De'lonta v. Pruitt, No. 7:2011cv00483 - Document 55 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 09/11/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
CL S OFFI U, DI COURT ERK CE S. ST. AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED I T H E U NI N TED STATES DI STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W ESTER N D ISTRICT O F V I G IN I R A RO A N O K E DI SI N VI O sEF 112 1 02 J A C. ULI B; Y; , GLERK oy jq ss O PH ELI A ZR I D E ' NTA A EL LO C i lA ct on N o.7: cvvi i 11- 00483 Pl ntf ai if, M FM OR ANDUM O PI ON M V. By: H on.Jam es C.Turk H A RO LD CLA R K E,e al, t . Seni U ni ed St esD i ri Judge or t at st ct D ef endant s. Thi m a t ri pr e l bef e t Cour on De e nt 'M o i f Sum m a y J gm e t s te s es nty or he t f nda s ton or r ud n ( . 20) Defnda s M otonf Pr e i Or r( . 31,a Plitf' Motont DktNo. , e nt' i or otctve de DktNo. ) nd anifs i o Compe ( tNo.39 , Deenda t'moi aebr htonbe fofalDee nt e e t l Dk. ) The f ns tons r oug hal l fnda s xc p Sa a Pr t, who i s pa a e y r pr s nt d. r h uit s e rtl e ee e 1 Pli tf,Ophe i De'o a aVigi ai t pr e ngrr s fl t sc vi rg s a n if la l nt , r ni nma e oc edi / e, ied hi i l i ht a to unde 42U. C.j 1 Pli ifale t tDefnda sfie t f l tani cin r S. 983. antf lges ha e nt ald o olow ri ng r quie e t m a t d by t Pr s n Ra Elm i ton Ac ,f ie t pr e the f om s xua e r m n s nda e he i o pe i na i t a l d o ot c r r e l a s ul by aprs gua d,f ie t pr vi he wih pr rmed c c r a trs r poredt sa t ion r a ld o o de r t ope i al a e fe he e t he a s ul,a vi a e he due pr es rght i va i usw a t o houtt i tga i n oft s a t nd ol t d r oc s i s n r o ys hr ug he nvesi to he a l ge a e le d bus . l r s ns ,Def nda sha t l d a M o i f r Sum m a y J m e , a sng qua ii d n e po e e nt ve i e ton o r udg nt r i i lfe i m uniy asa d e e a ha a s f l d a M o i f Pr e tve O r rs eki a s a of m t ef ns , nd ve l o ie ton or ot c i de e ng t y di co r untlt que t o o q lt e i m u t i r s ve Pl i tf hasr ponded t t s ve y i he s i n f ua ii d m niy s e ol d. a n if es o he M oton f Sum m ar Judgm entaft t Courtgave notce underRos o v.G ar i 528 F. i or y er he i ebor rson, 2d 309( hCi.1 .Thematri now rpef diposton. rt r s t tf l t Co t 4t r 975) te s i or s ii Fo he eaons ha olow,he ur lTh Cour doesnotdi c s c ai saga ns Pr t i t sM emor m Opi o . e t s us l m i t uit n hi andu ni n 1 wilgr ntt M o i f Summ a y J gm e ba e on quaii d i mt t a t Pl n ifs l a he ton or r ud nt s d lfe m miy s o aitf j 1 3cli seki moneayda gesa wilga t M oi f Pr eci Or r 98 ams e ng tr ma nd l rnt he ton or ot tve de. S e iial t Co r g a t s mmayj d me to tePlitf sfiu et tancamsa an t p cfc l he u t r ns u r u g n n h anif alr o ri li g is y, Cl r ,Edm onds a C.Da s t f iur t p o e tc a m saga ns Cl r a W as ng on; he a ke , nd vi ; he a l e o r t c l i i t a ke nd hi l t f l e t pr ectcl m sagai Edm ondsand C.D avi ;t f l t pr de m edi car cl m aiur o ot ai nst s he aiure o ovi cal e ai a t Edm onds C.Da s W a s n,a La a al oft d pr e s c a m s The Co t so , vi , t o nd ng; nd l he ue oc s l i . ur ds s e Plitf' camsf rd ca ao ya dij ncier l fa ans t e eDee da t u d r imis s anifs li o e lr tr n n u tv ei g i t h s fn ns n e e 28U. C.j11 ()2)b)f f l et saeacam. ,heonl cai rmani i t S. 915e ( ( or aiur o tt li Thus t y l ms e i ng n he c s a e Pl i t f scl i s a i tSa a Pr t . a e r a n if a m ga ns r h uit 1. FA CT S l M a c 201 , O phe i D e'o t , a pr - r tve t a s xualhous d i t V igi a n rh 0 e n he r ni la 1 n a 2 e ope a i r ns e De t nto Coreci (1 parme f r tons ( VDOC' prs s tm, sfrtta fre t t Buc ng m ' ion yse wa is rnser d o he ki ha ) Coreci Ce e (t r tonal ntr C BKCC' afe s alge aprs guada Powhaa Core tona Ce tr ' tr he le d ion r t ) tn rci l ne (t 'hada us he.Se De'ant v. as No.109CV11 2011W L 795 ( D. û PCC' ) b ed r e lo a Pe ron, : 67, 934 E. Va. b.24,2011.Herta frf l dame i bewee t n- ssa Ator yGe rl Fe ) rnse olowe etng t n he As itnt t ne nea W ila M us a s ni rVDOC ofi i l whe ehe cli sofa ewe ea lgedl dic s d. lim e nd e o fc as r r am bus r le y s us e Soon a tra vi a BK CC,Pl i tf m e O fi e Sa a Pr t , pr s g r who alege y fe ni ng t a n if t f c r r h uit a ion ua d l dl r m e be e Pl i iff om a pr vi f ciiy.To puti brefy,Pl i ifalege t tar nd e m r d a ntf r e ous a lt t i l a ntf l s ha ou Febr y and M ar of2011 Sarah Pruit(sexualy f ed' Pl ntf sbr tti a delber e uar ch ts l ondl ' ai if eas tn i at a f c ulm a m er' nd ( ope a s e d' Pl i tf spe s 3I M a c 20 1 , Pl i tf nd or ef l 'a t gr d nd que ze ' a n if ni . n r h 1 a n if 2Alhough pr vi ca esi vi De'on a s lh r l tna ew ih a ca t lL ,t compl i s lsi wih a t e ous s nvol ng l t pel e as m t pia he ant pe l t t l rca e L. owe s 3The e i s e i ons senc i t Compl i a tt da e oft ale abus . On pa fve a sx oft r s om nc it y n he a nt bou he t s he l ged e ges i nd i he Compl nt t e Pl i ifa l t a e oc r ed i Fe uar and M a ch of201 buto pag si t ough e gh , ai , h a ntf leges he bus cu r n br y r 0, n es x hr i t s alge t ab eoc uredi Fe uay a M ac of20ll Be us t Plitf rpore t a eon Ap i l he le s he us c r n br r nd rh . ca e he an if e td he bus rl 3, 20llbutwasnott a f r t BKCC u i M a c 201 t Cour a s m est a e alege y occ e i 20ll r ns ered o ntl r h 0, he t su he bus l dl un'd n . 2 al ge y wr eal te t VDOC die t rHowa d Clr i or i hi t ts washa ng le dl ot et r o rco r a ke nf m ng m ha he vi (s r o pr e sw ih a s cu iy s a fm e be , buthi r pl wasunr ponsve t t a e, ie i us obl m t e r t t f m r' ' se y es i o he bus i t a a e s ng he com pul i t s f s ge y. ns e d ddr s i r son o el- ur r Com pl a 9. .t Pl i iffnaly r po t d t a l ge a e t he ps hol s ,Def nda La on Apr l a ntf i l e r e he le d bus o r yc ogi t e nt ng, i 1 2011 Pl i ift n ha a i e v e w ih D e e ntSpe i lA ge W a s n, ho pe f m e 3, . a ntf he d n nt r i w t f nda ca nt t o w r or d t i s i ton,w ih m i m a a s s a e f om D e e ntD a s a i tt tona i tga or he nve tga i t ni l s i t nc r f nda vi , n ns iu i l nves i t . Pl i tf a l gest tW a s a D a svi a e he due pr es rght i t i s i ton by no a n if le ha t on nd vi ol t d r oc s i s n he nve tga i t i e de i w ines e t s s i had pe tne i o m a i She al o a l ge t ta t rs nt r w ng t s s hat he a d r i nt nf r ton. s le s ha f e he rpore t a e s wase c tddie tyt a mi srtves gr ain (opr e the fom e td he bus , he s ore rcl o d nitai e eg to t otc r r f t rco a twihOfi e Pr i' a wasde edme c lc r d piet physca a urhe ntc t tc r ut) nd t ni dia ae es t he i l nd e otona pa n c m e e t t s xu a e. m i l i ol ct d o he e al bus Pl ntf a s brngs a due pr es c a m bas d on a l ga i t tA ge W a s f ie t ai i f l o i oc s l i e le tons ha nt t on a l d o fl o t r qui e c i c ton f m whe s z ng f m a e unde ga m en s f om Pl i tf . il ut he e r d onts a i or n ei i e l r r t r a n if l l. LEG AL STAN D A RD S The D e e nt ha r s d q lte i m u t a a a fr a i def ns ,e ilng t m f nda s ve ai e ua ii d m niy s n f im tve e e ntti he t s mmayj dg n .û lte i nt p o e t o tc r wh c mmic nsi to a o u r u me tç i d mmu iy r tcs f es o o t o tt in l oua i i u vi a i b who,i lgh ofcl a l e t bls d l w ,c d r s bl beleve t tt i a tons ol tons ut ni t e ry s a i he a oul ea ona y i ha he r c i weelwf .' m. v. nel652F.d 5 531( hCi. 1 (nba )(ii Sa irv. r a ul'He v Pur l, 3 24, 4t r 201 ) e nc ctng uce Kaz 533U. 1 206( ) ovenze i patbyPeas n v.Calaha 555U. 223( ) t, S. 94, 2001, r ld n r ro l n, S. 2009). Quaiid i lfe mmuniyi ve at se i r ()whehert pli ifsalgai saea t nvol s wo-tp nquiy: a t he antf' le tons tt cli t tdefnda s conduc vi ae ac tt i lorsauor rght a i s ( whehe am ha e nt' t oltd onsiutona ttt y i ; nd f o,b) t r t trghtw a c e ry e t bls d.Sa i r 533 U . a 206.l t Cour de e m i t tt f ct ha i s l a l s a i he uc e , S. t f he t t r nes ha he a s aleged,t l aken i t lghtm os f abl t t Pl ntf ,do notshow t t of i sconduct n he i t avor e o he ai if hat he fcer' 3 viltdac n t uina rg t te t eDee d n saee tte t s mmayj d me t to t oae o si to l ih ,h n h fn a t r n i d o u r u g n wi u t l h f rhe d s son ofqualt e i m uniy. d. t201 ' t r i cus i u ii d m t l a . D e e nt f t ra g t tt y a e e tte t a pr e tve or r a i tdicove y f nda s urhe r ue ha he r n il d o ot c i de ga ns s r be a et y ha r ied ade ens ofqualfe i c us he ve a s f e ii d mmuniy i t i pe ngdipostvem oton. t n he r ndi s ii i They s ek a pr t c i or raga ns di c r untlt Cour r e on t t e hol i s of e o e tve de i t s ove y i he t ul s he hr s d s ue quaii i lfed mmuniy.SeeSi er v. le 500U. 2 232- ( 991 ; row v. tgead, t ec t Gilv, S. 26, 33 1 ) Hal Fiz rl 45 U. 800,81 1 ( 982) Unde Sice ta Halw,t dititc tupo amoto f 7 S. 8- 9 1 , r e r nd ro he src our, n in or s mmayj d me ts o l n trq ied fn a t t r s o dt ds o e yr q e t u tl u r u g n, h ud o e ur e e d ns o e p n o ic v r e u ss ni de i ng t t r s d qualf e i m uniy que ton. c di he h e hol ii d m t si 11 1. EI TH A M EN DM ENT CLA I S GH M Tosaeac eofa tonunde j1 apli ifmus aleg t theha be n de i d tt aus ci r 983, antf t l e ha s e prve ofrgh s gua a e d by t Cons iu i n orl ws oft Unie St t s a t tt s de i ton i t r nt e he tt t o a he t d a e nd ha hi prva i r s t fom c e uled r onduc c m it d by a pe s a tng u erc orofs a e l .W e tv. ki , t om te r on c i nd ol t t aw s At ns 48 U. 42( 988)Topr ryal aSe ton 1 cai a i tasaeofi a unde t 7 S. 1 . opel lege ci 983 l m gans tt tcil r he Eihh Ame d n , panifmu td mo srt ta ()t alg dc n u ti t be tv l, gt n me t a litf s e n tae h t 1 he le e o d c s t j ciey o s fce l s rous'a ( t tt prs ofi a wa ç lbeaeyi fee t t pli ifs ufiinty ei '; nd 2) ha he ion fcil s i i rtl ndifrnt o he antf de rght ,he lh ors f t 'a had a t ufi i nty c pa e sa e ofm i ' Fa m e v.Br nna 511 i s at a e y' nd t fc e l ul bl t t s nd.' r r e n, U. 825,834( 4) S. 199 . A prs ofi i ls s de i a e i f e e i he know sofa dir ga ds a i on tc a how lber t ndif r nce f nd s e r n e e s ve rs t i a e he t or s f t t of i a m us bo h be a a e off c s xc s i i k o nm t alh a e y; he fci l t t w r at fom w hi t i e e c d be dr wn t ta s t nta r s of s r o ha m r ch he nf r nce oul a ha ubs a i l i k e i us r e s s a he m us al o d a t i e e .l a ton, i o ofi a sw ho xit , nd t s r w he nf r nce n ddii pr s n fci l ac ua l kne ofa s t nta r s t i a ehea t or s f t m a be f t ly w ubs a i l ik o nm t lh aey y ound f e re f om labiiy i t r ponded reas r i lt f hey es onabl t t rik,even i t hann uli at y y o he s f he t m el w asnotavert A prson of i alsdut undert Ei h Am endm enti t ensur ed. i fci ' y he ght so e r onabl saf y. eas e et Od m v. Caoi De t Co r, 4 F.d 7 , 7 (t Ci. 0 3 (n en l iai n o S. r l na p'of r.3 9 3 65 7 0 4h r 2 0 ) itr a ctto s omitd) te . To pr ry s a e a c a m upo w hi h r i c n be gr nt Pl i ifs a l ga i m us ope l t t l i n c elef a a ed, a ntf le tons t tsaeacl m t r i t ti plusbl onisfc 'As r tv.gbal556U. 662, ( ) ttt ai o elef ha s a i e t a e. hcof l , ' S. 678 2009 . Gl r r st Pl i ift a tc ae f c s wh a c pt d a tue, ha thow 't tt Pl ntf tt equie he antf o riult a t, en c e e s r t t s ha he ai if hass a ed a c a m e tti hi t r le ,ie. t ç a i lt ofe il e t r le .' Fr nc sv. tt l i n ilng m o e i f . , he pl usbiiy nttem nt o e i f '' a i Gico li588F. 1 1 ( hCi. a mel, 3d 86, 93 4t r 2009)(uoi As r t556U. a 678) q tng hcof, S. t . A. Faiure t Trai - C l l o n arke,E dm onds,C.D avi s De'o aase t cli a i tDee nsClr ( rcorofVDOC) Edmo lnt srs ams gans fnda t ake Die t , nds ( ade ofBKCC) a C. vi ( e ofSe iy)f f l et pr d t tani rquie W r n , nd Da s Chif curt or aiur o ovie he ri ng e rd byt Prs n RapeElmi tonAc, U. C.jj1 -15609( he io i nai t42 S. 5601 2006)(TREA'. t ' ) Unde t fr tpr oft quaii d i muniy a yss t Cour m us deer nei t r he is ong he lfe m t nal i, he t t t mi f he Pl ntf salegatonsst e a cl m t D ef ai if' l i at ai hat endant conductvi at Pl ntf constt i s' ol ed ai ips iutonalor saut r rg s Pli ifaleg t tt Def nt'f l et p ope l c t t o y i ht . antf l es ha he enda s aiur o r ry onduc PREAt m a t d ta ni i a vi aton ofherEi h A m e e rgh s a t i ac i na e unde nda e r i ng s ol i ght ndm nt i t nd hus s to bl r Se ton 1 4Butno e yvi ai offdeallw d veglrs t aci lrght cam purua t ci 983. t ver olton e r a s s ie o vi i s li gi s n t sci 1 o e ton 983.Thi i bec us s c i 1 is l c e esno r ght ' a he i pr de am e hod s s a e e ton 983 t e f r at i s r t r t ovi s , t frvi c tngfde a rg seswheec erd. Do v.Br erc 2 F.d440, ( h o ndiai e r l iht le r onfre ' e ' od ik, 25 3 447 4t Ci. 0 0 (nen l iainso te ) SW l eetetx a d sr cu eo asau ep o ien r 2 0 ) i tr a ctto mitd .' h r h e t n tu t r f ttt r vd o g i c to t tCongr s i e t c e t ne i vi ualrght ,t r i no bass f a prva e ndi a i n ha es nt nds o r a e w ndi d i s he e s i or i t s t whehe unde j1 orunde a i idrghtofa ton. Go acaUni v. ,536U. ui, t r r 983 r n mple i ci ' nz ' v. Doe S. 273, 6( 28 2002) . 4Con r l t t Pl i if sas eri , tePRE d e n ttitrn g n e p io eswi i te(ae oy o t ay o he a ntf ' s ton h A o s o ista s e d r rs n r t n h ctg r) f l h doetal v lealprsnr,'h u hFame vBrna , lU..85 8 8 4 (9 4,eonzdta p tnily unrbe io es'to g r r . en n 51 S 2 , 4 - 9 19 )rcj ie ht ' ta ge r ns nderprs r fceaheghtnedrs ofs uala ei t g r popultonofam al prs iones a i e ik ex bus n he eneal ai e lon. 5 No hi i t PREA s esst tCongr s i e d t c e t aprva erghtofa ton t ng n he ugg t ha e s nt nde o r a e i t i ci f i a est s pr s of i i s f no om pla e w ih t A c .See Bal v. kworh, o. or nm t o ue i on f c al or nc i nc t he t l Bec t N CV l100037, 1W L 43758 a *4( MontAug.31 201 (ii c es.û' PREA i 201 06, t D. . , 1) ctng as ) û-he f s i t nde t add e st pr e ofr pe i prs n, ut r z s gr ntm one a c e t s a n e d o r s he obl m a n i o a ho i e a y, nd r a e co ison t sudy t is ....Thesaut doe no g a tprs r a s cii rght.' mm s i o t he s ue t t e s t r n ione s ny pe tc i s' Chi c v.Edwads No.1: nnii r , 07 +v-229,2008W L 3851 a * ( Vt Aug.13,2008 . , 294, t 3 D. . ) Thus Pl ntf fist saeaj1983cli ba e o a alge vi ai oft PREA tani ai if al o tt am s d n n le d olton he ri ng rquie nt.Ac or Ri r v. a No. CV-11 201 W L 11 2602( D. i. a . e rme s c d vea Drke, 0982, 0 7 E. W s M r 23, 201 ;La v. his No. 08- 0291 2009W L 502956 ( D.Ca. c.1 2009 ; 0) w W ton, 2: CV- , 4 E. lDe 5, ) l c v.Yaes No.108- 001 200 W L 361 0( D.Ca.Oc.28,2009) ns oe t, : CV- 588, 9 781 E. l t . Be a e Pl ntf ha no s a e a c ai t tD e e nt vi l t d he co tt i lo c us ai i f s t t t d l m ha f nda s o a e r ns iutona r s a ut r r g sr l t d t t PREA ,D e e nt a e e il d t qua ii i m uniy undert fr t t t o y i ht e a e o he f nda s r ntte o lted m t he is Sa ce p o . 3 U. a 2 6. c r n l,h Co r g a t s mmayj d me tt Dee d n s u ir r ng 5 3 S. t 0 Ac o digy t e u t rn s u r u g n o fn a t on Pl i ifs f l e t t a n cl i s a ntf aiur o r i a m . B. Faiure t Protect- C l l o arke and W ashi on ngt Pl i ifa s a l gescl m s a i tD e e nt Cl r a W a hi t f f ii t a ntf l o le ai ga ns f nda s a ke nd s ng on or a lng o pr ec he f om t s xua a e s a l ge y s f r d a t ha ofO f i erPr t . ot t r r he e l bus he le dl uf e e t he nds fc uit Def nda s Cl r a W a hi on a e t die t a r ona die t ofV D OC,r s c i l e nt a ke nd s ngt r he r c or nd egi l r c or e pe tve y. Aspr vi l dic s d,t t e e t Pli ifr leson af l et pr d Pl A- a a e e ousy s us e o he xtnt he antf ei aiur o ovi e v m nd t d tann a t b ssf rh rfi r t p oe tcam, e camsaes b e tt d s sa sn e ri ig s he a i o e al e o rtc li h r li r u j c o imis l ic u PREA vi ai c nno f m t ba i fraj 1 cli ThePl nif ho ve ,doe no r l oltons a t or he ss o 983 am. aitf, we r s t ey e l i l on PREA a t ba i f he f iur t pr t c c ai s butal o a s rs c ai s ba ed xc us ve y s he s s or r a l e o o e t l m , s s et l m s 6 o Cl r s a W as ngt s f l et pr ve a l d s xua a e des t alege pe s nal n a ke' nd hi on' aiur o e nt lege e l bus pie l d r o know l dge ofa s cii r s t t Pl i tf . e pe tc i k o he a n if Unde t fr tpr oft qua ii i m uniy a l i , he Cour m us de e m i i t r he is ong he lfed m t na ys s t t t t r ne f he Pl ntf s a l ga i s a e a c a m t tD e e nt 'ale d co uc vi a e a c tt i lor ai if le tons t t l i ha f nda s l ge nd t ol t d ons iutona s a ut y r gh .To a d t a i a i ofq ii d i m uniy on a f itr t pr ec cl i ,a t t or i t voi he pplc ton ualf e m t a lle o ot t a m Plitf mus alg t a s wa s be toc n iin ta p e as bsa ta rs o s ro s anif t le e h t he s u j c t o dto s h t osd u tnil ik f e iu ha m ,a t tpr s of i i l w e e a t ly a a e ofa dir ga de t tr s Fa m e v. r nd ha i on fc a s r c ua l w r nd s e r d ha i k. r r Brmln, lU. 8 8 e a 51 S. 25, 34-37( 99 ;seas Pa s e r .Le v.Clveand,372F. 29 1 4) e lo nih x el e e l 3d 4, 303( hCi. 4t r 2004)(;nma ngt sa ssme ,i i i tn t rme rt tt cos t $ 1 ki hi se s nt t s mpora t o e mbe ha o r s he t es d fom m e eneglgenc t c cince s ki dei r t i fe enc t ofi r not hr hol r r i e o ons e -hoc ng lbe ae ndif r e, he fce s onl m us r cog z t f t gi ng r s t t r s butt a s m us dr w t a tona c us l y t e ni e he ac s vi i e o he i k, hey l o t a he ddii l a a i ee .'.tpqionofi i swhoa t lyk w ofas tnta rs t i t heat o s ft nfrnce' çl rs tcal ) cual ne ubsa il ik o nmae lh r aey m a be f y ound f e f om la lt i t y r ponde r as bl t t r s eve i t ha r e r i biiy f he es d e ona y o he i k, n f he nn uli tl wa no a re 'Odom v.S. r i De to Con. 349F. 765,770( hCi. tmaey s t ve td. ' Caolna p' f . , 3d 4t r 2003)(nenalcttonso te .solfcil c nbela eunde t dei rt i fee e itr iai mitd) dg fi as a ibl r he lbeae ndifrnc s andar onl t t ext t t ac ualy appr at t rs f orsi a gi case,and onl t d y o he ent hat hey t l eci e he ik act n ven y t t e e t y m a t c us i e enc t tt cic s a s a t y per e ve t m o he xt nt he ke he a al nf r e ha he r um t nce s he c i d he c e t d a s t nta r s ofs r ousha m .' r ih,37 F. a 304. r a e ubs a i l i k ei r ' Pa rs 2 3d t Pl ntf a l s t tDef nda Cl r w a a a e t tPl ntf wasa r s ofa s ul i ai i f lege ha e nt a ke s w r ha ai if t ik sa tn t o g ner lw a a t e s cii w a Ge r ly,Cl r w a a l ge y a a e t ta w e a ys nd hr e pe fc ys. ne a l a ke s le dl w r ha w i pr a pr bl m of s xuala e e s e i t e V D OC s t m a t tt a ge rpr s r des e d o e e bus xit d n h ys e nd ha r ns nde i one s ar a cl ofprsoner s e ass i s usceptbl t s i e o exualabuse.Specii l Pl ntf alegest tCl ke w as tcaly, ai if l ha ar pe s ly a a e t tPl ntf ha be n s xua l a s ule t i wihi V D O C d t t f t r ona l w r ha ai if s e e ly s a t d w ce t n ue o he ac t tt a e w a C um e t 'i a c tc e i w hi h Cl ke w a no a def nda .Se ha he bus st doc n ed' n our as n c ar s t e nt e De'ant v.Peas No.1: to a ron, 09CV11 2011W L 7 67, 95934( D.Va.Fe 24,2011.Pli if E. b. ) antf f t r a l s t tCl r a t nde a m e tng i M a c 201 w ih t n- s it ntAtonz y urhe lege ha a ke te d ei n rh 0 t he A s s a t e Ge r Mus i whiht ras f Pli ifsta frt BKCC (e a ebysat wa neal e n c he e on or antf rnse o s xual bus tfl s dic s d,a t ts wr t a lte t Cl r i m i M a c 2011i o m i hi ' hewa s us e nd ha he o e et r o a ke n d- r h nf r ng m ' s s ha ng s r o pr em s w ih a s a fm e be .' n s t oft spe s vi e i us obl t t f m r' l pie hi r onalknow l dge,s a l ges e he le t tCl r di no hi t pr ec he fom t t e tofab e f o a pr s gua d a BK CC. ha a ke d t ng o ot t r r he hr a us r m i on r t Pl i ifa l gest tW a hi t w a alo a a e t ts had be n pr vi l s xua l a ntf le ha s ng on s s w r ha he e e ous y e ly as a t b an i a e and by a co r c i na of i ra PCC by vi t oft pr vi l w s t t t s uled y nm t r e to l fce t r ue he e ous a ui, ha W as ngt n al o a t nde t m ee i i M a ch 201 w ih M us ,a t the û w ofo s d hi o s te d he tng n r 0 t e nd ha t kne r houl ha know n of't tPl i t f w asa r s ofa e by O fi e Pr t . ve ' ha a n i f t ik bus t c r uit De'ont f l t ale s fc e tf c sunde l i he f itr t pr e tc ai aga ns l a ais o l ge ufi i n a t r y ng r a lle o ot c l m i t Defnda sClr a W ahi ont s vi s e nt ake nd s ngt o ur ve ummayj r udgme tbasd onquaiidi n e lfe mmuniy. t l i i pl us bl t tt s t o D e e a s a t die t ra r gi t s m a i e ha he e w f nd nt , s he r c o nd e onaldiec orofV D OC,w o d r t ul ga he pe s nala a e s f om a c t s i whi h t y w e e notde e nt ,f om whi h t y t r ro w r ne s r our ca e n c he r f nda s r c he w o d know ofs ii r s t Pl ntf a BKCC . ul pec f c i ks o ai if t Pl ntf r i on t M a c 2011 l te t Cl r t s ai i f eles he r h e t r o a ke o uppor herc ai t the a t w ih t l m ha c ed t dei rt i fe enc Howe r t Compl ntf ist al t ts t d hi t ta saf lbe ae ndif r e. ve ,he ai a l o lege ha he ol m ha t f me rwa s lya s uli he,us t tS hewa ha ngsrouspr e wihas c iy mbe s exual s a tng rj tha s s s vi e i oblms t e urt saf m e be . l r s t f m r ' n e pons ,Cl r s n a l te a tPl i if s s l - ur y c pul i n. es ' e a ke e t e t r bou a ntf e f s ger om s o Th e sa e e t d nots f c e l alege t tCl r r og z d t t a t gi ng r s t t r s ' tt m n s o ufi i nty l ha a ke ec ni e he û c s vi ie o he i k, f ' Pa s e r lLe v. e a 372F. 294, (t Ci. ni h x e. e Clvelnd, 3d 303 4h r 2004) t tafmaeguada BKCC ,ha e l r t w ou d s xua l as a tPl ntf .The quot l ngua f o t l te coul notputCl r on l e ly s ul ai if ed a ge r m he e t r d a ke 8 notc t ta s af m e be w a s xua l a i Pl i tf . t r or Cl r sr s i e ha t f m r s e ly busng a n if Fur he m e, a ke' e pons a e bout s l- ur r i f t revi e t tCl r di no a t ly di r ar t i or a i Pl i tf e f s ge y s ur he denc ha a ke d t c ua l s eg d he nf m ton a n if pr de ordr w a i e e fom t saed f cst tPl ntf wasa rs ofs xua a s ul b ovi d a n nf r nce r he t t a t ha ai if t ik e l s a t y s a fa BK CC . r i no pl us bl aleg ton t tCl r w a ( w a e oft ditnc rs ' tf t The e s a i e l a i ha a ke s s r a he s i t i k' Pl i tf a l ge y f c a BK CC,i a 306,o t tCl r kne of4a s cii r s di tnc f om a n if le dl a ed t d. t r ha a ke w : pe fc i k s i t r t ge rlrs jofwhi t ofie gwa la r .'d. or ngl t M ac 2011lte i he nea ikg ch he fc r s wa e'1 Acc di y,he rh etr s i uf i i n t ade t l s ns fc e t o qua e y uppor a c tt i lcl i t tCl r f ie t pr e Pl i if t ons iutona a m ha a ke a l d o ot ct a ntf . Pl i i fa s a l gest tt s t def nda s a t d a M a ch 201 m e tng i w hi h a ntf l o le ha he e wo e nt tende r 0 ei n c t a tndee dic s d Pl i ifsa eby a sa fm e ra PCC,whi h pr ci t td t he te s s us e antf bus t f mbe t c e piae he ta f rt BK CC . n i bot def nda s w e e a t m e tng a w e e a a e a s a fm e be r ns e o Eve f h e nt r t he e i nd r w r t f m r s xua l abus d Pl ntf ,of i i l i a be f e ly e ai i f fc a s û y m ound fee f o la lt i t y r ponded r r m i biiy f he es ra ona y't apecevedrs Fame v. ema 511U. 825,844( 994) I i e s bl 'o r i ik. r r Brl n, S. 1 .t s unc tove tdt tbe aus oft m e tng,Pl i ifwa s e nty ta f re t BKCC a on r re ha c e he e i antf s ubs que l r ns e r d o nd t saf m em be alege y r po i e f t a e a PCC w a t r i t d f f a em i a i he t f r l dl es nsbl or he bus t s e m na e or r t z ton. Se Dkt N o. Ex.1a 3. ue t t r as bl ne soft sr s e . 24, t D o he e ona e s hi e pons ,Pl i i fc nnotr l on e a ntf a ey t sm ee i ass fci nte de t tof i i l f ie t pr t c he f om a dif e as a l nta hi tng uf i e vi nce ha fc a s a l d o o e t r r fer nt s ia t a dif r tf ciiy, ih no ot s ii knowl dge ofot rrs . f e en a lt w t her pec tc e he i ks Cons r ng t e de e i t lghtm os f vor bl t t Pl i if t Cour c l s tui he vi nc n he i t a a e o he a ntf , he t onc ude t ts ha ummar j y udgme ba e onquaii i nt s d lfed mmuniys dbega e t Defnda sClr t houl rntd o e nt ake a W as ngt on t f iur t pr e tc a m be a e t Pl i ifha nots fci nty a l ge nd hi on he a l e o ot c l i c us he a ntf s uf i e l le d f c st tove c e t hi h bu d r quied t sa e a de i r t i i f r nc cl i .Thus he a t ha r om he g r en e r o t t lbe a e nd f e e e a m , r cl m s f lundert fr tSauci el entand Defe ai ai he is er em ndant ar entted t qualfed i m uniy.533 s e il o ii m t U . at206. S. 9 C . Faiure t Pro e t- Edm onds C.D a s l o tc , vi Pl i iff t ralege t tEdm onds a D a svi a e t Ei t A m e a ntf urhe l s ha nd vi ol t d he gh h ndm e by nt f ii t r m oveOfi e Pr t fom ofende c a td i t pende y oft s xua a e alng o e tc r uit r f r ontc urng he nc he e l bus i tg ton. oweve , ai i fha no a l ge t tOf i rPr itc tnue t w or i c a t nves i a i H r Pl ntf s t le d ha fce u t on i d o k n ont c wih he pe s na l To t e e tPl n ifs e t pur ue cl i s o be l oft ot r t r r o ly. he xt n ai tf e ks o s a m n ha f he he prs r t tw e e alege y i da rbe us ofc ntnue c a twih Of i erPr t,s i one s ha r l dl n nge ca e o i d ont c t fc uit he lc sa ngt dos Se Da sv.Sc t,1 F.d 8 807( hCi.1999) Tot e e s a ks tndi o o. e vi ot 76 3 05, 4t r . he xtnt he a l ge t tD e e ant a tonsvi a e sat 1 w ora i s r tve pr edur ,s h vi a i le s ha f nd s' c i ol t d t e a dm nit a i oc e uc ol tons do notc tt e Ei ht orFou t e h Am e e vi a i ns Se R i ci v.Count ofFa r a ons iut g h r e nt ndm nt ol to . e c o y if x. Viani,907F. 1 1 (t Ci.1 ; vi v.Sc r ,468U. 18 1 - ( 984) ri a 2d 459, 469 4h r 990) Da s heer S. 3, 9194 1 (C de e ntsvi ain ofasae1w orrgultoni ge rlyir e ntt t de ii of 1 fnda ' olto A tt a e ai s neal relva o he cson q lf di n t.) Th r fr ,h Co r g a t s mma yj g n b s do q ai e uaii mmu iy' . eeo e t e u t rn s u r ud me t a e n u lt d e ' i i m uniy i f vorofD e e nt Edm onds a C.Da sast t s f iur t pr e tc a m unde m t n a f nda s nd vi o hi a l e o ot c l i r Sa e ' fr tpr uci r s i s ong.533 U . a 206. S. t D . Faiure t Provi M edi Care - Edm onds,C .Davi W at l o de cal s, son,Lang Pl i tf alege t ta t r s r por e t s xua abus o Apr l1 2011 s was a n if l s ha fe he e t d he e l e n i 3, , he e co t d die l t a i s r tve s gr to a w a notgi n m e ca t e t e . s r e r cty o dm ni ta i e ega i n nd s ve di l r a m nt M e c tea m e c a m s u rSec i 1 f l w ihi t Ei ht Am e e ' di al r t nt l i nde ton 983 a l t n he g h ndm nt s pr bii a ns cuela unus lp s n . tlev.Gambl 429U. 97,1 ( 976) ohi ton gai t r nd ua unihme t Esel e, S. 04 1 . To s a e a cl i unde t Ei ht Am e e o a f iur t pr de m e ca ca e cl i ,a tt am r he g h ndm nt n a l e o ovi di l r a m pl ntf m us s ai if t how a i i a e i f e e t s rous m e c lnee ' oft i a e.I d ber t ndif r nce o e i del di a ds ' he nm t d. û e i a e i f er e r quiesa s i t tt de e nt ... t ly knew ofa i nor t lber t ndif enc e r D how ng ha he f nda s ac ua l nd g ed a de a nee' s r o nee f m edi alc r ' Young v. t ofM t Ra e ,238 F. 567,5 t i s e i us d or c a e. ' Civ . ni r 3d 75 76 ( t Ci. 0 )( i to so te ) C AIsro s. . dc l e di o et a h sb e d a n sd 4h r 2 01 ct in mitd .t eiu . me ia n e s n h t a e n ig o e a g by a phys c a a m a tng tea m e orone t ti s obvi ust te n a l y pe s w oul i i n s nda i r t nt ha s o o ha ve a r on d e iyr c zet nec st fradocorsatni 'I v.Shr ve 5 F. 225,241(t Ci. asl e ogni he esiy o t ' te ton. ko ' e , 35 3d 4h r 2008)(nenalcttonomit . itr iai ted) Th Pl i iff is t alege t ts i o m e of i i s oft pai t a s taleg y e a ntf a l o l ha he nf r d fc al he n he s aul l edl c us d ort ts a ke pr s of i a sf m e c lt e t e on A prl13,2011 ora a tm e a e ha he s d i on fci l or di a r a m nt i t ny i t r fe . She m er l alege t tDef nda s a tonsvi aed a nita i r ultons he ea tr olt dmi sr tve eg a i s e y l s ha e nt ' c i because t f l t ensur t s recei m edi car as soon aspos bl A gai hey aied o e hat he ved cal e si e. n, vi a i ofa m i s r tve pr ed esa e no a tona eundert Ei h A m e e .Se ol tons d ni t a i oc ur r t c i bl he ght ndm nt e Rici v.Co yofFaifxeVa.90 F. 1 9,1 (t Ci.1 0) Davi v.Sc rr 468 co unt ra , 7 2d 45 469 4h r 99 . s , hee, U. 1 1 -9 (98 .W hies havi ai c ns r ase de ofdei rt i ifr nc S. 83, 91 4 1 4) l uc olton a eve vi nce lbeae ndfee e, sel v.Shrve,535F.d225, ( hCi.20 ) i t sc eii i ufiin . n i e ko e 3 242 4t r 08,n hi as t s ns fce t Eve f Pl i i fha a l d t s ha a ked f rm e c te t e , he alege f l e t pr vi a ntf d lege hat he d s o di al r a m nt t l d aiur o o de t e t e sildoesnots a e a c a m .Thi i be a e t m edi alne w asnots f c e l r a m nt tl tt li s s c us he c ed uf i i nty s r ousf om t vi w oft D e e nt on Aprl1 2011 ei r he e he f nda s i 3, . Pl i i fa l s t tt ab e,f i a s ez ng ofhe br s a pe s oc ur e a ntf lege ha he us ondlng nd que i r ea t nd ni , c r d i Febr r a M a c of2011. r por oft al ed a e di notocc untlAprl1 n ua y nd r h The e t he leg bus d ur i i 3, 2011, tl as t o w e a t rany i t nc ofa e. n i Pl i ifha r quesed m e ca a e tw eks fe ns a e bus Eve f a ntf d e t di l c r ,s f ist a l ge t tD e enda s kne s had a nee f m e c ltea m e on Apr l1 a e he a l o le ha f nt w he d or di a r t nt i 3. l ot rwor ,i wa nott o o oust te a1y pe s woul e sl r c zet n he ds t s i bvi ha ven a r on s d a iy e ogni he nec s iy f r a doc or sa t n i n. 1 a 241 The e w e e no fui t tcoul be gat r f om e st o t ' t e t o ' d. t . r r ' l ds ha d he ed r t vi i ,asw oul be t siuaton i a ra cas Br si orany ot physi evi he ctm d he t i n pe e. ui ng, her cal dence of t a s ul,w o d lke y nots ilbe vi i e a t ttm e a l a tt o w e ks a t rt m os r c nt he s a t ul i l tl s bl t ha i , t e s w e f e he t ee 5Loc lO pe a i Pr edu e 720.7 alege y m a t i e a e medi al r at en f a e vi i s r tng oc r a l dl nda es mm di t c t e m t or bus ctm . 11 aleg a e.Abs nti or ton fom t Pli ifa tas cii nee f m e c c r l ed bus e nf ma i r he antf bou pe fc d or dial a e, Dee f ndan s a1 non- e ca per onnel woul notr c z a c e rne f m edi a t e t e . t, 1 m di l s , d e ogni e l a ed or c l r a m nt Thus Pl i iff ist a l ge f c ss a i a c a m t tD e e nt (a t ly kne ofa i e , a ntf a l o le a t t tng l i ha f nda s C c ua l w nd gnor d a d t i ' s r ousnee f m e c c r .' o v. t ofM t R a e , F. 567,575 e a nee s e i d or di al a e ' Y ung Civ . ni r 238 3d -76 ( t Ci. 0 )(iaino te )Ac o dn l, an iffist saea Eih hAme d n 4h r 2 01 ctto mitd . c r igy Plitf al o tt n g t n me t cl i a i tD e e a m ga ns f ndan s Edm o ,C . a s W a s a La on t f iur t pr vi t nds D vi , t on, nd ng he a l e o o de m e c lc r cl i a t s D e e nt a e e il d t qua ii i m uniy unde t fr t di a a e a m nd he e f nda s r ntte o lfed m t r he i s ee n o S u ir 5 U. a 20 Thee o e teCo r g a t s mmayj d me t nt s lme t f a ce . 33 S. t 6. rf r,h u t rn s u r u g n o hi gr nd. ou I . V FO UR TEEN TH A M EN DM EN T C LA IM S Consr ng he c pl i tlbe a l Pl ntf a l gest tD e e n sha vi a e t e tui r om a n i r ly, ai if le ha f nda t ve ol t d hr e lbe t itr t a onepr ryi ees.TheCour g a ss i ry neess nd ope t ntr t t r nt ummayj r udgme i fvorof nt n a De e n s a t a 1c a m s o t gr f nda t s o 1 l i n he ound ofq ii d i m uniy,be aus none s tci nty ualt e m t c e ufi e l a l ge de i ton ofa cons iutona l pr t c e lbe t o pr r y i e es . le s prva i tt i ly o e t d i r y r ope t nt r t The lbe t i e es cl i s f ul t e ui i s i ton a t rt a l a i ofa e i ry nt r t a m a t he ns ng nve tga i f e he leg ton bus a i tO f i e Pr t . ga ns fc r uit The fr tcl i i a i tW a s n f f iur t i er e a i a e t tt is a m s ga ns t o or a l e o nt vi w n nm t ha he Pl i i fi ntfe asha ng he pf i onna i t s c i a ns W a de Edm o f a ntf de ii d vi l ul nf ton, he e ond s gai t r n nds or p eu gn Plitf sg iva c , n t etidi a an tDa i frs sann afa d rj d ig an if re n e a d h h r s g is vs o u tiig lwe i s i ton.To pr vai o he Sec i n 1983 c a m t tD e e nt vi a e he pr dur ldue nve tga i e l n r to l i ha f nda s ol t d r oce a pr es rghs t Pl ntf mus pr t t( )s ha apr tce lbe t i ers a ( t t oc s i t,he ai if t ove ha 1 he d oe td i ry nt et nd 2) ha i e e twa adve s l afe t d by t a to oft De e nt wihou t pr eci nsofdue nt r s s r ey f c e he c ins he f nda s t t he ot to pr es g a ee byt Foure nt Amend n .Slza v.Evat 21F. 590,593( h Ci. oc s uarnt d he te h me t e k t, 3d 4t r 1 4) 99 . l m a e do notha a c tt i naly pr t c e rghtt a gre nc pr e e. da sv. n ts ve onsiuto l o e t d i o i va e oc dur A m Ri , F. 72,75(t Ci.1 'Flc v. ba 932F. 728 729( t Ci.1 ) Be a ea ce 40 3d 4h r 994) ik Al , , 2d , 8h r 991. c us s a e g i va pr ed e doesnotco era s t ntve rghtupon pr s i a e ,a prs n t t r e nce oc ur nf ny ubs a i i ion nm t s io of i i ls f iu e t co pl w ih t sa e prs s g i va e pr ed e i nota tona e unde fc a ' a l r o m y t he t t i on' re nc oc ur s c i bl r j 1 8 . a nv. a ,8 5F.d6 9 6 0(t Ci.1 8 . e te ep icpe , an ifs 9 3 M n Ad ms 5 2 3 , 4 9h r 98 ) Und r h s rn i ls Plitf' a l ga i f lt s a e a c tt i na due pr es c a m .Si e Pl ntf doe no ha a le tons ai o t t onsiuto l oc s l i nc ai if s t ve cons iutonalri t a grevance pr tt i ght o i ocedur s cnnnothave a constt i e, he iutonalr ghtt t i hat he gri evancepr ocedur or i tgatonsofpartcul i at com pl nt ar conduct i any e nves i i i ar nm e ai s e ed n pa tc a w a Thes tu'e lbe t i e e tdue pr es c a m s a e m er co pl nt a ri ul r y. e l e i r y nt r s oc s l i r e m ai s boutt he me hodby whih t i tga i wa c uc e a t e or mus f l t c he nvesi ton s ond t d nd her f e t ai. Pl i i fs pr r y i e e tc a m , i tW a s f c i ca i he f m a e a ntf ope t nt r s l i aga ns t on or ont s tng r e l und r a m e sw iho fli outt f m r quied b pr s r gul tons do nota l ge a e g r nt t ut ilng he or e r y i on e a i , es le f he e nt a l d o olo i on oc dur s he ol i pr opert i eres . Even i t Def nda sf ie t f l w prs pr e e , t vi aton oft y nt t6 he c a m e r gul to do notrs t t l velofc tt i lvi a i .Se Ri i v. l i d e a i ns i e o he e ons iutona ol tons e cc o Count of v Faifx,Va.907F. 1 9,1 ( h Ci.1 ) Da sv.Sc rr 468U. 1 1 -94 ra , 2d 45 469 4t r 990 ; vi hee , S. 83, 91 ( 98 . 1 4) Therf e,heCour ga ss eor t t rnt ummayj r udgme basd o qualte i nt e n ii d mmuniyont due t he pr es c a m sag ns D e e oc s l i ai t f ndan s W a s Edm onds a Da sbe a e t Pl ntf hasf ie t t on, , nd vi c us he ai i f a ld t saea c tt i cai .Se Sa ir 5 U. a 206. o t t onsiutonal l m e uce , 33 S. t C LA IM S FO R D ECLA M TO RY AN D INJU N CTIVE R ELIEF 6 M oe v rt e l e t(r itnin l.e rv to ljo p o et b asaee ly ed 1n tvoaet ro e,K gi n o )ne to a.d p iains f rp ry y tt mpo e og o ilt he n g . pr dur lr quie e soft Due Pr s Cl us oft Fouree h Am e e i a m ea ngf pos- prva i oce a e r m nt he oce s a e he t nt ndm nt f ni ul tde i ton r dyf rt l si a lbl 'Huds v. l r 46sU. 517, ( 984) Eve whe a ofii c ic t te eme o he os s vaia e. ' on Pame, S. 533 1 . n n n fcal onfs aes h i ae' pr ry purua t a ofk ilpolc t i aehasn c tt i lduepr es cl m i posnm t s ope t s nt o n t a iy, he nm t o onsiutona oc s ai f t de i aton r m e espr vi ade t pr t ton oft pr t i t es a i s Se Zi r on v. r h, U. pr v i e di o ded qua e o ec i he opery n er t t s ue. e ne m Bu c 494 S. -- - l 3 1 8( 9 0 . l itf h salg dn fc ss g etn t a p s- e rv to r me i sa a lb et h ra t e l , 2 1 9 ) P an if a le e o a t u g sig h t o td p i ai n e d e v ia l o e t h prs we e i ade e t pr ec he pr ry i e e t unde t cic sanc s ale . ion r n quat o ot t r ope t nt r s s r he r um t es he l ges Quaiidi nt d e n t a camsf rd caao ya d ij n tv r le . fmiev. lfe mmu iy o s o b r li o e lrtr n nu cie eif Lee n W i ma 672F. 292,303( hCi. 2)Cû amsf de lrtr andij tverle ae de n, 3d 4t r 201 cli or caaoy nunci eif r notafe t byq lte i fced uaii d mmuniy.) Ho ve, o t ra onscieda t ' . we rf r he e s ' t bove, ai ifs Pl ntf alegai a i tt movi Dee nt f lt saea cai a tona eunde j1 7 l tons gans he ng fnda s ai o tt ny l m ci bl r 983. Th r f r,h c u t imis sPli tf scamsa ans te eDee d n sf rij n tv o e eo e te o r d s se anif li g i th s f n a t o n u cie r de aaor r i , zs tt 28U. C.j1915e( ( . clrt y elefplruan o S. ()2)b)8 VI . C O NC LU SI N O Ba e o tef r g ig teCo r g a t s mmayj d me to teg o n o qu li d s d n h o e on ,h u t rns u r u g n n h r u d f ai e t i mmuniyi f voroft movi Dee nt ont cli f mo t ydamage und j 1 3: t na he ng fnda s he ams or near s er 98 Pl i if s f iur t tai c a m saga ns Cl ke Edm onds a C.Da s t f iur t pr e a ntf a l e o r n l i i t ar , , nd vi ; he a l e o ot ct c a m sa i tCl r a W as ng on;t f l e t pr t c c a m s a i tEdm o a C . l i ga ns a ke nd hi t he aiur o o e t l i ga ns nds nd D a s t f iur t pr de m e c lc r cl i a t Edm onds C. a s W a s a La a vi ; he a l e o ovi di a a e a m s o , D vi , t on, nd ng; nd al f h d ep o e scams Tot e tn t a Plitf s e sij n tveo d caao yrl f 1 o t e u r c s li . he xe t h t anif e k nu ci r e lrt r ei e rltdt t s cams t Cour dimis s hcamsunde j1 ( ( ( f fiur t sae eae o he e li ,he t s ses uc li r 915e)2)b) or al e o tt acam, n ds se a yrltdsaelw camswih u p eu ieu d rj 1 6 () Fnal li a d imis s n eae tt a li t o t rj d c n e 3 7 c. i l y, t Courtgrant Def he s endant M oton f Pr ectve Or The cl m s agai tSar Pr t s' i or ot i der. ai ns ah uit r m ai pe ng bef r t Cour . e n ndi o e he t ENTER: i /! a o S p e e , 01 Ths y f e tmb r 2 2. ) ' / Jz o Jam es C.Tur k Seni U nied St esD it i Ju e or t at s rct 7 To t e en t tPl i tf brngscl m s unde sat Iw ,tec u t e l e t e ecs s p lme tluidcin he xt t ha a n if i ai r t e a h o r d ci so x rie u pe na j rs ito n o e sc camsa ddimisste wih u peu ie p ruat o2 U. C. 1 6 () v r u h li n s se h m to t rj dc , u s n t 8 S. j 3 7 c. 8 Un e j 1 5 e( )b ,tec r ma s mma i ds s a a to tld i f r p u e i û t n t i t ec u t d r 9l ( )2 ( ) h ou t y u rl imis n ci n ie n o ma a p rs t a y i f h o r y a me de e m i . .hatt a ton ...f l t sat a cl m on whi h r le may be gr nt d. t r nes . t he c i ais o t e ai c eif a e ' ' 14