Makdessi v. Fields et al, No. 7:2011cv00262 - Document 167 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/2/2014. (tvt)

Download PDF
e FQX: OFFI U,. GK M l CE S DI r AT ROA NOKE, VA rê r I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR I O F VI G I A CT R NI ROANOKE DI I ON V SI A DI ED DI M M EZ M A K DE SSI B E MAt 2 2 1 29 ; : JULA 2. '2.' ' ERK l ' 'Y CL BY; , DEP ' L ERK Cas N o.7: CV 00262 e 11 Cas N o. 1 e 7: 3CV 00079 Ca eNo. 1 s 7: 4CV 00034 Pl ntf , ai i f V. M E M O R AND UM O PI O N M HAROLD CLARKE, AL , :I By: Gl n E.Conr d e a ChifUnie St t sDititJ e t d a e src udge Dee da ts. fn nt) Pl ntf Adi Eddi Rn z M a s has fld a pl a ng t t he e il s t RI ai if b e me kdes i ie e di ha ntte : TI OR NOTI a c ant Pr f Ne d t ha Emegl nc Or rofPr eci a Pror CE nd ompli ; oof or e o ve r el y de ot ton nd i Noie' Ma d sic mp an t tRie No t Cor ci n lCe tr(RNCC' o t asha e tc .1 k e s o lis ha v r rh re to a n e E ' C ' f l v I ki desgnae s ve a ga t r i aes i t pr e tve c t i td e r l ngse nm t n he otc i usody lni a G l a es' a l t s û eg t ' nd de tr pr e ai s' a die t d t m t m a a pln t t trd' of M akde s,bec us he i a te es nt tve ,' nd r c e he o ke a o i i' ge si a e s s t h who com pl ns a lt tm e. M a nic ai l he i kdes ils s m l e ous i t nc i Fe ta y,M a c a s it m r ns n es n brz r r h, nd Aprl201 ofga t sde o ta i t i powe t fgh ,t e t n,s ly ha a s a e or i 4, ngser m nsr tng he r r o i t hr a e exua l r s , nd xt t o se lc r t a omm is y a ot rie sors r i e 9om o he i t si t t t a lgedl wih t s ar nd he t m e vc s t r nma e n he mi, le y t he kno l dge a a qui s e e oft t i m a ge a i tga o . A lhough M a w e nd c e c nc he m t na r nd nves i t r t kdes ialege s l s r pori s h c tonst ofi a s he cai no one ha i si t d t st ton. M a s i e tng uc ondii o fcil , l ms s nve tga e he iua i kde s saest tbe us he doesno wa t go t s p e ton,he hasno t hed' t e is a t t ha ca e t nt o o e ga i tt pus ' hes s ues t RNCC, u i wrtn i ta t teVign aDe rme to Co rcins(C b t s iig nse d o h r ii pat n f re t 1 o VDOC' dr co a d ' ie tr n ) t c tf r he p. he our o l 1 I t headi ofhi moton, M a n he ng s i kdess lss t t ee cas r er i it he hr es ef enced i t he ng oft s n he adi hi or der: Cas No.72 1CV00262,a e 1 boutevent a W alens Ri St e Prs whi i now on appeal s t l dge at ion, ch s ; CaeNo. 1 s 7:3CV00 9, c se d ma e frij re t hssoude a Ke nMou anCorcina 07 whih e ks a g s o nuis o i h l r t e nti reto l Cent ;and Cas No.7: 4CV 00034,r si compl nt a er e 1 ai ng ai s bouthi tansert t pr e i c t uni a s r f o he ot ctve us ody t t Ri N orh CorectonalCent . ver t r i er Thec u tc nsr e M a d siss bmiso a a mo in s e ig itro uo y ijmcie o r o tu s k e s' u s in s to e kn n el c tr n t tv r le die tng t VDOC die t a lnnnme s di t st t se t pr ec M a s e if r ci he r cor nd l d ubor na e o ake t ps o ot t kdes i fom ongoi g a tvii a t eae vi e e wihi t RN CC pr e tve c t y uni. r ng ang c i tes nd hr t ned olnc t n he ot c i usod t 1A)p ei n r ij n to ma ne e is t p e e ta ij r o h r wh c no e e t e ç rlmi ay n u cin y v r sue o rv n n nu y r a m ih t v n h ( movi pa t co e wa c us d by t wr c am e i t t ryi a ton. Om e ng ry nt nds s a e he ong l i d n he mde l ng c i ' ' za W o l Trve v. A,1 1F.d 1 ,1 ( t Ci.1 9 ) I r M ir s f AninltLii .3 3F.d rd a l TW 1 3 4 6 4h r 9 7 ; n e co o t t s tg, 3 3 t 51 5 ( h Ci. 7, 26 4t r 2003) . M a s doe no aleg t t t potnta ha m he s ks t pr ve t ough a kdes i s t l e ha he e il r ee o e nt hr n itro uo y ijmci n aie dr cl fo t p s wr n sh h scame a ans o t asi n el c tr n t to rs s ie ty r m he a t o g e a li d g i t f l n ki a of t t ee c es he ct s Ra he ,M akde s al s a ne c am - t tt diecor a ny he hr as ie . t r s i lege w li ha he r t nd unna e RNCC ofk il know i ae g t sco r a i i i t t ot ri t i t m d t as nm t angser ntol nd ntm da e he he nma es n he RNCC pr t c i c t y t t butt ke no se t a lvi t t s c tons The e or whie o e tve usod mi, a tps o le ae he e ondii . r f e, l hi moton f i e l t y r i mus be de e e c ofhi t eepe ng c es t co twil s i or nt rocu or elef t ni d a h s hr ndi as , he ur l di e tt c er t fl t m o i as a ne a s pa a e c vi a i A n a opr a e or r w il r c he l k o ie he ton w nd e r t i l cton. ppr i t de l is t sda s ue hi y. TheClr i die t d t s nda c oft sor rt t pli ifa t c ek s rce o e opy hi de o he antf nd o ouns ofr co d el e r f t de e or he f ndant . s d ENTER:Ths % d yo Ma , 4. i a f y 201 Chi U nie St t s D it i tJ ef t d a e s rc udge 2

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.