-RSB Johnson v. Oasis Management System et al, No. 7:2011cv00515 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2011)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 11/2/2011. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
G ERK; O#FI U,,DI CPUA . C: : .T.ATf-1!7fE, A l. . < V 7 1 q t .. d . .! I TH E U N I ED STATE S D I N T STRI T C O U R T C FO R TH E W E STERN D I STR I T O F VI G I I C R N A R O A N O K E DI I O N V SI LA W REN CE JO H N SO N , N0# 22 2 1 21 NtLI u, 'r ù , ERK I) A '' ' C ' Y BY; CA SE N O .7: 11CV 00515 D Pe i i r, tt one M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N N O V S. OASI M ANAGEM ENT SYSTEM , 1 , S M By:Jame C.Tur s k Seni Uni Stat Di t ctJudge or ted es s ri R espondent s. Lawr e J enc ohns a i t pr e ng pr K ,fl d t s pe ii f a wrtofha s on, n nma e oce di o ie hi tton or i bea c pus i t Cic t Cour f t Ciy of Sa e ,Vigi a. J or n he r ui t or he t lm r ni ohns a f r l i ae,i on, ede a nm t s ei c re t c n i d a a l c lr go a j i a c mpli ta he i entted t habeas r lef u rnl o fne t o a e in l al nd o ans h t s il o y e o b c us v ro s l i c n iinsa t ej i ae u c nsi to a. Because he appear d t be e a e a iu i ng o dto t h al r n o tt in l v u c le ng t e uton of hi f de al c i i l s nt nce t Cicui Cour ta f r e ha l ngi he xec i s e r r m na e e , he r t t r ns e r d J l s s pe ii t t s c tf f rhe di poston. Bas d on J m s s de a f ha as o m on' tton o hi our or u t r s ii e ol on' m nd or be r le ,t c tc t ue a doc t d hi s i s on a a pe ii f r a w rtof ha as c pus e i f he our onsr d nd ke e s ubm s i s tton o i be or , purua t 28U. C.j2241.Aferrviwi t peii t c tc udest ti mus be s nt o S. t e e ng he tton, he our oncl ha t t s m a iy di m i s f f l e t s a e a c a m . um rl s s ed or aiur o t t l i J ohns n,who i s r i a f r lc i i ls nt nce i cure l hous d a t W ese n o s e v ng ede a rm na e e , s r nty e t he tr V igi a Reg ona J li Sa e , igi a. H e c pl i abouts ve a lvi c tonst whi h r ni i l ai n l m V r ni om a ns e r l i ng ondii o c h h sb e s b e tdwhi a t ej i:a an rei tej i' me ia u i ij ce J l o wi e a e n u j ce l t h al ) u s n h als dc l n t ne td oms n t e h ane dl t tha ara be us df rat c osst t b)t f pr dedt J ona t e e ha d le dy en e o uberul i es; he ood ovi o ohns t he ji i d urto al i a e uae'a i p e a e i a t ae ma ne,p o lmswhih c u e al s t tiin l n d q t' nd s rp rd n n msf n r r b e n y c as i t Enotbl wei l sa midl di nihed he t ' c j i rgultonsgral r tit nmaes s a e ght os nd l y mi s alh' ) al e ai . e ty esrc Jol s s abiiy t texer se w ih diec s i ' by requii hi t e ci i i a r m on' lt o û ci t r t unlght' r ng m o xer se ns de oom wih o yonewieme hwalope t t outi d)t hih c toftl honecal t oug t t nl r s l n o he sde; he g os eep ls hr h he j i' tlp o e s se lmisJ h s n sa l yt c n es wi hsfmi a d h satr e e als ee h n y tm i t o n o ' bit o o v re t i a l n i to n y; ) i h y t j i' tlp o es se p o d sn p ia yf rc lsb t e J h s na dh satme a dt he als ee h n y tm r vie o rv c o al ewe n o n o n i to y; n ) hih p ie c a g d f rie i t j i' c mmis r a u tt t rc g u igp ie fxn . g rc s h r e o tms n he als o say mo n o i ie o gn /rc i ig' p ' Be a e oft e condii ,J m s as e t t t he i e il d t ha as r i . H e alo s eks c us hes tons ol on s rs ha s ntte o be elef s e ij ncier le a data se . nu tv eif n r n fr I i wels tld 1w t a h be s c r u j rs ito e tn s t prs n r'cams ta t s l ete a h t a a o p s u idcin x e d o io es li h t c aln e t e lg lba i o t e c n ie n, j 2 41c ( ) b t d e n t e tn t cams h l g h e a ss f h o fn me t 2 ()3 , u o s o x e d o li e c once ni t c tons of c i r ng he ondii onfneme . Prs r who wih t cha lnge t c tons of nt ione s s o le he ondii t i c i m e ,as oppos t is f c or dur to mus do s t ough cvi rght lws t her onfne nt ed o t a t ai n, t o hr i l i s a uis unde 42 U. C.j 1 ( ai tsae ofiil)o Bi nsv.Si Unknown Na Age sof r S. 983 ag ns tt fcas r ve x med nt Fed.Bur uofNacoi ,403U. 388( 971 (gans f r ofiil) a nott oughfdeal ea r tcs S. 1 ) a i t edeal fcas, nd hr e r ha aspr e di . M cnt h v.U. Paol Comm' 11 F.d 809,81 ( t Ci.1 ($ be oc e ngs l os S. r e n, 5 3 2 10h r 997) ( A ha as c us pr e ng a t ks t f t or d a i n of a pr s r s c i m e and s e t be op oc edi tac he ac ur to i one ' ontne nt e ks he r m e of i m e at r e e or a s r e d pe i of c i m e . I con r t a c vi r g s e dy m di e el as ho t ne rod ont ne nt n t as , i l i ht a ton (1at kst c tonsoft prs rsc i men ....'( mitng quoai l se ci tac he ondii he ione ' onfne t ' o ti ttonl; e as P es rv. d iue , 1U. 47 , 9( 9 3 (( j 1 8 a to i ap o e r me yf ra lo r ie Ro rg z 41 S. 5 49 1 7 ) $A1 9 3 ci n s r p r e d o 1 . . . sa e prs rw ho i m a ng a co tt i lc lenge t t co tons ofhi pr s lf but t t i one s ki ns iutona ha l o he ndii s i on ie, nott t fc orlngt ofhi c t y.'. o he a t e h s usod ' ) J ohns s pl di alege no gr und on w hi h hi c t on' ea ng l s o c s usody is l- t f c of hi t e f he a t s c i m e or t dur ton of hi c i m e t a e i vi a i of t c tt ton o l w s of onfne nt he a i s ontne n - r n ol ton he ons iu i r a t U nied St t . The e o e, hi a l ga i , a t he t a es rf r s le tons lhoug syl d as a petton f ha a c pus h t e ii or be s or r le ,do notac ualy pr s nta cl i st ts ei f t l e e ny a m ha ound i ha asorpr de a gr n be ovi ny ound on whi h he c c d be e il d t s h r i . Ther f e,t co twils m a iy di m i s hi ha a pe ii oul ntte o uc elef e or he ur l um rl s s s be s tton wi o tp eu ief rf iu et saeacam u o whc terq se rle c n b g a td.An t u rj d q o al r o tt li p n ih h e ue td eif a e rne h a opraeor rwile e t sda ppr it de l nt r hi y. Bec us J a e ohns i pr ee ng pr K ,t c tc d lber ly c t ue hi pl a ng a a on s oc di o he our oul i a l onsr s e di s . cvi rg sc ai underj 1 and alow hi t pr e d wih t c e. Howeve,co t i l iht ompl nt 983 l m o oc e t he as r ur r c ds i c t t t J e or ndi a e ha ohns i w e la a e of t r uie e s f f lng a c vi r gh s a ton. on s l w r he eq r m nt or ii i l i t ci Hi Bi e sa to ,J h s nv. Bre Ca eNo. :9 01 ,sc re tys h d e f raj r s v n cin o n o O' in, s 70 CV0 65 i u rn l c e uld o u y ti on N ove be 1 2011,i Bi St ne G a V igi a H e hasal o fl d a l a tone o he c vi ral m r 7, n g o p, r ni . s ie t e s t ri l rght aci i t s c t ohns v.O' in,Cas No.7: i s ton n hi our,J on Bre e 08CV00022 ( . Va.Ma .1 W D. r 6, 2 0 ) wh c p o e d d t t e s mmayj d me tsa e Depieh se i e tk o e g o t 0 9 , ih r c e e o h u r u g n tg . s t i v d n n wld e f he f de a ci lrght ltga i pr s ,J e r l vi i s ii ton oce s ohns purued hi c r taci i sae c q s e ng on s s uren ton n t t our e ki ha a r le . On t s r cor t c tdeci s t c t e hi c r nts isons a a cvi be s e if hi e d, he our lne o onsnz s ur e ubm s i s i l rgh sa ton. 1 i t ci ENTER:Thi 7. day ofN o mbe , s ve r 2011. Se ' U nie St t D i t i J or t d a es sr c udge 1 J hns n i a vie t a i hewih t p rueaj 1 3cvirgh sa to hema r s bmi hi o o s d sd h tf s es o u s 98 i l i t cin, y eu t s cl m si ase at pr l syl com pl nt Hew ilalo be r r t pr deevi ai n par e, opery t ed ai . l s equied o ovi dencet the has ha e ha td hsa nitai r me e a t e c oft camsh r ie , r u n t 42U. C.j 1 97 ( , x use i dmi sr tve e dis s o a h he li e as s pu s a t o S. 9 ea) a t ma a r raear ng me sr g r ngt $3 0 flngf ef flngafdeal ou t vi nd o ke pp op it ra e nt e a di he 50.0 ii e or ii e r c r ci l a to 1 S e28U. . .j 1 l ( )a d 1 5 b . cin. e S C j 9 4 a n 91 ( )
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
