Sensabaugh v. Shortt et al, No. 7:2011cv00444 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 09/22/2011. (kab)

Download PDF
P KS OFFI U. DI COURT CE S. SX A1 ROANOKE, ' VA rî Pg 5! ' ) I TH E U NI N TED STATES DI STR I T C O U RT C FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STR I T O F V I G I I C R N A R O A NO K E DIV ISIO N D ON N I W AY NE SEN SA BA U G H , E sEP 22 2 1 21 JULA C I BK D . $, CLERK CLERK CA SE N O .7: 11CV 00444 Pet toner, ii M EM O M N D UM O PIN IO N VS. By: Jam e C .Tur s k Se or U nied St esD i t i tJudge ni t at src S TEPHANI M . E SHORTT, AL. c , Res ponde t) nts. Dol eW a Se a ugh,aVigi ai t pr e ng pr K ,tl t spe ii f ra mi yne ns ba r ni nma e oc edi o ied hi tton o wrto h b a c r u , u s a t o28U. C. 2 4, h le gn t eM a 201 j d me to t e i f a e s o p s p ru n t S. j 25 c aln ig h y 0 u g n f h Fl Count Cic tCour unde whih hesa c c e ofabduc i wih i e tt detl oyd y r ui t r c t nds onvit d ton t nt n o ie, phone ha a s e ,a c e pt U pon r vi w oft r co d, he co tconc ude t tt r s m nt nd ont m . e e he e r t ur l s ha he p tto mu t es mma i d s s e wi o t rj dc , a e o h sfiu et e h us sae eiin s b u rl imis d t u p eu ie b s d n i al r o x a t tt y h c t e di s our r me e . l A lhoug Se a ug ' cl e y w rte s i sonsa e dit c tt r d, t y i ca e t h ns ba h s os 1 it n ubm s i r fi ul o ea l he ndi t t f l i s que e ofe nt r a e t t c he olow ng e nc ve s el t d o he onvi tonsunde c le i t spe ii n. ci r ha l nge n hi tto Se a ugh w a a r t d a de ai i Apr l2009 t f e crm i lc r s i t Fl ns ba s r es e nd t ned n i o ac i na ha ge n he oyd Count Ci c tCour . D urng t c s oft pr e ngs he w asr pr s nt d by s ve al y r ui t i he our e he oce di , e ee e e r co ta nt d a t ne . On M a 18,2010,i a he r ng be or J ur - ppoi e tor ys y n ai f e udge Ra W .G r bbs y u , l Sens abaugh' petton doesnoti udet sandar cour f m desgned f i at brngi s ii ncl he t d t or i or nm es i ng h b a camsun rj2 4.Rah r hes misasa kofha dwrte d u n swihnodic r a e a e s li de 25 t e , ub t tc n itn oc me t t s en bl mar ns f par a br gi , ew agr ph eaks,orheadi ngs. Hi alega i ar r s l tons e amblng and r ttve. l uded wih i epe ii ncl t hi s s ubmi i ar r ssons e andom copi ofl t sfom a t neysa cour or sw ih Sens baughts es eter r tor nd t der t a ' handwrten not ar it es ound t mar ns The a t he gi . tachment t t petton i udea copy oft conviton s o he ii ncl he ci and s nt ng or ent ed on M ay 25,2010,i e enci der er mposi t convitonsand s enceshechale ng he ci ent lnges her e. Se a ughplade guit t a f l c r ofa ns ba e d ly o eony ha ge bduc i wih i e t defl and mide e nor ton t nt nt o ie s m a c r esoft l phone ha a s e a c e pt On t s c ha g ee r s m nt nd ont m . he e onvi tons r s c i y, udge c i , e pe tvel J Gr bbss nt e hi t c u e enc d m o oncure t r sof42 ye r ,1 m on hs a 1 da i ionm e , r nt e m as 2 t , nd 0 ys mprs nt wi 4 y ass s e d d Thej dg as i o e afv -e rtnnofs p r ie p o ain. t 0 er upn e . h u e lo mp s d iey a e u e v sd r b to I hi j225 peii Sens ba c anst tt Commonwe t f ie t gi hi n s 4 tton, a ugh ompli ha he a1h ald o ve m atmeytil n t mp r dwi e ie c ;h t h til u g ddno lk S nsb u h fie t i l ra a d a ee t vd n e ta t e ra j d e i t ie e a a g , ald o h dee m i an a quat f c ua ba i f t g ly pla, de ed hi t o tr ne de e a t l ss or he uit e and ni m he pporuniyt t t o c r w ine s 'a t tt va i a t ne a nt d t r pr s nthi ha c l c sof onf ont t s es nd ha he rous tor ys ppoi e o e e e , m d ont i t i e e t f l t mee wih ort l t hi ,f iedt i tgae orma m otons f l t pr s nt r s, aied o t t ak o m al o nvesi t ke i , aied o e ent vi edefns and e pat y evi nce a s hi t pla g lyt c i e hedi not abl e es xcul or de , dvied m o e d uit o rm s d co m i,f l e y pr i ed t tSe a ug sa us rw o d be i t c toom durng t guit m t a s l om s ha ns ba h' cc e ul n he ourr i he ly pl a he r ng,a i s m e ca e ,f ie t r pr s nthi a a l l a ng hi t r pr e hi s l . e a i nd n o s s a ld o e e e m t l, e vi m o e es nt m e f 11 Unde 28U. C.j2254(9,afde a co tc nnotg a aha aspeiin unl st r S. 1 e r l ur a r nt be tto es he pe ii rha exha t t r m edi a ia e i t co t oft s a e i w hi h he w a ttone s us ed he e es va l bl n he urs he t t n c s c c e The e usi r quieme i s tsi by s ki r viw oft c am si t hihe t onvit d. xha ton e r nt s aited ee ng e e he i i n he g s saec u t t u id ci nt c n ie t cams Se O' ulia v. e c e, 2 U. 8 8 tt o r wihj rs ito o o sd r he li . e S lv n Bo rk l5 6 S. 3 , 8 ( 999) l Vigi a afe t tmef die ta lt t Cour ofAppe l ofVigi ahas 45 1 . n r ni, tr he i or rc ppea o he t as r ni e r d,a i a e ca e us hi s a e cour r m e e i one oft o w a Fis , ca tl a xpie n nm t n xha t s t t t e di s n w ys. r t he n i e sa e ha spe ii n w ih t Ci c tCour whe e he w asc t t bea tto t he r ui t r onvi t d,w ih a a ce t n ppea ofa a r e l n dve s de ii t t SuprmeCo tofVigi a.Va CodeAnn.j8. - a)1;j1 1- 1.I t cson o he e ur r ni . 0l654( ( ) 7. 41 n he a t r tve he ca fl a s a e ha s pe ii die ty w ih t Supr m e Cour ofV igi a le na i , n ie t t bea tton r c l t he e t r ni . j8. - 4( () W hihe rr et i t c est f l i i ce rt themus 0165 a)1. c ve out he nmae hoos o olow,t s la ha t uli t l pr e hi cli t t Supr m eCour ofVigi aa r c i anzi f o t t tma ey es nt s a ms o he e t r ni nd e e ve lng r m ha c t or afderldititc tc nco i rt meisofhi cli unde j225 our bef e e a src our a nsde he rt s ams r 4. Se aba ss ns ugh' ubmi sonsoferno i cai t the fl adie ta si f ndi ton ha ied r c ppea fom t M a l r he y 2 , 01 j d me t t eFl y Co nyCic i Co r.Heas p e e t n e d n et a h h s 5 2 0 u g n of h o d u t r ut u t lo r sn s o vie c h t e a s i t hi c r ntc ai s o a ubm ted s ur e l m n ppea ori a pe ii f a w rtofha l n tton or i beasc pust t Supr m e or o he e Co tofVigi a. Furhe m or eecr cr c dsoft Supr ur r ni t r e, l toni e or he eme Cour ofVigi a, c a e t r ni whih r a ia e o i do notr ted t tSens ba ha fl d a a a o ha spe ii n i t va l bl nlne, el ha a ugh s ie ny ppe l r bea tt o n he Supr m e Cour ofV i gi a r ar ng hi Fl Count crm i lc e t r ni eg di s oyd y i na onvi tons Onlne r or of ci . i ec ds t Fl Count Cic tCour r l c t tSe aba ha a pe ii f a w rtofha asc pus he oyd y r ui t efe t ha ns ugh s tton or i be or pe ng i t tc t tl d Se e be 8,201 i w hi h t Cic tCo thasnotye e e e a ndi n ha our , i e pt m r 0, n c he r ui ur t nt r d dec son.Thus i i a r ntt tSe a ug hassa ec t e ii , t s ppa e ha ns ba h t t our r medi sila ia et hi es tl va lbl o m, na ey, r ui Cour ha aspr edi a as eque a alt t Supr m eCour of m l Cic t t be oce ngs nd ubs nt ppe o he e t Vigi ai t Cic tCour petton i denid. r ni f he r ui t ii s e I s t i i cl a t tSe a ug sc r ntc ai sha notbe n pr s nt t or n hor , t s e r ha ns ba h' ur e l m ve e e e ed o a j d c tdbyt eS p e Co r o Vig na Uni h h se ha se t ea alb esaec u t du iae h u r me u t f r i i. tl e a x u td h v ia l tt o r r medis t sf r lc tc l o c i hi ha asc am she e.Acc di y,t c tmus e e , hi ede a our am t onsder s be l i r or ngl he our t dimishi j2254peii wiho prj c SeeSlvonv.Smih, U. 5 5 (971 s s s tton t ut eudie. at t 404 S. 3, 4 1 ) (idngt tj2 4ha e speiinmu t eds se wih u p eu iei p tto e h sn t fn i ha 25 b a tto s b imis d t o t rj d c f eiin r a o prs nt hi cai t t a opraesaec ta c dsildos .Ana opraeor r e e ed s l ms o he ppr it tt our nd oul tl o) ppr it de w ili s t sda l s ue hi y. The Clr i die t d t s nd co e oft sme or ndum opi on a a c pa ng ek s rce o e pis hi m a ni nd c om nyi o dert pe ii . r o ttoner ENTER:Thi l f da ofSe e be ,2011 s ptm r . ' sv* ,. Se o Unie St t Di t i t udg nl r t d a es s rc e 4

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.