Canada v. Clarke et al, No. 7:2011cv00408 - Document 10 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 10/11/2011. (kab)

Download PDF
rdFRK' OFFI U,.DI O URT S CE S SI A ROANQKE, T VA !, . ! . I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I C O UR T CT FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O AN O K E D I I ON V SI K ELVI A .CANADA N 0C' 1 1 22 1 r 1 JULk r .l 't 'GL Q ) ' ' ' ERK D BY; DEP CLERK C i lA c i N o.7: c vi t on 11 v00408 Pl nt f , ai i f M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N N O V. H AROLD CLARKE, AL. ET , D ef endants . By:Sa ue G .W is m l l on Uni e St esD i t i tJudge t d at sr c Kevi A. na pr e ngrr s hasfldaeo antpurua tt 42U. C.j1 l n Ca da, oce di / e, ie mpli s n o S. 983 na ngt nt e g de e nt ,a hi alegai nsa a t he doc mi we y- i ht f nda s nd s l to nd tac d ument dr o f 1 s one n or 87 pa s Fe rlRul ofCi lPr edu e8()2)r uie aS hor a pli sae ntoft cam ge . dea e vi oc r a( eq r s t t nd an ttme s he li s howi t tt pl de i e il d t r i .'Though t r ei g e ty r a d f ng ha he ea r s ntte o elef' he ul s r a l elxe orpr s o e pl i tf s i doesnotr qui e a c t o e a n if , t e r our t ndea t di c r cohe enc w he e t r i none, t vor o s e n r e r he e s or o pe mipr s pli tf st na de e nt t tha ltl mor i ntfa er ltons p t a r t o e a n if o me f nda s ha ve ite e de iibl ea i hi o c r ntc am t n per onss e t d a r ndom fom aphonebook. SeeBe ude tv. t of ohe e l i ha s elc e t a r a t Civ Ha on,775F. 1 4,1 -78( h Ci.1 ( tngt tdg rnci esr rngg neous mpt 2d 27 277 4t r 985) noi ha lpli pl equii e r co t ci ofpr s c nsnzton o e ompli sar not ho verwihoutlmis'.Thec tdimisda ant e , we , t i t' ) our s se pr ec s ort t scomplit Ca dav. ohns 7: -ved e s o hi an, na J on, 11c 00369( . Va. us 16,2 ) W D. Aug t 011 , f f lngt sae apl usbl cli f r le .Cana has i t sc e,s it t t c ta or aii o t t a i e a m or e if da ,n hi as ubm ted o he our c pl i t ti ne ry a e c duplc t oft com pl nti t te r i c e. He ha c ng d om a nt ha s a l n xa t i a e he ai n ha a ler as s ha e t co rpa andt na e ofaf w def nda s butt fr tffy- i pa a e,wih t he ve ge he m s e e nt , he is it sx ges r t he e ep i ofa sng e page, phot opy oft ea le c pl i . The onl no a e c nge t t xc ton i l a oc he ri r om a nt y t bl ha o he e r i rco pl nti Cana s a ton oft n pa ofr ques sf punii da ag , a le m ai s da' ddii e ges e t or tve m es c ompe at yda ges t clr or damag ,'ij tver i ,a atmporr r tani ns or ma ,d aat y de es' nunci elef nd e a y esr i ng or r Thei t ntcompli es e ily mi st e rirone. The c t et r t sis de . nsa ant s nta l nor he a le our r ie a e t o j cinst Ca a a sb r n o a do tnic mp e e sbepe dng n mi t ny eg t be to o n d ' u de s me n fe n o r h n il la i s a ng we t -ih d fn a t.Ac o dngy t c u t l ds s wih u p eu ieu d r2 U. C. ee d n s c r i l,he o r wi imis t o t rj dc n e 8 S. j l 1 5A( ()Ca da' compli f f l et saeaplusbl cli f r if 91 b) 1 na s ant or aiur o tt a i e am or ele . y.. .* . EN TER :Thi 11 h da ofO c o r 2011. s t y t be , , ' . ' ç, .' ' v' p , z' . I I S X TED TATES DI TRI J S CT UDGE

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.