Fields v. Mathena, No. 7:2011cv00001 - Document 27 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/05/2011. (kab)

Download PDF
CL S OFFI U.S.DI . ERK' CE ST COURY AT ROANOKE, V ' A FlEi k a I THE U N I N TED STA TES DI STRI CO URT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF V I GI A CT R NI R OAN O KE D I I ON V SI RU BEN TRAV I FI S ELD S, Pettoner, ii R . M ATH EN A , C. Re po n . s nde t ) ) ) ) ) ) ) 2CT 25 2 1 21 J A C. DL ULI D EY BY; , Ci lAci No.7: 1 vi ton 1 CV00001 M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI By: Hon.GlnE.Conr e ad Chi Unie SttsDiti J ef td ae srct udge Peii rRube Tr vi Fil ,aVigi a i t p oc e ngpr K ,fl ape ii f ttone n a s eds r ni nma e r e di o ied tton or wrto ha scopusunde 28U. C.j225 c le ngt vai t ofhi c ci i t i f bea r r S. 4, halngi he ldiy s onvitons n he Ci c tCour ofW a hi t Count Vi g ni By m e or ndlm opi on a o de e e ed M a r ui t s ng on y, r i a. m a z ni nd r r nt r y 1 , 01 ,h c u t imis dtepeiin fn igta t eVign ac u t' du iaino Fil s 8 2 1 t e o r ds se h tto , dn h t h r ii o rs a j dc t f ed ' o s fc e y oft e de e and i f e tve as it nc ofc uf i i nc he vi nc ne f c i s s a e ouns c ai sdi no i ve a el l m d t nvol n urr as bl a i ai ofcea l e t bls f e allw ora unr as bl detr i to of le ona e pplc ton l ry sa ihed ed r a n e ona e e m nai n t f c s The c ta s f m d t tFi l 'r m a ni cl i sw e e pr e aly de a t d. Fi l he a t . our l o ot ha e ds e i ng a m r oc dur l f ule e ds hasnow t l d a m o i f r co i r t o w hi h t c ur c t esasbe ng br htptr ua ie ton or e ns de a i n, c he o t ons nz i oug ls nt t Rul 59()oft Fe rlRul ofCi lPr ed e*Fo t f lwi r a ons t moton o e e he dea es vi oc ur . r he olo ng e s ,he i w ilbe de e l ni d. Rue5 ()p r t ac u toatro a nda u g n .S eFe . Crm P. 9 e .Th l 9 e emis o r t l r me j d me t e d R. i 5 () e e Unie S a e Cour ofAppea s f t Fourh Cic thasr cog z d t e g o td t t s t l or he t r ui e ni e hr e r undsf a e ng or m ndi aj gmen unde t sr e:$1 t a co ud t r hi ul ç() o c mmodaea itr e ngcha i c r lngl ( t t n ne v ni nge n ontoli aw;2) o a o frne e de eno a ia ea til o ()t c r tacea er of1 orprve cc unt o w vi nc t valbl t ra' r 3 o orec l r ror aw , e nt ma ie tij sie' Pa .n . . Am. tl r ls Co,1 F.d3 6 4 3( t Ci.1 9 ) n fs nu tc . c l s Co v. Na'Fie n . . 48 3 9 , 0 4h r 9 8 . ' *Fil ' tonwa tmey fldu e Rul 5 e . eds mo i s i l ie nd r e 9() l t i tntc s Fil m oton f ist s if a oft t e g ol f r le unde n he nsa a e, e ds' i a l o atsy ny he hr e r mds or ei f r Rul 59() Heha notctda rc ntc ngei t c toli lw, wl dico rd e e. s ie ny e e ha n he onr lng a ne y s vee e de e,o cla er t tmeisa aleai ora ndme t t c tsprvi j vi nc r e r ror ha rt n trton me nto he our' e ous udgme . nt Tot e e Fil m e ey s e t r ii t m atr t twe e de i d a s yt hi , ele he xt nt e ds r l e ks o eltgae te s ha r c de dverel o m r if i u a i b eu d rRue5 () Se Pa .n . ,1 8F.da 4 3 l a ye e th vig s n val l n e l 9 e . e c I s Co. 4 3 t 0 . n n v n , a n a r viwedt m o i a t pe tne pori nsoft r cor t c tr mai c nc t thi e e he ton nd he ri nt to he e d, he our e ns onvi ed ha s ha a c r pe ii n waspr ry di m i s d. Fort s r s ns t de e nts m oton f r be s o pus tto ope l s s e he e ea o , he f nda ' i o r o i e a i n m us be de e ec ns d r to t ni d. The Cl r i die t d t s nd c r ii copi s oft sm e o a e k s r c e o e e tted e hi m r ndum opi on a t ni nd he ac o pa ng o de t t pe ii ra c ns o r or f t r s c m nyi r r o he ttone nd ou el f ec d or he e ponde . nt ENTER: i 5 t/ d y o Oco e , 01 . Th s a f tb r 2 1 Chi fU nied St t D i t i tJ e t a es s rc udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.