-RSB Wolters v. Holder et al, No. 7:2011cv00509 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2011)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 10/31/2011. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OFII U. .D19)COURT S JCE S 1 ' f AT M NVI VA LLE, I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE W EjTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A ROANOKE DI SI VI ON 2f 2 J ULI BY: f O U L , CLERK . EP CE AN D REW W O LTER S, Pet toner, ii Ci lA c i N o.7: - vvi t on 11 c 00509 V. M EM P RANDUM OPI ON NI ERIC H O LDER ,e aI, t . R espondent s. By: H o Jac on L.K i e n. ks sr Se or Uni e St t s Di t c Judge ni t d a e s ri t Andr w W ole s a f de ali t pr ee ng pr K ,fl d apeii f awrtofha as e tr , e r nma e oc di o ie tton or i be copus purua t 28U. C.j2241 Peii ralgest tof i sa t Unie Stts r , s nt o S. . ttone le ha scal t he td ae Pe tntayi Le Count Vigi a(E Lee',tldnumer flei i ntrporsa i t nie ir n e y, r ni C USP ' ie ) ous as ncde e t gans hi a c us dhi ta frt ot rBura ofPrs ns(( 'fciiis.Peii rdoe no m nd a e s rnse o he e u io CBOP' a lte ttone s t ) de crbea har t hi lbe t orpr t i e essasar s toft epr e di . Thi m at r s i ny m o s i ry opery ntr t e ul hes oc e ngs s te i bef emefrprlmi r rviw,puru t Rue 1b a 4oft Rul Goveni j225 s or o ei nay e e s anto ls () nd he es r ng 4 Ca e .Afe r ve n p tto e ' s miso s l s s t ep t inwih u p eu ie s s tr e iwig ei n rs ub sin , dimis h ei o t o t rj dc . i t lmus dimi sa ac i orc am fl b a i t i 1de e m i t tt a ton or t s s ny ton l i ied y n nma e f t r ne ha he c i cl m i fi ousorf ist sa ea cai o whih r le ma be g ant Se 28U. C. ai s rvol a l o tt l m n c ei f y r ed. e S. jj1915( ( ,1 5A( ( ) 42U. C.j1 () Thefrtsandadi l scl msba e e)2) 91 b)1; S. 997ec . is t r ncude ai s d upon t n i s a ym e il s l galt or 'lcai ofi rnge ntofa lga i e e twhih % ndiput bl rte s e he yy'il ms nfi me a e l nt r s c cl a l doe no e s ,' c a m sw he e t t ac ualc e i ar cl a l ba e es . N e t ke v. e r y s t xit' or l i r he f t ont ntons e e r y s l s' iz f ' W ila , U. 31 3 ( 989) Thescondsa r i t fmiirsa r f amoi t lims 490 S. 9, 27 1 . e tndad s he a la tndad or ton o d s s u e F d rlRu eo Ci l o e u e1 b () a c p i t p an ifsfdu l imis nd r e ea l f viPr c d r 2()6 , c e tng he litf a a a lga i a tue A c le tons s r . ompli tnee t s ta pl i s ae e oft ca m s an ds $ hor nd an tt m nt he li howi t tt a ng ha he pl de i e ildt rlef' nds fcinttgjcua algai ...or s arg t r ifa ea r s ntte o ei a ufi e tfa t l le tons t aie ihto ele bove t s ultvelvel.... l At. r v. mbl 550U. 5 555( he pec ai e ' l lCo p. Two v, 'Be S. 44, 2007)(ntr l i ena quoai maksomit .A pl ntf sbassf rle kequiesmor t nlbesa tton r ted) ai if i or eif t r r e ha a l nd c usons....'I Ther f e,apl ntf mus tal f c ss fcentt sae alt elm e s oncl i ' d. e or ai if t tlege a t ufi i o t t 1 he e nt ofëhe cam . Bas v. I DupontdeNe ur & Co.324F. 761, (t Ci.2003 . t ) li ' s E.. ' mo s , 3d 765 4h r ) H ow e r det r i ng w he hera c pl i s a e a pl i e c ai f r le i $ ve , e m ni t om a nt t t s aus bl l m or e i f s ( a c ne ts e ii ts ta r q rst rve n c u tod a o is udca e e in ea o tx -p cfc a k h t e uie he e iwi g o r t r w n t j iil xp re c nd c m o s e. A s of v.l , U . om n ens ' hcr t gbal ' S. - - , 1 S. .1 1 ( 29 Ct 937, 950 2009) Thus ac t . , our sr e igac mplitu d rRue 1 ( )6 c nie tf pe dn sta a en t nildt a ce nn o an n e l 2 b ( ) a d n iy la ig h t r o e t e o n t a s pton oft ut bec us t y c i tofno m or t l bel a c l i ns I A lhough I s um i r h a e he ons s e han a s nd onc us o . d. t lbealyc tuepr K co ai s Hane v.Kener 404U. 51 5 21( 972) ldonotac i r l onsr o mpl nt, i s r , S. 9, 20- 1 , t ast i a e' advoc t ,s s e de opi s a ut y a co tt i he nm t s a e ua pont vel ng t t or nd ns iutonalcl i s t i a e a m he nm t fiedt ceal rieont fceoft c ant al o l ry as he a he ompli .SeeBr kv. rol,1 F. 241, ( h oc Ca r l 07 3d 243 4t Ci.1 ( tg,J,c uri ; udetv.CivofHa on,775F. 1 1 ( hCi. r 997) Luti . onc rng) Bea t t mpt 2d 274, 278 4t r 1 .Se as Gor v.Le ,5 F. 11 11 ( hCi.1978)(e og zngt ta 985) e lo don eke 74 2d 47, 51 4t r rc nii ha dititc ti no e ctdt asumet r eofa aef anr K pl nit src our s t xpe e o s he ol dvoc t or o aitf). Pe ii r a a st a l e t thi uns ii c tt i lr ght w e e vi a e ttone ppe r o leg ha s pec fed ons iutona i s r ol t d bec us t f le i i ntr porsca e hi ta f rfom U SP Le t ot rBOP f iii s a e he a s nc de e t us d s r nse r e o he aclte , whi hebe ivese ch le xpos d hi t ha s rc tonsofc i me .' TheFit Amendme e m o r he ondii onfne nt fh nt pr e t agans de i to oflf lbery, pr ryby t f de a g r ot c s i t prva i ns ie, i t or ope t he e r l ove nmen .Se U .S. t e Cons . m e V.Thus ape ii rmus s t a nd. , ttone t how i or rt pr va lon a d pr s c am t tt n de o e i ue oce s l i ha he go r nthasi e f e wih apr e t d lbe t o pr pe t i e e ta t tt pr e es ve nme nt rer d t ot c e i ry r o ry nt r s nd ha he oc dm t tld t t deprva i we ec tt i lyi ufk int ha e o he i ton r onsiutona l ns t e . 1Pettone des rbesot rfct notr lvantt hi peii ,a hea no l st tt y a enotpa tofa cl m ii r c i he a s ee o s tton nd ck w edge ha he r r ny ai r s i t i t pe ii l tad,pe iine sae hewilfl as r t ci lrg sa i a t ef t. aied n he nsant tton. nse tto r t ts l ie epa ae vi iht cton bout hos acs Ac di y,ldonotc i rt e r neousi or tont dee net mert oft peii , a t y woul not cor ngl onsde he xta nf mai o tnni he is he tton nd he d af e tt o co e,r r es . f c he ut m ega dl s The f tofpetto rsc c i a i io e i i t ta f rofhi lbe t t ac ii ne ' onviton nd mprs nm nt mples he r ns e s i ry o prs of i a s w ho i t rbr di c e i a i s e hi s nt nce. G a t v.Ta or 946 i on fci l , n hei oad s r ton dm ni t r s e e s on vl , F. 3 343( hCi.1 ) Ne rhels ,d onfne ntt prs doesno srp ap io ro 2d 40, 4t r 991 . vet e s < i me o ion c t ti rs ne f al lbe t i e e t . 1 To de er i whe he a i t r t i ace t n lbe t i e e t 1m us l i ry ntr ss' d. ' t m ne t r n nma e e ans rai i ry ntr s, t l a t na ur oft cl i e i e e ta de e m i whe he t D ue Pr s Cl us a i s ook t he t e he a m d nt r s nd t r ne t r he oce s a e pple . Boa dofRe nt ofStt Cole sv. h, U. 564,570- ( 972) Ani t hol a r ze s ae lge Rot 408 S. 71 1 . nmae ds pr e t bl rghti t e it e t t whih he ha algii a ecai ofe il m e .Gr e t ot c a e i n hos n er ss o c s e tm t l m ntte nt e nholz v.nmaesofNe Pe la Cor.Complx, U. 1,7(979 .Howe , ttone do not l t b. na nd r e 442 S. 1 ) verpeii r es have a l gii a e c a m ofe il m e t how t BOP c a s f e hi or i whi h f iiy he ny e tm t l i ntte nt o he l s ii s m n c ac lt s r hi s ntnc W iki onv.Ausi 5 U. 209,22122( eves s e e e. l ns tn, 45 S. - 2005) SeeM ood v. ccet . v Da t, 429U. 78,88( 976)(t ngrs hasgi nfdeal ionofi asf ldicei t co r ... S. 1 ico e s ve e r prs fcil ul s rton o ntol c to ofc i me ....'.Furhemor,peiine doe notde ci a ay c a ondiins onfne nt ' ) t r e tto r s s rbe n tpial nd sg f nthar hi on hi i r lton t t or na y i i sofprs lf SeeSa n v. i nika ds p m n ea i o he di r ncdent ion ie. ndi Con r 515I S. 2,484( 995 .De piepeiine' alegai offlei i ntrpo t, s ne, J. 47 1 ) s t tto rs l tons as ncde e rs hi Fit Am e fh ndmentrght a e notpr e l i i t d.Ac r ngl Idim ist pe ii wihou i s r es nty mplcae co di y, s s he tton t t prj cef fii t saeacli uponwhihr ifma beg a e eudi or alng o tt am c ele y rntd. The Clr i dieced t s nd a c oft sM e a ek s r t o e opy hi mor ndum Opi o a t a ompa ng ni n nd he cc nyi O r rt pe ii r de o ttone . ENTER :Thi da ofOc o r 2011. y t be , e ' ni U nie St t D i ti tJ e or t d a es s r c udg
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
