Parker v. Astrue, No. 7:2011cv00280 - Document 17 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 2/29/12. (med)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
ra= ms OF CE U. DI M I FI S. ST. X ATROANOKE, VA FlFn L I TH E U NI N TED STA TES D I STRI CO U R T CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI I A CT RG NI ROAN OK E D I I ON V SI D AN I PA R K ER EL f DI NA M .PA R K ER ,de a e or A ce s d FEB 29 2 1 22 J A C, LEY, L ULI DU ERK ' <' ';. 4 ïg v Cas N o.7: - ve 11 c 280 Pl i if a ntf , M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI M I AEL J.A STRU E, CH Commi sone ofSoc a Secliy, si r i l trt By:Jam esC .Turk Se or U nie St e Di t c Judge ni t d at s s ri t De e nt f nda . Pli ifDa e Pake (s ai if'or$Mr Pake' br antf nil r r t ntf ç . r r' oughtt sa tononbe fofhi pl ) hi ci hal s d c ae wie Din Pa k r(; r. ak r)f r e iw o Dee d n M ih e J Asr e(t e e e s d f, a a r e ( s P re ' o r ve f f n a t c a l . tu ûh M ' t Commisone ' ' fna de ii de i hi camsf rdia lt i lr nc be tt und rTil si r' s i l cson nyng s li o sbiiy nsza e neis e te ) 1 o t So ilS c rt Ac (h ( t) ep risfldcos- to sfrml r u g n 1 fhe ca e u iy t te $ ' .Th a t i r smoi n o mmayj d me t Ac ' e e ( Nos 1 1 .A heai wa hedonFe uay7,201 andt matr aenow rpef ECF . 0, 4) rng s l br r 2, he tes r i or diposton.Fo t r s s tf rh beow,t Cour fndst tt r i s t ntale de e s ii r he ea ons e o t l he t i ha he e s ubsa i vi nc s uppori t Com m i s one ' de s o A c di y, he Com m i s one ' M o i f tng he s i r s ci i n. cor ngl t s i r s ton or SummayJ me ( No.1 i GRANTED andt Pli ifsMoton f Summay r udg nt ECF 4) s he antf i or r J udgme ( No.1 i DENI nt ECF 0) s ED. ProceduralH i torv s Thi c e ha a as e a un ualy l pr e alhit y. M r . r pr t c i l s as s m s d n us l ong oc dur s or s Pa ker o e tve y a idf Dia lt I urnceBe is($ B' i Aprl2003,algi dia lt asofJ y22, pple or s biiy ns a neft t ' n i DI ) le ng s biiy ul 1 993,a trs wasi ve i amot rvehil a ci n .Shewa i tr d f be isuntl fe he nvol d n o c e c de t s nste or neft i Se e be 30,1 pt m r 994. A c or ngl w hie i i undiput d t tM r . r r sco to ha t ke c di y, l t s s e ha s Pa ke ' ndii n d a n at n f rt wor eby 1 ur o he s 997,t Pl ntf o y s e be ft f t lmiedperod bewe n J y he ai if nl e ks ne is or he i t i t e ul 22,1 u i Se e be 30,1 993 ntl ptm r 994.Afe a i talhe rngon J 1 20 an Adm i sr tve tr n nii a i une 0, 04, nita i La J d eo t eS ca S c rt Ad nsrto (ALJ'is e aNo ieofDe iin w u g f h o il e u i miitain t ' su d y $ ) tc cso Unf r bl on A ugus 3,2004, nyi M r .Pa ke ' c a m f rdi a lt bene is avo a e t de ng s r r s l i o s biiy ft . On M a c 25, r h 2006, he SocalSe urt Admi sr i AppeasCounc lr m a d t t i c iy nitaton l i e nde he c e t t A LJbe a e t A LJ ha f l t a qua el a e st cl i a ' a l d m e a as o he c us he d aied o de t y ddr s he a m nt s lege nt l i paim e si hi de i i A fe a s e e ala i sr i he r ng w a he d on Aug t m r nt n s c s on. t r uppl m nt dm ni tatve a i s l us 21 2006, heALJis aNo i ofDec son on No , t s ued tce ii vembe 22,2006,fndi M r .Pa ke not r i ng s r r dia ed.TheAppea sCounci de e M r . r rsr q s t r vi w t ALJ' de son,a s bl l l nid s Pa ke ' e ue t o e e he S cii nd Pl i ifa al d t A LJ S de i i n t t sCou t On D e e be 11 2008,t Cour gr nt a ntf ppe e he ' c s o o hi r. cm r , he t a ed t Com m i s one ' M oton t Re a O n Se e be 27,2009,t A ppea s Counc lr m a d he s i rs i o m nd. pt m r he l i e nde t c et adif e ALJbec us t o i nalALJ' tna i la yssofM r . r r swor he as o fer nt a e he rgi S i nc a nal i s Pa ke ' k a tviy afe t al ge diabiiy ons tda ewa i ufi e t pe mi afndi t tt wor ci t tr he le d s lt e t s ns fcint o r t i ng ha he k m e t m onea y c ie i t be c i r d ts t nta g i ula tviy.' t he tr rt ra o onsde e subsa il a nf c i t ' M r . r r di d on Fe ua y 27,2009, nd he hus nd, a elPa ke , ass tt e s Pa ke e br r a r ba D ni z r w ubs iut d a a pa t i t c e. On N ove be 8,201 t ALJ i s d a de s on fndi M r . r rnot s ry n he as m r 0, he s ue ci i i ng s Pa ke dia e Th Ap e l Co n i d cie t a s mej rs ito o t ec s , kn teALJS sbld. e p as u cl e l d o su u idcin f h a e ma ig h n ' de s on fna . M r Pa ke tm e y fl d s ti t s Co t ci i i l . r r i l ie ui n hi ur . II M edi H i orv . cal st M r .Pa ke wa 45 ye r o1 whe s tl f dia lt i u a e be t i 2003, s r r s as d n he ied or s biiy ns r nc neks n ma nghe ape s ofyo era unde t rgultons R.1 ki r ron ung ge r he e ai . 383.See20C. R.j F. 4 4.5 3 .M r. r e wa trtda n s dwihTy I(u e ie da ee i 1 7 He 0 1 6 /) s Pak r s is ig o e t pe v n l) ib ts n 9 7. r m e c r c dsr fe tahit r ofco plc to r lt d t he dibe e fom t 1 dial e or e l c so y m i ai ns ea e o r a t s r he 980sa nd ea l 1 ry 990s The e pr em s i l c oni f tgue m a ai e i om ni pai ull s ons o t . s obl nc ude hr c a i / l s /ns a, nf e i n he f e /e r hyper r t i,ne opahy, pr son a a ey,a we g l s Acc di t e ts ve e ke a oss ur t de es i nd nxit nd i ht os . or ng o M r . r r s m edi a pr de s m a oft s pr e sc d have be n n elor t d by a e s Pa ke ' c l ovi r , ny he e obl m oul e m i ae bl ma nage e ofhe di be es m nt r a t . M r .Pa ke a tnde hi s hooluntlt lt gr e,b di notg a t . Shelt r s r r te d gh c i we fh ad ut d r dua e ae be mece tfe asanur e' ai Ats epoi ,ncl ng fom 1 t 1 ca riid s s de. om nt i udi r 993 o 994,s c r d f he a e or t eeedery wo e who ha Alhei ' die ei he hom e Herm ai r e i t rc r wa hr l l m n d z mers s as n r . n ol n hei a e s t pr de c pa ons p,whie o he s d d t ks s h a c ng a c ea ng. Fr Aug t o ovi om ni hi l t r i as uc s ooki nd l ni om us t i De e rof1 mtl c mbe 998,M r . r rwor d f ltme i t di nghalkic n ofRad or s Pa ke ke ul-i n he ni l/ t he f d Uni riy,pe f m i t kss h a c ng measa ce ng dihe . ve st ror ng as uc s ooki l nd lani s s M r . r rc a m sD l f om J y 22,1 s Pa ke l i B r ul 993. Tha da s w e t t podi ti t t y, he nt o he ars c pl i ng ofa pai 'll s on on t bo t ofhe s c t ofhe r g f t R . om a ni nf e i u he tom r e ond oe r i ht oo . 644. The podititobs r ed no sgnsofi e ton oruler i a hede i d t l son wihout a rs e v i nf c i c aton nd brde he e i t c plc ton. R.644. I Oc obe of 1 om i a i n t r 993,M r . r rs s Pa ke oughtt e t e f om herpodi ti tf r a m nt r a r s or a pa nf ll s on on t s e t R . i u ei he am oe. 643. The podi t i tde i t l s on,r vea i a a rs brded he e i e lng s o r s r i i lul e a i a a vi e M r .Par ra ec nda y upe fc a c r ton nd d s d s ke boutw ound c r a a opr a e s a e nd ppr i t hoe gear R.643. . On J anuary 13,1994,M rs.Par saw neur ogitDr.Roli H aw l com pl ni of ker ol s ln ey, ai ng ne k pai R.1 c n. 343. M r . r rt d D r H a ey t ts ha l tw ei s nce t a ci enta s Pa ke ol . wl ha he d os ght i he c d nd had so dt ki he i uln f oneye r R.1 t ppe a ng r ns i or a. 280,1 343.Dr Ha e not d t tM r . r r . wl y e ha s Pa ke ha a r a tve de e s on due t t au om obie a c de . She a s had t nder s ofhe l f d e ci pr s i o he t l c i nt lo e ne s r et l e c r i a r s pr uc ng pa n u i o t l f s de ofhe f ce. r .Pa ker s l f s de ow r e v c l oot , od i i p nt he e t i r a M s r ' e t houl r wa sifwihm id lm iai o m o i Sheha no de p tndon r l xesduet am id di bei s tf t l i tton f ton. d e e ete o l a tc pe i r lne opa hy. Dr Ha e notd t swoul beheped by g c r ofM r .Pa ke ' rphe a ur t . wl y e hi d l ood ontol s r rs bl s r She as ha dec e edpi prc s ns ton ove he l f tie m us e.Ot r s , ood uga . lo d r as n i k e ai r r e t rc ps cl he wie he c pl t ne ol c e m i ton w a no m a . R.1 4. r om e e ur ogi xa na i s r l 34 l t s i of1 n he prng 993,M r . r rr pore t ts ha ar e e exa t tdi not s Pa ke e td ha he d ec nt ye m ha d r ve la pr bl m s R .1 44. D r H a e sr vi w ofM r .Pa ke ' J y 1 x- a not e a ny o e . 3 . wl y' e e s r r s ul 993 r ys es s e c r i lhypol dos s R .1 44.H e ne v c om e v ca or i . 3 r r e onduc i s udi s ton t es howed a m id di be i l a tc dit la sa xona pe i r lne opahy. R.1 l rphe a ur t 345.Dr Ha e c ude t tM r .Pa ke ha al f . wly oncl d ha s r r d e t (6- pai uls ns r pos-r um ai r diul t c us d by t mot ve cl a i n a a 2 7 nf e o y tta tc a c opahy a e he or hi e cc de t nd m idand a ympt tcunde l ng s l s oma i ryi ymm ercdibe i s ns y a ti a tc e or xona dit lperphe al l sa i r neur pa hy. R.1 o t 345. O n J anua y 25,1 r 994, r . r r sx- a a M Rlofhe c r c ls ne M s Pa ke ' r ys nd r e vi a pi s howe mid na r ng oft lf ne a f a i a no e de eofdic he niton orot r d l rowi he e t ur l or m na nd vi nc s r ai he sgnii a a i tc nt bnor alt R .1 m iy. 278. 11 St 1. andard ofR e ew vi l a yi f rdia lt be ft , cli a t be r t bur ofpr ng t ts i n ppl ng o s biiy ne is a am n a s he den ovi ha he s unde adia lt Bl oc v Rihar on,483F. 773,775( hCi.1 .Thesa r f r sbiiy. al k . c ds 2d 4t r 972) tndad or di a lt i s rc . D i a lt i d i d ast ç na lt t e ge i a s t nta gai ul s biiy s ti t s biiy s efne he i biiy o nga n ny ubs a i l nf i aci t byr a o ofa m e c l dee mi bl physc lorme a i par ntwhi h c n be tviy esn ny dialy t r na e ia nt l m ime c a e xpec e t r ul i dea h o w hi h ha l s e orc n be e c e t l tf a con i t d o es t n t r c s a t d a xpe t d o as or tnuouspe i rod ofno l st n 1 monhs' 42U. C.j423( ( ( .A cama mus s tsyt t es ha 2 t .' S. d)2)A) li nt t aif he Com miso t the ç s i ner ha r s i lorm e t li im e ori nnen sa e ofs h s vert t t physca n a mpar nt mpai t r uc e iy ha (l i notonl una et dohe prviuswor butc nnotco i rng g r age e ai a she s y bl o r e o k a , nsde i hel , duc ton, nd w or e r e e, nga i a ot r ki ofs t nta ga nf wor w hi e s si t k xpe i nc e ge n ny he nd ubs a i l i ul k ch xi t n he nai le onomy .... I j423( ()A) tona c 'd ' d)2 ( . l a s s ng D I c a m s t Com m i sone a i s a fve- t p s que i li r The n s es i B l i , he s i r pple i s e e nta nquiy. Co si n rc n ie swh te acama t ( )h swo k dd rngt ealg dp ro o mmiso e o sd r eh r li n : 1 a r e u i h l e eid f e dia lt ( ha as veei ime ;( ha ac tont tme t o e l t s rt ofa sbiiy; 2) s e r mpar nt 3) s ondii ha es r quas he eveiy lse i i nt ( coul rt nt he pa trlva wo k;a ( i not whehe s c d itd mpanne ;4) d eur o r s ee nt r nd 5) f , t r he oul p ro oh rwo kp e e ti ten to a e o o .S e2 C. R. j4 4 1 2 ()4 .I ii e fnn t e r r s n n h ain l c n my e 0 F. j 0 .5 0 a( ) f t s de e mi a a poi i t fve se a ysst tt cli a i notdia e t i uiy t r ned t ny nt n he i -t p nal i ha he am nt s s bl d, he nq r i dit yc as .1L Ac or Fikev Asr , 1 - 335,201 W L 291 a * ( hCi. mme ael e es 6 c d s . tue No. 1 1 2 82, t 2 4t r J n. 201 .Thef t a ffhse oft i r rquiea a s s ntoft cai nts a 6, 2) ourh nd it tps he nquiy e r n sesme he l ma ' ResdualFunci Ca iy(ù ',whihi t nc i tonal pact C RFC') c s he ompa e wiht physc la me a r d t he ia nd ntl de a oft c ai ants pa tr e ntw or a ofo he w o k pr s n i t na i m nds he l m ' s el va k nd t r r e e t n he tonale onom y. c Mc ai v Sc k ,71 F. 866,869(t Ci.1 . L n . hweier 5 2d 4h r 983) Thi Cour ' r vi w i lm ied t de e m i ng whe he t r i s t nta e de e i t s ts e e s i t o t r ni t r he e s ubs a i l vi nc n he rc dt s e or o uppor t Comm isone ' fndi off c a whehe t c r c l w wasa id. t he s i rs i ngs a t nd t r he or e t a pple 4 U. C. 4 5 g .Ac o dn l , rve ngc u t yn t ub ttt is u g n frt a o 2 S. j 0 () c r ig y a e iwi o r ma o s si e t j d me t o h t f u t Com m i s one ,buti t a m us def rt t Co m i s o r sde e m i tons i t y ar he si r ns e d t e o he m s i ne ' t r na i f he e s upporedby s tnta e de e.Ha v Sulian 907F. 1 1 ( hCi.1 ) t ubsa il vi nc ys . lv , 2d 453, 456 4t r 990 . Subsa ile de i nota ta g orc i r bl n tnta vi nce s d r e onsde a e mountofe de ,' e c v Unde wooJ l vi nce'Pir e . r 487U. 5 565( 988,buti S et name es nil ofe de eghoughls wha l s S. 52, 1 ) s' mor ha r citla vi nc t ome tes t aprpondea ,' Jwlv Celbrz e 3 F. 6 642( h Ci.l .l ot rwor , han e rnce'f '. e ez , 68 2d 40, 4t r 966) n he ds s t n i e de ei C uch r lva e de easar s na em i mi hta e a ade t t ubsa tal vi nc s t s ee nt vi nc ea o bl nd g cc pt s quae o s ppo tac l i ' Rihar s v. r e,402U. 38 401( 971 . u r oncuson. c d on Pe als ' S. 9, 1 ) IV. Di scussi on Ta ngi o ac ountm e c lr or , xper tsi ony, t t si ony ofM r . ki nt c di a ec ds e t e tm and he e tm s Pa ke ' f miy a finds t ALJf r rs a l nd re , he ound t tM r . r rha S lg 'r titonsi ha s Pake d l i ht' esrc i n s pe f mi daiy lvi aci te ,mait i ng s i lf to ng,a s t i ng û once ta i ror ng l i ng tviis n ani oc a unc ini nd usani i c n r ton, pe s s e e,orpa e.' R .1 1. The ALJ f t rf r i t nc c ' 51 urhe ound t ta m e a f tona lm ia i n w a ha ny nt l unc i l i t to s no s ve e a t tt r c d di no r fec a r pea e e s esofde e i a i or n- e r , nd ha he e or d t e l t ny e t d pi od t r or ton de ompe a i i wor orwor lke s ti .R.1 1 2.No t e s be a et ALJ c ns ton n k k-i e tngs 51 -1 ne hels , c us he f oundt tM r .Pa ke ha ls ver physc i r nt'durng t r l va tm epe i t ha s r r d te e ial mpaime s' i he e e nt i rod,he ALJco i d he evauai n t de em i whehe s c d ha pe f m e a ofhe pas ntnue r l to o t r ne t r he oul ve ror d ny r t r l van wor o a o he w or e s i i s gnii an num be s i t na i lec e e t k r ny t r k xitng n i tc t r n he tona onom y. R . 1 2. W hie t ALJde e ne t tM r .Par rsRFC fom J y 2 1 t Se e be 30, 51 l he t nni d ha s ke ' ' r ul 2, 993 o ptm r 1 4, oul ha pr c ude he f o pe f m i he pa tr l va w or s de e m i d t t 99 w d ve e l d r r m r or ng r s e e nt k, he t r ne ha M r . r rc dpe f r lghtwor R.1 s Pa ke oul ro m i k. 515.Ac or ngl t ALJc ude M r . r r c di y,he oncl d s Pa ke wasnotdiabld fom J y 1 t Se e r1 4. s e r ul 993 o pt mbe 99 M r Pake aguest ALJma t sgniia er swhihwarnts , r rr he de wo i fc nt ror c ra ummayj me r udg nt i hi f vo . Fi s , c ai s t A LJ e r d by dicou i t t s i o oft t e tng n s a r r t he l m , he re s ntng he e tm ny he r a i phys c a a r l ng on t t tm ony ofa m edi a e r , e uli i a i or ec es a i he i i n nd e yi he es i c l xpe t r s tng n n nc r t t bls d ons td t ofdi a lt Se ond, con e t tM r . r rdi no ha t RFC t pe f m e ae s biiy. c he t nds ha s Pa ke d t ve he o r or t wo kie tte b teALJ Th Co r a d e s se c o te eo j cin i tr he r d n i d y h i . e u t d rs e a h f h s b e to s n un. A . The A LJ A ppled t C orrectLaw i I erri M rs.Parker' O nsetD at of i he n nf ng s e Di lt sabiiy Pli ifa guest tt ALJ Sde son t tM r . r rwa notdia ed wast r s t antf r ha he ' cii ha s Pa ke s s bl he e ul ofhe m ipl c d r la e on t t s i on ofm edi a e rs a t tt A LJ i t ad s d r s a e e i nc he e tm y c l xpe t nd ha he ns e houl ha i e r d t ons tda e fom t t s i o ofDr H a l y a M r .Pa ke ' f m iy a ve nf r e he e t r he e tm ny . w e nd s r r s a l nd fi nds Pl n ifsa gum e i i ore ta amat roflw. I deenni ng t ons tdaeof re . aitf r nt s nc r c s te a n t ni he e t dia lt m a f t sa e e l td t t ri udi t i vi ' al ga i t wor s biiy, ny acor r vauae ogehe ncl ng he ndi duals le ton, he k 20, te 1 nd : e s biiy, 983 hi t y, nd t m edi ale de e. SSR 83- Til s 1 a X V I Ons tofD i a lt 1 W L s or a he c vi nc 31 249. l de e m i ng t da e ofons tofdi a lt t da e alege by t i vi ls d be n t r ni he t e s biiy, he t l d he ndi dua houl us d i i i c it ntwih al t e de a ia e. SSR 83- s a est t ALJ s d fr t e f t s ons s e t 1 he vi nce va l bl 20 t t hat he houl is l k t t fl be or i e e esa em a oo o he ie f e nf r nc r de.l r as bl i e e sc l bemadefom t f e ona e nf r nce amot r he e de e i t f l ,t n i m a be nec s r t e or ot r s ce ofdoc e a i 1 vi nc n he ie he t y es a y o xpl e he our s um nt ton. d. W he t m edi alorwor evi nce i no c it ntw ih t a l ga i a tona de op e n he c k de s t ons s e t he le ton, ddii l vel m nt ma bene dedt r c l t dicr pa y.Be us t sc s i ve sowl pr e sve y e o e oncie he s e nc ca e hi a e nvol s l y ogr s i i ime s t r i no pr c s ons tdaer or d i t medialr cor . The ef e,i wa mpar nt , he e s e ie e t ec de n he c e ds r or t s ne es a y f t ALJt i e t ons tda eofdia lt fo t m e c la ot re de e c s r or he o nf r he e t s biiy r m he di a nd he vi nc t tde c i s t hi t y a s pt m ol oft di e s pr s . I To m a t s ha s rbe he s or nd ym o ogy he s a e oce s d. ke he e i e e e ,SSR 83- r uie t A LJt tr tca lon t s r i e ofa m e ca ad s . Fi ly, nf r nc s 20 eq r s he o is l he e v c s di l vior na l t o e da e m us be txed ba e on t f t a c n ne rbe i ons s en w ih t m edi a he ns t t t i sd he ac s nd a ve nc i t t t he cl e de e ofr c d. f vi nc e or #. The A LJ f l e t e r quie e sa c le on t s r c ofm e ca e rs Dr olow d hes e r m nt nd a l d he e vi es di l xpe t . W adW .Stve C& .St ns' a Dr Chare H. lnd(t . lnd')t a ss he i r e ns Dr eve ' nd , ls Hola tDr Hola ' o sit r n ) i er i t ons dat ofM rs.Par s di lt The A LJ' concl i reled i parton D r nf rng he et e ker' sabiiy. S us on i n . H ola st s i ony t tbas d on t e de e he c d notde e ne t tM r .Pa ke ha a l nd' e tm ha e he vi nc oul t nni ha s r r d ts ve e'me a i imen durng t r lva ttm epe i R.1 te r ' nt l mpa r t i he ee n i rod. 586. Addii ly,Dr St ve tona l . e ns opi t tM r .Pa kerw a c r a nl di a e by 1 ned ha s r s e t i y s bl d 997. R .1 93. Buthe a s t s ii d t tafe 5 l o e tf e ha t r r viwi t e de e fom J yof19 t ough Septmbe of1 4, r .Pa ke ' he lh was e e ng he vi nc , r ul 93 hr e r 99 M s r rs at on t ve ge ofde e i a i n d t he di be es buts w a sili a f tona s a e a no he r t ror t o ue o r a t , he s tl n unc i l t t nd t di a e R.1 -99. Dr St ve c l s bl d. 598 . e ns onc uded t tM r . r r s a om obie a i nti 1 ha s Pa ke ' ut l cc de n 993 di notc us he t e re e as ve ea oun ofpan orf tona lmia i . R.1 d a e r o xpe i nc e r m t i unci l i t tons 596.Dr . St vens t s i ony i cons s e w ih Dr H a l y' m e c r por sa t tm e t tM r . r r s e ' e tm s i t nt t . w e s di al e t t he i ha s Pa ke ' ne ol i e m i ton w asnonnalo he t n s et nde s ove he ce v ca s ne,a s if ur og c xa na i t r ha om e nw s r r r i l pi tf s de , nd t a e ofde p t ndon r fexe aswelast M Rla x-a fom J nua y of houl r a he bs nce e e el s l he nd r ys r a r 1 t ts 994 ha howe onl m id na r ng oft l tne a f n i lwih no e de eofdic d y l rowi he ef ur l or m na t vi nc s he ni ton orot rs gnii a a r ai he i t c nt bnonua iy. R .1 lt 344. Ther f e, r St vens a Dr H ola s e or D . e ' nd . l nd' tsi etmonywa c itntwiht r or asawhol.Se 20C. R.j 4.527( ( ( a s onsse t he ec d e e F. 40 1 d)4) As ge r m a t r Co m i s one w ilgi m or wei tt m edi alopi o t ta e c it ntw ih ne al te , m s i r l ve e gh o c ni ns ha r ons s e t t r or a awhol) he ec d s e. The A LJ a s c i r d t t s i o ofM r . r r s f m iy a f i nds M r Pa ke ' l o ons de e he e tm ny s Pa ke ' a l nd r e . . r r s t tm ony c r obor t t t s i ony ofD r St ve t tPl ntf w asc bl ofpe f m i a esi o r a ed he e tm . e ns ha ai i f apa e r or ng t l s a lm ied r nge oflghtw or durng t tm e perod i que ton. M r Pa ke ' t tm ony ea t i t a i k i he i i n si . r r s es i a bouthi w ie' c r oft t e e de l w om e i he ho e he e hus a m i ge tng m a red, s f s a e he hr e l ry n n r m , r nt i s n ti ri he pa tc pa i i va a i i udi t i ho y oo a c m pi a ot rs i r ri i ton n c tons ncl ng he r ne m n nd a ng, nd he oc al a tviis s c i te , upporst fndi t tM r . r rwa no dia e a t tmeofhe dae ls t he i ng ha s Pa ke s t s bld t he i r t at i ur I i t e t tt t tm ony ofM r . r ra he f i ns ed. t s nz ha he es i s Pa ke nd r rendsw asnote tr l c i t nt n i e y onss e w ih t A LJ' fndi Forexnm pl Edih Hughest tfed t she knew M r Par i 1995, t he S i ng. e, t esi i hat s. ker n a asoft tda e M r . r w a una e t s a f m or t n a s t i e a r pe t dl nd ha t , s Pa ker s bl o t nd or e ha hor tm nd e a e y ne dt 1edown.R.151 ede o i 3.Thi t tmony c d a gua y s s esi oul r bl uppor t Pli tf sc e i t he a n if ontnton t tM r . r rw asdi a e durng t r l nttm e pe i d. Buti i nott sCour ' r e t ha s Pa ke s bl d i he e eva i ro ts hi ts ol o ( e ihc n lci e ie c , k c e iii d tnnn to s o s b t ue(t) u g n fr C weg o fit vd n e ma e r dblt ee iain , r u si t is j d me t o r ng y t t toft a nc ' Walsv Bar har, F. 28 290(t Ci. ha he ge y. ' l . n t296 3d 7, 4h r 2002)( tngMa r v quoi sto . A # l2 0F.d 1 ,1 6( t Ci. 0 ) (n ema q oainmakso te ) Th Co r fn s p , 7 3 71 7 4h r 2 01) itl l u tto r mitd . e u ti d t tt ALJ c r ty c pled w ih SSR 83- i i e ng t ons tda e ofM r . r r s ha he or ec l om i t 20 n nf ni he e t s Pa ke ' di a lt s biiy. B.The e i Subs antalEvi ncet Supportt ALJ' Dec s o t G i Lit e r s t i de o he S i i n o ve t l W ei t D r.H aw l y' O pi on ght o e s ni M r Pa ke ar s t tt A LJ e r d i notgi ng c r lng w e g t D r Hawl y' . r r gue ha he re n vi ontoli i ht o . e s 2004 l te s m a i ng Pa ke ' m e ca r or f om 1 e t r um rzi r r s di l ec ds r 993- 994. Af e r e i t r or 1 t r evi w ng he ec d, t Co tfndst tt A LJ Sdec son nott g ve c t oli wei t Dr H a l s2004 he ur i ha he ' ii o i on r lng ght o . w ey' c rs or e ponde e wass nc uppored by s t nta e de e. t ubs a i l vi nc M r Pmke con e t tt ALJe r d i d s untngt opi on ofM r . r r s . r t nds ha he re n ico i he ni s Pa ke ' te tng phys c an,Dr H a l y,a i t d r l ng t o hea l on t opi on oft c uli rai ii . w e nd nsea e yi o viy he ni he ons tng e r , r St ve . M r Pa ke t s s ci le e i n t t f l i t xtoft ALJ' xpe t D . e ns . r r ake pe a xc pto o he olow ng e he S OP1 0n: n1 Theunde sgne m us c i rt pos i ebis st tate tng physcin m a brng t ri d t onsde he sbl a e ha r a i ia y i o adia lt e ua i Thepai ntsr gulrphysca m a wa t do af vo f a fi nd s biiy val ton. te ' e a i in y nt o a r or re a cle ,a s t t ea i phys c a m a t qui kl f nd di a lt A ddii ly, he nd i nt nd o he r tng i i n y oo c y i s biiy. tona l t cl i a ' r gul rphys c a m a nota pr i t how t pa i nt sca e c pa e t ot r a m nts e a ii n y p ec a e he te ' s om r s o he sm iarcases. i l R .15 M r Pa ke a guest tt s s a e e ti r pr s nt tve oft A LJ S e r i di c i 08. . r r r ha hi t t m n s e e e a i he ' r or n s ountng D r Ha l sopi on. I s . w ey' ni n uppor oft sa g e ,he r le upo H al v As r e, o. 0 c t hi r um nt e is n l . t u N 7: 7- v- 005 2008W L 5 720( . Va. c. ,2008) whe eaMagitaeJ 90, 455 W D. De 31 , r srt udgei t sDitit n hi src de i d sm ia l ng ge. H e e,lke i H al,i he e i no a s e ofe de ... o s es bi s r de i l r a ua r i n l û r s t hr d t vi nce t ugg t a . . . a a s h s gesi i co e ey unf nd ny uc ug ton s mplt l ounde ' f a # The ALJ' uns d. #. t 4. ' S uppore td s c a i t tDr H a l a l r d pr e s ona , a bi s m a notha bee t bes pe ul ton ha . w ey, ea ne of s i l w s a ed y ve n he t c oc o wo ds a i a pe r t c s a p rin o Dr Ha e ' j d me ta dc a a tr h t h ie f r , s t p a s o a t s eso s n . wly s u g n n h r ce t a c nnotbe s a uppored by t r c d. H o e r i H al, he M a s r t J t he e or w ve , n l t git a e udge f ound t t A LJ hat he ha dic t d t tea i physca st tmony s ey o t ba i oft ph i a si e il d s oun e he r tng iin' esi oll n he ss he yscin' t nta pot bi e .' d. He e des t he unf tnaesa e nt t r i a pl e de i t r co d t as s'1 r , pie r oru t tt me , he e s m e vi nce n he e r o s uppor t ALJ Sdecson t gi lmie wei t Dr Ha e sopi on. t he ' ii o ve i t d ght o . wly' ni M r Pa ke i co r c t tt opi o ofa t e tng physc a i or narl e il d t m o e . r r s r e t ha he ni n r ai i i n s di iy ntte o r wei t nt tofanon-r tngphyscin.20C. R. 404.5 d)2) Addii l whee ghtha ha teai ia F. j 1 27( ( . tonaly, r t teai physca sopi on i t l-uppore by me c l a ce a e ci c a he r tng i in' ni s t ls we td di aly c pt bl lnial nd lbor t y dignosi t chni a a or a tc e quesa i noti onsse twih t o he s t nta e de e i nd s nc it n t he t r ubsa il vi nc n ghe c er c d,'twilbegi c r lngweg .f . TheALJSevauatonofme c t l as e or 'i l ven ontoli iht # ' l i dial o ni m us t ke i o ac ount i e ala, he he t y a e w e ls pi ons t a nt c , nt r i w t r he r l- uppo t d and ho c i t nt re w onss e t yaewiht ot e de ei t rco d.Hi sv Bar t 453F. 559,563( hCi. he r t he her vi nc n he e r ne . nhar, 3d 4t r 2006 .I a opi oni nots ) f n ni s upporedbyt medc le de eori ot r s i onsse wih t he ia vi nc s hewie nc itnt t t rc d,tma begi n t i tc ntyls weg . Cr gv.Chare ,76F.d 58 590( h he e or i y ve t gnii a l e s iht' ai s ' tr 3 5, 4t Ci.1 ) SeealoHu e v Sulian,993F. 31 35( hCi.1 ( c i ( t LJ r 996 . s ntr . lv 2d , 4t r 992) per uram) An W ma c y hoos t gi l s w e ghtt t t s i ony ofa te i phys ci n i t r i pe s i e o ve es i o he e tm r atng i a f he e s r uasve c taye de e'. Her,t ALJpr ryde lne t gi c r lngweghtt Dr onrr vi nc ') e he ope l ci d o ve ontoli i o . Ha l y' 2004 l te bec us i i nots ppo t d by o he e denc i t r or W her ,a he e we s et r a e t s u re t r vi e n he ec d. e s r, t ALJ de e m i st tt t e tng phys c a s opi on i nott be a cor d co r lng w e g , he t r ne ha he r a i i i n' ni s o c de ntoli i ht s mus l kt t f l ngt deemi how muc weg t a or i:( )t lngt oft he t oo o he olowi o tr ne h iht o cc d t 1 he e h he teame trltons p a t feque yofe mi ton;( t naur ande e oft r t n eai hi nd he r nc xa nai 2) he t e xtnt he 10 teamentrl i hi ( t e e t whiht te tngphyscin' opi oni s r t eatons p; 3) he xtnt o c he rai i a s ni s uppore by td o j cieme ia e ie c ' 4 t ee e tt wh c t ete tn p y iin' o i o i c n itn b e tv dc l vd n e ( ) h xtn o ih h raig h sca s pnin s o sse t , wiht eoh re ie ei t er c r ' 5 t ep y iin ss e il , n ( )o h rfco ss c a t h te vd nc n h e o d ( ) h h sca ' p cat a d 6 t e a t r u h s , y' t te i phys ci n' f m ii rt w ih ot ri or a i i t c ai a ' ca e r o d a t he r atng i a s a la iy t he nf m ton n he l m nt s s ec r nd he t e tng phys c a sunde sandi ofSoc a Se urt di a lt pr a sand t re de i r rai i i n' r t ng i l c iy s biiy ogr m hei vi nta y r q rme t.I j4 4.5 () Ac o d Wif r v Ch tr 91 F.u p. 98 4 ( D. . e uie n s d 0 1 27d ; c r n o d . ae , 7 s p 3 , 01 E. Va 1 . 996) Dr H a l s2004 opi on s a ed t tw he he s w M r .Pa ke on J nua y 1 1 . w ey' ni t t ha n a s r r a r 3, 994, Cs w a t aly a pe m ane l di a e f a ga nf em pl e .... tc a l bec us 'he s ot l nd r nty s bl d or ny i ul oym nt pari ul ry a e o h rs v r dprs in' R. 2 5(mp a i a d d .Asa i ta matr t ALJp o el f e e ee e eso . 1 7 e h ss d e ) ' n ni l te,he i r p ry deci t r l on Dr Ha e s2004 lgalc ncuson whe he ornota cai ti dia e lned o ey . wly' e o l i t r l man s s bld wihi t mea ngoft Ac i adeemi to r e v t t Commisone .20 C. R.j t n he ni he t s tr nain esr ed o he si r F. 404.5274 1 $. Sec ond,Dr Ha ey' 200 opi on,wrte mor t n ade deafe hi clni a . wl s 4 ni itn e ha ca tr s i c l e ua i o M r . r r a val ton f s Pa ke , ppea s i ons s e w ih hi own m e ca t ndi m a o t da e r nc it nt t s di l i ngs de n he t ofhe e ua i i 1 r val ton n 994.W hie i hi 200 lte , ati t d pa tofM r . r r sdia lt l n s 4 e tr he trbu e r s Pa ke ' s biiy t a pai ulLef C6- Se or Pos Tr u a i Ra cul t i 199 D r H a l y co l d o nf t 7 ns y t a m tc di opa hy, n 4, . w e nc ude t tt s r di opa hy w asonl S id.' l a J nua y 1 4 l te t M r . ke ,D r Ha l ha hi a cul t y d l ' n a r 99 e t r o s Par r . w ey m wr e: C ag ee w ih D r Le t tyou a e s f rng f om a r c i de es i due t your ot ( r I t . e ha r uf e i r ea tve pr s on o a om o l a i nt It nk t ti hasca ed yourw e ghtl s l s o a tt f rf a ut bie cc de . hi ha t us i os , os f ppe ie o ood nd s and consri i ofyournonnali er t ' R .l344. To be s e, depr si i a serous ex, t cton nt es s.' 1 ur es on s i 'ç ctvede es i i ge aly atansentcondii pr ci t t d by a sr sf lf eventorot ç Rea i pr son s ner l r i ton e pia e tes ul ie her e r nme t l a t r' Wal v Asr e 5 F.d 1 48,1 4n. ( 0hCi. 00 ( iai o te ) nvio n a f co . ' l . tu , 61 3 0 05 4 1 t r 2 9) ctton mitd . m e ca c di l once n. Butt ALJc d ha pr pe l c ncude t tDr Ha e s2004 r he oul ve o ry o l d ha . wly' concl i ofçsever depr si 'i i uson ç e es on' s nconsit w ih t ot evi s ent t he her dence i t r d,es aly n he ecor peci l snc Dr Ha ey di nott r t de es i S e r ' i hi 1 4 r por a t r i no ot r i e . wl d e m he pr son ç ve e' n s 99 e t nd he e s s he e de t s por s h a fndi vi nce o up t uc i ng. M or ove ,heALJdi t keM r . r rsde e so i t a counti he de ii l e rt d a s Pa ke ' pr s i n n o c n r c son. n f c , he A LJ f und dt tt c ai a ha m e ca l de e m i d m e a i pai nt durng t a tt o sha he l m nt d di ly t r ne nt l m nne s i he pe i ofJ y 1 tlough herdae ls i ur d,whi h c r s rod ul 993 lr t a t ns e c ore ponde t s c i 1 04 d o e tons 2. (fe tv d s r es a d 1 06(n eyr ltdds r es o t eLitn o l ar nsi efc afcie io d r) n 2. a xit eae io d r) f h sig f mp ime t n fe t a t ttme. R.1 08( tha i ' ' 5 empha i omit .Addii l t ALJ abetrl tnty,f ndt t ss ted) tonaly,he , l i euca l ou ha M r .Pa ke ha pr ded s f c e m e c ldocu e a i t i c t t pe s s e ofa s r r d ovi ufi i nt di a m nt ton o ndi a e he r it nce depr s i s om e unde bot Sec i n 1 04 a Se to 1 06. The i s i diput i e sve yndr r h t o 2. nd c i n 2. s ue n s e s whe he t tde e son r nde ed M r .Pa ke dia e wihi t m e ni oft Ac . t r ha pr s i e r s r r s bld t n he a ng he t A de e sve afec i di or rm e t t r uiie l velofs ve iy f di a lt whe e i pr s i f tve s de e s he eq st e e r t or s biiy r t r uls i a l a tt o oft f l i es t n t e s w he olow ng: 1 M a ke r ti ton ofa tvii ofda l lvi or . r d esr c i c i tes iy i ng; 2.M a ke difc tesi m ant i ng s i f nci ng'o r d fi uli n i ani ocal u toni , r 3.D e i i nc e ofc en r ton, r it nc orpa r s tng i f eq ntf iur t fc e i s onc t a i pe s s e e ce e uli n r ue a l e o c eets i atmeyma r(nwor s ti orele e;or omplt a ks n i l nne i k etngs s wherl 4.Re a e e s s ofde e i a i n orde m pe a i i wor orw or lke s ti pe t d piode t ror to co ns ton n k k- i e tngs whi h c us t i vi c a e he ndi dualt w ihdr w f o t tst ton ort e o t a r m ha iua i o xpere e e ba i i nce xac r ton o sg a s mp o ( ihma icu ed tro aino a p iebe a o s. f ins nd y t ms whc y n ld eeirto f da tv h vir) 20C. R. .404,s .P,a 1j 1 0 (1 .A de esi anxit r lt dior r F. pt ubpt pp. 2.4 993) pr sve ey-eaed s de , m ea nwhie, ons iut a di a lt i i m e t one oft afec i di or rr r m e t o l c tt es s biiy f t e s he f tve s de equie n s r rs t (nc eei biiyt f toni pe ntyouti t aeaofone' home' 1 j euls t omplt na lt o unci nde nde l sde he r i s .' d. 12. 06. 12 I dee m i ngt s ve iy ofM r . r rsme ala l nt durngt tm epe i i n tr ni he e rt s Pa ke ' nt ime s i he i rod n quesi t A LJeva ua ed a 1t e de e bef r he ,i l ng Dr H a l y' not s M r . ton, he l t 1 he vi nc o e r nc udi . w e s e, s Pa ke ' own r pons st t Soc a Se urt d s lt que tol ie,t e e ofhe s il r rs es e o he i l c iy iabiiy si ma r he xt nt r oca ac i tesdurng a a t r e nttm e pe i a t ext ntofhe oc pa i la lte . tvii i nd her he el va i rod, nd he e r cu tona biii s M or ove ,alhough t A LJa e r t he cknow l dge t tt r w a s m e e de e i t r c d ofM r e d ha he e s o vi nc n he e or s. Pa ke ' s e p pr e s f tgue, nd w e g l sdurng t r l va tm e perod,t A LJ f nd r r s l e obl m , a i a i ht os i he e e nt i i he ou no clni le de e t tt e pr e s w e e c us d by a m en a il s R .1511. A st A LJ i ca vi nc ha hes obl m r a e t l lnes . he corecl r ogni d,lgj is i notwhehe t cai ntha panands omsdurngt r ty ec ze tthe sue s t r he l ma d i ympt i he p ro u d ra j d c to b t eh rh rp i a fn to a l tto swees s v r a t b e id n e du iain, u wh t e e an nd u cin l i ain r o e ee s o e mi di a i ' R.1 3. s blng-' 51 M r .Pa ke ' podi t i tnot d t tprort Se e be 20,1 s r rs a r s e ha i o pt m r 994, c pl i sw e e her om a nt r r l tve y m i r R .1 4. On J nua y 1 1 e a i l no . 27 a r 3, 994,Dr H a e c m e e on he phys ca . wl y om nt d r i l e m i ton t tPl i tf had r a tve de es i f om t ac i nt .1 xa na i ha a n if e ci pr s on r he c de .R 343-44. D r H a l y . we not alc ofdee tndon r fe s butc l ed a k pe e lxe , oncudedt tt swa t r ul ofad id d a tc ha hi s he es t l l i bei m ne opa hy' whi h c d be tea ed by s mpl ke pi co r ofM r . r r' bl s r R . ur t ' c oul r t i y e ng nt ol s Pa ke s ood uga . Hedi no a d t ppea ove l c e ed a tM r . r rsc ton. TheALJdic e r ry onc m bou s Pa ke ' ondii s ount d Dr Ha e s2004 di nosst tM r .Pa kerwa dia e durngt r e nttm epe i d . wly' ag i ha s r s s bld i he elva i ro i r i ul l be a e ofhe s ve e de e s on' be a e i w a i ons s e w ih t ot r t tc ary c us pa r e r pr s i ' c us t s nc it nt t he he e i e c i t erc r .R.1 0 Th ALJddn terb ra o a l rj ci ate tngs u c vd n e n h e od 5 8. e i o r y e s n by ee t ng r ai o re opi on s ni ubmitd a o m ael tn yea sahe t pl i ifsda el ti ur d, r t r was te ppr xi t y e r r he antf t as ns e whe e he e n o j cieme ia e d n et a i ar n so sr e b t ete tn s u c e se p irt o be tv dc l vie c h t mp ime t b e v d y h r aig o re xitd ro o t dael ti ur Se gene al John onv Bar t 434F. 650, he t as ns ed. e rl y s . nhar, 3d 656-57( h Ci.2005 4t r ) (ç t t houghDr Str i notate tngphysca t ALJpr rya r dhi o ni sgniian Al . ars rai iin,he opel wade s pi on i fc t 13 weg t c us Dr S art o o g l rv e dJ h s n' me ia r c r s t eo j cieme ia ih be a e . tr h r u hy e iwe o n o s d c l e o d ,h b e tv dc l evi nc s de e uppor sD r St r ' c us on,a hi o ni i c it ntw ih t o he m e c l t . a r s oncl i nd s pi on s ons s e t he t r di a 0pilons'. r1 ' - ) A c or ng y,t Cour tnds t tt r i s t nta e de e t s c di l he ti ha he e s ubsa i l vi nc o uppor t A LJ S t he ' t ndi t tM r .Par rdi no ha a pr um ptve di a lt unde St p Thr oft eva ua i i ng ha s ke d t ve es i s biiy r e ee he l ton pr s . Thei uiy doesnotso t r ,howe r be a et ALJdee mi dt tM r .Pa ke oce s nq r t p he e ve , c us he tr ne ha s r r had s ve ephys c li pai nt durng t r e ntpe i t tneiherm e nore l d a ls e e r i a m nue s i he el va r od ha t t qua e it d i pa nne . A c or ng y,t A LJ m oved o t s e f a fve oft e l ton. AtSt p m i nt c di l he n o t ps our nd i he va ua i e Fou , heALJdee nedt tM r Pa ke ' RFC d i t r l va tm epe i woul notha rt tnni ha s. r rs urng he e e nt i rod d ve pe m it d he t pe f r te r o r onn a t tr l va w o k. The ALJ S i r t n s f e t St p Fi , ny t pas e e nt r ' ' ' nquiy he hi t d o e ve wh r s es ug t od tr n wh te j b e se i sg i c n n mb r i ten to l ee h o h t eemie eh r o s xitd n inf a t u e s n h aina i ec no d i t r e o my urng he elvantpe i whi h M r .Pa kerc d ha pe f rod c s r oul ve r onned i lg ofher n i ht RFC , a ,e a i a e r e e. ge duc ton, nd xpe i nc 2 C. Subst i Evi ant al dence Support t ALJ' R FC D et i i and C oncl i s he S erm naton us on t M rs Parker W as N otDi abl hat . s ed The A LJcons de e t e de e asa w hol mz f und t tdurng t pe i f om J y i r d he vi nc e d o ha i he r od r ul 22,1 tz ough Se e be 30,1 993 lr pt m r 994,M r . r rr t ne t RFC t lf a orc r up t 20 s Pa ke e ai d he o i t nd/ ar y o poundsoc sonal a 1 poundsfe nty. Thevoc tona e r c r c e i d Pl n ifs ca i ly nd 0 r que l ai l xpe t ha a t rze aitf p s wo ka aCe tfe Nu sn Asitn a asmis ild me im e e t n l o a ac s e at r s riid rig ssa t s e -k l e du x ri a j b; s ahir o a a s m is le lg w or a c s e - kil d, i ht k nd onve e e sor s r s a a s le lghtw o k;he w o k ni nc t e upe vi or s kil d, i r r r i t U ni r iy kic n a uns le m e u wor s m ia t s m is led,lg e r i l n he ve s t t he s kil d, di m k i l r o e - kil i ht xe tona w or R.15l5. Gi ng M rs.Par t beneftoft doubt t A LJ concl k. vi ker he i he , he uded t herR FC hat 2Atsep fve oft s t i he equentale uaton, t eb de o s o ngta t r weej bsi t enaina i val i h ur n f h wi h t hee r o n h t l o e conomy t tt cai antcoul havere ona y peror e s fst t Com mi soner ha he l m d as bl f m d hit o he si . 14 durng t pe i ofJ y 22,1 t Se t mbe 30,1 i he rod ul 993 o p e r 994,woul havepr l d ecuded he fom rr per o m i he pas r l va w or How e r t ALJ f f r ng r t e e nt k. ve , he ound t tt tt r w a a s gnii a ha ha he e s i fc nt n mb ro j b i tenai n l c n myta Mr. ak rc ul h v pef r d tkngit u e f o s n h to a e o o h t s P re o d a e ro me ,a i n o ac ounthe m e c ly de em i bl i im e t ,f tona lm ia i ,a e a i a c r di al t r na e mpar n s unc i l i ttons ge, duc ton, nd w or e r e e. k xpe i nc Pl ntf a g t tt A LJ ha no ba i f fndi t tM r . r rc d pe f r ai if r ues ha he d s s or i ng ha s Pa ke oul r o m ot rwor a t llght'e ri na l li al ofhe lmiai we ec i r d.Thetna he k t he ti ' xe to l eve f l r i t tons r onsde e i l r ponsbiiy f de e m i ng a ca ma ' RFC i s c fc ly r s r edt t Co misone . 20 es i lt or t r ni li nts s pe ii al e e v o he m s i r C. R.jj40 1 27( ;41 927/) Se aloColar v Chare ,No.94- 457,1 W L 371 F. 4.5 e) 6. . e s v d . tr 1 995 620 ( h Ci. un. ,1 (ç dee nai ofacama ' r i lf toni ca ciyle 4t rJ 21 995) $ The tnui ton li nts esdua unci ng pa t is wiht ALJ notaphysca a i ba e uponalrlva e denc ') I deemi ngMr. t he , iin, nd s s d l ee nt vi e. . n tr ni ' s Pa ke ' R FC , he A LJ a i d t f ve s e s r rs t pple he i - t p eque i e ua i pr s de c i d a ve. ntal val ton oce s s rbe bo A lhough t A LJ di no fnd D r Ha l sc us o t tM r . r r w a c pl t l t he d ti . w ey' oncl i n ha s Pa ke s om e e y dia e durngt r e ttmepe i t bes s bl d i he elvan i rod o uppore bym e ca e de e t ALJdi fnd td di l vi nc , he di t tM r .Pa ke ha ment i par nt d i t pe i ofJ y 1 t oug he dael s ha s r r d al m ime s urng he rod ul 993 hr h r t a t i l e i l ng de es i a anxi t and d t nni d t tPl i ifm ett r quie e s f ns z d, nc udi r pr s on nd e y, e e ne ha a ntf he e r m nt or pr s e umptvedia lt und s ton 1 0 pa a a A a 1 06. 15 -10.TheALJ i s biiy er eci 2.4 r gr ph nd 2. R. 08 a s s d t f tona s ve iy ofM r . r rsme a i ime sand c ude t the s es e he unci l e rt s Pa ke ' nt l mpar nt oncl d ha r m e a c ton r ule i onl û lght'r s rc i i he a lt t pe f m da l lvi nt l ondii es t d n y s i ' e t i ton n r biiy o r or s iy i ng a tvii s W ih r s c t s alf nctoni t A LJco i r t t s i ony de c i ng c i te . t e pe t o oci u i ng, he nsde ed he e tm s rbi Pl i if shone oo a va to ng,c i ui t c r f t e dery w om e and wor ng i a ntf ' ym n nd ca i ni ontn ng o a e or he l l n, ki n auni r iy c e e i and de e ned t tt pl i tf m e alc ton r s t d i onl ve s t af t r a, t nni ha he a n ifs nt ondii e ule n y tsi ' r r cton i herabiiy t m ai ai soci f i ng. A ddii l t A LJ tlght' esti i n lt o nt n al unctoni tonaly, he 15 dee m i d t t pli ifsm e a c tonr s t d i onl ûsi ' r srci n i he tr ne hat he a ntf ntl ondii e ule n y tlght' e ti to n r c e r ton,Pe s s e ,a pac onc nt a i r it nce nd e.Ba e on t e de e a utM r . r r spe s l sd he vi nc bo s Pa ke ' r ona a tvii a e pl m en a tvii , he ALJ de e m i d t tt r c d doesnotr fec c i tes nd m oy t c i tes t t r ne ha he e or el t de e i a i orde om pens ton i w o k orw or lke s ti . Thi l veloff tona t r or ton c ai n r k-i e tngs se unc i l lmiaindesg t ame ali i ntt ti no s vee.20C. R.j404.520() i tto inaes nt mpanne ha s n-e r F. 1 a. M r Pa ke ne a g t tt ALJha no ba i f de e m i ng t tM r .Pa ke c d . r r xt r ues ha he d ss or t r ni ha s r r oul pef r asg iia tn mb ro j b i ten to a e o o p irt h rd t ls i s rd.Th ro m in fc n u e f o s n h ain l c n my ro o e ae a t n u e e t r s o t ePlitf' o j cin i t a t eALJer di no tkngit a c u tal fMr. h u t f h anifs be to s h t h re n t a i n o c o n l o s Pa ke ' aim e t i c bi ton w ih one a he . The Pl i if s brefcor e ty poi soutt t r r s l n s n om na i t not r a ntf i rcl nt ha t ALJdee m i d t tM r .Pa ke s f r d anumbe ofme c ly de e m i bl physca he tr ne ha s r r ufe e r di a l t r na e i l i pa r e sdlrng t pe i i quesi n, nc udi m i m nt zi he r od n to i l ng di be e m e lt ,non- om pla t m id di be i ne opa hy,c r c lsr i m id c r i a a t s lius c i n , l a tc ur t e vi a t a n, l e v c l arl ii, sbl dibeesr aedne ver otdiea ei he nec t i he c s tl ts pos i e a t elt r r o s s n r k, enson ada he , i om ni ,hype t ns on,t c a e, nd l i on t bo t m oft s ond t rght ns a r e i obac o bus a eson he t o he ec oe, i f . s i pa r e si com bi ton ha m or t n a m i m ale f ton t cl m a ' oot The e m i m nt n na i d e ha ni f ec he ai nts f toni a s t r or ha a 's ve e'phys c li pa r e . unc i ng nd he he ef e d te r ' i a m im nt R .1 505. Buta fndi ofa t e r physca i pa nne ' i notapers det nni ton t ta i ng t ve e s i l m i nt' s e e na i ha cli nti una et wor a ma s bl o k.Rat r t ALJmus e ua et physc a l e t unde se f he , he t val t he ial im n s r t ps our and fve oft s ue i e ua i di c s d abo t de e m i t e e oft c a m ants i he eq ntal val ton s us e ve o t r ne he xt nt he l i ' r i ua f tona ca ciy,i a Tha i wha ha ne he e. See R.1 4-1 D r St ve es d l unc i l pa t f ny. t s t ppe d r 51 6. . e ns t s ii t tM r .Pa ke w oul ha s f r f tgue t r t and pos i y f e nturna i e tfed ha s r r d ve uf e ed a i , hi s , sbl r que i ton durng t tm epe i i que ton. R.1 -16 Nonehees ,Dr St nst i he i rod n si 599 00. t l s . eve houghtM r . s Pak rwo db fnedn alg t o wi t a ii t mo ea o nds me' R. 60 r e ul e i t i h j b t he blt o v r u o . 1 0. i h y ' M r.Par al ar ker so guest t ALJ di notpose an appr i e hypot i queston t hat he d oprat hetcal i o t Voc tona Expe t(t '.Na l hecli t tt ALJdi notakt VE t tkei o he ai l r t ) mey, ams ha he VE' d s he o a nt 16 ac ountM r . r rsf tgue pan, d t e e t he lgs a i biiy t sa f a c s Pa ke ' ai , i nee o l vae r e , nd na lt o t nd or pr onge pe i d oftm e. d n or r f a vo tonale r ' opi on t be r e nto he pf ,i ol d r o i t de or l ca i xpe ts ni o el va r l ul t mus bebas d upon a c i r ton ofa lo he e de ei t r c d. Wal rv Bowe 88 t e onsde a i l t r vi nc n he e or ' ' ke . n, 9 F.d47,50( hCi.1 .l a ef todeemi t exe ofM r.Pake ' RFC,heALJ 2 4t r 989) n n for t tr ne he tnt s r rs t pr ed ahy he i alt t VE a a ke he t gi an e r o ni ast M r .Par r s opos pot tc o he nd s d r o ve xpe t pi on o s ke ' a ii t d aj brq ii glg te e t na do eta wa s d na y b ly o o o e urn ih x ri n n h t s e e tr : t o Le ' a s ef hypot i a numbe o .... t dibe e a ot is ,s ts s um or hetc l r ne due o a t s nd her s ues he w oul ha ha s e a tona lm ia i ns. She di ha s e f pr bl m s d ve d om ddii l i t to d ve om oot o e occ sona l durng t stm epe i ' t ' s l t a s es s d notclmb a i ly, i hi i rod, 93 o 94, o e' s um he houl s i l dde s duet f pr e s She s ul notw or a hei s She s d notope a e a r, o oot obl m . ho d k t ght . houl rt f pe l orf c r sw ih he f e .Due t f tpr bl m s s s d pr bl not oot da s oot ont ol t r e t o oo o e , he houl oba y h v aj bd i n a h rp i ia o c p to . . Le' f rh ra s meta s ed a e o rvig s e rncp l c u ain . . t u te su h t h ' s pr bl be be tw or ng a a i oba y s ki t n ndoora t m pe a ur c r l d e r e ,a w or nd e r t e ontole nvionm nt nd k s d note c r t di be e tuc ua i .Le ' a s e t tt s i vi ua c d houl xa e ba e a t s l t tons t s um ha hi ndi d l oul s oc s ona l c ouc c a l a soop . ..She w oul ne d t be i a w o k envionm e ca i ly r h, r w , nd t . d e o n r r nt t ts c os t t ba hr ,s s ' ha good a ce st a ba hr ,a s m i nee ha ' l e o he t oom o hed ve c s o t oom nd he ght d t cha posur brel a i plc - ( .Stve jde ci i ( js tofmovi o nge t es ify, nd n a e Dr e ns s rbed t as or ng a ound altl bi, nd 11 cali c ngi postr sbre l a i plc w ihoutl a ng r ite t a ' l t ha ng tle ify nd n a e t 1 e vi t w or s ti w or a he k e tng, kpl ce. R.1 0-11 Thi de a ld a s cii i uiy a a st ha t ke i t a ountt me c l 61 . s t ie nd pe fc nq r ppe r o ve a n n o cc he di a evi nc t tt A LJ f de e ha he ound c e bl a s t n i t d. The V E r ponded t ts m e i t t r di e nd ubs a ta e es ha o one n ha s t to c d be a ca hi r a com pa on,a r c ptoni ti o m a i c e k,ora ge r lof i e iua i n oul s e, ni e e i s /nf r ton l r ne a fc cek A1o to ej b weeg n r l a alb ei teU. e o o Up ncos-x miain lr . l f h s o s r e eal v i l n h S. c n my. o r se n n to y a by M r Pa ker scot s ,t V E a it d t ta f e ntne d f ba hr . r ' m el he dm te ha r que e or t oom br a ,ie.20 t 30 e ks . o mi tsada ot t nbr a ,wo de l t c s e j Addii l c e a ke nue y her ha e ks ul xcude he a hir ob. tonaly, ounsl s d w he he f tgue, ns ni pr ng o ' f e up,orne di t le dow n f e e d pe i t r a i i om a, oppi ne s e t e ng o i or xt nde r ods wo d e l e a oft a or m e i ned oc upa i .TheVE a it d t ta c ul xcud ny he f e nto c tons dm te ha ompa o co d ni n ul notbemor lmie t nt pes s wasl nga t ,R.1 6,a t tnoj woul e i td ha he ron he ooki fer 61 nd ha ob d t er t a pe s s nee ng t le dow n durng t da out i ofbr k tm esorbei a e ol a e r on' di o i i he y sde ea i ng bs nt 17 m or t n t daysam ont R.1 7.l i cla ,he t tt VE' a s s ntdi t keM r . e ha wo h. 61 t s e r t n, ha he s s es me d a s Pak rss be t c mplit it a c u tnc mbn to wihteo j cieme ia e i e c . r e' u j ci o ans no c o n i o iain t h b e tv dc l v d n e ve The A LJ St ' houg f ,co i r d i re t t VE, l w ih o he evi nce i t r c d, ht ul ns de e nqui i s o he a ong t t r de n he e or c nce t Cour t tt r i s t nta e de e t s onvi he t ha he e s ubs a i l vi nc o uppor t A LJ S fndi t tM r . t he ' i ng ha s Pa ke ha t RFC t per or lgh ors de a y w or d i t r e nttm e pe i r r d he o f m i t e nt r k ur ng he el va i rod. V . Concl on usi W he e ashe e,i onfi tng e d nc alow sr as bl m i t dif rast w he he a r, r t lc i vi e e l c e ona e nds o f e o t r cama ti ds be , teCo r mu t ee t t eCo sin rss u dj d me t J h s n li n s ia ld' h u t s d fr o h mmiso e ' o n u g n . o n o , ' 434 F. a 653. The A LJ a i d t c r c l ga s a r a t r i s t tale de t 3d t pple he or e t e l t nda ds nd he e s ubsan i vi nce o s uppor he f t fndi . Fort a or m e i d r a ons t Com m i s one ' M oton f r t r ac ual i ngs he f e ntone e s , he s i rs i o Summ a y J m e i GRANTED a M r Pake ' M o i f Summar J r udg nt s nd . r rs ton or y udgme i nt s D EN I . An a o i t Or rs l i s t sda ED ppr pr a e de ha l s ue hi y. ENTER:Thi f9 a o F bray 2 2 s y f e u r, 01 . / ' 18 J rUnie St t i ti tJ t d a es s r c udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
