Campbell v. Unknown, No. 7:2011cv00409 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 09/02/2011. (kab)

Download PDF
cl s OFF' u.s. sT. znK' CE Dl counT AT DANM L E, L vA FL DA C eo IE . I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O AN O K E DIV ISIO N DER RY M O R E CA M PBELL, Pl ntif ai f , V. UN K N O W N , De fendant. SEP û2 2 1 21 J I I DUDL C RK ULA R s, EPUW CLERK v4, . J Ci lA cton No.7: cvvi i 11- 00409 ) ) ) ) ) ) ) M EM O M NDVM OPI ON NI By: H on.Jacks L.K i e on sr Seni U nied St esD i ri Judge or t at st ct Pl i if a Vi gi a i a e pr e ng pr y ,tl d a m o i f a t m por y r tai ng a ntf , r ni nm t oc edi o q ie ton or e ar esr ni - o de (i 'tt r r s ac e ofc tc r tvi ai ' Bewe 2001a 20 r r; TRO' to ed e s ontmpt our/ontac olton. t en ) ' nd 04, pl i ifw a hous d a t Buc nghn Cor e tona Cent ra t W ale R i St t Prs a ntf s e t he ki m r ci l e nd he l ns dge a e i on, whihaef iiisoft Vigi aDe rme ofCon-ci C6 c r aclte he r ni pa t nt e tons VDOC') Pl ntf fl acvi '. ai if ied i l rght a ton,purua t 42 U. C.j 1 a na ng28dee i s ci s nt o S. 983 nd mi fndant,al ngc ttto la s legi onsiuina nd sa ut y de i tonsr l td t i t rai 1hi r lg on a t f he r ei d. Ide e t tt ol prva i e ae o, n e la, s ei i nd he ood ec ve nid he d fn a t' to frs mma yj d me tb c u eId tr n dt a ad s u eo maeil a t e e d n s mo in o u r u g n e a s eemie h t ip t f tra fc e se a t whe he çca xit d s o t r û mpbe lsa r nc t t Comm on Fa edi ti pr s rbe byr i o l' dhe e e o he r e s e c i d elgi us beif.'Ca les' mpbelv. l e a.No.7: c 023,si o a 8( . Va. .1 2004) l Angeone. t l, 01 v01 lp p. t W D. Apr 9, , afd,No.04- ( h Ci.Se .27,2006) Ias f adiput ofmaei f tast whehe f' 6928 4t r pt . lo ound s e tral ac o t r t def nt co d as e ta gove nm e a i e e tt no a om m oda e hi a l ge r lgi he enda s ul s r ny r nt l nt r s o t cc t s le d e i ous belef By a s e ntO r r 1r quie t de e nt t e t rt l a r s i s. ubs que de , e r d he f nda s o ihe i e e pons t a e st e o ddr s he gove n e ali e es ort pr depl ntf wih hi r que t dit The de e nt c et r m nt nt r t o ovi ai if t s e sed e . f nda s hos o pr de t di t w ho w oul t ontnue t r e ve t Com m on Fa e di ti ac or nc w ih t ovi he e , dû i c o ec i he r e n c da e t he a ia eDi son Opeai Pr d e a I tt i lOpeai Pr ed e a s j c t pplc bl vii rtng oce urs nd nsiutona rtng oc ur s nd ub e t o lPlitf r ie num e ouscai sandnamednum e ousdefnda s. Howe r a lt ot rcl i sw e c et anif as d r lm r e nt ve . l he he am r iher ds se frfizet saeacam o d nidb smmayj d me t las n tdta panifn me d fn a t imisd o alr o tt li r e e y u r u g n. lo oe h t litf a d ee d ns l whohadno f t alege a ns t m , acs l d gai t he t ditsc i da ia lt fom t VDOC.'( s Af.De .'Res ( 01 v01 no. he e ' ontnue valbiiy r he ' Ba s f ( fs p. 7: c 023, 57 j3. Theca eco l dwiho alga d tr nai ofpli ifsdi cli )r ) s ncude t ut e l eemi ton antf' et am. I t i t ntca e pl i ifr ue t a TRO be us VD O C of i al s oppe pl i if s n he ns a s , a ntf eq s s ca e fci s t d a ntf r e ptoft Com m on Fa e di ton M a 28, 1 D es t pl i if s greva est r s l t ec i he r e y 201 . pie a ntf i nc o e o ve he is pli ifsildoe notr c ve i a ha l tweghtf t pas f l mont . Pl i if s ue, antf tl s e ei t nd s os i or he t otr hs antf s eme shi ditwih c uppl nt s e t omm is r ptr has swo t $2 ada Pl i ifal st t1 s a y lc e rh y. antf lege ha Sa r d r e on t s m ate ' i Apr l2004 and t tV D O C i i co em ptofa c tor e . s lea y ul d hi t r' n i ha s n nt our d r Pl i ifr quessa r le a Or rr quii VDOC ofi i st gi hi t Comm on Fa edit antf e t s ei f n de e rng tcal o ve m he r e and a r hi $2 pe da hedoesnotr c vet Comm o Far di t wa d m r y e ei he n e e. Thepur eofaTRO i t p e evet sausquoanda dposi eirpa a eij y pos s o r s r he tt voi sbl re r bl nul t a pa t pe ng ltga i untla he rng m a be c uc e See St khous .I v. t of o ry ndi ii ton i ai y ond t d. ea e nc. Civ Raec 1 6F.d6 4, 3 (t Ci.1 9 )(Theg a to itrm gnu ci )rle i a lih, 6 3 3 6 7 4h r 9 9 $ r n f n ei ij n tve eif s n ' e r or na y r m ed i vi t e r s ofave y f rr ac ngpo e , c i t bea i d xta di r e y nvol ng he xe cie r a -e hi w r whih s o pple onl i t lmie cr umsa swhihce ryde ndi.) s ntt Fe r lRul ofCi l y n he i td ic tnce c lal ma t'.Purua o de a e ' vi Pr e ze65( ,t c tma is aTe ayRetani Or rwihoutpr vi ngnotc oc dlr b) he our y sue mporr sri ng de t o di ie whe e 'pe ik f t i a afi vi oraverfed e r s c t ae s n n fda t ii ompl i c e ry s ant l a l how t ti me ae a ha m dit nd irpaa l ij r ,o s o d ma ewil e ut otemo a tb f r t ea ves pat = nb h ad re rbe nu y ls , r a g l r s lt h v n eo e h d re ry a e e r i oppostongj'l a ton,t movi pa t mus cetf i wrtnganyef t ma t gi n ii .' n ddii he ng ry t riy n ii fors de o ve no i a t r as w hy i s ul notbe r quied. (d. M or r t mova mus etbls tce nd he e ons t ho d e r l) eove,he nt t sa ih ()t thei lkeyt s ce dont mert,2)t tt baanc ofe testpsi hi f r a 1 ha s i l o uc e he is ( ha he l e quii i n s avo , nd ( t ta ij ton i i t publci e et W i e v. tlRe Dee eComwisI . 1 S. 3) ha n nunci s n he i ntr s. ntr Na' s. fns l nc, 29 Ct 3 3 76( . 65, 74- 2008) . Pl i ifi note il d t a TRO . A lhoug Ias um e pl ntf ha a snc r y he d a ntf s ntte o t h s ai i f s i e el l r lgi bei ft tr r hi t ha t Comm on Fa edi ,pl i iff l t e t bls a e i ous le ha equies m o ve he r et antf ais o sa ih lke i i lhood ofs ce son t m e is Pl i ifdi nottl a co pl ntt s uc s he rt . a ntf d ie m ai o uppor t m oton,a t he i nd, des t hi a g e st t c r r Idi noten e a Or rr rngt VDOC t pr de pie s r um nt o he onta y, d t r n de equii he o ovi pl ntf w ih t Com m on Fa e D i t Eve i pl i if s d r e ve a Com m on Fa e D i ta ai if t he r e. n f a ntf houl ec i r e t s omepoi nea l a de a a t VDOC m a lwf l r ti tt tdi f avaldr a on. nt ry c de go, he y a uly esrc ha et or i es Furhe m or pl i ifi i a dif r ntf ciiyt n t onehewasi durng hi prorltga i t r e, antf s n fe e a lt ha he n i s i ii ton, w hi h i plca esdif r ntpolc e a def nda st t pr ora ton.M or ove ,t bal nc c m i t fe e i i s nd e nt han he i c i e r he a e o e te pr s nty tpsi f voroft VDOC t dee m i ho t r ton ism e sa s a c f quiis e e l i n a he o tr ne w o a i t al nd c r e r o ce a r st t a ofi t si hasac os t Comm onwe t ofVigi a.l e es ur s c os he hous nds nma e t r s he alh r ni nde d, i ovngafd r l o r i ted yt - a a mi itaino ap io i ac u s tej dcay nv li e ea c u tn h a -o d y d nsrto f rs n s o re h u iir ge r ly di appr ne a l s ovesoft ki See e. ,Be lv. oli h,441 U . 520,540 n. 548 1. a ng. , g. l W fs S. 23, 129 ( 979)(xpli ngt tmanti ngs c iya or ra o rtngi tt i i ma gea e 1 e ani ha i ani e urt nd de nd peai nsiuton n na bl f s on a e ' onsde a i ... ula l wihi t pr nc a pr e sonale ts of a hi r s i r tons pec i ry t n he ovi e nd of s i c xperie core tonsofi as'.Thepublc' i ee ti betrsr edbynotprs ntyi efrngwih rci fcil' ) i s ntrs s te e v e e l ntrei t pe la m i s r ton,e pe i ly snc pl i if s de c i i ofhi pr o ltga i i i on-c . na d ni t a i s c a l i e a ntf ' s rpton s i r ii ton s nc e t Theme isoft sis we eno de e m i d i 20 a pli ifdoe notpr dea c rt hi s ue r t t r ne n 04, nd antf s ovi ompli a nt t pr ce f t ri t sa ton.Bas d o t aleg tonsi t flngand t pr s ntsa usof o o ed urhe n hi ci e n he l a i n he ii he e e tt t c s pl i iff l t e t bls t r quieme sf aTRO , Ide hi r ques,a 1dim is he a e, antf ais o sa ih he e r nt or ny s e t nd s s t aci wihoutprj ce. he ton t eudi The Cl r i di e t d t s nd c e oft sM e or e k s r c e o e opi s hi m andum O pi on a t a om pa ng ni nd he cc nyi O r t pl ntf der o ai if. ENT ER :Thi s da of Se e be ,2011 y pt m r . Sen' rU nied St es D it i J t at s rct udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.