DePaola v. Wade et al, No. 7:2011cv00198 - Document 55 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 7/7/2015. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
R > W FGEUS DI COUR RY: I SX T vRFIED kv x Ld A x I T H E U N I D STAT ES D I T RI CO U RT N TE S CT FO R TH E W E ST ERN D ISTR ICT O F V IRG I I N A RO AN O KE D I SIO N W J 2! 2 1 UL 25 J BY: C. Dc CL EM CJOSEPH DEPAOI , A Ci lA ct on N o. 7: -c vi i : 11 v-00198 Pl ntf y ai if M EM O RAN D U M O PIN IO N By:H on.M i chaelF.U r bansl d J ESWADE,eta. AM 1, Unied Stt DititJudge t aes stc D ef endant s. Pr s p n f Etc o e hDe oarDe oa'mo dtec t tt atzisMac 3 , o e bid f iJ sp pa l < Pa 1' ve h ot o le t rh 0 ) t 201 j gme dimisnghi a to algngvi ai ofhi Fis a Fo te hAme nt 2 ud nt s si s cin le i oltons s tt nd ute nt ndme rght and t Rei ousLa U seand l dtz i s he lgi nd ns a donalzed Pe onsA ctof2000,42 U . C. i rs S. j 2 0 c , t e .' , I A'.ECF No 4 .De oaa srst t al W a e 7 1F.d4 2 (t j 0 0 c e s q (RTU P ' T ) . 9 pa l set ha W lv. d , 4 3 9 4h Ci. 4,etblhe ne lw i t Fourh Cic tt a c tdcst sc utsdeii a r201 ) sa i d w a n he s t rui l t onta it hi ot ' cson nd a e tt shm t v c d nof i jd me u d zFe ea Rueo CiiPt c due6 @ .Fo te n ie i o aa o hs u g nt n e d zl l f vl o e t 0 l rh ra o t t olw,h c l t e s ns ha f l t e oz DEN I De oasmo o t atrt ej g n . o r ES pa l' d n o l h ud me t e D e a fl t sacdon i A prl2011 cl m i t prson of i satRed O ni St e paol led hi n i ai ng hat i fcal on at Prs n (ROS Jr f sdt a c mmo ael s e uet op ziiaei te2 1 o ev nc o io t P' eu e o c o d t a z q s t at p t r h 0 0 bsr a e f I ) i c z Ram adan becausehe di nots d how I l i m at i sr l sanac ezal elecdng hi sncer y he d zei ousbelef as s i el l lgi is tquie byVigni De rme ofCoze do CVDOC' poiy Fz m 20 O oug 200 e rd ri a pat nt rc ns i ' lc . o 07 I h 9, D e ol obs r e Ra a n a a M usi i a epa dcpa i i da l f s s Af e D e o a nodûe pa a e v d m da s lm nm t r i tng n i a t . t r pa l y d DePaola v. Wade et al Doc. 55 ROSP of il t thei e dt o eveRa da i 201 f s r edie tzJa sW a ûcas ha ntnde o bst ma n t 0,ood edc rco me de z ake De ol t s aQurnorot rllmi maeil i hi posesonpurua t VDOC s d pa a o how a he sa c trasn s ssi s nt o poiy De ol owne aQutn a c dha c idwih t rquetbutrf e t dos lc . pa a d a nd oul ve omple t he e s, eusd o o. W a t nlf t s a G :Aot ri ts De ol alge l r tive hi Qtr a tidt de he et o pe k . he nmae . pa a l dy ere d s zan nd te o I e s m on W ade,buthedi notr ur RO SP s equenty deni D e a' r um d et n. ubs l ed paol s eques t obs t o erve Dockets.Justia.com Ram adan be cause he di notdèm onstat hi snce l he d zei ousbei sby pos sng Isam i d t e s i tey l lgi lef ses i l c m at ral e i s. D epaol t broughts tcl m i t tt V D O C polc reqlii t he s a hen ui ai ng ha he iy ltng hat how Isam i l c m at tal t par i ei Ram adan vi at hi rght undert FistAm e enta RT, e i s o dcpat n ol ed s i s he r ndm nd UIPA a nd hsr t t e ua p oe do u e teFoute hAme d n .OnMac 3 , 0 2 t ec t t i kh s o q l r tc n nd r h t ent n me t th 0 2 1 ,h ot r e ee isf loz rga i dee nt'mot fzs ntr d t ma de rntng fnda s bn o ummayj gme ont RTUI a Fis r ud nt he , PA nd rt A m e entcai s,and dim i sng t Four ee h Am e entequalpz ecdon cl m wihout ndm lm s s i he t nt ndm ot ai t prj c .Thec tde e De oascos motonf s eudie our nid pa l' r s i or ummayj me .Thec t f r udg nt ou t oundt hat De ol' cam fri unc rle unde RTUI a t Fis Ame ntwa mootbecus pa as li o nj dve eif r PA nd he rt ndme s a e VD O C changed ispolcy and no l rrequied s egat i at t pr ntI l m i m at il i t i onge t egr ed nm es o ese s a c eras n or t par pat i Ram adan. The cot alo hel t def der o dci e n ut s d hat endant w er enéted t quai s e l o lûed i m uriy on t FistAm endm entc nm f dam agesbec m lt he r l i oz ause Tr onabl of swoul notha teas e scer d ve under ood t as ng D epaol t s st hat ki a o how s e i ci ofhi srcer r i ousbei and r ov ng om ndi a s il e elgi lef em i hi fo t Ra da padcpain l twhe het fs d go c rt wo dvol eDe oh' m r m he ma n t i to i s n eu e tq oopeae ul i at pa s fee exez s rght.' D e r cie i s'l paol v. W a e No 71 - 0 1 8 2 1 W L 1 7 6 8 a * ( . Va a d , . :1CV-0 9 , 0 2 0 7 7 , t 3 W D. . Ma. 201 ) TheFourhCicltafume t dititc tsde ii on Ocobe 3 201 r 30, 2. t rt f d he src our' cson i t t, 2 b cus ir o ndn rv ri eet r'De oav W a e 4 9F. p' 5 6 5 63 (t1 r 2 1 ) e a e tf u o e es ro . pa l . d , 7 Ap x 3 , 3 - 7 4l Ci. 0 2. f bl ' ' Fourl Cicti ent ed ism andat i N ovem be 2012. rhe ta t lt er t en r O n Febtz y 3,2014,t Fot h Cicui is W al v. ade,whi ar e att s m e aar he ut r t s ued l W ch os he a pts f lt i em r ed taesam eV D O C polcy,a t l ed t ta s e Ram adan peùod asi ion aciiy, nt et l i nd eat o le am n D epaol RO SP of al deni Gar W al' re tt pazdcpat i Ram adan beca e he di not a, ûci s ed y ls ques o i en us d poss t bl iem sofli lsami f t ilaccot ess angi e t ls l c aih r . dance wih VD O C' polc TheW al cout t S iy. l t 1Theco talo hedt tRLUI doe no a horzeda ge a ns de e nt i t i i vi o o tci ur s l ha PA s t ut i ma s gai t f nda s n her ndi dual r fi al c p cte , n ta h li i n tc alng do i l ae b De oasisa t to t atrte u g n . a a iis a d h t odng s o h l e r mpi td y pa l' n tn moin o le h j d me t e c 2 r eached t opposie concl i oft pane i D epaol Contar t t percuram hol ng i he t usons he ln a. t y o he i di n D epaol t W al couz concl a, he l t uded t t c hat he hange i ' O C polcy di notm oott cl m sf n VD i d he ai ot equiabl z i and t def nda sw e notentted t qualfed i m uniy f dam age on t Fis t e elef hat e nt re il o ii m t or s he r t Ame ndme cam.TheW alc zthedft t(lhoug pzs of il mus ma detz na nt li l olr l fha at hq ion fcas t ke emi dons ofwho i entted t accom m odadons,i e s il o t xceeds t ra hort t deci whi i any,r i ous hei ut iy o de ch, f elgi r eEcsar s fci l i port ast cons a t an appz i egauge off t ' 741 F. at499. e ufi enty m ant o dtze oprat aih.' 3d W l e notng t i Tne rs i l e uat a sncert t t' t pane hed t qualfed ûl i hat t K ve pec fcaly val ed i iy es ,' he l l hat ii i m uliy s zd nots el def m a t hotl hi d endant f om dam agesbecaus t ta gum entove l sr e hat fr rooks t he broaderrghtati s t i at ar endted t r i ousci at accom m oda i s ue:hat nm es e l o elgi let y donsabsenta lgtmaer a on t t c r r .z 1 at502. I lghtoft f ci ,D epaol m oved t scour e ii t e s o he onta y' G. ' ni hese m lngs a hi t . t atrhi j o le s udgme o Nove t1 201 3aki tec ur t va aeisme rnd opi on nt n mbe 7, 4, s ng l o t o c t t mo a um ni a a o d ru d rRue6 9 4,5, r() ECFNo 4 . nd r e n e l 0 $() () o 6. .9 Dititc t t po s s jrs it n t rve Rue6 $)mo n wi uteveo te sr ol s ses u idci o e iw l 0 c r o do s t la f h ho appel e cour t decded t a lat t hat i he ppeala i ued a m andat i t cas See St nd ss e n he e. andat 0 1 Co.of d 1 Caio ni v. tdStts 429U. 17 19(976 ( r tigcititc t t zviw Rue60:) lfr a Unie ae, S. , 1 ) pemitn lstc outs o e e l modonsdepieama t af mi t undelmgde ii ) Nobr av. nkl, F. x2 st ndae & ng he ry' cson; e Hi e 576 App' 24 (t Ci. 0 4 (I i we stldt t cstc c t ma , to tla efo t ea p l t c u t 4. z2 1 ) < ts l et ha a l tit out y wi u ev z m h p el e o r, h t l e i h a e eti aRue6 mo nt a wa fe wihnarao a l a u to t atrtedsrc ntran l 0$) do h t s l d ti e s n be mo n f i fe h itit l me c te ee isj me , ve i t a laec tha ara ydei dt a a oft t our ntrd t udg nte n f he ppelt our s le d cde he ppe l ha jd me t'.Co rstk at o se a r a hwh nas sigRue6 $)mo in .Fis,f' u g n .) u t a e a -tp pp o c e sesn l 0 ' v t s rtfl o te l 2A lhought W alcoul not t exitnceoft pro r i i De a, i di notc t he l ' ed he se t he ir ulng n paol t d omm e on De a' ca e nt paol s s o w hehe W alhadar toaci efe t r t r l er tve f c. 3De oasmial fldamoinfrr l ffo u g n i teFo rhCic io J n ay2 , 01 , sigt Pa l i lry i e to o ei r mj d me tn h u t rut n a u r 9 2 5 akn he e c tt r ope hi a ala r m andt c et t sc tf f rherpr e ngsi lghtofW al.I tadof our o e n s ppe nd e he as o hi our or u t oce di n i l nse te tngt r ques a apeii t r c lt m a t t Clr oft Cour ofAppe si onnedDepaol t tt r a i he e t s tton o e al he ndae,he ek he t al nf a ha he Co r o Ap e l wo dn t du c t De a l' rq et u s a toF u t Cic t c l e4 () De oav u t f p as ul o aj diae p oas e u sp ru n t o rh ruiLo a Rul 0 d. pa l . Wa e No 1 6 0 ( t Ci. a . 9 2 5 . d , . 2-8 3 4h r Jn 2 , 01 ) m ovi pardesm ustm ake a t es d s ng hr hol howi t t i m odon was tm el t t had a ng hat her i y; hat hey meioiusd fn eo cam;h tn u fi p eucc t t o o igpat wo l rs l a dta rt ro ee s z li ta o n az rj l e o he pp sn ry ud eut n h t i ; e e xc pdona crumsa e warntzleffom t j me ' Cr soa Eqzt Pa t r. J' v. l ic tnc s ra ei r he udg nt' osr ds tiy rnes T C Do a Pz ucs I , 3:1 dc od t nc,No. 1 CV00 ,201 K 65 39, t* ( . Va Fe 1 201 ) se 069 4 21 a 2 W D. . b. 9, 4; e as Na'Crdt inAd n. . . a , F.d2 2 2 4(t Ci. 9 3 ( t gta no al lo t e iUno mi Bd v Gr 1 3 6 , 6 4h t 1 9 ) noi h t t l l n c ursrquiee e i lcrumsa e) trpade c os t si da t e hol t yt n mus o t e r xcptona ic tnc s.Afe z s r shi ni lhrs d,he he t sù f o eo tesxs cfcsc o so Rue6 9 e W ene v. r o 7 F.d2 4 2 7(t a sy n f h i peii e d n f l 0 $.S e r z Cab , 31 2 0 , 0 4h Ci.1 4 .flhec tne dnota t s whehe t mova ssds dt s t ehol r 98 ) f' our e e dd es t z he nt a ie hee hr s d re r e s,howevet i t cour f ds t t m ovant have nots fci l s quiem nt , f he tm hat he s uf enty adshed one oft he Rul 60$)g oundsf rle. Ct soa E li Pat z, 4WL 6 39, t* (ii Do lv. e r oz eif' osr ds z rnes201 ' 521 a 2 ctng wel SaeFam Fie& Cau lyAut. n . .9 3F.d4 , 8(t Ci. 9 3) Wih u a d esn tt z r s at o I s Co, 9 2 6 4 4. r 1 9 ). to t d tsig h whet rD epaol s ifest t eshol requiem e s t cot f dst D e a' m oton cannot he a ats i he hr d t nt, he ut m hat paol s i sd f Ru e6 $)4 ,5, t() a sy l 0 () () o 6 . De oaag e t t i jd me ti n w v i p ru n t Ru e6 q be a s W a pa l t u s ha hs u g n s o od u s a t o l 0 $/) cu e E dt cl c nlcswihhsj g n .A j g n i v i u d rRue6 $) o l i fl rn eig ie t o fit t i ud me t ud me ts od n e l 0 /) ny f fl e d rn y te c u t spo rest e tri'whc g n rl rs l fo lc o s be tmatro p ro l o z wa wels o n e q' ih e eal eut r m a k f u jc te r es na y s jrs ito .Ba ml & Ez tLt v. miiLt , 3 F.d2 8 2 1(t Ci. 9 0 (u d gV. l idcin u i z n ns. d. Ge n. d.6 7 2 3 , 4 4 h r 1 8 ) q o n T. A.I . . ro.n .5 7F.d2 0 2 42 (0 Ci. 9 9) A c u t alg der r d no v i a .nc v Aic .l c, 9 2 2 , 2 -5 1 + t 1 7 ). o ê' l e ro s o t od s e jd me ta dalw rl fu d rRue6 $) .S eL a 2 2rEro , o v r d e no ma et u g n n l ei n e l 0 /) e c t 4 f z rh we e, o s t k he o e L j g nt oda ,h zf zy d. Ci. 6 9 4 i ia pia l. (in l r Te lnCo . ud me v i nd t eeo e Fe R. v P. 0 $() s n p l b e' ct g n e xo c ' i , 5 6F.d1 9 , 0 9(dCi. 9 9 (x li n t t jd me t u dno b v i e ni t ec l t 9 2 0 2 1 9 2 r 1 7 ) e plnig ha a u g n wo l t e od ve f h oz r ma ag os er i t lw)) De ol doe notc ett tt sc tha juicido t her de r s ror n he a ). pa a s onts ha hi our d t sl n o a c hsc s , ndt ec u tf sn tao t s g eto h r s.Rue6 6 4 d e n ta pya d i a e a h o t md o e s n o u g s t ewie l 0 $() o s o p l n D epaol cannots rei undert s s a eek lef hi ubsecdon, De oasmi r c n e st a W al e ie hsc u eo a t nu e Rue6 9 5, ih pa l i l l o tnd h t lrvv s i a s f ci nd r l 0 $() whc ay o pemisrle fom afna j me i ttej me ha be nsts d,ee sd,ozcic te ii r t eif r i ludg nt fdl udg nt s e aife tlae a lshag d;ts bae ona erirj gme ta ha benrves do va ae ora yngipr pedveyi no sd n ale ud nt l t s e e re r c td; ppli t os c l s a ln e e ttbe' Fe . Ci P. 0 $() Co rsrpe tdyh v d tt n dt t s bsq nt o g r qla l. d R. v. 6 q 5. u t e ae l a e eemie ha a u e ue i ' c a g i t e1w d e n tp o i eas f in bai f r a a n aj g n u d rRue6 9 5 . h n e n h a o s o z vd ufce t ss o v c d g ud me t n e l 0 $() S eDo l 9 3F.da 4 Sodn ta Rue6 9 5 i e e ls a pia l T r tee r e e wel 9 2 t 8 lig h t l 0 $() s v n es p l be t e h al r , c whe i j udgme i net rr sj iat notpr i sc lttlet l'; n HurCo tCo. Goodwi nt s ihe e udc a ovde olaea soppe' Be ) ns. v. n, 1 6F. D. 8 , 8 ( D. o 1 8 )afds bn m. n Ht Co tv Go d n 8 5F.d8 9(t 1 R. 2 1 2 3 E. M . 9 7 f' u o Be u ns. . o wi, 5 2 5 8h Ci. 9 8 tW h1 Rue6 9 5 a t o ie rl ffo aj g n o t eg o n t a t ep ir t 1 8 ) t i l 0 $() u h rz s ei rm ud me t n h r u d h t h ro f e e j gme uponwhihiwa ba e ha be nrvesdorvaae i doe nota hoierle fom a ud nt c t s s d s e e te ctd,t s ut rz eif r j g nt nt eg o ndta telw a p e b tec t i ma igisa jdcdo i d cae ud me o h z u h t h a p h d y h outn kn t du ia n s e lrd er ousi a he a unzltdpr e dip7.Gi nt tDe ol se rle s eyo t tone n not r nd eae oc e n ' ve ha pa a e ks eif oll n he ) b ssof h c nfci gd cso i WalRue6 q 5 cn tsr ea a a e u of eiffrhi ai t e o l t eiin t l l 0 $() a no ev s n v n e rl o s in l , e m odon. De oasst n e t zu n frattn tejd me fl u d zRue6 ( 6, eet pa l' to g s ag me t o lei g h u g nt al n e l 01 )wh t he s $( c u tma g a t eif o T n ohe ra o ta j d isrl f'Rue6 $()a pl st o r y tn rl f r f y t r e s n h tus fe ei ' l 09 6 p i o e a e e ff e ta z i r cru tn e .S eAc ema nv. tdSae, 4 U.. 9 , 0 (9 0. xro dnaf: ic msa c s e k r n Uni tts 3 0 S 1 3 2 2 1 5 ) e tAlhough a clar cutchange i t 1 can be t bass f Rul 60 r i ,a changei t 1w wil f t e n he aw he i or e elef n he a l notal a pr de t tal ext aozdi r cr nst w ys ovi he tzy t na y icm ancesneces ar t r s y o eopen a case.Som et ng hi m ore t a m e changei t 1w i neces ar t pt de t gt han re n he a s s y o ovi he ound f Rul 60 r i ,es i ly oz e elef pec al whe aj n udgme ha be ne c ed. Be HutCo tCo.1 F. D. t28 s eas Dowel9 nt s e xe ut ' n ' ns. , 16 R. a 49 e lo l, 93 F.da 4 (g c a g i d cso a lw s b e u n t af lud me t z vd snob ssf rrl f 2 t 8 ïA) h n e n e iin la u sq e t o ma j g n p o ie < ai o ei e unde Rue60q 6.) Be zviwi a c n si t lw, ouzsgvesg sc nt t l $()7. yond e e ng ny ha ge n he a c t i ini a ' c i rton t t f lt ofj me a whehe t c tofa asrviwe t c etd onsdeai o he maiy udg nt nd t t he out ppel e e d he ontse decii SeeBen H t Cons .Co. 116 F. D .at284. Cour salo re e w het t a lat son. u t , R. t s viw her he ppel e cour i ended f t ne lw t ha a t r dve ef ect See St he on v.M c an Cont ctn t nt or he w a o ve et oac f . e ns Le m i C o, 7 F.d5 4 a * (t Ci. 9 2 (flmigd na o Rue6 9 6 rl f eet eS p e .9 7 2 7 , t 2 4. r 1 9 ) af n e il f l 0 $() ei wh z h u r me h z e - Cot is dc lc g1w oney a attt c s a is a di nots e tztoa dveefc) utsue onfie a e r fe he ae tsue nd d ugg s er c fe t; Mctt h v. S Se l .7 6F.d3 3 3 6(t Ci. 9 4.'h ds c c mt li tl t tis l l t U.. te Co , 2 2 3 , 3 7. r 1 8 ) F e itit o ut ey enn i h ma t dice t deemi whehe e ta di r crumsa e j tf rle.S Se he o 9 he s zdon o tr ne t r xror nay ic tnc s usiy eif pe t ns n, 77 F.da * ; e . tCa . . . n' Ca . ,6 1F.d1 6 , 0 8(0 Ci. 9 0 (ocn 2 t 2 S c Mu . s Co v Ce t u s Co, 2 2 0 2 1 6 1 1 r 1 8 ) h l'g h ta ac t 'r l gu e Rue6 $)6 s o l n tb atrdf x e tframa fs a u eo h t out ui nd r l 0 () h ud o e l e f c p o s n e e niet b s f st o ) ce . D epaol and W alundenibl purs sm ia c a l a y ued i lr ases. Bot ale vi adonsofRT, I a h l ged ol U PA nd t FistAm e entafert y w er notalowed t par pa e i t obs a ofRam adan he r ndm t he e l o dci t n he ew nce pt uantt W 3O C' 2010 polcy. Com ar W al,741 F. at496,wih D epaol 479 F.App' at us o S i e l 3d t a, x 536- D epaol and W al pa i ed i t obs va ofRam adan asV D O C i at f 37. a l rdcpat n he er nce nm es ot m ul e yeatspzor t 2010. Com a W al,741 F. at494, 11 ECF N o.10- p.3. RO SP dpl i o te l 3d w t1 1, deni bot oft i requess t par ii eilRam adan bec ed h he t t o tcpat t ause t owned no i lca off t hey nci i aih. H ow e r,t t pl ndfs at pt t com pl wih V D O C' polc vared gt l W alexpl ned ve he wo ai f' tem s o y t S iy i eaty. l ai t W ade t he l thi r i ousposs s onsdutng hi t ans ert RO SP,s ed W ade hi st eo hat os s elgi es i i sr f o how s at c tj gme a pr oft l tpz zy notfe W a ofhow hepatcpae i Ra a t our ud nt s oof he os opet, iid de tii td n mad n he pa tt ye t ,a s w e t t' D O C a ove hi z c i oft c m on f i d e i a c da e s wo a s nd ho d ha V ppr d s e e pt he om a t i t n c ot nc wih hi Ilmi beif.W alv. a , 7: -v- 91 a * 3( . Va. v. 201 ) l t s sa c les l W de No. 11c 001 , t 2- W D. No 30, 2 . n com pats D epaol ref i on, a used t show any z i ousm at dal t W ade,m ai aned hi r us lwhe o elgi e so nt i s ef a n wane a tmo lfom t Ra da padcpain l ta onyatmptdt s w hi Qt n r d bout e va r he ma n r i to i , nd l te e o ho s ua s when he ale y and uns l gedl ucces uly s m oned W adebac t hi cel. D e a,2012 W L sf l um k o s l paol 1077678,at*3- A fezpur i t neces ar gz e 4. t mzng he s y i vance pr ocedur a 61ng t rc m si es nd i hei bi n 6 f alcour ,b0t W al' and D e a' RT, I cli sw er dim i ed asm ootand t rFr eder t . h ls paol s U PA am e s ss hei ee Exer s cl m swer cina s ed on t bass ofqualfed i m uniy. Com par W al,741 F. at494, cie ai e ls i s he i ii m t e l 3d wih D epaol 2012 W L 1077678,at*2t a, 6. The decii ent red by t s cot ilD epaol and by t Fot h Cicui i W alalo at sons e hi ut r a he ut t t n l s e bae o smi rlw.I De oal d eW i o rl do Lo lc v Le , 7 F.d1 4(t Ci. sd n i l a n pa lyu g l n ei n vea e . e 4 2 3 7 4h r a s e 2 )t zc z aFis Ame me rg t pat paei Ra da butga e q lfe 006,o e ognie tt nd nt iht o rki t n ma n, rntd uaiid i m uniy beca t def m t use he endant act reas s ed onabl gi t (i i pe m i sbl f prs of as t y ven hat dt s r s i e or ion scil o adoptpolci desgned t cont olcos s pr i es i o r t , eventopez adonaldirupdons and ve iy t sncert of s , rf he i iy r lgi belef- e n w hen t e polc esar i fi ei ous i s ve hos ii e n rcdon w ih f ee exe i e rght .' D epaol , 2012 t r rc s i s'4 a W L 1077678,at*5. The paneli W al aso hea l reled on Lovel t de et i t W als n ll viy i ace o t m ne hat l' pa paton i Ra adan w asa cl l esabls tght butcont as y det m i t prson zdci i n m eary t ihed i , z dngl er ned hat i ofi i sunr fcal easona y a i bl btdged t rght See W al 741 F. a 502- The Fouzt Ci catpanel hat i . l, 3d t 03, h t li addt sed whet rt 1w w asuncl rzegar ng t us ofsncert t t t det ne ei biiy f es he he a ea di he e i iy es s o ermi lgi lt or rl iusa c mmo a o s e pann :<nl to o ru e uvo a sae n i Lo ea eta ei o c o d d n , x liig < kh f u n q i cl ttme tn v lc h t g 1 i t sa ee l t r lgousditr a c nma e r ndted o eii ea y c omm oda , nee nott ia pr vi l pa s d dons we d o ve e ousy s e j gme ont a oprae s ofpadcta snc rt tssi or tt de ndt tprs n of il ud nt he ppr itnes r tlr i eiy e t t de o ma ha io ûcas z actr onabl i adm i s e g t zght' W al,741 F. at502- Thus t D epaol cour and eas yn nit e hat i .' l 3d 03. , he a t W alpanelcam e t ve dif entconcl i aboutta r l o ry f er usons le easona eapplcadon ofsncett t t but bl i i iy ess, ari ta e due t vazancesi i e r adon oft lw-notc ngesillw . rved lez o i n nt m et he a ha ta TheW alde ii doe notc ttzes hfe ta r i r'crumsa e a t j df rle l cson s onsi f uc txro dnay' ic tnc s s o us y eif a fom De ol' j me . Fouth Cictta wel ot tcruisha f r pa as udg ntThe t rti, s las he ic t, ve oundt tacer ha la 4Bot t dititc tsdecso i D e ol a t Fourh Cicui pa ' decsoni W als r d m a ciai , h he src our' iin n pa a nd he t r t nels ii n l ha e ny ttons i ldn Cutrv W i is n 5 4U. 7 9( 05; d t v. . fGo en r Mas alUni , 4 F. 2 2(t ncu ig te . l n o , 4 S. 0 20 )Ripah Bd o v r os rh l v.4 7 3d 9 4h k Ci. 0 6 9 nio v. ra hv 2 9F.d6 (t Ci. 0 1, n M a irel v. u r9 F.d2 5(t Ci. r 2 0 ) Mo s n Garc t, 3 3 48 4h r 2 0 ) a d cailo S mne, 73 2 9 4h r . 1 9 ) Th c ut as rviwe O' nev. tt o S a a z 48 U. 3 2(98 ) b tdveg di terve o 9 2 . e o rs lo e e d Lo Esae f h b z , 2 S. 4 1 7 , u i re n h i iws f isr e nc Compa eW al,741F. at500n.3- 4, ih De ol 201 W L 1 t elva e. r l 3d 1 1 w t pa a, 2 077678 a # , t 4. c hange i taegover ng 1w doesnotam ountt ext nl ni a o raozdi r cz sanceson isow n. See na y icum t t D owel,993 F. at48;St hens 977 F. at*2;M cl ht 726 F. at336;Ben H urCons . l 2d e on, 2d vni , 2d t Co. 116 F. D .at284.H ere,t Folr h Ci ui hasnote i , R. he zt rc t xpezenced a groundbr ng change il eaki r t e l w;t a i a n oft lw by fa Fou t Cic ztsmpl va id i t s t sm i r c s s l a he pplc do a he a l e r h r ti i y re n he e wo i l a e . a The couz alo i s t s s wayed by ofae sgri nt hough notconcl i -consdet l t i lica -t usve i adons s h as , uc manti ngt fnaiyofDe ol7j i ani he i lt pa as udgme e ee byt dititc z a af me byt nt ntrd he stc ou t nd X d he Fourt Cic tneary tueeyea a A ddii l t Fourt Cicli panelci nots h r ui l l rs go. tonaly, he h r at ld ugges W al t l h drto cieefc, c wo l bezq ie f rDe oat s c e do l sRue6 $)mo o . a er a t fe twhih ud e urd o pa l o u c e n a l 0 v i d ns D epaol hasnotof e a zeas t s a f red ny ons o uppot t ext aor na rei he s t he t di ry lef eeks ot t t her han he Fourt Ci c tsdecii i W al The cout i noti i t reopen a l cosed cas bas on t h r ui7 son n l. ts nclned o ong l e ed he is s uance ofa decii t a i t s e1w t dif ent al tsm iar s soff s a re hed s on hat ppled he am a o fer , bei i l , et act nd ac a contarytes t r ul. M or eover t f sstz , he act tt oundi D epaol scl m ss ng a' li ugges a l ofwilngnesst com pl t ack li o y wih RO SP ofki sta was notptes i W al' ca U nlke W al w ho had no c r ove hi t f al lat ent n ls se. i l, ontol r s cic s a r um t ncesand atem pt t com pl wih V D O C polc D epaol admis t r fng W ade' t ed o y t iy, a t o ebufi s r eques sdes t w ar ngs t t contaryand pos son ofr i ousie s Com plancei t pie ni o he t ses i elgi t m . i s pat ul l necess y f t s et ofpts rsand of ii si se egadon,a ci dnguihe t dc ary ar or he af y ione fcal n gr nd ls s s he f aalcicum s ancesunde l ng D epaol sand W al' cl m s actz r t ryi a' ls oi . Alhough t cour i s pat i t D epaol sar ent ,he hasnotdem onstat t t t he t s ym hetc o a' gum s t ed hat he is nc o W al mo n st e ta t ia ycru tn e j d yn rl f nd rRue6 9 6.The sua e f la u t o xro dn r ic msa c s us fig ei u e l 0 $() e cour w ilnotas ta pr er t l set ef ence bet ween t Fourt Cicui pa s de s onsw hen D e a' wo h r t nel' cii paol s 5TheFourhCicui pa i W alr f e e Depaol' c eandw a awa eoft c s 'si iaii , ye silc e t r t neln l eernc d as as s r he a es m lrtes t tl hos nott dic st rtoaci a ia lt ofisde si See7 F. a 496n. Rer aci t c nnotbe o s us he er tve pplc biiy t ci on. 41 3d t 4. to tviy a p eu d a dwo dn ti l a pyh r gve ta b t W alsa dDe ol'j d me t rle o tesme1w rs me , n ul o l y p l ee i n h t 0h l n pa as u g ns eid n h a a ke ' a piddifrnl Se Brwnv Mi h l, 9 F. 8 5 8 7(t Ci.1 7 )(( hed cso t b a pid p l fbe t e y. e o . t el5 8 2d 3 , 3 4h r 9 9 (T1 eiin o e p le c t nonr toaci l mus et bls ane prnci eoflw,et byovenulng ce rpatpr c nto whih ltga s er tvey t sa ih w i pl a iher i la s e ede n c ii nt mayhaver i ...orb de di a is offrti e sonwho r s u i wasnotcla l f e hado e ..' eled, y ci ng n sue is mpr s i se e olton e ry or s w d..' (u tn Che rnei Co v Hu o , 0 U. 9 ,1 '1 71:. q oig vo o l . . s n 4 4 S. 7 06(9 ) 8 ca m s ha be n t t ughl r vi we by bot t sc ta t c tofa a s Be a e D e ol li ve e ho o y e e d h hi our nd he our ppe l. c us pa a ha n tme h sbzd nu d rRu e6 q 6, i mo o t atrt jd me t t d n e . s o t i t e n e l 0 $() hs d n o le he u g n mus be e id r D epaol s d be t ured by ' O C' setl entagz m enti W alt any f urepolci wih a houl eass VD S tem ee n l hat ut i es t sncert z r ent ts lnotbebas s el upon a r r m entt t i at s i iy equiem s fhal ed ol y equie hat he nm e how a pos s on ofa t bl t i ouspr t pet ai ng t t M usi f ih. W al,N o.7: c 00191, ses i angi e elgi opery t ni o he lm at ' ' l 11- v- a * ( . Va Apr 1 2 4) t 3 W D. . . 0, 01 . I t sc s , ve,t c ur i notwii t ditr isownj me ,nott toft n hi a e howe t he o t s lng o sub t l udg nt ha he c u to a pe l. eeo e De oasmo int atrt jd me t tfi Ac o cn l, o t f p asTh zf z, pa l' t o l he u g n mus al c rl gy o e . i De l' mot t atrt j me wilbeDEN I Ana opraeo de wilbee ee paoas bn o le he udg nt l ED. ppr it z r l ntrd. Entrd:J y7,2 5 ee ul 01 / /- 4D r /. &-r ' % + r 4 2. Mi chaelF.U r ki bans UntdSae Ditit ud e i tts stc l g e 9
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
