Jones v. Applebee's of Virginia, Inc., No. 7:2010cv00339 - Document 35 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 8/5/2011. (eot)

Download PDF
CLERKS OFFI U..DI O URT CE S ST. ATROANOKE, VA FI LED I TH E UN I N TED STATES DI STR I C O U RT CT FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STRI T O F VI G I A C R NI RO A N O K E DIVISION CAM I LLE A .JO N ES, AU 15 2 1 6 21 JUL . A BY: gCL ERK ' W C C i lA ct on N o.7: cv-00339 vi i 10- Pl nt f , ai i f M EM O M N D U M O PI I N N O V. APPLEBEE ' OF V I G I I ,I C . S R N A N , By:Sam ue G . is l W l on Unied St es Di t ctJudge t at s ri Defendant . Thi i a a ton bypr s pl ntf ,Ca il A . one ,a i the f m e e pl r s s n ci o e ai i f m le J s ga ns r or r m oye , Ap lb eso Vigna I c (Ap lb e s' algngta h rma a e a Ap lb es p e e ' f r ii, n .i p e e ''7 l i h t e n g r t p e e ' d ) e dic i i t a r t laed a i the ,a ha a s d he ,i vi ai ofTil Vl oft Ci l s rm naed nd e ai t ga ns r nd r s e r n ol ton te l he vi Ri t Ac of1 42U. C.j 00e, s q.Alhoug t ti i c r l she edt begi ghs t 964, S. 20 et e t h he ral s urenty c dul o n i l st n t r e w e ks, onesf ie t a t nd eihe ofhe s he e de ii a di not n es ha h e e J a ld o te t r r c dul d postons nd d rs n t Ap lb e s d s o r rq e t o moinf rs mmayj d me t Th c u t id epo d o p e e '' ic vey e u ss r t o u r u g n . e o r fn s o t tJ neshasf ie t m e ngf l e ge i t ltga i s fl a i tAppl be s a ha o a l d o ani uly nga n he ii ton he ied ga ns e e' , nd dimis shermotonunde Fe r lRul ofCi lPr ce ur (1 e' 3 s se i r de a e vi o d e i ' 7. Rul ) 1. Ba e on unco r di t d e d nc s bm it d by Appl e' a a s i s on f o sd nt a c e vi e e u te ebe s nd ubm s i r m J ones f nue a t ne Te y G rm es J s f ie t r s ' o r tor y, n' i , one a l d o e pond t Appl be sdi c r r quess o e e' s ove y e t , ort a t e t rofhe t o s hed e de ii . Gr m es c r pondenc w ih t c t o tend ihe r w c ul d postons i ' or es e t he our s st tJ ne l s co m uni a e w ih Gr m e ofi e, hr h hi pa a e l o M a 6, 1 how ha o s a t m c t d t i s' fc t oug s r l ga , n y 201 . A tt tm e,Jones i or ed Gr m es'par egalt she w asgoi t vi i herparent i Texas hat i nf m i al hat ng o st sn untlJ 6, 1 J i une 201 . onesdi no a t nd he J 7,2011 d poston, t co tgr nt d d t te r une e ii and he ur a e K Grme 'm oto t wihdr w asJ s at r y a trhepr de t cour wih he l tknown i s in o t a one ' to ne fe ovi d he t t r as a e s The Cl r sof i s ntno i e ofGrm e 'w ihdr ddr s . e k' fce e tc i s t awal o J s'a es . Appl be s t one ddr s e e' s hed e a s c c ul d e ond de ii ofJ ne f J 27, 20l1 a s ntnotc t J pos ton o s or une ' dr s ' , nd e i e o ones ad es J onesf ie t a a a he s co de ii a s pr vi d no r s f he a e e t a l d o ppe r t r e nd poston, nd he o de ea on or r bs nc o Applbeesort c t Applbe st nmove f s e ' he our. e e' he d or ummayj me ,i pa tbe a eof r udg nt n r, c us J s'r f a t e ge i t di c r pr e s A p e e' s ntJ s Ros bo o no i e one e us l o nga n he s ove y oc s . pl be s e one e r tc i o mi gJ n so h rrg t ofl ars o s t i moi nfrs mmayj g n a t a ç if nfr n o e f e ih t i e p n e o t to o u r ud me t nd h tt l e s l (hedi notfl ar pons t Cour coul dimis( jlws tont ba i of't moi fr s dj ie es e,he t d s s her a ui he ss is ton o s mmayj dg n .( sbo oNo ie1 ECF No. 3. J n sfie t r s o .Ap lbe ' h s u r u me t Ro e r tc , 3 ) o e ald o e p nd pe es a a k dtec u tor l o ismoi nfrs mmayj d me twi o tah aig. s e h o r t ue n t to o u r u g n t u e rn h I I. J sha f ie t m e ni uly pa tcpaei t dic r pr e sofhe c e. She one s al d o a ngf l rii t n he s ove y oc s r as m i s d he t o s he ed de ii w iho e a ton,a f l d t r s s e r w c dul postons t ut xpl na i nd aie o e pond Appl be s e e' i erog t i wihoute a ton.Unde Rul 37( , pa t ma bes nci frf l et nt r aores t xplnai r e d)a ry y a toned o aiur o a t nd isown de ii a f f iur t r pond t di c r r ue t . The cou tl te t pos ton nd or a l e o es o s ove y eq s s r ookst t o he f l ngfco si deer ni a a opraes nci t 1 whehert no compl ngpa t olowi a tr n t mi ng n ppr it a ton:t ) t he n( yi ry a tdi b dfih ( )tea n o p eu ieta n n o inc c u e tea v ray ( )te ce n a at , 2 h mou t f rj dc h t o c mpl e a s d h d es r , 3 h a ne df dee rnc oft pa tculrs tofnon-ompla e, nd( whehe ls dr tc e or tre e he ri a or c inc a 4) t r e s asi s i woul ha be e f tve ' And r on v. und. orA d nc m e .Educ. Em p' of mwtons d ve en f ec i .' es Fo f va e nt & t Am.I ans 15 F. 500,504( hCi.1 ) Appl ngt st tt c r fndst tdimis ndi , 5 3d 4t r 998 . yi hi es,he ou t i ha s sal o J s c ai s a i tAppl be si t onl a o i t r m ed f one ' l m ga ns e e' s he y ppr pr a e e y. 1Grm e al o m o f a e e i oftm et r s i s s ved or n xt ns on i o e pond t Appl be s dic ' r que t bec e ofJ s o e e' ' s ovel e s s aus y one a enc f o t a e The c tga J s a ext i n untl une 27,2011t r po Ba e on t bs e r m he r a. our ve one n ens o iJ o es nd. s d he unc r dit r pr s nttonsby Appl e',s nev rs onta ced e e e ai ebe s he er e ponde d. Bec us ofJ ne sl ei t sc s f t pas s ve a mont , heco tpr s sba a e o s' ienc n hi a e or he t e r l hs t ur e ume d fi 2 Furhennore, Ap e esha b e p eu ie b J n s sln ea ih sbe nf re t at h. t plbe ' s e n rj dc d y o e ' ie c s t a e o c d o pr pa e f ti lw ihou ha ng de ed t pl ntf orr ce ve a di c r f om he . W ih e r or r a t t vi pos he ai i f e i d ny s ove y r r t t i l s t n t e w e ksa a A ppl bee s c nnotbe f c t de e a ac i w he e i ha ral e s ha hr e e w y, e ' n or ed o f nd n ton r t s bee c n omplt l de edt opporuniy t obt i dic r fom t pl ntf. Be a eJ e ey ni he t t o an s ove y r he ai if c us onesi s i nor ng he s t t c tc l otc a t n a o i t l s e s nc i Thus dim i s li t g i r ui, he our a m r f a ppr pr a e e s r a ton. , s s a s he onl a o i t r edy - J s s ta i tA p e e' c y ppr pr a e em one ' ui ga ns pl be s annotc i w ih J ne c pl t l ontnue t o s om e e y de ng i t r g t t tt m e is ofhe c s . The ef e, he c tdi m i s J s'c a m s nyi t he i ht o es he r t r ae r or t our s s es one l i . ' z .y ' . ,. Ent Augus 5,2011. er: t .' .* . . .. . ... ..' v> . >' .' .* .. .'' '. , , a< .' e 1 .* f, , .'' a. .. c ' . '' . .' .' TED STATES D I STRI J D GE CT U 2J onesmay, ofcoure,fl am otonf r consde ain wiht cour unde Rul 59. l an m oton f s ie i or e i r to t he t r e n y i or r co i r ton,J e nsde ai oness dexpli t r s f rhera enc a he de ii a f l et rs houl an he ea ons o bs e t r postons nd aiur o e pondt o Applbe swrte dic el e e' itn s ov y.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.