Sensabaugh v. Shortt et al, No. 7:2011cv00443 - Document 15 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 3/21/2012. (tvt)

Download PDF
u h .. , t,R' ï # U ATROANOV , VA . FlPD ? - MA2 2 12 1 22 FNTHU IEETDE RCRCVCGRA IRTE WET SAIS ITO TIOIT O H ENT DR TSDS I RU I S N T F N J A C, ULI D av; DP Lv E gy R O AN O K E D I ISIO N V D O NN I W A YN E SEN SA BA U G H , E Ci lA cton N o.7: c 00443 vi i 11- v- Pli c ant M EM O M N D UM O PIN IO N STEPH A N I SH O R TT,etal, E . De ndant. fe s By: H on.Jam es C .Turk Seni U nied St es D i ri Judge or t at st ct D onni W a Se a ugh, oc ed ng pr s ,fl d a c vi r gh sa ton pur ua t 42 e yne ns ba pr e i o e ie i l i t ci s nt o U. C.j 1 Thi c ei pr s tybef et Cour onwhatt Cour consr sa amoi S. 983. s as s eenl or he t he t tue s ton t atro a n i p ir u g n , n e Fe . Ci . 5 () ( tNo. 4 . o le r me d t ro j d me t u d r d R. v P. 9 e . Dk . 1 ) s Thi Cour pr vi l dimis Se a ugh' c s f fiur t saeacli ( . s t e ousy s sed nsba s a e or al e o tt am. DktNo. 1 ) Howe r s eq l t Cour lanedt tSe a ughha malda Ame d 0. ve, ubs uenty,he te r ha ns ba d ie n nde Compli prort hi c s be ng dimis d. Acc di y, heCour va t isprordimi s l ant i o s a e i s se or ngl t t caed t i s s a o de t s ei t Ame dCompli sae acam u whihr le c dbegrntd.( . r r o e f he nde ant ttd li pon c eif oul a e Dkt No.1 .TheCour r ewedt Ame 2) tevi he ndedCo antbutdi nottnda ne e de eo mpli d i ny w vi nc r cli t tco ds vi sr ni unde 28U. C.j1 5() s t Cour dimis dt ams ha ul ur ve cee ng r S. 91 e, o he t s se he Ame ndedCo aitf f l et saeacam.( t No.1 . mpl n or aiur o tt li Dk. 2) I hi moto t a ndt Cou tsj me tSe a ughmake t f l ng n s in o me he r' udg n ns ba s he olowi a g ns:( )t tn1w s t t tlsa ' c us t yweeçs ..beor Jnuay2 r ume t 1 he e a uis ' il tnd'be a e he r çend . f e a r 2, s 201 '1( hepai t $350flngfea i e ildt alwy r a ( hes dha be n 2' 2) , d he ii e nd s ntte o a e , nd 3) houl ve e gr ed l ant eavet nm end hi Com pl nt A ddii l Sens o s ai . tonaly, abaugh appearst r at i an o est e, n a e a e f m , he ar e she m a i hi Co pl i a Am e bbr vi t d or t gum nt de n s m a nt nd nded Com pl nt ai . 'TheCour c tuest sa a a s ri t Sens ba s r hi co pli ont t def nt. t onsr hi s n s e ton hat a ugh eved s m ant he en enda s E , CL ' ERK Y A moint atro a n afn lu g n u d rF d R. v P. 9 e ma b g a tdi to o le r me d ia j d me t n e e . Ci. 5 () y e rne f ne esay14)t a ommodaea i eve ngc ng i c r lnglw;( t a co frne c sr ;1 o cc t n ntr ni ha e n ontoli a 2) o c unt o w e de enota ia ea ti ' ( t c rec ace rero oflw o prve manie tij tc ' vi nc valbl t ralor 3) o or t la rr a r e nt fs n usie. , ' Pa .n . . . Na 'FieI s Co.1 8F.d3 6 4 3(t Ci.1 9 )(iainso t d . c l s Co v Am. tl r n . , 4 3 9 , 0 4h r 9 8 ctto mit ) e F rh r r ,ie o sdeaino aj d me t fe ise tyi a e ta r iayrme ywhc u temo e C c n i rto f u g n a tr t nr s n xr o dn r e d ih r s ul beus ds rngl 'l (ntr lquotto maksomitdl s eRo ns v.W i ho d e pa i y. d. i ena ' ain r te ; e bi on x Fitai Cor ,599F. 403,411(t Ci. 0) lrton p. 3d 4h r 201 . Noneoft agume sad nc dbySe a ughstsyt Rul 59( sa r Thee he r nt va e ns ba aif he e e) tndad. r ha be n no c s e hange i t c r lng l w a Se aba ha notpr s nt ne e de e t t n he ont oli a nd ns ugh s e e ed w vi nc ha waspr vi usy una ia et hi .Fi ly,Se a ugh ha f ie t pr s nta e de eofa e o l va lbl o m nal ns ba s a ld o e e ny vi nc û nietij tc 'i hi c s ,des t wha t Cour bele i hi snc r beleft t d fs nusie'n s a e pie t he ma t ives s s i ee i o he con r r Se a ug sa g e t thi l w s t s ul t tl s a ' c us t y w e e s r d t a y. ns ba h' r um nt ha s a uis ho d t il t nd' be a e he s r e ve be or J nua y 22,201 i unpe s i f rt r as . Fis, he e i no i c ton t t f e a r 2, s r uasve o wo e ons r t t r s ndi a i ha Sens ba h f l d t pr rpr edur st s r hi lw s t a t s r i ewoul be a ug olowe he ope oc e o eve s a uis nd hus e v c d i f ec i und r Fe R . v. 4. Spe ii a l t r i no e de e t ta s m onsw a e r ne f tve e d. Ci P. c tc ly, he e s vi nc ha um s ve i s d i t sc e;nori t r a e de e t ta wa v r ofs r c w ass s ue n hi as s he e ny vi nc ha ie e vi e ought Se ond, nd, . c a m or i po t nty,e n i Se a ugh ha pr ry s r d hi Com pl i on t t n def n s e m r a l ve f ns ba d ope l e ve s a nt he e enda t , pr pe s r c doesnott u p t sCour ' oblga i t dim i s l galy m e il s c ai spur ua o r e vi e r m hi ts i ton o s s e l rtes l m s nt t 28U. C.j 1 5() o S. 91 e.Addii ly,Se a ugh' agume t thei e ildt a atr y tonal nsba s r nt ha s ntte o n tone be us hepa dt flng f ei unpe s i Alho t Cou tgr nt d Se a ug s ca e i he ii e s r uasve. t ugh he r a e ns ba h' a i a i t pr ee i f r a pa rs whi h u rc r a n c r um s a e w oul e il hi t pplc ton o oc d n o m upe i , c nde e t i i c t nc s d ntte m o a courtappoi ed ator nt t ney,asnot above,t Courtwasoblgat t di m i hi case under28 ed he i ed o s ss s U. C j1 5()f f l et saeacli S. 91 e or aiur o tt am.Thus Se a ughwa no e ildt ac t , ns ba s t ntte o our a ppoi e a t ne nt d tor y. Fort f eg ng r as ,t Cour de e Pl i if sm o i t a t rora e t he or oi e ons he t ni s a ntf ' ton o le m nd he j d me t Ana p o raeo d rs al hsd yis e u g n . p r p it r e h lt i a su . ENTER:T ip dyo Mac 2 1. hs x a f rh 02 Z S ' Unie St t D it l tJ t d a es s rc udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.