-RSB Robinson v. Williams, No. 7:2011cv00303 - Document 26 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 4/30/12. (tvt) (Additional attachment(s) added on 4/30/2012: # 1 VDOC 866.1) (tvt).
Download PDF
cteRK' oe/l u, oIT o>:e : ce :. : . AT I Nvl VA M kkE, F n I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A ROANOKE DI I ON V SI AR ,2f F 2 O JUt BY: K EI R .RO BI SO N , TH N Pl nt f , ai i f By: D M EM OM NDUM O PI J N N O I V ESTI A TO R W I I M S, N G LL A De e f ndant . . Ci lA cti N o.7: cvvi on 11- 00303 V. D H on.Jacks L.K i on ser Se orUnied St esDit i tJudge ni t at src Keih R .Robi on,a V igi a i a e pr e ng pr K ,fl d a c vi r gh s c pl i , t ns r ni nm t oc edi o ie i l i t om a nt p ru n t 4 U.. j 1 8 wihj rs ito v se i 2 U. C. 1 4 .Plitf na s u s a t o 2 SC. 9 3 t u idcin e td n 8 S. j 3 3 anif me I si t W ila ,aVigi àDe rme ofCore tons(I nve tgaor lims r ni pa t nt r ci 1 VDOC' c r to lofi r a ' orecina fce, s ) t s e de e he ol f ndant Pl i ifalege t tde e a us d e e sve f c i vi ai oft . antf l s ha f nd nt e xc s i or e,n olton he Ei ht Am e en oft U nie St t Cons iuto D e enda fl a m o i n f s m m' g h ndm t he t d a es tt i n. f nt ied t o or um y j udgme ,a pli ifr ponde ma ngt matrrpef diposton.Afe r e ngt nt nd antf es d, ki he te i or s ii tr eviwi he r c d,Igrntdefnda ' motonf s e or a e nts i or ummayj r udgme be us pli iff ldt e us nt ca e antf aie o xha t ava l bl a i s r tve r m e e . ia e dm ni ta i e di s The r cor r ve l t f l i f t . On A prl8,2011 pl i iff l d an i or al e d e a s he olow ng ac s i , a ntf ie nf m co ai t ofiil a t W ale Ri Stt Prs (t ARSP' bec us dee ntspolc mpl nt o fcas t he lns dge ae ion G W ' a e fnda ' ie ) d bi pl ntf on M a ch 1 2011 ca i pl ntf t s a i t W AR SP m e ca de rm e og t ai i f r 8, , us ng ai if o t y n he di l pa t nt f t eeda Pl ntf a l ed t tde e nti t ntonaly 1tt polc dog unnec s a iy bie or hr ys. ai if leg ha f nda n e i l e he i e e s rl t pl i if St f deni d t i or a com pl nt a ntf . a f e he nf m l ai . Pli iffl ar ulrgreva eon Aprl21 2011 i whih pl ntf de e beng a ntf ied eg a i nc i , , n c ai if ni d i i ved i a t gh a s d he i notdone anyt ng w r ' he t dog bi hi i t nvol n i t nd ai d had hi ong' w n he t m n he u r rghtl The w a de oft W A RSP de e t r ul rgr e nc on M a 24, 2011, ppe - i eg. r n he ni d he eg a i va e y f ndi t pl ntf w asf ghtng w ih anot i at , def nda r pea e y or e pl i ift i ng hat ai if i i t her nm e e nt e t dl der d a ntf o , sop fghtng,pl i ifdi no r po t t o de s a de e ntpr pe l us t K- t sop t i i antf d t es nd o he r r , nd f nda o ry ed he 9 o t t fgh .Thewa de a s d pl i ift the c ul a he i t r n dvie antf ha o d ppea t gre nc de al butpl i if l he i va e ni , antf c e nott a alt de s on. hos o ppe he ci i 1. 1 A p ryi e tte t s a t s n i d o umma yj d me tCf h p e d n s t eds o ey a dd sl s r l r u g n ' t e la i g ,h ic v r n ico u e i m ae il on fl,and a a fdaviss t tt r i no ge neis ast a m ae ilf c t ra s ie ny fi t how ha he e s nui sue o ny tra a t a t tt mova i e ildt j nd ha he nt s ntte o udgme asamatroflw. Fe R. v.P.56() M ae il nt te a ' d. Ci ' c . tra f c s a e t e ne s ar t e t bls t e em e sofa pa t sc e ofac i Ande s v. a t r hos ce s y o s a i h he l nt ry' aus ton. r on Li ryLobby.l , U. 2 248( 986) A g nui is ofmaeilfc e ssi,n be t nc.477 S. 42, 1 . e ne sue tra a t xit f i vi ng t r or and al r s bl i e e esdr wn t e r i a lg m os f a et t ewi he ec d l ea ona e nf r nc a her fom n i ht t avor bl o he non- ngpa t ar s bl f tfnde c drt naveditf t nonmovi ry, ea ona e ac-i r oul eur r c or he mova .Jz The nt #. m ovi pa t hast bur n of s i - û ha i , ntng o t t dit i tc t t tt r i ng ry he de how ng d t s poi i ut o he s rc our - ha he e s t a a e e ofe de e t s n bs nc vi nc o uppor t nonm ovi pa t s c e ' Cel ex Cor v. t e t 477 t he ng ry' as .' ot p. Ca r t, U. 31 325 ( S. 7, 1986) l t movants tsist sbur n,he t non- ntmus s tf t . f he aife hi de t n he mova t e orh s c t c a i s bl f c s t tde ons r t t e se e ofa ge ne i s of f tf t i l Fe pe ii , dm s i e a t ha m ta e he xi t nc nui s ue ac or ra . d. R. v. 5 () Ceoe 4 7U. a 3 2 2 A pa' i e t ldt s mmayj g n i te Ci P. 6 c ; ltx, 7 S. t 2 - 3. ty s ni e o u r ud me t f h t t r co d a a whol c d notl a a r tona t i rof f c t tnd i f voroft non- o nt e r s e oul e d a i l re ato i n a he m va . W i imsv. ifn 9 2F.d8 0 8 3( t Ci.1 91.Co v rey s mmayj g n i la l Grfi , 5 2 2 , 2 4h r 9 ) n es l , u r ud me t s i ppr i t i t e de e i s f c e tf a r s bl f c - i rt r t n a ve di ti f vor na opr a e f he vi nc s uf i i n or ea ona e a t fnde o e ur r c n a oft non- ovi pa t A nde s n,477 U . a 248. he m ng ry. ro S. t Def nda a g st tpl ntf f ie t exha ta ia e a nita i r m e esf e nt r ue ha ai if a ld o us val bl dmi sr tve e di or pli ifscai a t dogbie.ThePrs Lii tonRef m Ac pr de t ttg oa ton antf' l m bout he t ion tgai or t ovi s ha tnl ci s l bebr hal oughtwihr pe tt prs n c tonsunderg 1 t es c o io ondii j 983)...by aprs rconfne i , ione i dn a yj i, rs n o oh rc re to a fcl yu i s c a mi itaierme isa aea albe n alp io r te o r ci n l a ii nt u h d nsrtv e d e s r v ia l t l aee used.'42U. C.j 1 () Thee usi rquie r xha t ' S. 997ea . xha ton e rmenti ma t yand( pple t s ndaor i is o a ali t s t a utprs lf .' Porerv. se 534U. 51 524,532 ( 2) SPr r lnmae uis bo ion ielq' t Nusl, S. 6, 200 . ' ope exha ton dem a com pla e w ih a a us i nds i nc t n genc s de dlnesa ot r c ii alpr dur lr e . y' a i nd he rtc oce a ul s ' ' W o d o dv Na 5 U. 81 9 ( 0 6 .W h naprs npr vd sa a miitai eg iv n e o f r . o, 48 S. , 0 2 0 ) e io o ie n d n srtv re a c pr dur t i a emus fl agre ncer sng apa tc a c am a puruei t ough al oce e,he nm t t ie iva aii riul r l i nd s t hr l avalbl lvel ofa lt E opel e us.'I ;Di v.Pa ,291F.d485, - ( t ia e e s ppea o t ry xha t' d. xon pr ce 3 490 91 7h Ci.2002) . i t sf l et exha ti a afimai dee et tadee ntha t r . An nmae' aiur o us s n fr tve fns ha fnda s he bur nt pr J v. k,549U. 1 216( ) de o ove. ones Boc S. 99, 2007 . VDOC De t ntOpe ai Pr e e(t ' 8 1,nmaeGre nc Pr dur,i parme r tng oc dur ûDOP' 66. l t iva e oce e s ) a m e ha s f i a e t r s ve c pl i s a a a i s r tve de i i ,a c l ng c ni m or nm t s o e ol om a nt , ppe l dm nit a i c s ons nd hale e polc esand pr edu e . 1 The pr s pr de c r c i ii oc r s oce s ovi s or e tonala i s r t r m e nst i ntf dm ni t a o s a o de i y pot n i lpr e a i ne s r co r tt epr e si atm ey m a r A l is sa e e ta obl ms nd, f ces a y, rec hos oblm n i l nne . l s ue r gre bl e pti s aboutpolc es pr ed es a de i i oft V i gi a Pa ol Boar i va e xce s ues i i , oc ur , nd c s ons he r ni r e d; dicplna y he rng pe li a / pr dur lero s sae a f r lc tde sons l ws si i r ai nates nd or oce a r r ; t t nd ede a our cii , a , and r atons;and ot m ater beyond t V D O C' cont . egul i her t s he S rol l a esa e orent t t i a e gre nc pr edur w he t y e e t V D OC a nm t r i ed o he nm t i va e oc e n he nt r he nd w he t y ar t a f r ed t di f r ntf ciii . Prort s itng a g i vanc t i a e m us ' n he e r ns e r o f e e a ltes i o ubm ti re e, he nm t t 'Defnda r le u t afida toft W ARSP Gre nc Coor naor who de c i sDOP 866. a has e nt eis pon he t vi he iva e di t , s rbe 1 nd a ce st plitf sg i ncer or .H o e r de e ntdi notdocke acopy oft polcy.DOP 866. c s o an if reva ec ds w ve , f nda d t he i 1 pr de t ti a e ,s h aspl ntf,a ei or e oft avalbl g ivanc pr edur whent e e t ovi s ha nm t s uc ai if r nf m d he ia e re e oc es hey ntr he VDOC a whenta fr e t adif r VDOC f lt Pl ntf doesnotde t he i fmiirwihVDOC nd r nse r d o feent aciiy. ai if ny hat s a la t greva pr dur s a pl ntf' g i nc s i nce oce e , nd ai ifs reva es uppor t c uson t tpl ntf knowsofDOP 866.' t he oncl i ha ai if 1s rq ie ns Ac o dn y, tk j dca n tc o DOP8 6 1whc i a albl a e urme t. c r igl l a e u iil oie f 6 ., ih s v i e t a htp:/ /www . vadoc.tt va. /bou oc esdocument/ 866- pdfa wa t polc i f c durng sae. usa Fpr edc / s8oo/ l. nd s he iy n or e i plitf' g iv n e .S eF d. Evd. 0lb()( r tigj dca n tc o fcswhc G a b a c rtl a d anifs re a c s e e R. i 2 ( )2 pemi n u iil oie f a t ih ç n e c uaey n l c r a i d tr ie fo s u c swh e a c r c c n o ra o a ybequ sine ' ; n v J h s n No 3:o c e dl eem n d r m o r e os c u a y a n t e s n bl y e to d ' Pe v . o n o , . l -v ) 6 0 2 1U.. s. 3 , 01 S DitLEXI 8 4 , 0llW L3 5 51 ( D. . g. 201 )(in Bo e v Ra , . :7c S 5 31 2 3 9 9 E. Va Au 3, 1 ct g wlr . v No 70 -v i 0 5 5 2 0 U.. s. 0 6 , 0 7 S Dit LEXI 8 1 3, 00 W L 4 6 91 ( . Va No . 0 2 0 ) Dee d n i r mid d t S 83 2 7 2 8 5 W D. . v 3 , 0 7 . f n a t s e n e o d c e ac p o aVDOC p lc wh ntep lc i u e t s p o t moinfrsmma'j g n. ok t oy f oiy e h oiy s sd o u p r a to o u l ud me t y m a agood f ih efor t i or al r s vet c pl ntby s itng an i or c pli ke at f t o nf m ly e ol he om ai ubm ti nf mal om ant f m ,whih i a ia ei housng unis I no r s ve t i t m us fl ar gulr or c s va lbl n i t . f t e ol d, he nma e t ie e a gr e nce w ihi t ry c l nda da f om t da e oft occ r e or i de . Onl o i s i va t n hi t a e r ys r he t he ur enc nci nt y ne s ue perg i va e m a be a r s ed. Reg a gre nc m a r ce ve t ee l ve sofr e . A r e nc y dd e s ul r i va es y e i hr e l evi w f iiy' W ar n or Supe i e ntc ac lt s de rnt nde onduc st f r t û ve l'r vi w oft gre nc A n t he is , ç l ' e e Le he i va e. i t may a pma e ppea t wa de sde son t t Re o lOmbuds a Die t f aLeve 1 l he r n' cii o he gi na m n/ r c or or l1 det r i ton,w hi h i ge r l t fnall ve ofr vi w . The De y D i e t orDi e t r of e m na i c s ne aly he i e l e e put r c or rco t V DO C c he onduct t r vi w f t f w i s s a pe l bl t Le 1 1 s he e e or he e s ue p a a e o vel 1 . Pl i iffl d a i or a com pl i a a r gul rgr e nc The a e above t a ntf ie n nf m l a nt nd e a i va e. ra he w a de ss gna ur o t r s r n' i t e n he e pons t t r ul rgre nce i or e pl i ifoft rghtt e o he eg a i va nf m d a ntf he i o a a t w a de sde i i Pl i ifdi nota a t w a den' Le lr e t a r gi l ppe l he r n' c s on. a ntf d ppe l he r s vel evi w o e ona diecorf Le 1 r viw .Pl i ifdoesnotpr e a evi nc t thee r t or vel 1 e e antf es nt ny de e ha xhause a ia e t d valbl ad i sr tve r m e e a doesno e a n ar a on f f ii t e m ni ta i e di s nd t xpl i e s or a lng o xhaus . A c or ngl t c di y, d fn a ti e tte t s mmayj d me tf rpanifsfiu et e ha s a ia l ee d n s n ild o u z u g n o li tf alr o x u t valbe a i s r tve r m edi . dm nit a i e es 1 1. 1 F rt f r g n ra o s lg a td fn a tsmoin frs mma yj d me t o he o e oig e s n , rn e e d n ' to o u r u g n . The Clr i diec e t s nd c esoft sM e or ndum Opi on a t a ompa ng e k s r t d o e opi hi m a ni nd he cc nyi O r rt pl i i fa c de o a ntf nd ouns lofr or f def nt e ec d or enda . EN TER : Thi w.day ofApr l 201 i, 2. e Se orU nied St esD i t ctJ t at sri udge