em a y oss i l n he cal t ort cl sii i uni. Changesti a prs he as fcaton t tn ioner' l ton, vara i ofdaiy r i changesi s oca i itons l outne, n c dii sofc fn me t(ncudi a mi srtv s g e a in) a t ed nilo p i lg s(r ) on ton oni e n i l ng d nitaie e r g to , nd h e a f rvie e ae matr whihe r p ion rc na tcp t (ndwhih)a ec nemplt db hi orgna s ne cet tes c vey rs e a n iiae a c r o t ae y s ii l e tn o prs ' t ,s c ion'; hus uch hangesdo notti rggerdue pr spr ectons. Gason v.Tavl ,946 F. 340,343 oces ot i t or 2d ( t Ci. 9 ) 4h r 1 91 . co l ncudest tAt nsf ist sa e ac am t tNur eSc rzde i d hi ofco tt inal ha ki a l o tt l i ha s hwa t prve m nsiuto ly pr e t d rght , ki a s f ist sa ea c tt i lc am a i tt s rf .Se Sha ot c e i s At ns l o al o tt ny onsiutona l i ga ns he he if e w v.Staud,1 F. 791 799 ( hCi.1 ) r 3 3d , 4t r 994 .Thec r g a st s rf smoto t dimis For ou t r nt he heif' in o s s. t es mera o , ki fist d mo srt ta h i e tte t j d me ta ama trof a h a e s ns At ns al o e n tae h t e s n ild o u g n s te lw. Th r fr ,h c u t e isAt i ' to f r u g n a t t i d fn a t eeo e te o r d ne kns moins o j d me t s o hs e e d n . C . G ri evances and M edi R ecords cal At nsal esva yt tLtShoreli efr wiht gre ncepr ed e .( 1ki leg guel ha . tl ntreed t he iva oc urs DE 1 p.1 ) l ltrs s i ,At nsco ai t tShorelr ponde t g iva esa Le l , 3. n ae ubmisons ki mpl ns ha tl es d o re nc t ves 1 1 , I ,a t , 1 and 1 lhough t gr e he i vanc pr e e i ca e t tt uppe l ve gr e nce s ul be e oc dur ndi t d ha he r e l i va s ho d a d e s db t j ic p an o tes e if l mae d n t a ac nsiui n lyp o e tdrg t d rs e y he al a ti r h h rf. n t s o o h ve o tt to al r tce ih t agre ncepr dur Ada v. c 40F. 72,75(t Ci.1 , ikv. ba,9 F. o iva oce e. ms Rie, 3d 4h r 994) Flc Al 32 2d . 7 , 29(t Ci.1 91 .Theeo e ap io o fca ' fi r t c mpywihaj i' g iv n e 28 7 8h r 9 ) rf r , rs n fiils al e o o l t als re a c u 1 2 pr e ei no a to bl unde j 1 oc dur s t cina e r 983. At nsas co pl i t tShorelr f e t pr de hi wih co e ofhi media ki lo m ans ha tl e us d o ovi m t pis s cl L rcor org iva es ( 1 1 p.1 ) Ot rs si i caet tAt nswa edt s t e ds re nc . DE - , 3. he ubmisons ndi t ha kl nt o ubmi t e c esasexhi t i one ofhi l w s t . At ns ha a t c d num er c esofm e c l hes opi bis n s a uis ki s ta he ous opi di a r co dsa gre nc t hi pl adi and m otons i Cas N o. 11 00493,i t sc e a e r nd i va es o s e ngs i n e 7: CV n hi as , nd i hi sa ec ta ton. At nsf l t s iy a pariulrm e c lr c d o g iva et the n s tt our c i ki ais o pecf ny tc a di a e or r re nc ha wa una et obt n ora r pec i whih i biiy t s i s h co est ac t s s bl o ai ny es t n c na lt o ubm t uc pi o our ha a r ey afe t d hi ltga i e f t.Ther f e, saleg i n t tSho t ldenid hi dve s l f c e s ii ton fors e or hi l ato ha rel e m 1 At nsal com pl nsi l ersubmi i t tShorel' ac i cons iut dif e 2 ki so ai n at ssons ha t ls tons tt ed fer nt tet n o Atisc mp rdt oh rn tsu iyteg iv n epo e ue .Al g du e u l rame t f kn , o ae o te imae sn h re a c rc d rs l e n q a e tea mental doesnotsuppor a cl m ofconsiutonaldeprvâton. SeeM orion v. Gar a y,239 r t one t ai tt l i i rs r Mht F.d 6 ,65 ( t Ci. )(opr a e al o e to cli aItga ti s frtde nsrt t t 3 48 4 4h r 2001 t ove n qu prt cin am, ii n ç t is mo tae ha mu hehasbeen teat dif enty f om ot swih whom he i sm iary st ed and t t une r ed fer l r her t s i l l iuat hat he qual te t ntwa t r s to it ni al pu po e u dic i nain' . rame s he e ul f n e ton or r s f l s rmi to ' ) 12 phot opi f l t sa ea cai ofc tt tona sgnii a .Se Le sv.Ca ey,51 U. oc es ais o t t l m onsiu i l i fc nce e wi s 8 S. 3 351( 996)(i ngt ti t cami de a ofie r ae t a e soft cou t mus 43, 1 fndi ha nmae li ng nil tms eltd o cc s he rs t s t tt de i tonçhi r dhi efo t t purueal lcai '.Se as Si how ha he prvai ç nde e s frs o s ega l m') e lo mmonsv. Ka ra No. - 6 , 0 7W L 2 37 3 * ( D. 1. 0 7 (iigd cso )(i igt a v i, 07 31 8 2 0 9 01 , 2 C. 112 0 ) ctn e iins fndn h t i t ha noc tt i lrg t ac ofhi media rco ds.Thecour grnt Lt nmae s onsiutona iht o opy s cl e r ) t a s . Sho tl' m oton t dimis Fo t s m er as ,At nsf ist de re ls i o s s . r he a e ons ki a l o monsr et the i e ild tat ha s ntte t j d me ta amatroflw.Th rf r ,h c u t e isAti s mo in f r u g n a t o u g n s te a e eo e t e o r d n e k n ' to s o j d me t s o t sde e nt hi f nda . D . M oton t A m end i o O n D e e be 20,2011 A t ns fl d a m oton i t s a e c t s ki t a m a lr cm r , ki ie i n he t t our , ee ng o dd i oom ofiesa dee nt i t e#CL11 1 4. ( 23- ) l t smoton,At nsalge t ti fc r s fnda s n d cas - 39 ' DE 6. n hi i 5 ki le s ha n Ocobe 2011 L. ng de a ma lng one ofAt ns lte sf f da on o oc aso t r , Ga wer l yed ii ki ' et r or our ys ne c i n, be us hedi nothaves fce f ca e d ufi int undst co rt c toft c rii mai s r i e s o ve he os he e tfed l e v c he t houghthewa e At nsal ge t ti Nove be 2011 B. li nt d. ki le s ha n m r , De lngerde a d hi out ng l ye s goi m a lby t da . At ns s a est the w a st a c i i le r s a ns G a e a i en ys ki t t ha nt o dd rm na ha ge gai t ngw r nd D e lnge f t i ale m i ha i ofhi m a l li r or he r l ged s ndlng s i. Pr va e c tze cn i t ii ns nnotbr ng a d r c c i i lac i a i ta t rper on orpe ii i i e t rm na ton ga ns no he s tton f de alco t t c pe t c i i lpr e uton ofa he pe s M a ne v. yl ,477 U . e r ur s o om l he rm na os c i not r r on. i Ta or S. 131 1 (986 'Le kev. mme n,454U. 8 8 87( 981 -Li R.S. RihadD.41 , 37 1 ) e , Ti nna S. 3, 6- 1 ) da , v. c r , 0 U. 61 61 ( 973) Be a eAt nshasnorg t brnge i na vha g i t seo ta i t S. 4, 9 1 . c us ki iht o i rmi l r es n hi ur gans t s mai r he e l oom ofi r ,t c tde e hi m oto t a nd.3 tce s he our ni s s i n o me l 1 At nsi cat t when he a t ed t fl acrmi w a r agai tGa 3 ki ndi es hat tempt o ie i nal r ant ns ngweri t sat n he t e c tr ove temal ly,hema sr t ç ttdt ti wa n hi hec dd ( e a ei wasFe r l' olt r h idea t gitae ç ae ha t s ot ng oul o bl c us t s dea . ' ( 23 6. DE - ) C onc us on l i Fort r s nssaed, hec tc l st tAt ns s isons i t sc s a i he ea o t t t our oncude ha ki ' ubm s i , n hi a e nd n hi p e iusfd rla to a o t h smes be matr f it p e e tfcssaiga y s r vo e e a cin b u t e a u j d te , al o r sn a t ttn n a tona ecam unde j 1 ag ns a oft movi dee nt.Theef e,t c tgrnt ci bl li r 983 ai t ny he ng fnda s r or he our a s dee nt'motonss ki dimis t rRul 1 b)6) Fo t smer a ons At nsf l t fnda s i ee ng s salmde e 2( ( . r he a e s , ki ais o d mo sr t t a hei e tte t j d me ta amatro lw, n a c r ig y t ec u t e is e n tae h t s n ild o u g n s te f a a d c o dn l ,h o r d ne pli tf' mo insf r u g n a oh rp ndn mo in . anifs to o j d me t nd t e e ig to s The Cl r i die t d t s nd co esoft sm em or ndu opi on a a com pa ng ek s rce o e pi hi a m ni nd c nyi o d rt pl i if r e o a ntf . E R:T i ' NTE hsR dyo Au ut2 1 . a f g s,0 2 Chi fU nie St t D i ti tJ e t d a es s r c udge 14
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
