Ye Gon v. Holt et al, No. 7:2011cv00575 - Document 139 (W.D. Va. 2014)
Court Description: Memorandum Opinion and ORDER granting 123 Motion to Stay. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 01/17/2014. (kab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Ye Gon v. Holt et al Doc. 139 G F*P8 OFFI U. DI M URT CE S. SX AT F? -''Kl îA '* '3 . ' D - F I THE UNI S N TED TATESDI TRI COURT S CT J l? 2 1 AN 29 , F T WEOTNRNDIT ISIO N V RGI I :UCCj CUERK OR HE RSAE O K E D IV C OF I N A t L ; . S RI T A ssp ZH ENL IY E G O N , Petti i oner, GEM LD S. HOLT, S.M ar hal U. s #or t W est D i ri ofV i ni and be ern st ct rgi a, FLO Y D A Y LO R ,W arden oft he Ce ralV i gi a R e onalJai, nt r ni gi l ) ) ) ) ) ) ) Case N o.7: cv11- 00575 M EM OM NDUM O PI ON NI By:Jam e C.T ur s k Seni U nied Stat Di t ctJudge or t es s ri Respondents . By M e or ndum Opi on a Or re e edNove be 25,201 t sCour de e m a ni nd de nt r m r 3, hi t nid Peii rZhe iYeGon' (é Gon' peii f ha asco pust 28U. C.j2241 ECF ttone nl st Ye ' tton or be r mder ) S. . No 1 7 1 8.nc n u cinwi t a Or e,h Co r sa e t ee ta ii no Peiin rf ra . 1 , 1 l o j n to t h t d r te u t ty d h xrd to f tto e o h pe i oft ry da ,wih t ag ee e ofcom s f rRe ponde s i or t a l hi t rod hit ys t he r m nt t el o s nt, n der o low m o fl anotc ofa ie ie ppea a s e af rhe sa l nd e k ' t r t y. u Pe ii rhasnow tl d hi a ttone ie s ppea a ha a s fl d am o i f say i whih he l nd s lo ie ton or t n c r ue t t tt C o te e is say d i t pe nc ofhi appe .ECF N o. 123.. eq s s ha he ur xt nd t t ur ng he nde y s al The m o i ha bee f ly bref wih Res ton s n ul i ed, t ponde sflngar s e i opposto s ECF N o. nt ii e pons n iin, ee 1 a Pe ii rflnga r pl ECF No.1 TheCour hasc e uly c i r t 34, nd ttone ii e y, 36. t ar f l onsde ed he r peci a g e soft pa tes Fort r s s tf rh brefy be o t Cour GRANTS es tve r um nt he ri . he ea ons e o t i l l w, he t Pe ii rsmoton t sa hi e r dii pr e ngsdurngt pe nc ofhi a a . ttone ' i o ty s xta ton oce di i he nde y s ppe l Ast pa tesagr e,he eai f f c or t Cour mus c i ri de e mi ng he ri e t r e our a t s he t t onsde n t r ni whehe t grntasay:ç()whehe t sa a ia ha madeasr s ngt thei t r o a t i1 t r he ty pplc nt s tong howi ha s lkel t s ce dont me is ( whehe t a ia wilbeirpaabl ij e a e a i y o uc e he rt; 2) t r he pplc nt l re r y n urd bs nt Dockets.Justia.com sa ()wh t e is a c o tesa wil u tnil ijlet oh rp risitr se i t e ty; 3 eh r su n e f h ty l s bsa tal nt he t e ate nee td n h y r pr e ng,a ( whe et publci eetle . Nke v.Hol r 556U. 41 43 ( ) oc edi nd 4) r he i ntrs is' n ' de, S. 8, 4 2009 (iaino te ) Th frtt fco so t ets S r t emo tciia . L ctto mitd . e is wo a t r f h e t t e h s rtc l'4. a ' The Cour hasc i r d al oft f c or and c l st tasa dtrngt pe nc t onsde e l he a t s oncude ha t y li he nde y oft sa a i wa r nt l pa tc a ,whie t Cour bele s i hasr ac d t r g hi ppe l s r a ed. n ri ul r l he t i ve t e he he i ht c uson a t t me isofPeii ' m a c am s t 1w on a l s s m eoft ei s oncl i s o he rt ttoners ny l i ,he a t ea t o hos s ues i u stldo i n ts b e t oa yr c n a to iydrcl o p i ta t Co r h sn td S e s n et r s o u j c t n e e t uh rt ie ty n o n, s he u t a oe . e e ge r l ECF N o.11 A s Pe ii rnot s m or ve ,s e oft e i s a e l galone t t ne aly 7. ttone e , eo r om hos s ues r e s ha wil erv e dd n v , n teei ad sic po sb l yap n lo j d e o t Fo rh lb e iwe e o o a d h r s itn t siii a e f u g s n he u t t Cic tm a r a h adif r ntc l i t n t sCo tha on s m eoft editc tis s Cf r ui y e c fe e oncuson ha hi ur s o hos fi ul sue . . ECF No.1 a 5 6. iet Cour r c z st taç e e C sbiiy'ofr i ' s 24 t - R l he t e ogni e ha ç r pos i lt m elef i i uf i e t s ns fci nt o how a lkelhood ofs ce son t m e is N ken, U . a 434,i conc udest t i i uc s he r t , 566 S. t t l ha Pettone hass ii r hown mor t n s h a%me e pos i lt ' s ce di on a l s s m eofhi e ha uc ç r sbiiy'of uc e ng t ea t o s cai s es ci l hi dualc i i iy c le l m , pe aly s rm nalt ha lngesa hi non bi i i c lenge . nd s s n dem hal s Addii ly,al wi a sa i t sc ewilpr ve YeGon fom be ng e r died tonal lo ng t y n hi as l e nt r i xta t whiehi ca ei be ng he r by t a la eco t be us i hewe ee r die hi c am s l s s s i a d he ppelt ur, ca e f r xta t d, s l i woul beef tveymooed.SeeLi to v.Gr r 203F. 470, 74(t Ci. d feci l t ndsr m abe, 3d 473- 7h r 2000) ( r peii rwa e r die whiehi a alwa pe ngde pieavai sa ofe rdii whe e ttone s xta td l s ppe s ndi s t ld ty xta ton, hi a alwa de lrdmoota dimis d) Att ve ylas,e ni t Fourh Cic tr e s ppe s cae nd s se . he r e t ve f he t rui uld i hi f vor i woul bean e yvit yt twoul no lkey r ul i hi bei r bln t t n s a ,t d mpt c or ha d t i l es t n s ng e r ed o he Unie Stt . . i av.Pata 2008W L 331 * ( D. a.J n.31 2008)(r tng td aes Cf Noreg srna, 394, 3 S. Fl a , gani say ofext ton wher t courtf t radii e he ound t t case i ved uni and com pl l i ues hat he nvol que ex egal ss a ir pa a eha m be aus 'ft sa i notgr nt i i obviust tNoregawilbe nd re r bl r c e t he t y s i a ed t s o ha i l 2 e r die t Fr nc bef r hi a xta t d o a e o e s ppea i r ol d'andoncee r dii occ s lhef r l l s es ve ' xta ton ur ,t ede a t c u t wil a kj rs ito a dt a p a wil fe t l b mo t d . . El e i No ig o rs llc u idcin n he p e l l ef ci y e oe . . ( v n f re a ve prvaisonhi a li woul beaPyrhi vit y. l d,t Govenme i not e l s ppea,t d r c cor ' ndee he ). r nt d does di a ee ' ha i Y e G o w e e de t d whie hi a a waspendi t a alw oul be m oo . s gr ' t t f n r por e l s ppe l ng, he ppe d t Se ECF No.1 a 1 n. Thus e r dii whiehi a a i pe ngwoul e f c i l voi e 34 t 6 6. , xta ton l s ppe l s ndi d fe tvey d Peii ' a lt t s ek me ngf a lae r vi oft sCour' de son a t wo d ttoners biiy o e ani ul ppe lt e ew hi ts cii nd hus ul r ul i ir pa a e ha m . es t n r e r bl r The Cour hasc i r d t Gove n e ' a p l e st t t ons de e he r m nt s r m nt o he cont ar Cf ECFNo. 34a 1 1 but i t m unc ncng. r y, a 1 t 6- 7, fnds he onvi i . Addii ly, het r a f urhNke f c o sdo notwei hea l agans t gr ntng tona l t hid nd o t n a tr gh viy i t he a i ofasay. The Gove n e a g si iso t r m nt r ue n t pposton t tt t r and f rh f c or a ealo ii ha he hid ou t a t s r s i i t he e, poi st t l ngt oftmePe ii rse r dii c ehasbee pe ng, mplcaed r and nt o he e h i ttone ' xta ton as n ndi lr y bl mi Pe ii rf t de a i r ol i TheCour sm pl doesnotagr et t a gel n ng ttone or he l y n es uton. ti y e ha Peii ri r s i c f al o e n mos, t de a i hi e r dii pr ee ng a ttone s e ponsbl or l, r ve t of he l ys n s xta ton oc di , nd c ranl nott et tha o ured snc he fl hi ha aspe ii .l e ti y hos ha ve cc r i e ied s be tton Fort e r s ns t Cour G R AN TS Pe ii r s m oton t sa hi e r dii ECF hes ea o , he t ttone ' i o t y s xt a ton, N . 123, a dwi sa t e f re n o i j g n whl h sa p a i pe igb f r t e n l ty he n o c me t f t ud me t ie i p e l s ndn eo e h l s Unied St t Cour ofAppea sf t Fourh Cic t The Cour' Am e d Fi Or ra t aes t l or he t r ui. ts nde nal de nd J m e ,e e edt ss m eda wilr fe tt Cour' r lng e e ng t sa udg nt ntr hi a y, l e l c he ts ui xt ndi he t y. E ER:hs74- oJr r,03 NT T i1 a fa y21. ' ma y Y J Jam esC .Ttr lk Se orUnied St t D i ti tJ ni t a es s r c udge 1 Forexam pl ,t ha e he beaspetton waspendi g bef et sCour, tanseredt anot court ii n' or hi tr f r o her and t tans ered bac and i wasalo f l rpe aferahea i andnotr ed on f m or t one hen r f r k, t s uly i t rng ul or e han yea Thes delysar notatrbulbl t Pe ii . r. e a e ti e o ttoner
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
