Young v. Department Of Corrections, No. 7:2011cv00352 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/25/2011. (tvt)

Download PDF
et eer l .Dlr= ue ev FeEu s , v . 4N kv o eK ,A F'FD . I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I CO UR T CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A R O A N O K E D I SI N VI O M A R CU S D.Y O U N G , JUL 2s 2 1 21 JULA C. I BY; DE G CLE CA SE N O .7: 11CV 00352 Pl ntf , ai i f M EM O M ND U M O PI I N N O VS. D EPA R TM EN T O F CO RR EC TI N S, O By: G l n E.C onrad e C hi fU ni e St e Di t i Judge e t d at s s r ct Def endant . M a c D. Young,a Vigi a i ae pr e ng pr K ,fld t s cvi rg s a ton r us r ni nm t oce di o ie hi i l i ht c i plruan t 42 U. C. j1 zs t o S. 983, alegi t t whie he has be n i ace aed a M ai l ng ha l e nc r rt t ron Co rcin l e t n Ce tr( re to a Tr ame t ne MCTC)f rma yy as o fcash vee pei n e o hm wi o n e r, fiil a x rme td n i t h t lki of ps hi dr and m e cne' He s eks m o t r da l al nds yc c ugs di i .' e ne a y mage f t t de ii s or he mi ntfed onsder ton he om a nt he our i ha m he hass f r fom t i aci . U pon c i a i of t c pl i , t c tfnds r ufe ed r her tons1 t tt s a to mus be ds se wi u p eu ie b c u e i i ce rfo t e f c o t ha hi cin t imis d t t rj d c , e a s t s la r m h a e f he ho c ompl i t t pl ntf di no e us a i sr tve r m e e bef e flng t s a to as ant ha ai if d t xha t dm nita i e di s or ii hi c i n, rquied unde 42 U. C.j 1 9 ea,a d heh sn tn me a d fn a ts b e tt s i u d r e r r S. 9 7 () n a o n d e e d n u j c o ut n e j1 983. The Prs Lii to Reonn Ac (< t ' pr de , n ion tgain f t : A' ovi s mong ot r t ngs t t a PLl ) he hi , ha prs r c nnotbrng a cvi aci n c e ni prs c tons untlhe ha tr texha t ione a i i l to onc r ng ion ondii i s is used avalbl admi srtvermedi . Nusl v.Po tr 534U. 51 524( ) Thi e usi ia e nitai e es se re, S. 6, 2002 . s xha ton 1 Y oung alo as erst he i i s s t hat s nnocentoft frtdegr mur ofens on w hi he sands he is ee der f e ch t convi ed and confned. l he s ct i f eekst chalenge t valdiy ofhi confnem entundera s e cour o l he i t s i Gt t j d me th ma d s i ti c u t nyb fl jap t infrawrt f a e sc ru , us a to2 u g n, e y o o n hs o r o l y in ei o o io h b a og s p ru n t 8 i t U. C. 225 ,a trh vig frtprs ntdhl camst t hg s saec r f a l iai S e S. j 4 fe a n is e e e s ll o he ihe t tt ou t or d udc ton. e . Prie v. rg z 41lU. 475( 9 ) Be a eYou ofe sno idiaint th ha e use e sr Rod iue , S. 1 73 . c us ng f r n c to ha e s xha td sat c tr m edi r r ng t valdiy ofhi confnementpur uantt hi c cton,t cour w il t e our e es ega di he i t s i s o s onvi i he t l n tc nsr eh sc r n s miso a aj2 4 p tton. o o tu i ure t ub s ins s 25 eii r quie e a i t i li ae s t ,whe he t y i vege r lcr sanc orpa tc a e r m nt pples o û nm t uis al t r he nvol ne a icum t es ri ulr e s s ...w he he t y a l ge e e s ve f c or s e o he w r ' a w he he or nott pi ode , t r he le xc s i or e om t r ong,' nd t r he f r ofr le t i t s eks i a lbl t ough e usi ofa i sr tve r m e e . l om e if he nma e e s vaia e hr xha ton dm nitai e di s d. To compl wih j 1 () a i t mus f l e c se oft esabls d admi srtve y t 997ea , n nmae t olow a h tp he t ihe nitai pr e et tt sa epr dest prs r a mee alde i wihi t tpr dur be or oc dur ha he tt ovi o ione s nd t 1 adlnes t n ha oce e f e flnghi j1 a ton.SeeW oodfr v. o,548U. 81 90- ( ii s 983 ci o d Ng S. , 94 2006) . O n t f c ofhi co pl nt Y o m g a ist the di no fl a gr e nc s r r ng he a e s m ai , t dm t ha d t ie ny i va e ega di t camsrie i hi j 1 co ai .Heas s te aveiid satme f m onwhih he li asd n s 983 mpl nt lo ubmitd rfe t e nt or c he c c d t of t tle optons i c tng t t t prs whe e he i hous d has no he ke wo he lr e i , ndi a i ha he i on r s e greva i nce pr dur a t t he i sil hous d a t prs whe e t alege vi a i oce e nd ha s tl e t he ion r he l d oltons oc ur ed. c r Th c u t a e j iil tc o t ef c t t sap io fcl yo eae b teVigni e o r tk s udca noie f h a t ha a rs n a ii p r td y h r i a t De rme of Core tons ( pat nt rci VDOC) MCTC ha a etbls d admi srtve rmedi , s n sa ihe nitai e es pr e le f i a es t us o s e of w hi h i flng a gre nc Young,ho eve ,ad is oc dtr or nm t o e, ne t p c s ii i va e. w r m t t the hasnotfl d an gre nc c ha ie y i va e once i hi c r ntcl i s Thus i i cl rf om Y oung' m ng s ur e am . , t s ea r s s si t the di notc y wih t e ubmisons ha d ompl t he xhausi pr son of j 1 ton ovii 997e()asr rd a equie b f r fl t i lws i. Ac o dngy t ec u tmus d s s h sc mp an wi o tp eudc eo e ii h s a ut c r i l, h o r ng t imis i o lit t u rj ie h f rn n o in ewih j1 9 ea . o o c mpl c t 9 7 ( ) a 1 1 I t atr tve,t c twildimist sc antt r28 U. C.j 1 5 b) 1 n he lenai he our l s s hi ompli mde S. 91 A( () f fiur t saea aci bl cli .To saeac us ofa ton unde j1 apli ifmus or al e o tt ny tona e am tt a e ci r 983, antf t es a i h t the hasbe n deprve ofrght g r nt e by t Cons iuton or l w s oft U nie t bls ha e i d i s ua a e d he tt i a he t d St t s a t tt s de i ton r s t f om c uc c m it d by a pe s a tng t de c or a e nd ha hi pr va i e uled r ond t om te r on c i m r ol o saelw. W e tv Ati s 4 7U. 4 ( 98 ) ti n w wels tldt a saea e ce ,s c f tt a s . k n , 8 S. 2 1 8 .I s o l et h t tt g n is u h e a t de rm e of c r cto ,a e cons de e t be tn m s'of t sat t ta e notç r ons' s he pa t nt or e i ns r i rd o û r ' he t e ha r t s ' pe s be tt s i u d rj 1 8 .W i v.Mih g n De ' o S aePo ie 4 U. 5 ,7 ( 9 9 . u j c o ut n e 9 3 l l c ia pt f tt lc , 91 S. 8 1 1 8 ) Theonl defndan Youngna si t VDOC.Hec nno prvali a j1 cli agans t s y e t me s he a t e in 983 am i t hi def nda ,a t e or hi c pl i m us be dim i s d. e nt nd her f e, s om a nt t s se F rt ra o sae , h c u t imis sYo ng sc mpan wih u p eu ie pzs a t o he e s ns ttd t e o r ds se u ' o lit t o t rj d c , t u n r t j1 9 ea , o fiu et e h us a mi itaierme is a dpu s n t j1 5 b ( ) f r o 9 7 ( ) fr alr o x a t d nsrtv e de , n rua t o 91 A( )1, o f itr t sae ac am . An appr it or rwile e t sda alle o t t l i opra e de l nt r hi y.The Clr i dieced t s nd ek s r t o e c e oft sm e a opi s hi mor ndum opi on a ac ompa ng or rt pl ntf. ni nd c nyi de o ai if ENTER:Thi VS d yo J l, 01 . s a f uy 2 1 Chi fU nie St t D i ti tJ e t d a es s r c udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.