-RSB Carty v. D'Alienandrin, No. 7:2011cv00536 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2011)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 11/16/2011. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Rl S OFFI U.. ST. FRK' CE S DI COURT AT ROANOiE, C VA 1t 1D : 1J ,-7 N2V 16 2 1 21 I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W ESTER N D ISTR ICT O F V IRG I IA N RO AN O K E D I I ON V SI CH R IS CA RTY , Pl ntff ai i , V. J. .D ' I AN D R IN , C AL EN D ef endant . ) ) ) ) ) ) ) JULA C. ' ' I ' A BY; DE L E C i lA cton N o.7:11cv00536 vi i M EM O M N D U M O PI I N N O By:Sam uelG .W ison l Unied St e D i t i tJudge t at s s r c Pl i if Chr s Ca t a V igi a i a e pr e di pr s ,brngs t s ci lr g s a ton a ntf , i r y, r ni nm t oc e ng o e i hi vi i ht c i unde 42U. C.j1983,alegi t tt defnda fie t pr dehi wih a quaeme c r S. l ng ha he e nt ald o ovi m t de t dial c r The c tfnds t tCa t s alega i ns f lt s a e a cl i upon w hi h t c tm a gr nt a e. our i ha ry' l to ai o t t am c he our y a rle, n ,h r f r , imis sh sa to p ru n t 28U. C. 1 5 e( )B)i . eif a d te eo e d s se i cin u s a t o S. j 91 ()2 ( (i ) 1 . Ca t alg st a i 2 07 a traS eiushe d ijly, ap sca i t VignIln s ry le e h t n 0 , fe t ro a nt ' hy iin n he r i sa d s r ' E a d gnos d' Ca t asr r ng t e t e f he d t a a Cary s a e t the w a ta f r ed t di e ' r y equii r a m nt or a r um . t t t s ha s r ns e r o t V i g ni D e m en of Cor ec i i A ugus 2009,and t t D r D ' le ndrn f ie t he r i a pm t r tons n t ha . A i na i a l d o pr de hi w ih ade t m e c lt e t e f r hi hea t a a. Cons que ty,hi c ton ovi m t qua e di a r a m nt o s d r um e n l s ondii ç e ai unc nged' a at tm es he e r e es he c ,pai ove hi e , vi i l s d m ns r ha ' nd i xpe i nc ada hes n r s yes s on os , dz ie s a d n usa Heas b l ve t th ma ha eatmo a ar s l o h sh a ij r izn s , n a e . lo ei s ha e y v u r s e ut f i e d nu y. e Ca t a l ges t t on A ug t 25, 2011 he m e w ih D r D ' le ndr n f a m e c l ry le ha us , t t . A i na i or di a a nt e . Ca t c a m s t t he r que t a l ur ogi ale l i ' i l ng a M Rl o ppoi m nt ry l i ha e s ed t ol c va uaton, nc udi n ne ' r CT s a , t s i he ha a t or butD r D ' i na i de ed hi r ques . c n o ee f se tl d um , . Ale ndr n ni 'Ca t aloac e ha i lr eque t o he ts hos e t r s ed ry s knowldgest thehasm adesm ia r sst ot rdocor andt er quesswe ealodeni . RK I l. Ca t a g r y r ues t t D r D ' le ndrn' de a of Ca t s r ques f a tne ol c l ha . A i na i s ni l ry' e t or t ur ogi a e l i 'de o t a es de i r t i f e enc t hi s rous m e ca ne d. How e r t c t va uaton' m nsr t lbe a e ndif r e o s e i di l e ve , he our fnds t tCa t s alega i a ountt not ng m o e t n a doc or pa i di a ee en w hi i ha r y' l tons m o hi r ha t - tent s gr m t ch i notacina eunde j1 3.Theef e t c tdimis hi compli . s to bl r 98 r or,he our s ses s ant To s a e a cogni bl Ei ht Am e e c a m f de a of m e c c r , a pl i if tt za e g h ndm nt l i or ni l di al a e a ntf mus alg f cs s fce tt d mo srt t a j i o fcaswee dei eaey idfee tt a t le e a t ufiin o e n tae h t al fiil r lb rtl n ifrn o sro me ca nee Eselev. mbl 429U. 97,1 ( 976) St esv.Va.De tofCor. eius di l d. t l Ga e, S. 05 1 ; apl n' r, 90 F. pp.48 492 ( D. 1 . To e tbls dei r t i feenc a pli ifmus 4 su 7, E. Va. 995) sa ih lbe ae ndifr e, antf t pr e f c s t de onsr t t t t de e n ha a t l know l es nt a t o m t a e ha he f nda t d c ua edge of a di r r f a nd s ega d or n o j cieys ro sme ia n e Fame v Brn a 51 U. 8 , 3 ( 9 4 ; e as Rihv. be tv l e iu dc l e d. r r . e n n, 1 S. 25 8 7 1 9 ) s e lo s J hns 1 F. 1 o on, 31 2d 092,1 ( h Ci.1 .A cam co eni adiag e me bewee a 096 4t r 997) li nc r ng s r e nt t n n i a e a m edi lpe s nne r r ng di gnos s or c s oft e m e does noti plc t t nm t nd ca r o l ega di a i our e r at nt m i a e he Ei t Ame nt W rc v.Coli ,766 F. 841 8 ( h Ci.1 ) Rusel,528F. a ghh ndme . iht lns 2d , 49 4t r 985 ; s l 2d t 31 Hari v.M ura 761F.Supp.409,41 ( D.Va.1 . Furhe,que tonsofme c l 9; rs ry, 4 E. 990) t r si dia j d me ta en ts b e tt j diilrv e Ru sl,5 8F.d a 31 ( i n S il v Ku k l u g n r o u j c o u ca e iw. sel 2 2 t 9 ct g h eds . n e, i 442F. 409( h Ci.1 ). 2d 9t r 971) Cary co ede t the ha be s e a e l t d by D r D ' le ndr n a t t t t nc s ha s en e n nd va ua e . A i na i nd ha he doc or has de e m i t t a neur ogi a e l to t s ar h f a tunor i not nec s a y. t t r ned ha ol c l va ua i n o e c or t s e sr Alhoug hem a diagr e wih t c s ofte t e hei r c vi hi cli i not ng mor t h y s e t he our e r am nt s e ei ng, s am s hi e t n a doc orpa int diagr e e , whih i not a tona e under t Ei h Am e ha t - te s e m nt c s c i bl he ght ndme . nt A c or ng y, t c t fnds t t Ca t has no de onsr e t t t de e n a t d wih c di l he our i ha ry t m tat d ha he f nda t c e t delber e i f ence and,t Catt hasf l t s a e a cons iutonalcl m . i at ndifer hus, 'y aied o t t tt i ai 11 1. Fo t r as s a ed he ei t c tdi m i s Ca t s a ton f f itr t sa e a cl i r he e ons t t r n, he our s s es r y' c i or a lle o t t am purua t j 1 5()2)B)i) s nt o 91 e( ( (i. ENTER: Thi 1 h da ofNove be , 1. s 6t y m r 201 ..77' .' < . . .. . .x . . -' A >', g A' . ..< ' ' .' X y.(,. '. x. z . I TED STA TES D I STRI J D GE CT U
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
