-RSB McKinney v. Commonwealth Of Virginia, No. 7:2011cv00576 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 01/03/2012. (kab)

Download PDF
CLERKSOFFI U. DI COURT CE S. ST. AT RCANOKE, VA P) 73 L I TH E U NITED STA TES D ISTR ICT CO UR T N FO R TH E W ESTERN DISTRICT O F V IRG I IA N R O A NO K E D IVISION D O N W . CK I N EY , M N J 2ù 2 1 AN 22 JULI . A BY; LEY, LERK C A SE N O .7: 11CV 00576 Pe i i r, t tone M EM O M ND U M O PI O N NI V S. CO M M O NW EALT H O F V I G I I , R N A By: Jam esC .Turk Seni U ni ed StatesD i tri Judge or t s ct R espondent . D on W .M c i y, pr ee ng pr > , fl t s pe ii f a wr t of ha as c pus K nne oc di o q ied hi tton or i be or , - puruan t 28 U. C.j2254,c le ng t valdiy ofhi c i me a t Sout sen s to S. halngi he i t s onfne nt t he hwetr Vigi a M entlHe t I tt e i Bi St Ga Vig ni pur ua t a sat c tor r of r ni a a1h nsiut n g one p, r i a, s nt o t e our de i unt r c m im e . U pon r vi of t r c d,t cour c ude t tt pe ii m us nvol a y om t nt e ew he e or he t oncl s ha he tton t bes ummaiydimis dwihoutprj c f f l et de nsrt hi exha tonofsaec t rl s se t eudie or aiur o mo tae s usi tt our r m e es1 e di . M c i y s a est the hasbe c i d s nce Oct r 1 K nne t t ha en ontne i obe 993,r l t t a pas c i i l e a ed o t rm na c r on w hi h he w a f ha ge c s ound notguit by r s n o i a t l hi o ly ea o f ns niy. n s ne page pe ii n, tto Mc n e c aln e t ej rs ito o t eW ieCo n yCic i Co r t is eo d r Kin y h le g s h u id cin f h s u t rut u to su r e s c e ni hi c i e ,s nc t orgi c onc r ng s onfnem nt i e he i nal onduc f whi h he w ascha ged occ r d i Le t or c r ur e n e Co ny M c n e a srst a ti c u t ho dod r srla e b sd o t i j rs ito a u t . Ki n y se t h t h s o r s ul r e hi ee s , a e n h s u idcin l pr e . obl m 11 1 Unde Rul 4 o t RulsGov r i j2 Ca e , h c ur ma s mma iydimisaj2 4 r e f he e e nng 254 s s t e o t y u rl s s 25 pe ii i i i cl rfom t petton t tt pettoneri notenttedt t r i s tton f t s ea r he ii ha he ii s il o he elef ought . I Vigi a,ape s f n r ni r on ound no guit byr a on ofi a t i c mit by cic tc t t ly es ns niy s om ted, r ui our or r t t t m por r c t oft Com m i s o r ofM e a Hea t M e alRe a da i a de , o he e a y us ody he s i ne nt l 1h, nt t r ton nd Subsa eAbus Se vc (iheCommisone '.SeeVigi aCodej1 2- 82. The tnc e r ies t t si r' ) r ni 9. 1 2. Co m i s one m us c m si r t onduc a t ough ps hi ti e l ton oft i vi t hor yc a r c va ua i he ndi duala r co m e nd e m nd t t co ta a opr a e co s ofa ton. The e fe , he cic tc tc uc s a hemi o he ur n ppr i t ur e c i r a tr t r ui our ond t ng, purua t Va Codej 1 2- 82. t deemi i t i vi lr quiesi te s nt o . 9. 1 3,o tr ne f he ndi dua e r npaint hos t lz ton. l s t c ti unt r l c m ist i vi ua t t c t oft pia i a i f o, he our nvol a iy om t he ndi d l o he us ody he Com m i sone , ho hast di c e i bot t d t r i t a opr a e f ciiy f te m en si r w he s r ton h o e e m ne he ppr i t a lt or r at t a t m a nec s a y t a f r t ot rf ciii w ihouts ki co ta o l V a. nd o ke e s r r ns e s o he a ltes t ee ng ur ppr va . Code j1 2- 8 4.Thecicuicou tmus hol ahe i n lyf t frtfveyeasatre r of 9. 1 2. r t r t d arng nnual or he is i r fe nty t c he ommime or r a bi nni l t r afe ,t r viw t i vi ls sausa t as e s t nt de , nd e aly he e tr o e e he ndi dua ' tt nd o s s t ne df c i d i ten hos tlz ton.j 1 2- 2. Att she rng,t c tr eves he e or ontnue npai t piaiai 9. 18 5. hi a i he our ec i e de e fom a clni a ps a r s w ho ha e l t t i vi . The c tm us de er i vi nc r i c l ychi t i t s va ua ed he ndi dual our t t m ne whehe t i vi nee c i d i te thos t i ton a e e a t rcommime t r he ndi dual ds ontnue npai n pialzai nd nt r no he t nt or r o fnd t tc mimen i no l rwa r nt a o de t t i vi ber e s d. de , r i ha om t t s onge r a ed nd r r hat he ndi dual ela e = l d Un e 28U. C. 2 5 (9, fd r l o r c n o g a tah be sp tto u ls te dr S. j 2 4 1 a e ea c u t n n t rn a a eiin n e s h peii rha exha t t r medisa lbl i t c t oft sa ei whi h hewas ttone s used he e e vaia e n he ours he t t n c c ce Prie v. iuez 411U. 475(973) I t peiine hasf l t e us onvitd. esr Rodrg , S. 1 . f he tto r aied o xha t s a e c tr m e es t f r c tm us di m i st pe ii Sl yt v.Sm ih,404 U . 53 t t our e di , he ede al our t s s he tton. a on t S. ( 971. 1 ) l Vi gi a,a pers cont n r ni on ined purs uantt an i unt com m im entor under o nvol ary t der j1 2- 82. c nchalnget vai t oft tc 9. 1 5 a le he ldiy ha ommime or rbyflng apeiin frawrtof t nt de ii tto o i h b a c r u i t ecruic u tha is e tej d me twiha a p a o a a v red cso a e s o p s n h ic t o r t t su d h u g n , t n p e l f n d es e iin t t Supr m eCour ofVigi a orhe c n purues h ape ii i t Su e Cour of o he e t r ni , a s uc tton n he pr me t Vigi a.SeeM ilrv. aock,356F. 273, ( h Ci.1 ( i Vigi ac t r ni le Bll 2d 274 4t r 966) notng r ni our r m e esa lbl t c l e di vaia e o halengevaldiy ofc i m e unde a i unt r c i t onfne nt r n nvol a y omm ime t nt or r.W hihe rr et i t c est f l ii cla t theuli t ymus prs nt de) c ve out he nmae hoos o olow,t s e r ha tmael t ee hi c a m sc s l i once ni t va i t ofhi com m im e t t Supr m e Cour ofV igi a a r ng he ldiy s t nt o he e t r ni nd r e ve a nli f om t tcour be o e a f r ldi t i tc tca c i hi ha s c ai s ec i lng r ha t f r ede a sr c our n ons der s bea l m . Se O' lva v.Boecke,526U. 838,8 ( 999) e Suli n r l S. 45 1 . I t sca e t pe ii ofe sno i c ton t tM c nne hasfl asa ec ta to n hi s , he tton f r ndi a i ha Ki y ied t t our ci n c le ng t va i t oft c mime or runde whi h he i pr s nty c i d. The hal ngi he ldiy he om t nt de r c s e e l onfne bzde ofpr vi t ta cai ha be n e use le wih t peii ne . M al yv.Smih,27 lr n o ng ha l m s e xha t d i s t he ttq r lor t F.d991 994( hCi.1 .Mc nne sf llet de taehi e usi ofa ia e 3 , 4t r 994) Ki y' aitr o monsr t s xha ton valbl s a e c tr m e esm a t s m a y di m i s lofhi pe ii by t s c t pur ua t Rul t t our e di nda es um r s s a s tton hi our , s nt o e M oe ria r ove , t ppea st tM c i y' c l ng t t va i t oft com m im e or r r ha K nne s hale e o he ldiy he t nt de i s d by t W i e Count Cicui Co ti wihoutm e i,i s uc a t Com m i sonerw as s ue he s y r t ur s t rt na m h s he si n trq ie t c n ieM c n e frte t n i af cl yl c tdi t ej rs ito wh r te o e urd o o fn Kin y o rame t n a ii o ae n h u idcin ee h t orgi lc i na c z aos Se j 1 2- 8 4. i na rmi l hage z e. e 9. 1 2. Fo t er a o ssae ,hec u t imis sM c n e sj2 5 p tto wih u p eu ie r h e s n ttd t o r ds se Kin y' 2 4 eiin t o t rj d c . A n a opra e or w ili s t s da The Cl r i die t t s nd c e oft s ppr i t der l s ue hi y. e k s r c ed o e opi s hi m e o a um o ni n a ac om pa ng o de t pe ii ne . m r nd pi o nd c nyi r r o tto r E E T i #Y dyo Jnay2 1. NT R: hs . a faur,02 ' J Senl U nied St es D it i udge o t at s rc

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.