-RSB Robinson v. Williams, No. 7:2011cv00303 - Document 26 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 4/30/12. (tvt) (Additional attachment(s) added on 4/30/2012: # 1 VDOC 866.1) (tvt).
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
cteRK' oe/l u, oIT o>:e : ce :. : . AT I Nvl VA M kkE, F n I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A ROANOKE DI I ON V SI AR ,2f F 2 O JUt BY: K EI R .RO BI SO N , TH N Pl nt f , ai i f By: D M EM OM NDUM O PI J N N O I V ESTI A TO R W I I M S, N G LL A De e f ndant . . Ci lA cti N o.7: cvvi on 11- 00303 V. D H on.Jacks L.K i on ser Se orUnied St esDit i tJudge ni t at src Keih R .Robi on,a V igi a i a e pr e ng pr K ,fl d a c vi r gh s c pl i , t ns r ni nm t oc edi o ie i l i t om a nt p ru n t 4 U.. j 1 8 wihj rs ito v se i 2 U. C. 1 4 .Plitf na s u s a t o 2 SC. 9 3 t u idcin e td n 8 S. j 3 3 anif me I si t W ila ,aVigi à De rme ofCore tons(I nve tgaor lims r ni pa t nt r ci 1 VDOC' c r to lofi r a ' orecina fce, s ) t s e de e he ol f ndant Pl i ifalege t tde e a us d e e sve f c i vi ai oft . antf l s ha f nd nt e xc s i or e,n olton he Ei ht Am e en oft U nie St t Cons iuto D e enda fl a m o i n f s m m' g h ndm t he t d a es tt i n. f nt ied t o or um y j udgme ,a pli ifr ponde ma ngt matrrpef diposton.Afe r e ngt nt nd antf es d, ki he te i or s ii tr eviwi he r c d,Igrntdefnda ' motonf s e or a e nts i or ummayj r udgme be us pli iff ldt e us nt ca e antf aie o xha t ava l bl a i s r tve r m e e . ia e dm ni ta i e di s The r cor r ve l t f l i f t . On A prl8,2011 pl i iff l d an i or al e d e a s he olow ng ac s i , a ntf ie nf m co ai t ofiil a t W ale Ri Stt Prs (t ARSP' bec us dee ntspolc mpl nt o fcas t he lns dge ae ion G W ' a e fnda ' ie ) d bi pl ntf on M a ch 1 2011 ca i pl ntf t s a i t W AR SP m e ca de rm e og t ai i f r 8, , us ng ai if o t y n he di l pa t nt f t eeda Pl ntf a l ed t tde e nti t ntonaly 1tt polc dog unnec s a iy bie or hr ys. ai if leg ha f nda n e i l e he i e e s rl t pl i if St f deni d t i or a com pl nt a ntf . a f e he nf m l ai . Pli iffl ar ulrgreva eon Aprl21 2011 i whih pl ntf de e beng a ntf ied eg a i nc i , , n c ai if ni d i i ved i a t gh a s d he i notdone anyt ng w r ' he t dog bi hi i t nvol n i t nd ai d had hi ong' w n he t m n he u r rghtl The w a de oft W A RSP de e t r ul rgr e nc on M a 24, 2011, ppe - i eg. r n he ni d he eg a i va e y f ndi t pl ntf w asf ghtng w ih anot i at , def nda r pea e y or e pl i ift i ng hat ai if i i t her nm e e nt e t dl der d a ntf o , sop fghtng,pl i ifdi no r po t t o de s a de e ntpr pe l us t K- t sop t i i antf d t es nd o he r r , nd f nda o ry ed he 9 o t t fgh .Thewa de a s d pl i ift the c ul a he i t r n dvie antf ha o d ppea t gre nc de al butpl i if l he i va e ni , antf c e nott a alt de s on. hos o ppe he ci i 1. 1 A p ryi e tte t s a t s n i d o umma yj d me tCf h p e d n s t eds o ey a dd sl s r l r u g n ' t e la i g ,h ic v r n ico u e i m ae il on fl,and a a fdaviss t tt r i no ge neis ast a m ae ilf c t ra s ie ny fi t how ha he e s nui sue o ny tra a t a t tt mova i e ildt j nd ha he nt s ntte o udgme asamatroflw. Fe R. v.P.56() M ae il nt te a ' d. Ci ' c . tra f c s a e t e ne s ar t e t bls t e em e sofa pa t sc e ofac i Ande s v. a t r hos ce s y o s a i h he l nt ry' aus ton. r on Li ryLobby.l , U. 2 248( 986) A g nui is ofmaeilfc e ssi,n be t nc.477 S. 42, 1 . e ne sue tra a t xit f i vi ng t r or and al r s bl i e e esdr wn t e r i a lg m os f a et t ewi he ec d l ea ona e nf r nc a her fom n i ht t avor bl o he non- ngpa t ar s bl f tfnde c drt naveditf t nonmovi ry, ea ona e ac-i r oul eur r c or he mova .Jz The nt #. m ovi pa t hast bur n of s i - û ha i , ntng o t t dit i tc t t tt r i ng ry he de how ng d t s poi i ut o he s rc our - ha he e s t a a e e ofe de e t s n bs nc vi nc o uppor t nonm ovi pa t s c e ' Cel ex Cor v. t e t 477 t he ng ry' as .' ot p. Ca r t, U. 31 325 ( S. 7, 1986) l t movants tsist sbur n,he t non- ntmus s tf t . f he aife hi de t n he mova t e orh s c t c a i s bl f c s t tde ons r t t e se e ofa ge ne i s of f tf t i l Fe pe ii , dm s i e a t ha m ta e he xi t nc nui s ue ac or ra . d. R. v. 5 () Ceoe 4 7U. a 3 2 2 A pa' i e t ldt s mmayj g n i te Ci P. 6 c ; ltx, 7 S. t 2 - 3. ty s ni e o u r ud me t f h t t r co d a a whol c d notl a a r tona t i rof f c t tnd i f voroft non- o nt e r s e oul e d a i l re ato i n a he m va . W i imsv. ifn 9 2F.d8 0 8 3( t Ci.1 91.Co v rey s mmayj g n i la l Grfi , 5 2 2 , 2 4h r 9 ) n es l , u r ud me t s i ppr i t i t e de e i s f c e tf a r s bl f c - i rt r t n a ve di ti f vor na opr a e f he vi nc s uf i i n or ea ona e a t fnde o e ur r c n a oft non- ovi pa t A nde s n,477 U . a 248. he m ng ry. ro S. t Def nda a g st tpl ntf f ie t exha ta ia e a nita i r m e esf e nt r ue ha ai if a ld o us val bl dmi sr tve e di or pli ifscai a t dogbie.ThePrs Lii tonRef m Ac pr de t ttg oa ton antf' l m bout he t ion tgai or t ovi s ha tnl ci s l bebr hal oughtwihr pe tt prs n c tonsunderg 1 t es c o io ondii j 983)...by aprs rconfne i , ione i dn a yj i, rs n o oh rc re to a fcl yu i s c a mi itaierme isa aea albe n alp io r te o r ci n l a ii nt u h d nsrtv e d e s r v ia l t l aee used.'42U. C.j 1 () Thee usi rquie r xha t ' S. 997ea . xha ton e rmenti ma t yand( pple t s ndaor i is o a ali t s t a utprs lf .' Porerv. se 534U. 51 524,532 ( 2) SPr r lnmae uis bo ion ielq' t Nusl, S. 6, 200 . ' ope exha ton dem a com pla e w ih a a us i nds i nc t n genc s de dlnesa ot r c ii alpr dur lr e . y' a i nd he rtc oce a ul s ' ' W o d o dv Na 5 U. 81 9 ( 0 6 .W h naprs npr vd sa a miitai eg iv n e o f r . o, 48 S. , 0 2 0 ) e io o ie n d n srtv re a c pr dur t i a emus fl agre ncer sng apa tc a c am a puruei t ough al oce e,he nm t t ie iva aii riul r l i nd s t hr l avalbl lvel ofa lt E opel e us.'I ;Di v.Pa ,291F.d485, - ( t ia e e s ppea o t ry xha t' d. xon pr ce 3 490 91 7h Ci.2002) . i t sf l et exha ti a afimai dee et tadee ntha t r . An nmae' aiur o us s n fr tve fns ha fnda s he bur nt pr J v. k,549U. 1 216( ) de o ove. ones Boc S. 99, 2007 . VDOC De t ntOpe ai Pr e e(t ' 8 1,nmaeGre nc Pr dur,i parme r tng oc dur ûDOP' 66. l t iva e oce e s ) a m e ha s f i a e t r s ve c pl i s a a a i s r tve de i i ,a c l ng c ni m or nm t s o e ol om a nt , ppe l dm nit a i c s ons nd hale e polc esand pr edu e . 1 The pr s pr de c r c i ii oc r s oce s ovi s or e tonala i s r t r m e nst i ntf dm ni t a o s a o de i y pot n i lpr e a i ne s r co r tt epr e si atm ey m a r A l is sa e e ta obl ms nd, f ces a y, rec hos oblm n i l nne . l s ue r gre bl e pti s aboutpolc es pr ed es a de i i oft V i gi a Pa ol Boar i va e xce s ues i i , oc ur , nd c s ons he r ni r e d; dicplna y he rng pe li a / pr dur lero s sae a f r lc tde sons l ws si i r ai nates nd or oce a r r ; t t nd ede a our cii , a , and r atons;and ot m ater beyond t V D O C' cont . egul i her t s he S rol l a esa e orent t t i a e gre nc pr edur w he t y e e t V D OC a nm t r i ed o he nm t i va e oc e n he nt r he nd w he t y ar t a f r ed t di f r ntf ciii . Prort s itng a g i vanc t i a e m us ' n he e r ns e r o f e e a ltes i o ubm ti re e, he nm t t 'Defnda r le u t afida toft W ARSP Gre nc Coor naor who de c i sDOP 866. a has e nt eis pon he t vi he iva e di t , s rbe 1 nd a ce st plitf sg i ncer or .H o e r de e ntdi notdocke acopy oft polcy.DOP 866. c s o an if reva ec ds w ve , f nda d t he i 1 pr de t ti a e ,s h aspl ntf,a ei or e oft avalbl g ivanc pr edur whent e e t ovi s ha nm t s uc ai if r nf m d he ia e re e oc es hey ntr he VDOC a whenta fr e t adif r VDOC f lt Pl ntf doesnotde t he i fmiirwihVDOC nd r nse r d o feent aciiy. ai if ny hat s a la t greva pr dur s a pl ntf' g i nc s i nce oce e , nd ai ifs reva es uppor t c uson t tpl ntf knowsofDOP 866.' t he oncl i ha ai if 1s rq ie ns Ac o dn y, tk j dca n tc o DOP8 6 1whc i a albl a e urme t. c r igl l a e u iil oie f 6 ., ih s v i e t a htp:/ /www . vadoc.tt va. /bou oc esdocument/ 866- pdfa wa t polc i f c durng sae. usa Fpr edc / s8oo/ l. nd s he iy n or e i plitf' g iv n e .S eF d. Evd. 0lb()( r tigj dca n tc o fcswhc G a b a c rtl a d anifs re a c s e e R. i 2 ( )2 pemi n u iil oie f a t ih ç n e c uaey n l c r a i d tr ie fo s u c swh e a c r c c n o ra o a ybequ sine ' ; n v J h s n No 3:o c e dl eem n d r m o r e os c u a y a n t e s n bl y e to d ' Pe v . o n o , . l -v ) 6 0 2 1U.. s. 3 , 01 S DitLEXI 8 4 , 0llW L3 5 51 ( D. . g. 201 )(in Bo e v Ra , . :7c S 5 31 2 3 9 9 E. Va Au 3, 1 ct g wlr . v No 70 -v i 0 5 5 2 0 U.. s. 0 6 , 0 7 S Dit LEXI 8 1 3, 00 W L 4 6 91 ( . Va No . 0 2 0 ) Dee d n i r mid d t S 83 2 7 2 8 5 W D. . v 3 , 0 7 . f n a t s e n e o d c e ac p o aVDOC p lc wh ntep lc i u e t s p o t moinfrsmma'j g n. ok t oy f oiy e h oiy s sd o u p r a to o u l ud me t y m a agood f ih efor t i or al r s vet c pl ntby s itng an i or c pli ke at f t o nf m ly e ol he om ai ubm ti nf mal om ant f m ,whih i a ia ei housng unis I no r s ve t i t m us fl ar gulr or c s va lbl n i t . f t e ol d, he nma e t ie e a gr e nce w ihi t ry c l nda da f om t da e oft occ r e or i de . Onl o i s i va t n hi t a e r ys r he t he ur enc nci nt y ne s ue perg i va e m a be a r s ed. Reg a gre nc m a r ce ve t ee l ve sofr e . A r e nc y dd e s ul r i va es y e i hr e l evi w f iiy' W ar n or Supe i e ntc ac lt s de rnt nde onduc st f r t û ve l'r vi w oft gre nc A n t he is , ç l ' e e Le he i va e. i t may a pma e ppea t wa de sde son t t Re o lOmbuds a Die t f aLeve 1 l he r n' cii o he gi na m n/ r c or or l1 det r i ton,w hi h i ge r l t fnall ve ofr vi w . The De y D i e t orDi e t r of e m na i c s ne aly he i e l e e put r c or rco t V DO C c he onduct t r vi w f t f w i s s a pe l bl t Le 1 1 s he e e or he e s ue p a a e o vel 1 . Pl i iffl d a i or a com pl i a a r gul rgr e nc The a e above t a ntf ie n nf m l a nt nd e a i va e. ra he w a de ss gna ur o t r s r n' i t e n he e pons t t r ul rgre nce i or e pl i ifoft rghtt e o he eg a i va nf m d a ntf he i o a a t w a de sde i i Pl i ifdi nota a t w a den' Le lr e t a r gi l ppe l he r n' c s on. a ntf d ppe l he r s vel evi w o e ona diecorf Le 1 r viw .Pl i ifdoesnotpr e a evi nc t thee r t or vel 1 e e antf es nt ny de e ha xhause a ia e t d valbl ad i sr tve r m e e a doesno e a n ar a on f f ii t e m ni ta i e di s nd t xpl i e s or a lng o xhaus . A c or ngl t c di y, d fn a ti e tte t s mmayj d me tf rpanifsfiu et e ha s a ia l ee d n s n ild o u z u g n o li tf alr o x u t valbe a i s r tve r m edi . dm nit a i e es 1 1. 1 F rt f r g n ra o s lg a td fn a tsmoin frs mma yj d me t o he o e oig e s n , rn e e d n ' to o u r u g n . The Clr i diec e t s nd c esoft sM e or ndum Opi on a t a ompa ng e k s r t d o e opi hi m a ni nd he cc nyi O r rt pl i i fa c de o a ntf nd ouns lofr or f def nt e ec d or enda . EN TER : Thi w.day ofApr l 201 i, 2. e Se orU nied St esD i t ctJ t at sri udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
