Lay v. Legg et al, No. 7:2011cv00291 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 6/27/2011. (tvt)

Download PDF
ck e* OF I u. . s . RT FCE s DlY = TM K E. VA n I '' E U NITED STA TES DISTR ICT C O U R T N IH F( I TH E W ESTERN D I )t STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R O A NO K E D IVISI N O JN27 2 U JU Bz p D JO H N R .I A Y, U Pl ntif ai f , ) ) ) ) ) ) ) BEN SO N E. EG ( tt:1, IJ 1, ! 1. D ef endant . s 'CLERK q. % L Ci lA ct on N o.7: c 00291 vi i 11- v- M EM ORANPVM oèl ox xl 1 ):l on.Jac on L.K i er ,, l ks q Scni U nied St esD i ri Judge or t at st ct Pl ntf J R.La aVigi a i t pr e ng nr s ,fl d aci lrght co pli , ai if ohn y, r ni nma e oc edi o e ie vi i s m ant pur suantt Bi o vensv.Si U nknown N am edAxen sofFe a Bur u ofN a c i , 3 U. 38 x t der l ea r otcs 40 S. 8 - ( 971,a 42U. C.j1 Nihj iditonvetdi 28U. C.jj1 1 1 43.Pli ifdi 1 ) nd S. 983 vt urs ci se n S. 33 , 3 antf d nots ubmi pa e f t $3501lng f ewih hi ctmpl nta di notfl fna a t ym nt or he 5i e t s l ai nd d ie i ncil doc ument i s s n uppor of:rquett pr e îlf mapa rs See28U. C.jj l 4() 1 1 t 4 e s o oce d . or l up4 t. S. 91 a, 9 5. * x Pl i ilha atI a tt e n ha asci lc pl i sora a ntf' d e s hr e on- be vi om a nt ppea spr ous y di m i s as l evi l s s ed fi ous ol f 'f lng t s at a ct m upon w hi r i m ay be gr ed. See Lav v. Clnt n. t rvol - ol aii o t e ai eh etef ant i o e gk, 09' No. 7065( hC''Ap 29, 1 ( de de ng l vet pr ,edwihoutprpa nto 4t i. r. 20 0) or v nyi ea o oc t e t e yme f t a llea r lngflngfet bepadi f l. he ppea ' nd equii ii e o e i n ul) l a cor l wih28U. . jl l5 g , dsre c tprvi l a s dplitf t t n c dawe t SC. 9 ( ) a itit our e ousy dvie anif ha he had it ee s rles,' lz v.Cl l ofCour ,N o. 1 1 c 01 1 ( M d. un. 2010 ( de ûhr t it ' ay ert t :0-v- 3 0 D. J 2, ) or r a sng pl i i ft the i 8 t r e- tî 'pur ua tt 28 U. C. 1 15( ) Theeor pli if dvi i a nt f ha s : h e sl ke - r s n o S. j 9 g). rf e, antf . ne de t s m i t $350. flng f ore t bls an i i ntt ea ofs rousph ialha m e d o ub t he 00 ii ee sa ih mm ne hr t e i ysc r t pr e w ih a e vi s t Af e r vi w i pl i ils s i s ons i t s c vi a ton, i i cl o oc ed t i l ui. t r e e ng a ntf' ubm s i n hi i l c i t s ear t tpl ntf' ha ai iidoes notalege any f si catng t the i cun-nty unde any i m i l aet ndi i ha s e l r m nentt eatof hr a srousphysc li ur wihi t mea ngof28 t. C.j 1 5() Ba e ont fr goi ny e i ia qj y t n he ni lS. 91 g . s d he o e ng and t com pl n ,1lnd t tpl i tf hasf ie t d ons r t a i m i ntda rofs rous he ai t s ha a n if a l d o em ta e ny m ne nge ei physc ha m i t e c pl ntand di notpa t e$35 00 flng f e de piebei pr vi l ial r n h om ai d yl 4 0. ii e s t ng e ousy a s dolha ngt eesrke .Acc di y, de pl ntf si i motont pr e dt dvie ' vi hr ti s or ngl 1 ny ai if mpled i o oc e q fr p u ei a ddimistec mplitwih u p eu ief rfiu et p yt efl fea te oma a p rs n s s h o an to t rj dc o alr o a h ing e th i tmeofflngt c ai .See e. ,Du e v. mû-284F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.200 i 'i hc ompl nt , :. pye Pal u, i 3d 234, 237 1 t r 2) (e s ngt tt flngf i dteupon'lngacvi a tonwhe t f map rspr sons ra oni ha he li ee s t ti i i l ci n q or aupei ovii do nota y t pl i ifa t tt eour i notr quie t per i pl ntf a opporuniy t pa ppl o a nt f nd ha he ts e r d o m t ai i f n t t o y t tlng l atrde ng lavet pr e tlf nnapa rs. he ii ke fe nyi e o oee d r o . upe i) The Cl rti dî e t d t s c e oft s m c or nd opi on a t ac m pa ng e l s r c e o end opi s hi m a um ni nd he co nyi or t t pl nt f. der o he ai if EN --CI : '-' s II t lli , l = day ofJ une,20l1. 6 e rUnied St t s i t i tJ ni t a e sr c udge 2

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.