-RSB Moore v. Collins et al, No. 7:2011cv00506 - Document 6 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 11/21/2011. (kab)

Download PDF
CLERKS OFFI b S. SI COUK' CE Dk ' ; AT ROANOKE)7 1, % . FIFD L I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STRI T O F V I I I C RG N A RO AN O K E DIV I N SIO K ENN ETH D .M O O R E, N0V 2 1 2.4 2 1 JULI G. A DUD'!- C'1:'' .I e . î 2T ' ..9' '' .- ' ., ' sv: , DEPU 'ttï . -: '7 . # / CA SE N O .7: 11CV 00506 Pl ntf ai if, M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N N O VS. LT. COLLI c AL. D. NS, , By:JamesC.Tur k Seni Unied St es D i ri Judge or t at st ct Deendants. f t) Ke t D,M oo e a Vig ni i t pr e ng pr K ,tld t s c vi rght a ton nne h r, r i a nma e oc edi o ie hi i l i s c i purua t 42 U. C.j 1 ale ng t t prs ofcal s d pa hi co nst y s nt o S. 983 lgi ha ion fii s houl y m mpe aor dama s f a br ge or oken a e he s f r whe he f lon a i y sdewak whie wal ng t hi nkl ufe ed n el n c i l l ki o s p io j b i p io -u pid s o s Up n rviw o t er c r ,te c u tfn t tte a to rs n o n rs n s p le h e . o e e f h e o d h o r ids ha h ci n m us bes ma iy dim is t um rl s s ed. l M oor alege t f l i s que ofe nt . On D ec m be 28,201 he w a e l s he olow ng e nce ve s e r 0, s a sg t wor i t kic n a W a lnsRi Stt Prs Ea l t tm or ng, t5: a. . s i ned o k n he t he t le dge a e ion. ry ha ni a 00 m , o tc al ca l d hi t com e i f wor To ge t t kic n, oor ha t w al a r st fi i s le m o n or k. t o he t he M e d o k c os he prs ya d t a herbuidi ion r o not l ng.Onhi wa he si ped onha d ie a s s y, lp r c nd now,f l,a br kehi el nd o s lf a kl.Th ij r r q ie s r eyt isal paea dtv sr wsi t ea ke e t n e e nu y e ur d u g r o n tl a lt n i e c e n h n l. A fe t i i nt M oor fl d a i or alc pl nt g i va ,a a al , t r he nc de , e ie n nf m om ai , r e nce nd ppe s co ani a t unsf condii oft sde kwheehewasijted.l r pons , mpli ng bout he ae tons he i wal r n tr n es e of i a ss a e t tt W alensRi pr c i e i t add es s h s f t i s s d s n as fci l t t d ha he l dge a tc s o r s uc a e y s ue t oo as Pos i e. s bl ' ' M oor s st he ofs urt a t buidi s r s ratW al nsRi as e tng e ue he ad ec iy nd he l ng upe vio le dge, s ri t tt y s d ha s r w n s to s w dus on t s de a k,orcl a d of t s w a i e ha he houl ve t e al r a t he i w l e ne f he no nd c be or i a esw e e f c d t w a k t r . M o e a s c pl nst tuni ntf e prs f e nm t r or e o l he e or l o om ai ha de ii d i on ofi i sf ied t pr dehi wih a oprae s sf rwal ng i t s fcal al o ovi m t ppr i t hoe o ki n he nowy c tonshe ondii f c d,be us t r rt l ss sis t hi di notpr des tc e ta ton. He s ks ae ca e he ubbe emi hoe s ued o m d ovi ufi i nt r c i ee mo eay a dij n tv rle . n tr n nu cie eif 11 The c ti r quie t di m i sa a ton o c ai f l d by a pr s ne a ns a our s e r d o s s ny c i r l m ie i o r gai t gove nm e ale iy orofi e i t cour de er i t ac i n or c ai i f i ous m a i i , r nt ntt t c r f he t t m nes he t o l m s r vol , lc ous o f i t saeacam o whc r l f yb g a td 2 U.. j1 5 b ( ) I od r o r al o tt li n ih ei ma e rn e . 8 SC. 91 A( )1. n r e t s e saeacli i a f r cviacin,t pl ntf' tgjcua alegai mus bee ght tt am n ny edeal i l to he ai ifs tfa t l l tons t nou o r i e a rghtt r le a a s i o e i f bove t s ul tve l ve , t one t ti t aus bl on isf ce ' r t r he pec a i e l' o ' ha s t pl i e t a ,' a he t nmeel û onc i bl ' BelAt. . Twombl 550U. 544,5 ( ) ha r y f eva e.' l lCop v. c v, S. 70 2007 . The Ei h A m e ght ndm e tpr e t prs r f om crz la unus lvi c ii ns n ot c s i one s r te nd ual i ng ond to . Rhodesv.Cha n,452U. 337(981 . Topr aco tt i lcai r ae t a unsf pma S. 1 ) ove nsiutona l m eltd o n ae j i c n i o , o v r M o r mus s o t a t d fn a t rs n ofcasa tdwi al o dt n h we e, o e t h w h the ee d n p io fiil ce t i h d l eaei ifrnc -ha t e k e s b e tv l,h c n i o p e e tdas b tn il iko ei rt ndfee e t t h y n w, u j ciey te o dt n r s n e u sa ta rs f b i s rous ha m a ne r he es f l d t t ke i e s bl m e s r s ' o a l vi t i . Fa m e v. ei r nd ve t l s aie o a û a ona e a u e ' t le a e t r r r Brnna 51 U. 825,835- ( 994) e n, 1 S. 37 1 . M oor sco pl ntf l t a l f c sde o ta i delbe a e i f er nc b a ne e' m ai ais o lege a t m nsr tng i r t ndif e e y nyo . M oor sc e' ompl i is fi c t sofi i s sae i e t ha i mz s ant tel ndia e feal' tt d nt nt o ve ce d now on t sde ks he i wal ç ddr s e a s n a pos i e. The da r c to a s e s d s oo s sbl ' a ' nge ous ondii n boutw hi h he s s wasca ed by a c ue us n a tofna ur The pr s ofk i l ha no per ona c t olove how m uc s c t e. i on t a s ve s l on r r h now f lsorwha al t lve offee i oc ur be or t y ca s nd s e l r z ng c s f e he n e omeoneou t cla t tie a s t o e n ha c nd now of t f he sde a ks W hie t de e nt m a ha t ug i w a a r m o e pos i lt t ti a e i w l . l he f nda s y ve ho ht t s e t s biiy ha nm t s wak n o t eiysd wak mih fla dbe o sro l ij rd,t sn tra o a l t fn li g n h c ie l g t al n c me eiusy nu e ii o e s n b e o id t tt y w e e a a e ofa s t nta r s ofs rousha m . Se e. ,W a ke v. c ha he r w r ubs a i l i k ei r e, c. l r M Donal N o. d, C1 5 0 2 3 CKD P, 11W L 5 3 4 , 3( D. lNo 1 2 1 (u rl V -1 - 8 5 20 51 4 6 * E. Ca. v. 0, 01 ) s mmaiy dimisngcli rga di i t sf loniywakwa ) Mor r ofiesras bl c d s si am e r ng nmae' al c l ys. eove, fc r e ona y oul ha bele d t ti a es w ho a e i s onl t l i s ve i ve ha nm t , r s ued y e m s hoes w oul know t us c uton w he , d o e a i n w a ki on i y s de a ks 1 l ng c i w l . d. Pos i ene i nceby ofi a s i f ii t ce rt i ea s sbl glge fcil, n alng o la he c nd now mor quikl on t e c y he mor ngofDe mbe 28,201 ori f ii t pr de i t swih s st tha be tr ni ce r 0 n a lng o ovi nma e t hoe ha ve te tacin,smpl doe notgvers t a c tt i lcam a tona eunde j 1 r to i y s i ie o ny onsiutona li ci bl r 983. Se ec. e, . , Cou vofSacn nt v.Le s 523U. 8 849( 998 (t-lheConsiuto doe no nt rme o wi, S. 33, 1 ) sg f tt in s t gua a ee due ca e on t pa tofs a e of i i l ;la lt f ne i nty i lc e ha i r nt r he r t t fc a s i biiy or glge l nf i t d nn s c tgorcal bene t t t es d'ofco tt i lpr eci ) Ac di y,hec t l ae i ly ah he hr hol ' nsiutona ot tons. cor ngl t our wil s ummaiyds s M o r ' cam c n enngt ij re h s fee fo h sflo t iy rl imis o es li o c r i he nu is e u fr d r m i al n he c sde l a l lyfi ous pus ntt j 1 5 b)1.Bas o t sdipostonoft a ton, i wak s egal rvol , rua o 91 A( ( ) ed n hi s ii he ci t co t l as dimi spl ntf sot pendi motonsasm o . he ur wil lo s s ai if her ng i ot The Cl r i die t t s nd c e oft sm e or ndtm opi on a a co pa ng e k s r c ed o e opi s hi m a l ni nd c m nyi o d rt pl ntf . r e o ai if ENTER:Thi 1l# yofNo mbe,2011 s vHa ve r . S 3 krunie St t sDiti udg t t d a e src e .

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.