Parker v. Aylor et al, No. 7:2011cv00130 - Document 23 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 06/20/2011. (kab)

Download PDF
rlFRK' OFFI U. DI COURT S CE S. SX AT RCANOKE, VA FlEt t3 J UN I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI O F V I G I I CT R N A RO AN O K E DI SI N VI O M I A EL STEPH O N PAR K ER , CH 221 1 JULA C. R E ,CL I ' ' 7' ERK BY; DeP CLERK C I I A CTI N N O .7: V L O 11CV 0013 0 Pl ntif ai f , M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI VS. FLOYD G. AYLOR , AL , ZI By:Sa e G. i o mu l W l n s U ni ed St esD i tri Judge t at s ct D ef endant s. Pl i if M i ha St phon Pa ke ,a i a e pr ce di pr s tl d t s a ton pur ua t a ntf c el e r r n nm t o e ng o e, i e hi c i s n t 42U. C.j 1 o S. 983. I hi j 1 3 c ant Pakercai t tt defnda s i vi l a n s 98 ompli , r l ms ha he e nt,ndi duas t Ce r Vigni Regi J i (û ntal r i a onal al i CVRJ', vevi ae hi consiutonalrg sby no pe ti ' ha oltd s tt i iht ) t nnitng al t M usi i t s a CVRJ t c e t f J h1 c e tona pr ye , r ga dl s of l he lm nma e t o ongr ga e or uma ongr gai l a r e r es s c iy l ve . He cl i s t thi r lgi r uie hi t co r ga e f J a w ih a l o he e urt e l a m ha s e i on eq r s m o ng e t or um h t 1 t r M usi i tsa CVRJsmula lm nmae t i tneousy,butt j i wilno pe ti t ofdifr nts c iy l he al l t nni nmaes fe e e urt lve s t pa tci t t he . Pa ke saes t t t de enda s pe m i i t s of dif r t e l o ri pa e oget r r r t t ha he f nt r t nma e fe en s urt l ve st c ec iy e l o ongr t f ot rr s ,s h as s c c l a c r a n cl s e . The c s i ega e or he ea ons uc i k a l nd e t i a s s ae s c re ty b f r t e c u t o Pak rs moin fr a p ei n r ij ci n ( u rn l e o e h o r n r e ' to o r l ay nun to ECF No.2 ) mi 2 rq e tn ta t ec u t n on o t rLt Ak r fo h r si P r e b tknghsp a e r , e u si g h t h o r e j i fke . e s r m aa sng a k r y a i i ry r ug he e d he our oncl s w hi h Pa ke s a es ha oc r d t e tm es2 Upon r viw oft r cor , t c tc ude c r r tt s cur e hr e i . e e lThe c tnot st tt r a e aler tve s li f t Frda pr ye sknown, our e ha he e r t na i pe lngs or he i y a r a ong m ot na e ,asJ her m s umudh,J 'h,J a a J ua Thecour adopt t s li i pl ntf sCompl nt-l a a um a um h nd um h. t s he pelng n ai if ai -um h. 2I s n uppor oft s alega i , Par atc sva iusim at rque tf m sandot doc e st hi t he e l tons ker ta he ro n e e s or her um nt o s m o i How e r Par doesnotexpli i hi m o i how t ealege i i nt aer l edt hi undel ng ton. ve , ker an n s ton hes l d ncde s r eat o s ryi J a cl i . um h a m t ti mu td n t smoin f ritro uo y ij n tv r l f Ho v r te c u t l s r e ha t s e y hi to o n el c tr n u ci e ei . we e , h o r wil e v e Pa ke ' unde l ng compli on t de enda sby s pa a eor r r rs ryi a nt he f nt e r t de . Anitro uo y ij nci ni n t p r p it wh nt eh r c mpan do d e n t n el c tr nu to s o a p o rae e h am o lie f o s o a iefom t ha m alege i t compli . OmegaW ord Tr velv. A,111F. l 1 rs r he r l d n he ant l a TW 3d 4, 6 (t Ci.1 .(t- pur eofitrm e tbl rle i t pr t tt mo n , i t 4h r 997) t-he pos nei quia e eif s o oec he va t durng he l pe nc oft a ton,f om bei ha m e orf t rha m e i t m a nde y he c i r ng r d urhe r d n he nneri w hi h t m ova n c he nt c n e d iwa o wil eh r dtr ug t eilg lyalg di t ec mplit' .ûAJ o tn s t s r l b ame h o h h l ai l e n h o an .) I e t e ' g p ei n r ij n to ma n ve is et p e e t n ij r o h r whc n t ve temo i g r l ay n u cin y e r su o rv n a nu y r a m ih o e n h v n mi pat c e wasca e byt wr came i t undel ng a ton. L .s aloDe e ry ontnds us d he ong li d n he ryi ci ' 4. ee s vos ' , v He nco 4 F.d4 0, 71(t Ci.1 9 )(ap rymo igf rap ei n ij n to . ni t n, 2 3 7 4 8h r 9 4 ( a t vn o rlmi ry n u cin ( mu t e e s rl etb ihar lto hpbewe nt ij r came i t p rysmo ina dt e s n c sa i sa ls eains i t e he n u y li d n he a t' to n h y c onduc a sre i t c ant' Pake ' cai t tLtAkest hi pr ye r i not t se td n he ompli .). r rs l m ha . r ook s a r ug s r l e t hi cai i hi t de l ng lws tt tdef nt vi a e hi rghtt c e t wih eatd o s l m n s m ryi a ui ha enda s olt d s i o ongr ga e t al ot rM us i i a e f J a r ga dl s ofs e iy l ve . Pa ke doesnotna e Lt Ake l he lm nm t s or um h, e r e s e urt e l r r m . r asa d e nti hi compl i a Par rdoe no c am t tt alege pr ye nz i i n ha ef nda n s ant nd ke s t l i ha he l d a r g ncde t s anyr a i hi t hi pa tci ton i J a ort defnda s'r f alt pe ti aesof eltons p o s ri pa i n um h o e nt e us o nni nm t dif r nts urt lvest c egae f J a Furhe ,Pa ke doesno cli t tt fe e ec iy e l o ongr t or um h. t r r r t a m ha he cons iutonalvi a i a l ged i hi t de l ng J a cl i ca e Lt Aker t c i c t hi tt i ol tons le n s m r yi um h a m us d . s o onfs a e s Prayerrug. Assae , c u ts u sap ei n r ij n to i alws toprs r et esau q o ttd a o r is e r l ay n u cin n a uit e e v h tt s u mi a pr ventir pa abl ha m untlt c t a oppor u t t r e on t l w s tsm e is nd e re r e r i he our has n t niy o ul he a ui' r t . De e 42F. a 47l Pake ' moi f i el ut yij tver ifhasnot ngt do vos , 3d t . r rs ton or ntroc or n unci ele hi o wihpr s vi t sausquobewe nt pa te wihrga dt Pake ' j 1 c antTo t eer ng he tt t e he ris t e r o r rs 983 ompli . 2 t c r r Pa ke ' i tntmoton i bas on new as e tonsofmite t ntt ta ee ie y he onta y, r r s nsa i s ed s ri sr a me ha r ntr l dif r ntfom t c am r s d a t r ifr q se i hi J a l ws t The ene fe e r he l i aie nd he ele e ue t d n s um h a ui. s w a s ri nsm i s s e to ght uppor a s pa a e c a m a i tdi f r ntpr s n ofi i l i a s pa a e l w s t t e r t l i ga ns f e e i o tc a s n e r t a ui, ' h we e,h yc n o p o d t eb ssf rap ei n r ij n to i t i lws i. o v r te a n t r vie h a i o r l a y n u cin n h s a ut mi Ae o d n l t c ur wil e yplitf smoin frap ei n r ij n to c r i gy,he o t ld n an if to o r l ay nu cin. mi The c er w ils nd a c oft s or ra t a com pa ng m em or ndum opi o t l k l e opy hi de nd he c nyi a ni n o , pli if antf. ENTER: il dyo Jn, 0 1 Ths u a f u e2 1 . zrunie St t D i ti tJ t d a es sr c udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.