Descamps v. Bush et al, No. 7:2011cv00251 - Document 6 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/27/2011. (tvt)

Download PDF
# nlR 'AFIAqS D' O U T F KSO RCb i VX R I TF E6K ,A o FlE( s ) l . J 2? 2 1 U8 21 I THE UNI N TED STATE S DI STRI T C O U R T C FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STR I T O F VI G I I C R N A R O A N O K E DI I O N V SI M ATTH EW R .D ESCA M PS, J AG ULI BY: . . 'LEY CLERK ' .' D CA SE N O .7: CV 00 11 251 Pl ntf ai if, M EM O R AN DU M O PI I N N O V:. BUSH,ZI AL. , By: GlnE.Conrad e C hi fU nied St e D i t i tJudge e t at s s r c Dee fndants. t) M a t w R.D e c m ps a f de a i a e pr ee ng pr K , fl t s c vi r g s a ton the s a , e r l nm t oc di o ied hi i l i ht c i . ptrua tt Bi ns v.Si Unkno Na e Age sofFe Bur u ofNa c i s 403 U . 388 ts n o ve x wn m d nt d. ea r otc , S. ( 971,al i t t deenda s ion ofi i sa ot rfde a ofi r, ha vi aedhi 1 ) legng hat he f nt-prs tcal nd he e r l fces1 ve olt s c tt i na rg s by ho i hi i s r gaed c i m e ;c ica i l ldoc onsiuto l i ht usng m n eg e t onfne nt onfs tng ega umen s t a posa sa nd t ge t mps a ot r s hn rng hi a lt t a ce s t cours;a c i hi of nd he wie mpe i s biiy o c s he t c usng m c i he di no c mi;and de ng hi as it nc ofc rmes d t om t nyi m ssa e ouns l He a s alege t the wa e. lo l s ha s physc l a suledby c r ci lofi esa t Unie St esPe tntay Le Count (C ialy sa t ore tona tc r t he td at nie ir e yC USP Le ' ,i we tr Vign a a dt a t e ea i mae i t eBOP a r ewih (i t a (i)l e e' n sen r ii, n h t t v r l n ts n h ) s g e t hm) h t h s i f i i da r' He has a id t pr ee i f s n nge . ' pple o oc d n onna pa rs As r le , Des mps s e t upe i . ei f cn e ks o r i t t a pr o c vi ac i t t w a di m i s d a f i ous by t Unied St t s D i t i t Cour e ns a e i r i l ton ha s s s e s r vol he t a e sr c t f t Ea t r D i ti t of W as ngt or he s e n s r c hi on. U pon r vi w of t s i sons t c t w il e e he ubm s i , he our l s m a iy di m i st ac i um r l s s he ton. l f c ,De c n a t s amps has purue a muliude of pror lws t i t f de a c t,s s d tt i a uis n he e r l ours o ma y i fc, h ta la to ec u t a f u dt t i b re t r28U. C.j 1 1 ( )fo n ,n a t t a t e s n o r h s o n ha he s ar d mde S. 9 5g r m flng a fzt rcvi a tons wiho pr pay e oft $350. tlng f e. See De cn ii ny t he i l c i r t ut e m nt he 00 ii e s mps v. 1 Thedef endant D es s campsnam esi t slw s tar tBus e algil BOP (iq US Le a d n hi a ui e: d h t . sc ; sc ; P e n W ade Zyc US Flrnc a W a d n Ga d'S1 Lt.sc Fl e e USP Le W . e s' r n h; P o e e nd r e ur , S s (il ornc ; e And r . ' Bus No.CV- 1 - ( D.W as 2007 ( s ' unde j 1 5( ;De c mpsv.And e , h, 07- 21EFS E. h. ) dim d r 91 g) s a rs No.CF- 9100277-LQ ( D.W as 2000 ( s dt rj1 5( a fi o ) Aspa toft J E. h. ) dim' mde 91 d) s rvolus. r he sauo y s cin al wi g cvl l ia t t q aiy t p o e d i f nn pa p rs j1 5 g ttt r e to lo n ii i g n s o u l o r c e n o a u e i, 91 ( ) t f pr de ovi s: I no eve s l a prs r brng a cvi a ton ...unde t s s ton i t n nt ha l ione i i l ci r hi eci f he prs rhas on 3 ormor proroc sons whie i a c r t d orde a ne i a ione , e i ca i , l nc r e a e t i d n ny f ciiy,br a lt ought a a ton or a al i a c tof t Unie St t s t twas n ci ppe n our he t d a e ha dim is on t gr s s ed he ounds t ti i fi o ,m ai i ,o f is t sa e a c am ha t s rvol us lcous r al o t t li upon w hi h r i m a be gr nt d,unl s t prs r i unde i m i ntda e c elef y a e es he i one s r m ne ng r o sro p ysc lijly f eius h ia n t . r 2 U.. j 1 5 g . ûT1 erq iiei ne td n e o sro sp ysc lij r mu te ita 8 SC. 91 ( ) $ h e u st mmi n a g r f ei u h ia n u y s x s t ( t tme t co pl i ...i fl ...M or ove ,t e e i f us on t rs t tt he i he m ant s ied. e r he xc pton oc es he ik ha he c n u tc mplie o t rae c niuigo ft r ij r ,n to wh t e t eimaed s r e o d c o an d f h e tns o t n r uu e nu y o n eh r h n t e e v s n a rmed f pas mic e y or t s onduc . Smih v.W a 370 Fe App' 377,378 ( h Ci.201 t' ' t ng, d. x 4t r 0) ( n u ls e ) ( u tng M a t v.S et n 31 F.d 1 4 ,1 5 (t Ci.2 0 )(iig ohe u p bih d q oi ri n h l , 9 3 0 8 0 0 8h r 0 3 ctn t r o c s s. ae) Asa i t rcogni d asathr esrke' t rj1 g) Des mpscn pr ee n nmae e ze i e ti r' mde 915( , ca t nnot oc d i t slws twihoutpr pa ng t $350. tlng f e unl s he de n hi a ui t e yi he 00 ii e es monsr t t the i unde taes ha s r i n n d n e o sro sp ysc lijty Alh u h De c mp a aflo imaeha efld mmie t a g r f e iu h ia n t . t o g s a s nd elw n t v ie r a fda t a s ri t tDes n ps i i f a f hi lf ,t y f lt a l ge a f c s i s f i vis s e tng ha cm s n e r or s ie he ai o le ny a t n uppor of t t s co l or a s r i The com pl i s t t D es a ps m a i t s ac i a 1 c er pa t hi nc us y s e ton. a nt ha cm kes n hi ton 1 onc n s e nt ,wih no i c ton t ta oft a lged vi ai wilr occl i t f t e ort ta ve s t ndia i ha ny he le ol tons l e tr n he ' ur u ha ny of t m pl c hi i i i nt da r of s f rng physc ha m . The e or t c t he a es m n mm ne nge ufe i ial r r f e, he our c l st theha notme t sa r unde j 1 5()t pr edwihoutprpa ntoft oncude ha s t he tndad r 91 g o oce t e yme he flng fe. The aci wilbe s ii e ton l ummaiy dimis d unde j1 5( ,ba e on De c mps rl s se r 91 g) s d sa ' des g ton as ha ng t ee s r ke ,s Des m ps v.Bus N o.CV - 1 i na i vi hr - t i s ee ca h, 07- 21 EFS,s a a hi upr , nd s 2 f iur t demonsr t t the i i i ne tda r ofs rous physca hn m i r lto t t al e o ta e ha s n mmi n nge ei i l r n e ai n o he cha l nge c le d onduc ofpr s n ofi a s t i o fci l . I a e nt Des mps al ga i a e a s l gal fi ous a m a be s n ny ve , ca ' le tons r lo e ly rvol nd y umm miy l dimis ass h unde 28 U. C.j 1 5 b)1 . He fist alge f t i c tng t tt s sed uc r S. 91 A( ( ) al o le acs ndiai ha he i vi ual he has na e as de e nt we e pe s ly i ved i a wa i t a lge ndi d s m d f nda s r r ona l nvol n ny y n he le d c tm tonal vi a i , a t Fede a Btr a of Pr s (û ons i i ol tons nd he r l le u i ons E BOP' a d te v ro p io ' n h aius rs n ) f c lte he na e a e notpr a iii s m s r operde e nt unde Bi ns Se M c os v v.M ue l r 446 F. f nda s r ve . e cl ke le , 3d 2 2 27 - 2 ( s Ci.2 0 )(t- Bie sd crn alwsc n ttto lcamsa ans fd r l 6 , 127 1 t r 0 6 Cl -he v n o tie l o o si ina li g i t e e a u ofi i l,i t i i vi lca ii ,f a tonst ke unde col off de a lw....Butt fc as n he r ndi dua pactes or c i a n r or e r l a he a lbiiy oft tdocrne doesno o ni be oc prnci esofs r gn i miy s a t vaia lt ha ti t ve de dr k i pl ove ei mmt t o s o pe m i s t a i t t Unied St es is a nc es or f de al ofk e s s d i t r ofi i r t uis ga ns he t at , t ge i , e r t r ue n hei t c al c ctes' ( ttonsomit ) apa ii .) ciai ' ted . Fo t er a o ssae ,h c u t s se De c mp ' c mp an wi o tp eu ie r h e s n ttd te o r dimis s s a ss o lit t u rj d c , h ptrua t j1 5( ,ori t atr tve, rj 1 5 b)1 asfi ous Ana oprae zs nt o 91 g) n he lenai unde 91 A( ( ) rvol . ppr it o de wile e t t sef e t r r l nt r o hi f c . The Cl r i diec ed t s nd c e oft sm e or ndum opi on a a c pa ng e k s r t o e opi s hi m a ni nd c om nyi o de t pl ntf . r r o ai i f EN TER . :Ths2 5 a d yo J n , 01 . i a f u e2 1 Chi fUnied St t sDititJ e t a e src udge 3

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.