De'lonta v. Pruitt, No. 7:2011cv00483 - Document 75 (W.D. Va. 2013)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 01/14/2013. (kab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
raFRK,AT FI t,s,Dl c r X CE J sT. ROANOKE, VA FI LED I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI CT RGI A NI ROANOK E DI SI VI ON J 1i 2 1 AN 23 JUL . BY; ' ' 'DL , CL ERK DEPUTY CLERK OPHELI AZRI DEA A EL LONTA Ci lA c i N o.7: c 00483 vi ton 11- vPl ntf , ai if M EM ORANDUM OPI ON NI V. By: H on. m esC.Tur Ja k H A R O LD CLA R K E,etal, . Se or Uni e St e D i t i tJudge ni t d at s s r c D ef endants. Thi ma tr i pr s nty be or t Cour on De e nt Sa a Pr t' M oton f s te s e e l f e he t f nda 1 r h uits i or Sum mar J m e . ECF No.57.Pli if a pr - r tve ta s xual hous d i t Vigni y udg nt antf, e ope a i r ns e 2 e n he r i a De rme to Co r ci n (C pa t n f re to s 1 VDOC' p io s se alg st a S rh Pr i ap io g ad, ' rs n y tm, le e h t aa ut rs n u r ) t s x al a usdh r P tt a s rsq ai di ni a g omd u o whih sl r u g n e u ly b e e . rl t se t u lse mmu t s r t s p n c l i y mmayj d me t s ul be g a t d.Fo t r s t tf l t Cour GRANTS I PART a DENI I ho d r ne r he ea ons ha olow, he t N nd ES N PA R T t M oton f Sum m a y J m e . he i or r udg nt 1 . FA C TS l c n iei amoin f rsl r j d me t ac u t tc n ie t efcsa dd a n o sd rng to o l mmay u g n , o r mus o sd r h a t n rw a 1r as na e i e e esi t lghtm os f vo a e t t non1 e o bl nf r nc n he i t a r bl o he movi pa t M a s hia El c. ng ry. tus t e I d s Co. Ze ihRa i Co p.47 U. 5 4, 8 ( 9 6 ;s eas M LC Au o.LLC. . wn n u . v. nt do r , 5 S. 7 5 7 1 8 ) e lo ts v To of S.Pi s 532 F. 269,273 ( h Ci.2008)3 Pli ifOphei De'o a Cl lnt' or ne , 3d 4t r . antf la lnt De'o a' S anip)wa ta se rd t Bu kng n Co rcin l Ce tr Ct t i tf ' s r n fre o c i h m re to a ne BKCC' i Ap i 2 0 a pl ' n rl 01 , ) f c lt f m ae i aes Soon a tra vi a BKCC,Pl ntf e ount r d Ofk e Sa a Pr it a iiy or l nm t . fe ni ng t ai if nc e e t r r h ut 1 I he Compl nt De'ona alo na n r ai , l t s med a Defnda s va i prs ofkil.The Co tdimis d al cai s e nt rous ion t as ur s s e l l ms a ns t s pa ael rpr s t d Defndan s SeeECF Nos 55& 56.Pr t i t onl r m ai ng Defnda i t gai t he e r t y-e e en e e t. . uit s he y e ni e nt n he Case. 2û ai ifhas undegone varous pr e ze t e nce he fmi nt f t r , i udi de ma a ins a a ç ntf pl r i oc dlr s o nha r e ni eau es ncl ng r br so nd c m i lfce pe .She alo r ei es n te me t sow hai gr wt s tn he s n,a hassgni a he ca a el s ec ves koge r at nt o l r o h, ofe r ki nd i t nt k be s d v lp me tri)a wela oh rfmiiec aa trsis'ECFNo. , mp. t1 . r at e eo e n sc s l s te e nn h rceitc. ' 1 Co la 0 3I an eve t Pnzt ha no ofer adif rng s toffcs a t. n y n , it s t f ed fe i e tç ut'o t ee d n ap io g adwh trtme Plitf a ap e o sVDOC fcly. d it r r fn a f), rs n u r o is t an if t rviu pr ' a ii At t t ttm e,Prlt t d De'ont t ta t pr vi us f c lt , t us d t wach you a1t tme. ha i tit ol l a ha t he e o a iiy t e o t l 1 he i ' ' ECF No.1 Compl a 11 Sho ty afe ,Pr itr t ne t wor afe a f w da of a r a e t , . t . rl tr ut e ur d o ' k tr e ys f nd elt d o De'ont t tPr t' gilre ha c e Pr t t s f rfom f poioni by cooki he l a ha uits rfind d aus d uit o ufe r ood s ng ng r s ld e . Afe Prlt r ove ed, s t d De'onu t t t he we t ltai e t poie ggs tr tit ec r he ol l ha t s nt o sr ghtn' he gilre ' a woul &ç--he gilre sas up'i s di çha t ofs -a n.''1 The rfi nd,' nd d tf- r rfi nd' s f he d t t ype h- gai ' d. pur e oft s c pos hi onve s i wa t c r aton s o omm uniat t De'ont t tPrzt ç n' lke i whe c e o l a ha t ' ç it does t i t n peo e c os he '1 pl r s n' d. Alo dtrng Aprl 201 Pr i' ç vie 'De'ont t s bmi a r ques t t Pr t be s li i 0, ut t s d' t ad l a o u t e t ha uit nn e he Gc a tlaio ' whih woul alow Pnzt t t e a cos pr miy t Pli if' m d r ûont c i s ns ' c d l it o t p l e oxi t o antf . ' ke ' I Ar d. ound t s m etme,Przt ilcty de i r d a bl k br a blc l enyl t De'o a, he a i t t li il lve e i ac a nd a k ac ons o lnt u l i he e.4 d t - 2. ' sai t1t nk yo willke t s ' I . a 11 1 Atva i tm esfo Aprl201 t J y 30, t tng, t hi rous i rm i 0 o ul 201 Pr t ve ba l r prma 0, uit r ly e i nded o he i m a e who we e t l ng t De'ont a t d t m t t r n ts r aki o l a nd ol he o ç ta y fo he . 1 a 1 Va i ot ri e a tonsocc r e untlDe'on a w e toutf r ç wa r m r' d. t 2. rous he nt r c i ge ' u rd i l t n o s ge y on J y 30,201 I ur r ul 0. d. Upo he r t n o Nove r 2,201 De'o a was r a sg d t a t r buidi n r eur n mbe 0, l nt e s i ne o no he l ng, a y fo P ut' a sg me t Pr it<ma e i h rmiso t c met 'De lna sc l, el g wa rm r its si n n . ut x d l t e sin o o o' 'o t' eltli l n De'ont how g he body l l a ood r ooked a t lnghe t ts wa notaone.J l M ac 2011, nd eli r ha he s l #= n rh Pr itwoke up De'o a i he c la quesi d he a us t ily,G ut l nt n r el nd tone r cc aora l l You led t me;why i o di tyo c t l h?'#,a 1 Aloi M ac 2011 Pr itt e tne De'o awhe Pnzt dn' u ome o unc 'J. t 3. s n rh , ut hr ae d lnt n i' t t houghtt tDe'ont ha tl d t t o he prs g r a ha l a d a ke o wo t r ion ua ds boutDe'ont ss lore t ton. l a' exua i n a i 4TheCour notss t e ome i nsse y i t r cor a t how De'ont ac r t br andpa tes W he t y we e nco itnc n he e d s o l a quied he a ni . n he r confs atd,here a ton wast ts ha pmc s d t m t o h malo de whie a a pr viusf iiy a ic e xplna i ha he d ha e he hr ug i r r l t e o aclt nd t w eei he pos e sonwhe s a ve a BKCC.Se ECF No. 5 a 4hey r n r s s i n he ni d t e 21- t 8. 2 l Pr t t d De'ont iYou be tr notbe l ng t me, a don' t l t t e ot rf ma e d. uit ol l a, t te yi o nd t ak o hos he e l ofk e s. I t r ' d. ' On t or peha t ee ot so i Fe uay a M a c of 2011 Pnzt c wo r ps hr ca i ns n br r nd rh i t mne t o , De'ont ' ce l une l as l xpecedl a ts ly f ndld' Pl i i s br a t tn a dei r t a t y nd çexual o e ' antY e ss t i lbe a e nd f ce u ma r'a tgr d a s ez d' Pli tf spt ssI . Pl i ifdi notc e t or f l nne ' nd t ope nd que e ' a n if ni. d antf d ons nt o t sf i a gr ng.1 Dtrng t a e Przt t d D e'on a t t ç w ilm a i w or ' hi ondlng nd opi d. li he bus , tit ol l t ha $ l ke t 1 k' a d s t b e s a e(i)niea p r y.6I . t1 . s i tn e o a u ec u e Deln a n ç l ra t r sc c nd ek ' d a 2 Thee nsa c s f b s a s d ' t Yo r ' o physc pan fom t f r ef l s z ng of he prva e Pa t, e r m e e oto l pa n a ial i r he o c u quee i r i t rs xt e m i na i nd dites,a se p de i to l a 1 s as L=. a 23- (le ng ongoi pan fom t sr s nd le prvain. d. t 3; ee lo d t 24 algi ng i r he . a u e . ' n a alg st ts e s fee t q e ç moina i lc to s'fo t e a u e a a b s ) Del t l e ha h u fr d miu t to l mpiain ' r m h b s s o e e ta s xua1whos f sfom Ge rI ntt Dior r7J a 23. rnse ufer r nde de iy s de a #. t Ba e ont salge sxua a e Pl ntf s dPr t t r42U. C.j1 3,algi s d hi le d e l bus , ai if ue uitmde S. 98 le ng vi ai ns of her Ei ht Ame m e rg s as wdl as he rght unde t Prs n Ra olto g h nd nt i ht , r i s r he io pe El nainAc, 2U. C. j1 6 -1 6 9( 0 6 ($ i to t 4 S. j 5 01 5 0 2 0 ) ç mi PREA' . ' ) I. I LEG AL STANDARD Pr ithasr s d qua i i muniy as a a fr tve de e e,e ilng he t sl a y ut aie lsed m t n f ma i f ns ntti r o lmm r j d me t ç aiid i miyp o e t o fc r wh c mmi c n ttto lvo ai n b twh , u g n .ç lfe mmt t r tcs fies o o t o siuina ilto s u o ou i lght of cla l e t bls d l w,co d r s bl be ive t t t i a tons we e lwf l' n i e ry sa ihe a ul ea ona y le ha her c i r a u .' 5Ther i s i nsse i t Compl nta ai boutt daesoft alged a e. On page fveand sx oft he t he le bus e s ome nco itncy n he si i he Compli ,t Pli ifalegest a eocc r i Fe ay a M ach of201 butonpa sx t ough eiht ant he antf l he bus ured n bnz r nd r 0, ges i hr g , s ale t a eocc r d i Fe ua y a M arh of201l.Be us t Pl ntf wasnotta fred t BKCC he lges he bus ure n br r nd c ca e he ai if rnse r o untlAprl201 a De'o ar po tdt abus o Aprl1 2011,heCour a s st alge a eocc r d i i i 0 nd lnt e re he e n i 3, t t s ume he le d bus ure n Fe ta ya M a c 2011 notFe uay a M ach2010. brzr nd r h , br r nd r 6I i t cea i Pnzt alege y f e onebr s o bot . Th Co an a s mep nsdsuse teoj ct)o t s m l r f it l dl ondld ea t r h e mplit t o oit ic ss h b ets f t f i i t sng ar ECF No.1, he ondlng n he i ul , Compl a 1 1 buta ot rtmesus pl i c t ss h asGhe 'L. . t 2- 3, t he i es mal ndiaor uc t my'da a1 of t 2, r i br as ar nie a pe ky. J .( Your e t e c nd r ' #= empha i adde .Ta ng t fcma a s ri i t lg mos ' ss d) ki he a l s e tons n he iht t f vor bl t t Pl ntf,he Cour a s st ts algesPr itf e b0t br ass a a e o he ai if t t s ume ha he le ut ondld h e t. 1Ge d rIe tyDiode i ia sr n a dpesse tco sg n e ie tt to whc i ted sr t b , rte n e d ni s r r s ç ) to g n ritn r s-e d r d ni in, ih s h eie o e o h t l ka i it nc t tone i,oft ot r sx. Ame i n Ps arc Asociton,Di nosi a Sttsia M a nsse e ha s he he e ' ' rca ychiti s ai ag tc nd aitc l nualof Me tl s r r: M-V- 5 6( 0 0. na Diodes DS I TR 7 2 0 ) 3 He r v Pt el 6 2 F.d 5 4, 31( t Ci. 01 )(n b n )( i n S uce v. t,5 3 U. n y . mll, 5 3 2 5 4h r 2 1 e a c ct g a ir Kaz 3 S. i 1 4,2 6 ( 0 ) o ew- d i p r b Pe ro v Calh n 5 5 U. 2 3 ( 00 :.Qu lfe 9 0 2 01, v l l n a t y a s n . la a , 5 S. 2 2 9 e aiid i mmuniy i vesa t se i l ()whehert pli irsalegai sae acam t t t nvol wo-tp nquiy: a t he antf l tons tt li ha d fn a tsc n u tv oae ac n ttto a o sauo yrg t a d i s ,( )wh t e t a rg t e e d n ' o d c i ltd o si in l r tttr ih ; n f o b eh r h t ih u wasc e ry e t bls d.Sa i r 533 U . a 201.I t Cour dee m i t tt f t al ge l a l sa ihe uc e , S. t f he t t r nes ha he acs le d, t ke i t lg mos f vor bl t t Pl i if do nots a n n he i ht t a a e o he antf, how t tt ofk e ' c ha he t rs onduc vi ae a t ol td c nsi to a rg t t n te Dee d n i e tte t sl r j d me t wi u f rhe o tt in l ih , he h u fn a t s n ild o l mma y u g n t t u t r ho dic son ofqua ii i l t I a 201. s us i lfed mm miy. d. t 11 1. A N A LY SI S A . Pr s n R ape Elm i i A c Cl m io i naton t ai Li r ly co t i t Compli ,Pl nif s e r i t r j 1 f Pnlt' be al nsm ng he ant aitf e ks elef mde 983 or its vi ai nsoft PREA.As lm i Pr itvi a e t PREA whe s a l dl s xual a e olto he sl ng ut olt d he n he lege y e ly bus d Deln a t eei n b ssi 1w f rap iaec u eo a t n u d rj 1 3t e f r eaP 'o t, h r s o a i n a o rv t a s f ci n e 98 o n o c REA o vi ato çl e ton 1 is fce e no rght;r t ri pr desa mehod f vi c tng ol in. tslci 983 tel rats i s ahe t ovi t or ndiai fd r lrg t eswh r c n erd. Do v.Br d rc 22 F.d 4 0 4 7 ( t Ci.20 0 e ea ih s le e e o fre ' e ' o eik, 5 3 4 , 4 4h r 0 ) (nena ctto o te ) < W j e etetx a d sr cu eo asauep o ien idc to ta i tr l iains mitd .i h r h e t n tu t r f tt t r vd o n iai n h t l Cong e s i e t c eae ne i vi r s nt nds o r t w ndi dualrght ,t r i no ba i f a prvae s t whehe i s he e s ss or i t ui, t r t mderj 1 oru ra i id rgh ofa ton. Go a Uni v.Doe 5 U. 273,286 983 nde n mple i t ci ' nz ga v. ' , 36 S. ( 2) 200 . Not ng i t PREA s hi n he uggesst tCongr s i e d t c eae a prva e rghto a ton t ha es ntnde o r t i t i f ci f i t st s prs ofki l f nonc or nma e o ue ion t a s or omplanc wih t Ac .Se Balv.Be kwo t N o. i e t he t e l c rh, CV 1100037,2011W L 43758 a *4( M ont Aug.31,2011 ( tngcaes.Gl PREA i 06, t D. . ) cii s ) ç-he s i e d t a e s t pr e of r pe i pr s a t i s gr nt m o y, a c e t a nt nde o ddr s he obl m a n i on, u horze a ne nd r a es 4 c mison t sudy t is ...The saut does notgr t prs r a s cik rght.'' om s i o t he s ue. tt e an ione s ny pe t i s Chi civ.Edwa ds No.107- vnni r , : c 229,2008 W L 3851 , a *3 ( Vt Aug.13, 294 t D. . 2008 .Thus ) , Pl ntf f l t saea j 1 cl m ba e ona alege vi ai oft PREA.Ac or Ri r ai if ais o tt 983 ai s d n l d olton he c d vea v. a , 0 - 1 8 , 01 W L 1 7 6 2 ( D. i. a . 3 2 0 ; w v. h to No. Drke No. 9 CV- 1 2 2 0 1 2 0 E. W s M r 2 , 01 ) La W is n, 208CV- 2 ,2 0 W L 5 2 6 ( D.Ca.De .1 ,2 0 ) I s o v.Yae ,No 10 : - 0 91 0 9 0 95 4 E. l c 5 0 9;nce t s . :8 CV0 5 8 2 0 W L 3 7 0( D. l Oc. 8 2 0 ) 01 8 , 0 9 61 81 E. Ca. t 2 , 0 9 . Bec us Pl i if c nnots a e antf a how t tPr t vi a e he c tm tona or saut y rght ha uit olt d r onsi i l t t or i s unde t PREA,Przt i e il d t q lfe i uniy unde t trtSa irpr ng. 533 U . r he t t s ntte o uaii d mm t i r he è s uce o S. at206.Ac r ngl t Cour GRANTS t De e nts M oton f Slm ma y J m e on co di y, he t he f nda ' i or l r udg nt Pl ntf sPREA c am . ai if li B. Ei h A m e ght ndm e Cl m nt ai f'o saeacl m t r42 U. C.j 1 apli ifmus alget vi ain ofarght ç tt ai mde r S. 983, antf t le he olto i s cled by t Consi i orl oft Unied St t a m us s w t tt de i to of e tr he tmton aws he t aes nd t ho ha he prvai n t trghtwa comm itd by a pe s a tng t rc orofsae lm ' W e tv.At ns 487 U . ha i s te r on c i mde ol tt a ' s ki , S. 42,48( 988) I he j 1983cai Pli ifalege t tPr t s j ce he t c e a t ua 1 .n r l m, antf l s ha uit ub e td r o nzl nd mus l punihm e i vi a i of he Ei h Ame e rght whie a tng t r t c orof sae s nt n olton r ght ndm nt i s l c i mde he ol tt e t t li ha he s ntte o lw . I r pons , Przt ca mst ts i e il d t qualfe i uniy. a 8 n es i i d mm t The fr tpr oft q lte i m uniy a ys s i w he he - i t lghtm os f vo a e is ong he ua ii d m t nal i s t r n he i t a r bl t Pl i if Pl ntf a lgest tPr t t rook c o antf ai if le ha uit mde t onduc t tvi ae Pli ifsc tt i l t ha olt d antf ' onsiutona rght.Sa ir 533 U. a 201.l a j 1 cai a i ta sae ofkilunde t Ei h i s uce , S. t n 983 l m gans tt t a r he ght Bl a s wha conf i pa s i t Co ant Pli ifciest Vigi a c i i r pe s ue.ç antf n ome t usng s age n he mpli , antf t he r ni rm nal a ot t t i if pl s ist tde e tPnzt vi a e pl ntf Ei h Ame ubm t ha f ndan it olt d ai ifs ght ndmentrgh sa wel ast Prs Elmi ton Ac of i t s l he ion i nai t 2 0 (2U.. 9 1 6 9 a dsaelw Co eo Vianaj l 2- ) whc ,poe tdb teU..Co t uinb 0 3 4 SC. 5 0 , n tt a d f r ii 8. 61, ih rtce y h S nsi to y t mea ofa s xuala s ul/bus itm i ton,t e t,uponpl ntf,assa e a ns ny e s a ta e, n i dai hr as ai if tt d bove.'ECF No.1 Compl a 1 ' , . t 71 Li r l consr n t Compl nt t Cour i er est sr f enc t t r pesat easr ltng t Pli ifs 8. bealy tuig he ai , he t nt pr t hi eer e o he a t ut eai o antf ' rgh sunde t Ei h A m e e t befeefom c ue and t ualpunihm e r t rt n a s ri a s r e i t r he ght ndm nt o r r r l mus s nt ahe ha s e tng epaat cam un e teVigii ci n l a es ue S eLidaR. v lihadD.41 U.. 4, 9( 9 3 (: p iae li d r h r na rmia rp ott. e n S. .tc r , 0 S 61 61 1 7 ) çA) rv t ( ct e lc aj dcal c g ia l itrs i tep o euino n n r sc to o a ohe.) ii n aks u iily o nz be neetn h r sc to r o p o euin f n t r'. z ' Ame ndme ,apl ntf mus de taet t( )t al dco ti Gobe tvel s f e l nt ai if t monsrt ha 1 he lege nduc s ç j ci y, ufkinty s rous' a ( t tt prs n ofiilwa l i rtl i fe e t t pli ifsrg s ei '; nd 2) ha he io fca s ç beaey ndifr nt o he antf iht, del he t o s f t 'a ha a ç ufi i nty c pa e sa e ofmi ' Fn me v.Br nna 511 U . alh r a ey' nd d ' fc e l ul bl t t s nd. r r ' e n, S. 8 5 8 4( 9 4 . 2 , 3 19 ) Ast t trtpr oft qualfe i uniy t s,i i t iput d i t ca e 1w t t o he i s ong he ii d mm t e t t s md s e n he s a ha s xuala e by a pr s g r on a i a e m a vi a e t Ei h A m e m e .See W oodf d e bus i on ua d n nm t y ol t he ght nd nt or v. o 5 8 U. 8l 1 8( 0 6 ( e e,J,d se t )( c o dn l,t o e imae wh ae Ng , 4 S. , 1 2 0 ) Br y r . is ni t c r igy h s n t s o r ng W s xualy as a td by gua ds orwhos s xualas a t by ot i aesa e f iia e by g r , e l s ule r , e e s uls her nm t r acltt d ua ds ha s f e grvede i to oft i Eiht Ame ve uferd a prvains her g h ndme rght.) Fame,511U. a 834 nt i s' ; r r ' S. t (ç ngvi e l asa t i prs i smpl notpatoft pe lyt tci na ofe r pa ç Bei olnty suled n ion s i y r he nat ha rmi l fnde s y f rt ero fns sa an ts cey.)(nen lctto o te ) Sc we k v.Hato d 20 F.d o h i fe e g is o it ' itr a iai n mitd ; h n ' rf r , 4 3 1 8 ,1 9 ( t Ci. 0 0 CW s x l sa l o a imaeb ag ad r g r e so teg n e 1 7 1 7 9h r 2 0 ) e ua a su t n n n t y u r - e adls f h e d r of t guad or oft prs he r he ioner i de pl i fnsve t huma di t '' (ii Fei v. s e y ofe i o n gniy.' ctng lx ) M c rh , 3 F.d 6 9 7 2( t Ci.1 91 Bo d ev.S h id r 1 5F.d 8 7 8 ( dCi. ca tv 9 9 2 9 , 0 9h r 9 :; d i c n e e, 0 3 5 , 61 2 r 1 (ç c us sxua a e by acor ci ofke ma co tt es rousham i lct by 997) C a e e l bus Be re tons f r y nsiut ei r nfi ed a ofi e wih a s fc e l c pa e sa e o m i al ga i ofs h a e a e c ni bl a n fc r t ufi i nty ul bl t t f nd, le tons uc bus r og za e s Eih h Ame d n cams' se as Ro e v.Mc n l, .CI A.0 - 81JF,2 0 W L gt n me t li . e lo tn ); Do ad No V. 8 0 -J 0 9 4 4 3 7 a * ( De. v 3 , 0 9 (iigc s s, f 3 4 F. p' 8 6( dCi. 01 ) 3 8 6 , t 4 D. lNo . 0 2 0 ) ctn a e ) a fd. 9 Ap x 3 3 r 2 0 . Cours ha r cognied, howe r t t no e r a lga i of s xua a e i t ve e z ve , ha t ve y le ton e l bus s i b e tv l, s fkin l s ro s'f r p r os s o t Eihh Ame d n . S e W ikns v. ç j ciey u t e ty eiu ' o u p e f he g t o n me t e li Ga d ,1 0S. . 1 5 1 7 ( 0 ( g o e e ymae oe ttu h b ap io g ad gv srs d v 3 Ct 1 7 , 1 8 201 ) çNl t v r lv ln o c y rs n u r ie ie ç t af rlc us ofa ton. Boddi,1 F. a 861(çls aede s sofharsme a o edea a e ci ' ); e 05 3d t Gllolt piode a s nt nd t ouchi ... a e de pi a e.... Bu t y do no i ve a ha m of f de a cons iutona ng r s c bl t he t nvol r e rl tt i l pr tonsasdei by t Su eme Cour.l( tng Famer 511 U. a 833-4)9I ta opori fned he pr t' cii ' r , S. t 3 . nse d, co t mus co uc a f c -nt i ,c eby- as i r t de e m i i t s xuala e was urs t nd t a ti ensve as - c e nquiy o t r ne f he e bus s t inty s ro . ufk e l e i us On t f ct oft c s a ba a c it ntwih t a l i ofot rcours t Cour he a s he a e t r nd onsse t he nayss he t, he t c n l e t tPr itsalg d sxu la us o De lna i ç b e tv l,s fiin l s ro s' o o cud s ha ut' l e e a b e f 'o t s t j ciey u fce ty eiu 'f r e o p r s so t Eih hAme d n . eo r l n mao iy o c s swi fcu l i to u po e f he g t n me t Th vewhemig j rt f a e t a t a st ins h ua r oughl a l oust De'on a' ha f y naog o l t s ve ound a Ei h Am e e vi ai n.Se eg. W ood v. n ght ndm nt olto e. . , Be u li,6 2 F.d 1 41 1 4 - 9h Ci.2 1 )(le ain ta g a d ç to e ' p io e ' a car 9 3 0 , 0 9 51( t r 0 2 alg to s h t u r t r k d' rs n rs s n epe i f r a fw s c n s f rg ad' o g ai ain s tsid o j ci e a s b e tv ud n s o e e o d o u r s wn rtsc to aife b e tv nd u j ci e ee n so EihhAme d n cam) W ahigo v. v l, 9 F.d6 , 4 (t Ci. 01 ) lme t f g t n me t li ; s n tn Hiey 6 5 3 41 6 2 7 h r 2 2 ( ngaci bl c tt i cli baedondeane salegain t tatg r s ntfvet Gndi tona e onsiutonal am s ti e' l to ha &ua d pe i o s ve s co e n e nds gr t t l f i t pli ifs t tc e a pe s t z h t pli ifs a uiousy ondlng he a ntf ' esil s nd ni h oug he antf ' cl hi a t n whie srp s ar hi hi f nd e hi nude t tc e f r t or t ee ot ng nd he l ti e c ng m o l d s esi l s o wo hr sc n s'1; ahoun v Der la 31 F.d9 6 9 9 9 (t Ci. 0 3 ( l g to ta d nga e o d ')0 c l -el, 9 3 3 , 3 -40 7h r 2 0 ) al ai n h t mi e . srp s ac g a d t d Ge a rb l c mme t, f r e ( mae t p ro m tr v c tv ti e rh u r s i e sxu l i ad o n s' o c d i t) o ef r p o o ai e ma n ac s 'a ç n ed t i s i ks t a ds hi a la ea'whie he be o r'w ih no a l ga i of t , nd poi t he r tc ow r s na r l nt ve ' t le ton p ysc lijzy,sae a Eihh Ame d n cam) Sc we k 2 4 F.d a 1 9 - (n t h ia nl ttd n g t r n me t li ; h n , 0 3 t 1 6 98 imae sa e Ei h Ame e c am whe e gua d r pe t dl r que t d o a s gr d i t s tt d ght ndm nt l i r r e a e y e se r l ex, ope nma e' 9Th r a per t bea e r n dviin i tej dca te t n o c ssi whih a imaealg sap io ee p as o n megig i so n h u iil rame t f ae n c n n t l e rsn e gua d s xualy abus d hi or he . One cls of c e f us s on t l r e l e m r as as s oc e he angua i Boddi t t lmis Eiht ge n e ha i t g h Ame men cl mst s la et ti ds r o rpeii ' 1 F. a 8 and a hercas f us smor o nd t ai o exua bus ha s çeve e r e ttve, 05 3d t 61, ' not l s oc e en t o tmpoaysa d r so d cnc 'a t c mpeelc o p n lgc lutfc to frg ado imaesx a t ne rr tn ad f e e y' nd he o lt a k f e oo ia j siiain o u r -n-n t e u l c a us.S e eg,Wo d v Be u li, 9 F.d 1 41 1 5 - (t Ci.2 2 ; a o sv Duk , 0 -9 , 0 b e e . .. o . a car 6 2 3 0 , 0 051 9h r 01 ) Jc b . ro No. 4 1 41 20 7 WL 27 9 3 , t* - ( . Pa S p .l , 0 )Br mel Ia De to Co , 0 - 9 20 W L 31 71 7 6 4 6 a 34 W D. . e t 7 20 7; o lv.d ho p' f m No. 541 , 06 9 5, a * ( l a oOc. 1 2 0 ) Th Co r n e n ta d esti diiinsn eDelnasalg to so a u esae t 4 D. d h t3 , 0 6 . e u t e d o d r s hs vso ic ' t' le ain f b s tt o a Ei h Am e m en cl m unde eihersanda d. n ght nd t ai r t t r 1 H i v a yze t deaneesrght unde t Fo t nt Am e e , rt rt n t Ei h Am e e .See 0 vel nal d he ti ' i s r he uree h ndm nt ahe ha he ght ndm nt Belv. lih 4 U..5 0 5 5(9 9 (h Du P o e sClus p oe to saea lata geta to eu e l Wofs , 41 S 2 , 4 1 7 ) te e r c s a e rtcin r t e s s ra s h s nd r t Eihh Ame me t.Th Hiev c u tas n td ta dan u wa td tu hig o apesn' piaepat, he g t nd n) e v l o r lo oe h t t l n ne o c n f ro s rv t rs r it d t htm iit t vitm org aiyt a s ia ' s xualdesr s ca vi a eaprs rsc tmto lrg s nende o l lae he ci r tf he s alnts e ie , n olt ione ' onsi ina iht wh te o no t free etdb teas i n i s> iia t'(in oh rcs s. 9 F.da 6 3 eh r r the oc x re y h sal t s i fcn . ct g te ae )6 5 3 t 4 . a ' i butocks ex e hi ge t st i t ,a f cbl pr s e hi e t , pos d s nial o nma e nd or i y e s d s xpos pe si o t i ae' ed ni nt he nm t s cl he butoc ) Be y v.Os l,1 F. 11 11 (t Ci.1 ) (i ng s fce ot d t ks; n' wat 43 3d 27, 33 8h r 998 fndi ufiint e denc t s vi e o uppor a Ei ht Ame m e vi ai whe g r a tm p e t pe f m nont n g h nd nt ol ton n ua d te t d o ror r i pat outne down s a c s on f m ae i e pr ii d he f r s i nled u n he whe e r he e l nmat, opostone r o ex, nt d po r n s ewa n tf ly d e s d a d rpe tdy ma es x a c mme t t h r;W as n v. o e ,9 0 h s o u l rs e , n e ae l d e u l o ns o e) to J n s 8 F. 11 11 ( h Ci.1 2d 65, 66 8t r 992)(le tonst tguad pef me i i padown s rhes algai ha r ror d nvasve t eac am os daiy f t mont ,i whi h gua d co l t l or wo hs n c r nduc e 1adelbe ae e mi ton oft ge t l t d ç i r t xa nai he nia , a u , o rso c a dt ih ae s'wees fiin t s r iesl z j d me to imae s n s lwe t ma h n hg ra , r u fce t o u vv l . u g n n n t' ' mma y j 1 cam) J co v.Dtr No.0 1 2007 W L 2769 a *3- ( . Pa Se .1 983 li ; a bs lko, 4-941, 436, t 4 W D. . pt 7, 2 0 )(le ain t a g ad lo g l ' g o e a i maes b t c sa d g ni l o a snge 0 7 alg to s h t u r û u h y' r p d n n t ' u t k n e t s n i l r o a o c so , o i tec t s o ap t o sa c a wi o t yj si to ma b s fkin l c a i n n t n h ol e f ad wn e r h nd t u ml u tt in, y e u t t ty r h ka srous frEi h Ame me pur e ) Br lv.l ho De to Com , 05- 9,2006 e i o ght nd nt pos s; omel da p' f No. 41 W L 31 97157,a * ( l ho Oc.31,2006 algai t tguad a oa hed i t fom t 4 D. da t )(le ton ha r ppr c nmae r be nd,plce hi peni a ns i ae' clt butoc ,t n s e d t i t spe t a hi a d s s gai t nm t s o hed t ks he que ze he nma e' c or l mus l s be or s z ng t i ae' pr tm a y c o he g t s sa e a cli unde t c e f e quee i he nm t s esl bl l t d enial, t t s am r he Ei ht Ame g h ndme , obs r i t t t nvie s xua cont t t t i done malci l a nt e vng ha i uni t d e l ac ha s i ousy nd s si a l t ca eha m a t tdoe nota va e a l gii t s c iy i e es i t t of aditc ly o us r nd ha s d nc ny e tma e e m t nt r t s he ype c onduc t ti Gnc itntwih con e por r sa r ofde e y'a t r or ,vi a e t t ha s i onsse t t m a y tnda ds c nc nd, he ef e olt s he Eihh Ame d n ; Mo rs v. Ev rly 2 F. S p 2 2 4 2 2 43 ( D. Y. gt n me f) ri e se , 05 u p. d 3 , 4 - S. N. 2 0 )( e yng q ai e i nt wheef mae imae alg d t tamae g r e trd h r 0 2 d n i u lt d mmu i l y r e l n t l e ha e l uad n ee e ce la ni a d exua l as a t d' he a t s h c l t ght nd t s ly s ule ' r nd hat uc onduc wa pa tofa ong ng pa tm t s r n oi te a pr c ie ofm a e ofi e s e gi i s xua c t c wih f m a e i aes ;Thomasv.Dit nd a tc l tc r nga ng n e l on a t t e l nm t l s. ofColl a,887 F.Su 1 a # * ( D. 1 )(le ton t tg r t c f cbl lmbi pp. , t 3, 4-5 D. C. 995 algai ha uad wie ori y t he o a tmpt d t t uc i t spe s s xualy ha a s d i ae,a s ea r ouc d r te e o o h nma e' ni , e l r s e nm t nd pr d umor t t s ha t plitf tsah mo e u la dalnth' wa s t e ty sro s; 0v. ls r ug Cn v he an if f o s x a n s ic ' s uf nl e iu ) 01 Hilbo o h t . i ' ki De to Co r, 1 - 2 4 S ,2 2W L 4 3 4 ,a * - ( N. Se t 2 , 2 rp r p' f r.No. 2 CV- 0 - M 01 51 9 4 t 2 3 D. H. p . 5 201 ) e o t a d rc mme ai n a p o e .No 2 CV- 4- M ,2 2 W L 451 0 ,* ( N. Oc.2 n e o nd to p r v d .1 - 20 S 01 40 5 1 D. H. t , 201 (le tonst guadsi e i lyç abbe 'a i e' pe sa o tsilsdurng a 2) algai hat r ntntonal t gr d' n nmat s ni nd/r etce i pad wn s ac o f u o c so sae a cam ( n e t Fo re nh Ame d n ,a t t o e rh n o r c a ins tt d li u d r he u te t n me t s he imaewa ap era d ti e l.1 n t s r til ean e)1 De'ont hasa lge ar Pr itha notr td,t tPnzt m a s xualand t e tni l a le d, l ut s d ebute ha it de e hr ae ng r mar ove t c ls ofayea . spe i c mi td wih a las t i t nc off i e ks r he otr e r Thi rod ul nae t t e t wo nsa es ondlng De l a s br ss a gr ng a s ue zi herpe s De'o a ha alege s rous ongoi 'ont ' ea t nd opi nd q e ng ni. l nt s l d e i ng physc land e otona pan fo t i i nt e i lpan a lge y m a m or a ut by t ia m i l i r m he ncde , motona i le dl de e c e he f c t tDe'ont s f r fom Ge rl ntt Dior r The a lged a e wa bot s ve eand a t ha l a ufe s r nde de iy s de . le bus s h e r rpeii SeeBoddi,1 F. a 861(i-l r c nbenodoubtt ts veeo r ttvesxua e ttve. e 05 3d t çl-hee a l ha e r r epeii e l a us o a i t b a p io o f r c n b I be tv l,s fkin l s ro 'e o g t b e f n nmae y rs n fke a e o j ciey u f e ty eius n u h o c n ttt a EihhAme d n vo ain.)(mp a i a d d . s c Pr itsalg dc nd c o siu e n g t n me t ilto ' e h ss d e ) As u h, ut' le e o u t ' qua ii s a s fc e ty s i e n unde t hi he sa r e lfe s ufi i n l erous ve r he g r t nda d mbodi d i t Boddi lne of e n he ei i Thef l ng c esi t Boddi lnea editnguiha efom De'ont sf t algatons. J ks v.Made , l olowi as n he e i r si s bl r l a' acual le i ac on n' 1 8F. p' 65 6 -2(t Ci. 00 )(l gaino r b iga dga bi of rs n rsb to ksi ad pa ig 5 Ap x 6, 616 6h r 2 5 al to f u bn n rb ng p io e' u tc n e dn e ma n rddno a u tt a Eihh Amt me tvoain) J sp v. td Sae Fe .Bu eu o P io s 2 2 n e i t mo n o n g t nd n ilto ; o e h Uni tts d ra f rs n , 3 e F.d 9 ,a * - ( 0h Ci. 0 )(a l o nin ( Eihh Ame d n voain sae wh r imaealg d 3 01 t l2 1t r 20 0 tbe pi o ) no g t n me t ilto ttd ee n t l e e g r to he hm s v rli si as g e t ema e a e poe he be sst hm'; d i,1 5F.da 8 uad d uc d i e ea tme n u g si nn r nd x sd r rat o i ' Bo de 0 3 t 61 t v ) ( fmaeg ads u e ig amaeimaesh nd ço c ng' i p ni,a p esn a an thsb d wihh rfl a e l u r q e zn l n t' a ,t u hi 'hs e s nd r sig g is i o y t e ul t bo y,c mbn d wi sx al s g etv rmak ,i n ts fkinl sro s; ri v Wat, 0 - v- 7 8 d o it t e u l u g sie e r s s o u f e ty eiu ) Gaca . tsNo. 8C1.7 7 , h y 20 9W L27 7 8 , t* ( D. . S p.1 2 0 )twoi tn e o teg adnzbn hspel bl coh dp ns 0 7 0 5 a 7 S. N Y. e t , 0 9 t nsa c s f h u r h ig i r sl y lte e i ma a ns i e' cl hedbutoc ,aong wih s r i ppr it c gai t nmat s ot t ks l t eveal na oprae omment andanuna horz c ls a c we e s ut ied el e r h, r n ts fkinl sro sfrp r o e o teEihh Ame me t;W iimsv And ro No 0 - 2 4,2 0 WL o ut e ty eiu o u p s s f h g t nd n) la . e sn, . 3 3 5 0 4 l 2 2 2 ,a * ,* ( Kal S p . ,2 0 )(mdn noEihhAme dme tvoainwh r p io g ad ga be 28 9 7 t 1 4 D. r. e t 7 0 4 f ig gt n n ilto ee rsn u r rb d plitf'but k , x osdhipe i t panifa dma ecu esx a rmaks; neov. zi,1 3F. u p. anifs toc s e p e s ns o litf, n d r d e u le r ) Mo tr Cn se 5 S p 2d3 8 3 5( . N. 2 )Csv rl i tn e o s u e igo a lmaesp ns wihnoalg to o ijr ,s 6 , 7 SD. Y. 001 te ea' nsa c s f q ezn f n ' t' e i, t ' n l ain f nu y i e n ts t e t sro ) o uf nl eius. ki y c s s S es p an. . 'o t' alg to sc ranl s r ies mmayj d me tt e t emo e a e . e u r 8 De lna s le ain e ti y u vv u r u g n md r h r lni ntsanda d f lowe by t Ni h Cic ti W ood,69 F. a 1 51 e e t r o l d he nt r ui n 2 3d t 050- . The Cour a s c l s t De'o a ha al ged f c s on whih t f c inde c d t lo onc ude hat l nt s le at c he a t r oul de e m i t tPr itaced wih a t ufki nty c pabl sat ofm i 't her no l gii t l t r ne ha u t t t d f e l ul e t e s nd. û ' W e e tma e aw e o ce e o pe ogi a pu pos c n be i e nf r m nt r nol c l r e a nf nrd fom t de e nts al ge c r he f nda ' le d onduc ,t t he a e is l m a i s bus t ef y, n ome ciml sanc ,be s f inte de e of a c pa e sa e of mi ' r m t es ufk e vi nc ul bl tt nd. ' Boddi , 1 F. a 861.I c es of s xua abus o r pe, the conduc is l c tt e e 05 3d t n as e l e r a t t t te f onsiut s s fcint e de e t f ce wa us d ç i ousy and s ditc ly f t ve y pu pos of uf e vi nc hat or s e malci l a si a l or he r r e c usng ha' '' r v.Cor.Cor ofAm. 1 F. 1 1 1 ( 0h Ci.1 a i l 'Gion m. r p. , 91 3d 28 , 290 1 t r 999)(uoi q tng Whily v.Al r,475 U. 31 320- ( 986:.The co tc nno co eveofa lgii t te be s S. 2, 21 1 ur n t nc i ny e tmae 1w e or e e or pe ogial pup os behi Pnlt' al ge s xua a t e t ng a nf c m nt nol c e nd its le d e l nd hr aeni c me s 1t aone t i t nce of f ndlng a gr pi The s c om nt , e l he nsa s o i nd o ng. e ond e e nt oft Ei h l me he ght Ame e sa r i t r f e s tsi d,whi h i t s tsi t fr t ee e of t ndm nt t nda d s he e or a ife c n um a ifes he is lm nt he qua il i t t t s . lfed mm miy e t Unde t s ond e e e oft qua ii d i muniy t s,t Cour mus de e mi i t r he ec l m nt he lfe m t e t he t t t r ne f he rghtwas cea l e t bls d a t tm e ofDe e n ' aci .Sa ir 533 U. a 201.The i l ry sa ihe t he i f nda ts tons uce , S. t pur e oft s i r a qualfe i t t m o e ge r l i t ç ur t t d e nt pos hi nquiy, nd ii d mm miy r ne aly, s o < ens e ha ef nda s te s bl ca a i i e whe t rconduc m a gi rs t labiiy'by a tchi labiiy r a ona y n ntcpat n hei t y ve ie o i lt ta ng i lt o yi ûth c n o r o terg t(i ltdae s fiin l ce rt a ar ao a eo fca wo l nl f (l e o t u s f h i h v oae r) u fce ty la h t e s n bl f il ud unde s a t tw ha he i doi vi a est tr g .' U nie St t s v.La e ,520 U . 259,270 r t nd ha t s ng ol t ha i ht'' t d a e ni r S. ( 9 7 ( u tn Ankro ..Cr iho 4 3 U..6 5 6 0 ( 9 7 W i te fcs alg d 1 9 ) q o ig c s n y eg tn, 8 S 3 , 4 1 8 :. t h a t le e , h q lfe i muniy doe not s el Pr itfom la lt f he s xua a e of De'ont .See uaii d m t s hi d u t r ibiiy or r e l bus l a Sc nk,204 F. a 1 (t- ,t s ed t tqualfe i hwe 3d t1 97. çl -hus he hil ha iid mmuniy pr de i lmie t t ovi s s i td o 10 t e om cil who a e eihe una r oft rs o who t ke r a ona em e m est co e i. hos as r t r wa e he ik r a e s bl as o unt r t W he e gua ds t m s l s a e r s r r he eve r e ponsbl f r t r pe a s xua a e of i ae ,qua iid i e o he a nd e l bus nm ts lfe i ni o f r nos il '; e as j s tnt esmp eta dmo ta s lt o tr , h Eih h mmu t fe s h ed.) s e lo . (l h i ls n s b oue f ems t e g t y ' é û Amendme rg of prs s t be fe fom s xual a e was unque tonabl cla l nt i ht ioner o re r e bus si y e ry esa ihe pror t t tm e of t s a lged as aul,and no r a o bl prs gua d cou d t bls d i o he i hi le s t e s na e ion r l po sb yh v beiv d oh r s .) Tu n rv Hub e te 4 F. u p. d 1 4 ,1 5 - 3( . sil a e le e t e wie' ; r e . ir gs , 21 S p 2 1 9 1 2 5 W D. ' W i. 0 6 ( e yigq lfe i mi t g adswh alg dy tu h d imae sb to ksa d s 2 0 ) d n n uaiid mmt t o u r y o le e l o c e n t ' u tc n f e hi pe s. ondld s ni) Furhe mor ,Pnzt' al ge aci ns f l wihi t de i to of f a 'i t Prs t r e its le d to al t n he fnii n ç pe' n he ion r Ra e Elmi ai n Ac of2 0 ,se 4 U. C.j 1 6 (1 t tr la 'me nst e c r a p i n to t 0 3 e 2 S. 5 09 t Th em rpe a h an l k wld e o a s d my s x a a s utwi a o j c,o sx a f n l g o pes n f ri l no e g , r l o o , e u l s a l t n be t r e u l o di fa ro , o cby h n o a an tta p ro ' wil. .)(mp a i a d d ,za d aec i n lyp o cie b Va Co e r g i s h t e s n s 1 .' e h ss d e ll n r rmi al r s rb d y . d ' Ar j 1 .- 7. CWn a c s d i g it o s x a b tey i h s x al a us s a d fn d i m. 82 6 4. c u e s u l f e u l atr f e e u ly b e , s eie n y j 1 .- 7 1 . .(i a imae wh ha b e c mmitd t j i o c n itd a s ne e t 82 6 .0 . i n n t o s e n o te o al r o v ce nd t tnc d o ) c n ie n i a sae o lc lc re o lf cly o r go a j i,a d t a c s d i a o fn me t n tt r o a o r dina a ii r e in l al n he c u e s n t e oye orc r t le oyeeot oravol e rwih,t sat orl a c ci lfclt mpl e ontacua mpl l unte t he t e oc l one tona a iiy o r go a j i;i i ap sto o a t rt o rt eimae a dk o t tt eimaei u d r r e i n l al s n o i n f uho i ve h n t ; n n ws ha h n t s n e i y t eju s it n o te saeo lc lc re to a fclt o rgo a j i . .' . Co r tu h ti dci f h tt r o a o rcin l a i y r e in l al . .) The u t h s o i ' c l s t tDe'ont s rght no t be s xua l a ed by a prs gua d we e s fcinty oncude ha l a' i s t o e ly bus ion r r ufi e l wel- t bls i Fe a y a M a c of2011 lesa ihed n bnzr nd r h . Pr it ma t poi s i s ut kes wo nt n uppor of t a gum e t t her a tons a e s e de by t he r nt ha ci r hil d qualte i miy:( )s t no c r d wih a c i na ofe ei vi s xualasa t ii d mmt t 1 he d was t hage t ny rmi l fns nvol ng e sul 1 W a de Edmo ,t war n ofBKCC a t tm eD e'ont aleg s w a s xual a ed,alo a r i hi 2 r n nds he de t he i l a l es he s e ly bus s ve s n s am da tt t(Al saf bot s trt and a nita i sa f i l ngmys l, e i a vi ha t 1 tf, h ecliy dmi srtve tf,ncudi ef r ceve nnuali s r c tani n-e vie ri ng icu n r q rdi tu to o teP io Ra El nainAc 'ECFNo. -, mo dAf. 9 n ldig e uie nsr cin n h rs n pe i to t' mi 213 Ed n f ! . o sxu l batr ; a d ( ) te itr a p io i v siain d e d Deln as cams r e a tef' n 2 h n en l rs n n etg to e me ' t ' li o t o mde 'ECF No.58, e .Suppor ofDef' M .S l .J a 4. et roft e a gume s ç t d.' unf M m t .s lmm . t N ihe hes r nt ae rs r e ponsve t t i s be or t Co t t pot nta applc ton of q i d i muniy t i o he s ue f e he ur : he e i l i ai ualfe m t o De'ont s al ga i ofs xua a e.Pr t ofer no r s why t e t f t s ma t l a' le tons e l bus uit f s ea ons hes wo acor ke he a lged c tt i lvi a i a m or o l s s rous orDe'ont s rght nott be s xual le onsiutona olton ny e r es e i l a' i s o e ly a e a m or o ls e t bls d.The e or ,t Cour ne nota r s t m . bus d ny e r e s sa ihe r f e he t ed dd e s he I . V C O N CL USI N O Pr t' a lge aci - m a ng s xuala t r a e ng co me s aong wih a l a t uits le d tons ki e nd h e t ni m nt l t t es t i tnc s of f ndlng De'on a' br ass a gr ng De'ont s pe s whih ca e wo nsa e o i l t s e t nd opi l a' ni , c us d De'ont ongoi pan- a e no s ede by qualfe i mt t Thes aci ns a e s fcinty l a ng i r t hi l d ii d m miy. e to r ufi t l s rousf pur e oft Ei h Am e m e a Pr ita t d wih as fc e l c pa e sa e e i or pos s he ght nd nt nd ut c e t ufii nty ul bl t t ofmi N o r as bl peron c d ha t ug i M a c 2011t tt 1 per ted aprs nd. e ona e s oul ve ho ht n r h ha he aw mit ion gua d t f e a gr a i ae' br ass a peni.The e or t M oton f Slm ma y r o ondl nd ope n nm t s e t nd s r f e, he i or z r J m e i DENI a t Pli tf sEi h Am e e tCli .Bec us ho e r t r i no udg nt s ED s o a n if ght ndm n am a e, w ve , he e s prva e rghtof a ton t e or e a vi a i of t Prs Rape Elmi i Act Def nda ' i t i c i o nf c olton he ion i naton , e nts M o i f Slm ma y J ton or l r udgme i GR ANTED a t Pl ntf ' PREA c am . nt s s o ai ifs li ENTER: hs l dyo Jn ay 2 1. T i f a fau r, 0 3 . J Hon. am e C . k J s Tur 'v N Se orUnie St t sDititJ e ni t d a e src udg - 1 2
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
