Beaton v. Virginia Department Of Corrections et al, No. 7:2011cv00309 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 07/14/2011. (kab)

Download PDF

tan e:QFFI k. DI ,* :v e GE l :T e, AT ROANOKE, ' VA Flr7 t JUt 1 2 1 2 I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI O F V I G I A CT R NI RO AN O K E D IVISIO N CH W STO PH E R BEA T O N , Pl nt f , ai i f V. V . O . ,e aI, D. C. t . Dee f ndant . s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) J A C. ULI BY; DEP Y, ERK CL CLERK Ci lA c i N o.7: c vi t on 11 v00309 M EM O R AN DU M O PIN IO N By:Sam uelG . is W l on U ni ed StatesD i t ctJudge t s ri Pl i i fChr s ophe Bea on, Vi gi ai a e pr e ng pr K , i t sc vi r g s a ntf it r t a r ni nm t oc edi o br ngs hi i l i ht a tonunder42U. C.j 1 alegi t tt dee nt f l t pr dehi wihade t ci S. 983, l ng ha he fnda s aied o ovi m t quae me c lc r Thecour tndst tBe t sal ga i f lt sae acli upon whih t c t di a a e. ti ha a on' le tons ai o t t am c he our ma gan r i ;a t r or dimis shi a tonpurua t 28U. C.j1 5e ( ( (i. y r t elef nd,heef e, s s e s ci s nt o S. 91 ()2)B)i) 1. Be t nalg st a wh l wokiga a imaeplmb r h sipe a df l,n u ighs ao l e h t ie r n s n n t u e , e l d n el ij rn i e p kne a bac Bea on r e nd k. t eque t d m e c l tea m ent t ne da a a nur e e m i d hi . se di a r t he xt y nd s xa ne m U pon e m i ton, t nur e c l d upo D r W a t i tt i l physci n. Dr W a xa na i he s ale n . ng, he ns iutona ia . ng a s s d Be t sij i a or r d a x-a Thex-ay c mebac negai a Dr W a sese aon' nures nd de e n ry. r a k tve nd . ng pr s rbe i of n f t pan a t Be t of wor de a lf f ten da . Be t e c i d bupr e or he i nd ook aon f k t i or oure ys aon s a e t ta x- ay w as tnota o i t ' a r ues s a M Rl s n. H e a g t tD r W a t t s ha n r t ppr pra e ' nd eq t n ca r ues ha . ng wa l e lg n i h sa s sme t n te t n 'o Be t n sij re . s l g ie t n i se s n a d rame t' f ao ' nu is n l l. Be t c ans t t dee nt W a a t t glge lyl' a vi aed hi aon ompli ha fnda ng ced d i ntl ' nd olt ne s consiutona rg s by f lng t pr de hi wih ade t m e ca team e . Ho ve ,t tt i l i ht aii o ovi m t quae di l r t nt we r he cour fnds t Beat s alegatons nm ountt not ng m ore t a doct - i di agr ent ti hat on' l i o hi han orpatent s eem whihi notacina eunde j 1 c s to bl r 983.Therf e t c t s s e hi c ait eor,he our dimis s s ompl n . To sae a c za e Ei t Ame tt ogni bl gh h ndmen c am f deni of me c c r a pli if t l i or al dial a e, antf mu talg fcs s fiin t de n tae ta j i o fcas we e d l e aey id fe e tt a s l e a t u fce t o mo srt h t al fiil r ei rtl n ifrn o e b srousme ca ne Esel v.Ga e 429U. 97,1 ( 976) Stplsv. De tofCo . ei di l ed. tle mbl, S. 05 1 ; a e Va. p' n. , 904 F. supp.487,492 ( D. . 1 ) To etbls dei rt i fee ,a pl ntf mus E. Va 995 . sa ih lbeae ndifrnce ai if t pr s nt f ct t de ons r t t t t de e nt ha ac ual know l dge of a di r ga d f a e e a s o m t a e ha he f nda d t e nd s e r or n o j ciey sro sme ia ne d.Fa e v. e n n 5 1U. 8 5, 3 ( 9 4 . e as Rihv. b e tv l e iu dc l e nn r Brn a , 1 S. 2 8 7 1 9 ) s e lo s , J m s n, ol o F. 1 2d 092, 1 ( h Ci.1 . An a se ton of mee ne i nce or e n 096 4t r 997) s ri r glge ve m a pr tc i no enough t s a e an Ei h Am e l ac i e s t o tt ght ndm e tvi a i i t ad,pl i ifm us a l ge n ol ton; ns e a ntf t le de i a e i f er nce tby e t r ac uali e or r ckl s dir ga d. Es e l ,429 U . a 1 6. lber t ndif e t ihe t nt nt e es s e r ' t le ' S. t 0 , Da el v.W ila ,47 U. 327,328 ( 986) Mite y.Be n,896 F. 8 8 ( h Ci. ni s lims 4 S. 1 ; lir or 2d 48, 51 4t r 1 . A cl m c r ngadia e ntbewe n a i t a me ca pe s lr a di 990) ai onceni s greme t e n nmae nd di l ronne eg r ng di nos s or c s oft e t entdoes not i plc t t Ei h A m endm e . W r g v.Coli , ag i our e ram m i a e he ght nt i ht lns 766F. 841 8 ( h Ci.1985) Rusel 528F. a 31 Ha sv.M ura 761F.Supp. 2d , 49 4t r ; s l, 2d t 9; ni ry, 409, 41 ( D. .1 9 ) F rh r q e to so me ia j dg n aen ts b e tt j dca rve 4 E. Va 9 0 . u te , u sin f dc l u me t r o u j c o u iil e iw. Rusel 5 F. a 31 (ii Shi dsv.Kunkel442F. 409(t Ci.1 ). s l, 28 2d t 9 ctng el , 2d 9h r 971) Bea o conc s t tafe hi f l he wa s en,e ua e a te t d by Dr W a f tn ede ha tr s a l s e val t d, nd r a e . ng or hi ij re . Al o h h ma ds g e wi tec u s o te t n h i rc i n , i cam i s n u is t ug e y ia re t h o re f r ame t e s e evig h s li s h h no hi m o e t n a doc or pa i nt di a e e , w hi h i no a tona e unde t Ei ht t ng r ha t - te s gr em nt c s t c i bl r he g h Am e ndme . M or r t t e entBe t alege t t de enda W ang wa ne i n i nt eove , o he xt aon l s ha f nt s glge t n a s si gBe t n' ij re o d tr n n h sc u s o te t n , s e t n o meen gie c s e sn ao s n u is r ee mii g i o re f r ame t a s ri s f r e l n e o g a e a s not a tonabl unde t Ei t A m e r lo ci e r he gh h ndm e .A c r ngl t c ttnds t t Be t nt co di y, he our i ha a on hasnotde o t a ed t tt de e nt a t d wih delbe a e i f e e a t , t has m ns r t ha he f nda s c e t i r t ndi f r nce nd, hus Bea on f l t s at a cons iutonalcl m . aied o t e tt i ai 1 11. For t r as s a e he ei t c tdi m i s B e t s ac i f f iur t sa e a he e ons t t d r n, he our s s es a on' ton or a l e o t t cli purua t j 1 5()2)B)i) am s nt o 91 e ( ( (i. EN TER : Thi J y 1 2011 s ul 4, . . # a ... . , . . *' .' . .. .. < z ; le Stt sDiti tJ t d a e src udge v j s

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.