Demetriades et al v. Social Security Administration et al, No. 7:2011cv00407 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 09/13/2011. (rkc)

Download PDF
CLERK' OFFC Et-: :1 . nlr S J r r I ATRQM X , VA FIED L SE 13 2 1 P 21 I TH E UN I ED STA TES DI N T STR I C O U RT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STR I O F VI G I A CT R NI R O AN O K E DI SI N VI O PETER D EM ETR IAD E S,etal, . JULK C. DUDL CLERK EY BY: C i lA cton N o.7: cvvi i 11- 00407 Pl ntf s, ai if M EM ORANPVM OPI ON NI M I A EL J.A STR U E, CH Com m i s one ofSoc alSe uriy e/al3 si r i c t . By:Sam ue G . is l W l on Unied Stat D i t ctJudge t es s ri D ef endants . Thi i ana tonpurua t 5U. C.j552a b pli if,Pee andMihel s s ci s nt o S. , y antfs tr c e De tid s wh a ep o e dngif r mera e , o r r c e i n o mapa pe i, g i t iha l . tu , mmiso e o u rs a ans M c e J Asr e Co sin r f Soca Se urt a vai e oy soft SocalSec iyAdmi srton(6 ',heOfie il c iy nd rous mpl ee he i urt nitai çSSA' t fc ) oft I urnceCommisone i W etVigi a(sns a eCommiso r', ndt l ur e he ns a s i r n s r ni s urnc l s ine' a he ns anc ) Commisone t r pat admi srt ,Se c CM S,I (s dg ck' aii ou oft s i r hid ry nitaor dgwik nc.sse wi ), rsng t he s pe i ofs a s curt be ft pa bl t M r De tidesand al ge prva y vi ai us nson ocil e iy ne is ya e o . me ra le d i c ol tons. Eve vi w e i t lghtm os f vor bl t M r a M r .De e r a ,t ha no s a e a n e d n he i t a a e o . nd s m ti des hey ve t t t d pl us bl cl i f rr le . A c r ngl t cour di m i s st s c pl i pur ua t 28 U . C . a i e am o e if co di y, he t s s e hi om a nt s nt o S. j1 ()2)B)i) 915e( ( (i. M r D e e r a 's i ls c iy be ft w e e s pe d by t Br s ol Vi g ni Soc al . m t i des oc a e urt ne is r us nde he i t , r i a i Se urt Of i on M a 1, 0 a t rhe f l t pr i r que t doc e s. M r a M r . c iy fce y 201 fe aied o ov de e s ed um nt . nd s D e e r a s a l e t e doc e sw e e eve ualy pr vi d,a M r D e e r a s be ft m t i de leg hos um nt r nt l o de nd . m ti de ' ne is r ns a ed,bet een Sept berand O ct ei t t w em oberof2010. I t i erm ,M r.D em eti n he nt i r ades was a r d awor r sc pe a i s tlme of$90, wa de ke ' om ns ton ete nt 000.Ac or ngt M r a M r . c di o . nd s De ti de , hei c s m a ge ta f redt i be ft fom t Brsolofi et t mera s t r a e na r r nse r her neis r he it tc o he W yt vil of i e i Oct he le f c n oberof201 a t rt y m ove a on O c ober 1 201 M r a M r . 0 fe he d, nd t 8, 0, . nd s D e e r a s we e t d t s a t Evel Col a t W yt vil ofi M s Col i or e t m ti de r ol o pe k o yn e t he he le tce. . e nf m d he De e r a st tM r D em e ra 'be hs ne ded t be i tga ed a ca e e hi be tt m ti de ha . t i des nef e o nves i t nd nc l d s ne i s s tm elt rf f iur t pr dea r ea e f r g a tng t SSA pe m iso t obt nhi ome i a e or al e o ovi el s o m r n i he r s in o ai s w or r s c pe a i s tl e i or a i The W yt vil of i r ce ve t i o ton ke ' om ns ton e tem nt nf m ton. he le fce e i d he nf nua i on M r De e r a s's tl m e fom Sedg i k s e i e i e t rN ove be orD e e be of . m ti de e te nt r w c om tm n ihe m r cm r 201 The al o r c ve docum e a i o be ft pa d t M r D e e rade be w e 200 a 0. y s e ei d nt ton f ne is i o . m ti s t en 2 nd 2008. I De m berof201 t W yt le Soci lSe urt Of i e m a l d M r a M r . n ce 0, he hevil a c iy f c ie . nd s D e e ra a l te r ques i i o m a i o ho t s tl m e m one w a s n a m t i des e t r e tng nf r ton n w he e te nt y s pe t nd s pe us nded M r D e eti des be is f t e yea s M r a M r . e e r a aleget t . m r a ' neft or hr e r . . nd s D m ti des l ha SSA,e a1 vi atd t i trght t Prvac a una horze i or ai n. The a s a lge t . ol e her ti s o i y nd ut i d nf m to ' ' y lo le SSA ,e a1 c us d t m (i e i na i lc e ha a da a ' a û s a d a e e ous t . a e he Cnt nto l nfi t d nn nd m ge ' nd ç pl ye n gr gi di c onduc . t' ' II . kf.a ( r .De era 'co pli tdoe no c a n s fcen f t whih,i t ke a r nd M s m tides m a n s t onti ufi i t acs c f a n s t u ,w o d s r e ul uppo ta cl i t r i t ti pl us bl on isf ce A c or ngl t c ts r a m o elef ha s a i e t a . e di y, he our ua s nt ds se Mr a Mr . mera s c mplitwi o t rj dc . po e imis s . nd s De tide ' o an t u p eu ie h Pu s n t 28U. C. 1 5 e( )B)i , c u t h lt t nytme' imisa if r rua t o S. j 91 ()2 ( (i a o r s als a i 'd s s n n o ma ) a pa pe i c mpan i id al t saeacam u o whihrle ma b g a td. çAq u g u rs o li t f tt is o tt li p n c eif y e rn e ' ç j d e f 'g m us a ce a t u a loft f c uala l ga i c nt i i t c pl nt' Er ç o v. r , t c pt s r e 1 he a t le tons o a ned n he om ai . i ks n Pa dus ' 551U. 8 94 ( S. 9, 2007)( ttonsomitd) Thec tco tu pr s c ant lbe al ciai te . our nsr es o e ompli s i r ly, i i Ce ssrnge sa r t n f ma pla ngsd a t bylwye s'Se i (ntr l mposng d s ti nt tndads ha or l e di r fed a r . e d.i ena l ' q oainmak a dctto o te ) Ev nsi ,ç c mpan mus c nans fiin fcu l u tto r s n i i n mi d . e tl û o lit t o ti u fce t a t a a t la m a t r a e e ast u t t t t a cl i ofr le t ti pl us bl on isf ce.' A s r tv.l ba , te , cc pt d r e, o s a e a m e i f ha s a i e t a '' hc of q l 1 9S. .1 3 , 9 (00 )(u tn Bel lCo p v. mbl 5 0U. 5 4, 7 ( 0 7 2 Ct 9 7 1 49 2 9 q o ig l At. r . Two v, 5 S. 4 5 0 2 0 :; s eas At e tnv. C. fc o M a o , 6 F.d6 2 6 -8 ( C. r 2 0 )(l hl rr e lo h ro D. Ofie f y r 5 7 3 7 , 81 2 D. Ci. 0 9 E W ie c s s co ans mus behedt ls srnge sa r t nf ma pl di lq...e napr s e mplitj t l o e s ti nt tndads ha or l ea ngs, ve oe c pl na m us pl ad f c ua m a t rt tpe m ist c t o i e m or t n t m e e om ai nt t e a t l te ha r t he our t nf r e ha he r pos i lt ofmicond t')(ntr lquotto maksa ciai omit ) sbiiy s uc. i ena ' ain r nd ttons ted . H e e, r none oft f t pr e e i M r a M r .De e r a 'co pl nta e s fc e he ac s es nt d n . nd s m t i des m ai r uf i i nt t pla apl usbl cai orf t tm a tra i e lgi e o Alhoughrr sec o ed a i e l m or ha te n ntli bl ne. t / ompli sa e ant r hel t i e ssrnge sa r , Erc on,5 U. a 94, hi doe notgi pr s ltga t t d o s s ti nt tnda ds' i ks l ' 51 S. t t s s ve o e ii n s he prvieg ofs itng c a m sba ed on uni t li i e f c s Fr t f c s a pl ad, he c t i l e ubm ti l i s n e lg bl a t . om he a t s e t our ca o y di c r t tM r a M r .D e e r a 'a e c pl i ng t tt de a l ofM r n nl s e n ha . nd s m ti des r om a ni ha he t is . De era 's tl ntwe er e edby Se m tides eteme r elas dgwi k i vi ai oft Prvac Ac of1 c n olton he i y t 974. Thi ca e t De era d r a da a 'by sym ii t i efo t t hi fom SSA a s us d he m tides t m nd m ge' t eng her f rs o de r ha $90, s tlm e .I i notc e rhow a ha m wa c us d,wha t a i a lt oft 000 ete nt t s la ny r sa e t he pplc biiy he Prva y A c i ,o ho i w a vi a e fom t D e e ra 'c pl i ,w hi h m us c a n i c t s r w t s ol t d r he m t i des om a nt c t ont i eno h f c ua c en t a l t s c tt dr w t r s bl i e e e t tt de e nt ug a t l ont t o low hi our o a he ea ona e nf r nc ha he f nda s ar labl f a t o bl m i c e i e or c i na e s onduc . Thei c pl i f l t s i f t e basc pl ad ng t r om a nt ais o ats y hes i e i r qui e e s e r m nt . Acc di y, hecour dim is t rc or ngl t t s s es hei ompl it an . 11 1. Fort r as s a e t c t s i s M r a M r . e e r a 'co pl ntpur ua he e ons t t d, he our di m s es . nd s D m ti des m ai s nt t 28U. C. 1 5e ( ( (i wi u p eu iel o S. j 91 ()2)B)i t t rj d c . ) ho E nt r:Se e be 1 2O11 e pt m r 3, . I I STATESDITRI J X TED S CT UDGE 1S cin 1 5e apl st aln o mapapei fl s<na dto t c mplit fldb p io es.' c a v. e t 9l () p i o 1if r o e u rs ii t d i n o o ans ie y rsn rg 'Mih u ng i i j Ch retnCnv.4 4F.d7 5, 28(t Ci. 0 6 .Ac odngy ii tepo e v hcet dimisMr a dMr also t , 3 3 2 7 4h r2 0 ) c ri l,ts h rp r e il o s s . n s Demerade c pli . ti s' om ant 4

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.