-RSB Gilmer v. Thompson et al, No. 7:2011cv00456 - Document 37 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 02/07/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OFII t u Ll .COUR' S -CE lS. lsf F AT M NVILE, L VA # I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I CO U R T CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI T O F V I G I A C R NI RO AN O K E D I SI N VI O F D Oû FB ?2( 2 - JUL BK U . D > VI CE G I ER , N LM Pl ntf , ai if c RK E C i lA cton N o.7:11- 00456 vi i cvM EM O R AN D U M O PINIO N D R .T H O M PSO N ,etal, . D ef endant s. By: H on.Jacls L.K i t on ser Seni Uni StatesD i t ctJudge or ted s ri V i e Gim er a V i gi a i a epr e ng pr K ,tl a ci lr ght acton pur uantt nc l , r ni nm t oc edi o i ed vi i s i s o . 42U. C.5 1 S. 983.Pli ifnamesasdefnda sDr Thomps amedialdocora t W ale antf e nt . on, c t t he lns Ri Stt Prs CL ARSP' Dr Krsna ,aps hitita t W ARSP;a Lt Ha lon, dge ae ion W D; . is ppa yc ars t he nd . mit a W A R SP c c i oae tonalof i e . Pl i ifale t tt m edi altea m e he r e ve a t f c r a ntf l ges ha he c r t nt ec i s t he W A RSP f om Dr . r s Thom ps a Kr s na vi a e t Ei h A m e on nd i s ppa ol t s he ght ndm e oft U nied nt he t St t s Cons iuton. Pl ntf a l gest tLt H a it i e f r d w ih pl ntf st e t e by ae tt i ai i f le ha . m lon nt r e e t ai if r a m nt de ng hi greva f m she ne d t al r prs n ofi i sa m e c ls a foft doc or ' nyi m i nce or ede o e t i o fc al nd di a t f he t s Ei h A m endm e vi a i . Pl ntf r m a ns i a ce a e a t W A RSP. ght nt ol tons ai if e i nc r r t d t he Pr en l be or t co ti pl i if sm oto f ra Te por r R e t a ni O r r es ty f e he ur s a ntf in o m a y s r i ng de CTRO' .Plitf r q e t aTRO t h v a Emeg nc M e ia He rngfrDr S n a Gu t t ' anif e u ss ) o a e n r e y dc l ai o . a j y p a o CNN a Dr M at w Rudore oft Na i ll tt e ofM e alHe t t e an f nd . the f r he tona nsiut s nt alh o xpl i pl i ifsho i da SSRIwihdr wal Pli ifbega ahunge srket f c Dr Krs na t antf m ci l t a . antf n r ti o or e . is ppa o i s hi Ce e a m e a he t pr s rpton. Sgt Col m a c eq nty s of t wa e i s ue m l xa, nt l alh e c i i . e n ons ue l hut f he t r n pl ntf sc luntlpl ntf e hi hunge srke a pl i ifdr rk f c ofç wa e .,1 ai if el i ai if nds s r ti , nd antf a l our ups ( pee t r . , A qualf e m e a he t pr c ii ralege y t l pl i i ft tpl ntf w oul s a ve t de t ii d nt l alh a ttone l dl o d a ntf ha ai i f d t r o ah be or pl i i fr ce ves a t a f rt a t r c r c i lf c lt a a r ul o hi hunge sr ke f e a ntf e i r ns e o no he or e tona a iiy s es t f s r ti . Pl ntf pr vi l algedt theic n' q tsr mi be a eg )hag)NoCo r a ... ai if e ousy le ha ta t ui cea ng c us he s ntol nd M U ST M U ST M U ST K I Cpl Hila a Cg rci l Oltcejt comesi g s c l. LL . l nd ny ore tonaj fi r hat n hi) el' ' 1Pli ifdoe notale hed a hi own urne, bu hepr umabl dr nkw ae fom t t lt antf s lge r nk s i t es y a tr r he oie. ,t ( i M ot( 22)1( i na emphass. Pl ntf a knowl dhebe me Ci c o l Pror .no. orgi l il) ai if c edge co s c diulusy r f i 'a c urous' nd annotsop s e mi (d. t cra ng. l ) Thepur eofaTRO i t pr e v t sausquoanda dposi eirpaa eij r pos s o esr e he tt voi sbl re rbl n uy t a pa' pe ng ltga i t t la he i m a be c o ly ndi ii ton m i t arng y onduc e Se St nk t d. e e hous eI v. t of e nc. Ciy Raeg 1 6F.d 6 4, 3 ( t Ci. 9 9 (: g a t itrm gnu cie rle i a lih, 6 3 3 6 7 4h r 1 9 ) I The rn of nei ij n tv l eif s n e r or na y r m e i vi t e r i e ofa ve y f - e c ng pow e , hi h i t be a i xta di r e dy nvol ng he xe c s r arr a hi rw c so ppled onl i t lmiedcr tnc whihce ryde ndi.) Ima is aTRO wihout y n he i t icumsa es c lal ma t' . y sue ' t pr di notce w he e is cii f ct i a afi vi ora ve ii d c pl n cl a l s ovi ng i r dpe fc a s n n fda t r fe om ai t e r y how t t ha i d aea dir p rbl ijzy,o s o d ma ewil e utt t mo n beo et a v re mme it n re aa e nt ls , r n g lr s l o he va t f r he d es r pa t c nbehe r i oppostongl'Fe R.Ci P.65( .Themova mus aloetbls () ry a ad n ii .' d. v. b) nt t s sa ih 1 t thei lkel t s ce ont meis ( t tt balnceofe testpsi hi fvor a ( ha s i y o uc ed he rt, 2) ha he a quii i n s a , nd 3) t ta i unci i i t publci ees.W i e v. tlRes Deens Councll ,555U. ha n nj ton s n he i ntr t ntr Na' . f e i.nc. S. 7,20- ( 24 2008) Themovi pa t mus ce tf i wrtnganyef tmadet gi notc a t . ng ry t riy n ii for o ve ie nd he ras whynotces dno ber r e ons i houl t equied.Fe R.Ci P.65( . d. v. b) Pl i ifdoe notdes i any e f t m a t gi notc ofhi m oton f a TRO a a nt f s crbe f or he de o ve i e s i or nd t r s w hy notc s d no be r uie Pl i t f f l t des rbe how t r que t d he ea ons i e houl t eq r d. a n i f ais o c i he e s e m e c lt tm ony a e e ge y m edi lhe i w o d r m e t a l d c tt i l di a esi nd m r nc ca arng ul e dy he lege ons iutona d prva i r i ed i t c pl i o a s l-m pos hunge s rke.Se Om e W ord Tr vel e i tons a s n he om a nt r e f i ed r ti e ca l a v. A,111F.d 1 1 ( hCi.1 (ttngmova mus esa ih ar ai hi bewe n TW 3 4, 6 4t r 997) sai nt t tbls eltons p t e t ij ycli i t moin a t c he nur amed n he to nd he onduc gi ngrs t hi co ai ) Seeas l r t vi ie o s mpl nt. lo n e M i os tAnttus Lii ,333F. 51 5 ( h Ci. cr of ir t tg. 3d 7, 26 4t r 2003)(ttngt twihoutt sne ,he sai ha t hi xus t c ts dnotconsde t f t sf pr i nayij tverle).Sg . e ni nota our houl i r he acor or elmi r nunci eit t Colma s de e ntt t s a ton,a pl i ifdoesnotdem ons r t t de e nt 'know l f nda o hi c i nd a ntf t a e he f nda s edge of r r Br nna S. pl i ifnotha ng wa e i hi c lordrnki E ewa e . See Fa m e v. e n,511 U . antf vi t r n s el i ng s pe t r' ' 825,838( 994)(ttngdelbeaei fee r uie asaea t t ha be nperonal 1 sai i rt ndifrnce eq rs tt cor o ve e s ly a e off ct i c tng a s t ta r s ofs r oushar , d t ofi i lm us ha a t l war a s ndi a i ubs > i l i k e i m an he fc a t ve c ualy rc z dt e se eofs ars . e ognie he xitnc uch ik) Pl i if doe no es a ih t the i lke y t s ce d on t m e is be a e he a ntf s t t bls ha s i l o uc e he rt c us a know l s i hi flngst the f eq nty m e w ih Dr . m ps a K r s na a c edge n s ii ha r ue l t t s Tho on nd i s ppa nd di a ee w ih t e doc or 'di nos a t e t e s Se W r g v. lns 76 F. 8 , s gr s t hes t s ag es nd r a m nt . e i ht Coli , 6 2d 41 849( hCi.1 (ttngaprs rsdia e ntwihmedi lpe s me ove t co s of 4t r 985) sai ione ' s greme t ca rol l r he ure hi teame tdoesnotsaeaj 1 cai .Pli ifdoe no esa iht tt baa of sr t n tt 983 l m) antf s t tbls ha he lnce e te tps i hi f vorbe a e he ac quii s i n s a c us know l dgest the i be ng obs r d by a m e ca doc o , e ha s i e ve di l t r aps at i ,and cor ectonals affw hie decl i t eat t kilanyone w ho ent shi pr s ychi rst r i t l ar ng hr s o l er s i on c l. l vi a f de a c ti t da t da a i s r ton ofa prs i a cour e t e l nvol ng e r l our n he y- o- y dm nit a i i on s s he j cir ge al dia ove oftki udi ay nerly sppr s a ng.Se e. ,Belv.W olih,441U. 520,540n. 5 e, g. l fs S. 23, 48 1. (979 (xpl ni t tmai ani s urt andor ra opertngi tt i i 129 1 ) e ai ng ha nti ng ec iy de nd ai nsiuton n m a gea e f s on a e (c i r tons ... culary w ihi t pr nce a pr e sonal na bl a hi r G ons de a i pe i l t n he ovi nd of s i e rieofc rci ofiil' .Ac di y, antf fist esa iht r quie nt f a xpets ore tons fcas' cor ngl pli if al o tbls he e rme s or ) TRO,a Ideny hi r que t nd s e s. Pli ifi a s dt thei notpr e di L f mapa rsa t thei r ponsbl antf s dvie ha s oc e ng q or upe i nd ha s es i e f s r ng t c or e vi he ompl ntwihi 1 da ofDe mbe 1 2011 t dae hepad t $350 tlng ai t n 20 ys ce r , , he t i he ii f a t rbe ng de ed l ve t pr e t f mapa rs Se 28U. C. 1 4() Fe R. v. ee f e i ni ea o oce d q or upei. e S. j 91 a; d. Ci . P. ( 2.Robi on v Cl e 6 2F.d 6 5 6 8 0 (t Ci. 01 )(e o nii gg o c u et 4 m), ns i , 0 3 0 , 0 - 9 4h r 2 0 r c g zn o d a s o ps . d ly 1 -a s r iep ro wh nt f r pa p rsa p iain i pe dng ; rtav ea 20d y evc e id e q o ma u ei p lc t s n i l Urui . o Hars cCnt PolceDe t 91F. 451 453( Ci.1 ($ t f mapa rspli if ribur v. i p', 3d , 3d r 996) (An q or upei antf ha noco r o rt a s ntol ve he mountoftmet dititc ta t ma t j1 5( r i ' . i he src our tkes o ke he 91 d) ulng.) ' The Cl r i di e t d t s nd c esoft s M e or ndum Opi on a t a com pa ng e k s r c e o e opi hi m a ni nd he c nyi ( r rt pl i if l de o a ntf EN TER : s Thi , da ofFe ua y,201 -. y br r 2, / S i r Unie t t s i ti tJ o t d a e sr c udge 2 l 4( sae i p rie t r: Rue m) tts n et n pat n l adefnda i no s r d w ihi l da a trt c pl nti tld,t c t m oton f e nt s t e ve t n 20 ys fe he om ai s ie he our-on i o o iso atrn tc t t plit f- s ds s t a to wih u p eu iea ant r n t wn fe oie o he ani -mu t imishe cin to t rj dc g is f t tdefnda oro de t s r c bem a wihi as ciidtm e. Butit pli ifs ha e nt r r hat e vie de t n pe fe i f he antf hows goodca ef t f iur t c tm u te e t tm ef s r c f anappr it us or he al e,he our s xtnd he i or e vie or oprae pe i rod. 4
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
