Tawalbeh v. USA, No. 7:2000cv00858 - Document 28 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 07/24/2012. (kab)
Download PDF
rL ERKS OFFI U, Dt PGURT CE S. ST. A- FOAhCKE, r F J I VA (; pg ;$ r) I TH E U N I N TED STATE S D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R T H E W E STER N D I STR I O F VI G I I CT R N A ROANOKE DI I ON V SI FA H ED T.TA W AL BEH , UNITED STATE S O F A M ER I A C ) ) ) ) ) ) JUL - 2 1 22 JULA C t i' ( CL .' ERK , BY; D U'Y CLERK F C i lAc i N o.7: v00858 vi t on 00: M EM O R AN D U M O PI IO N N By:Sam uelG .W ison l U nie St e D i t i tJudge t d at s s r c Fa T.Tawabeh,af r i t pr ee ngpr s fl amoton ( ke No.27) hed l edeal nmae oc di o e, ied i Doc t purua tt Rul 60( oft Fe r lRul ofCi lPr ed e s ki t va ae t sc ts s n o e b) he de a es vi oc ur ee ng o c t hi our' Fe ua y 22,2002 or r de ng hi m o i t va a e s ta i or c r ts nt nc pur ua t br r de nyi s ton o c t , e s de, or ec e e e s nt o 28U. C.j2255.Thec ttndst tTa l h' i t n motoni,oralit nsa pur e , S. our i ha wabe s nsa t i s f l n e t nd poss a u a to ie s c e sv j2 5 mo ina d,h rf r , imis siwih u p eu ie n n uh rz d, u c s ie 2 5 to n t eeo e d s s e t t o t rj dc . I 1 98 a traj r til t e c u tc n itd Ta le o s v r lo sv r lo fn e n 9 , fe u y ra, h o r o vce wab h f e ea f e e a fe s s a ii outoft bum i ofa c rsng he ng ompeio ' so ewih a C ol ov Coc al' Ta abe a aed tt r s t r t d ot M kt i. w l h ppe l ' a t Unie St t s Cour of Appe s f t Foulh Cic t afimed hi c c i a nd he td ae t al or he ' t r ui fr s onviton nd s ntnc l 2000,Ta be fldaj2255moto whiht c tdimis d.Se Ci lAci e e e. n wal h ie in, c he our s se e vi ton No.7: v00858 ( s se Fe 22,2002 . l 2007,Ta l h fl amoto t rduc hi 00c dimisd b. ) n wabe ied in o e e s sntnc purua t 1 U. C.j 358 c ( ,whih t c tc tue a dimis d as a e e e s nt o 8 S. 2()2) c he our onsr d nd s se s c svej2255moton.Se Ci lAci No.7: v001 ( s s e Apr 9,2007) OnJ y uc esi i e vi ton 07c 45 dimis d . . ul 11 201 Ta be fl t i tntmoton i hi 2000 cl e j2255 a ton,agui t tt , 2, wal h ied he nsa i n s os d ci r ng ha he c ts dva t isor rdimisnghi j2255acin be us Ta l hhasdic rdnew our houl cae t de s si s to ca e wabe s ovee e denc a t r ha bee a s t ntve c ng i t l w . vi e nd he e s n ubsa i ha e n he a l I. TheFe a RulsofCi lPr edue,i l ngRul 60( ,goven cvi a tonsfld i derl e vi oc r ncudi e b) r i l ci ie n f r ldititcours t h r e ,desgne t gove n ltgai ofci la tons do nota ede a src t. d suc ul s i d o r ii ton vi c i , nd c n o p o ie a t rt f r atc i o o e tr ig a ci na j dg n . Uni d Sae v. n n t r vd uho i o ta kng r v ru nn y rmi l u me t' ' t tts e M e i a, os 5: r c N . 04CR 0001 5: 1 80375,2011 U . D i t LEXI 1 5, 1 CV S. s . S 44998,2011 W L 6325881 , a * ( . Va.De 1 2011 ,s as Unie Stt v.Ber e ,421F.App' 292,293 ( h t 2 W D. c. 6, ) ee lo td aes . nir x 4t Ci.2011 (t'e Fe r l Rul of Ci lPr e e do notpr de a vehi e by whih g r ) Cf -h de a es vi oc dur ovi cl c a deenda lma c le hi crmi j f nt y halnge s i naludgme .) Tot se aS e60( moi t ts e nt' . hi nd, k ' Rul b) ton ha e ks t rv staj d me tds si g a j 2 5 a to a wih u me i s o l b ds s e a a o e ii u g n imisn 2 5 cin s t o t rt h u d e imis d s s ce sve ha s pe ii t pr ven def nt f om usng s a m oton t cic ve tt r e uc s i bea tton o e t enda s r i uch i o r um n he ul a i ts c sve j2255 a tonsi j2255( . M eia,2011U. Dit LEXI 1 gans uc esi ci n h)' rc ' S. s. S 44998 2011 , W L 6325881 at*2 ( tng Go ae v.Cr by,545 U. 5 53132 ( , cii nz lz os S. 24, - 2005). ûsi lry,a ) t mial m oton whi h s ks t a i c ee o dvanc one orm or s t ntve c a m s a l gedl om it d fom t i ta e e ubs a i l i le y te r he nii l j2255moin ort s tne evi nc o a g n i s to o ubmi w de e r r ume t n uppor ofadam r ie i t prorj t i as d n he i 2255 moi mus as be c tued a dimis d a ane s c sve j 2255 moin. Lz ton t lo onsr nd s se s w, uc esi to ' 4 ' ( tngGonz e 545U. a 5 32) Howe r nota1Rul 60( motonsma bec tue a cii alz, S. t 31- . ve , 1 e b) i y onsr d s as ce svej2255moton. M o es i al whe aRul 60( moton atc t c ltrl uc si i r pecic ly, n e b) i ta ks he olaea r e pr es i a j2255 pr ee ng ( cvi pr e ng) a oppos d t t s tnceoft eviw oc s n oc di a i l oce di , s e o he ubsa he f de alc ts r s uton ofa c am on t m e is t n t m o i may notbe co tued a a e r our' e ol i li he rt, he he ton nsr s s ce sve j 2255 moton. Gonzaez,5 U. a 532.Unie Stt v.W i soc 340 F.d uc si i l 45 S. t , td aes ne t k, 3 200, ( hCi. ) 207 4t r 2003 . Ta l h ad nce t a gume si hi Rul 6 b)moi net rofwhih algea wabe va s wo r nt n s e 0( ton, ihe c le de e t i t ci lc l t a r vi w pr s . l t a bot of hi a gum e s e t r ad es t f c n he vi ola er l e e oce s ns e d, h s r nt ihe dr s he 2 meisofhi pro j 2255 camsorwee omitd fo hi prorj 2255 cli . Unde eihe rt s ir li r te rm s i ams r t r s nai a r r es ofSl hae rtteort s ( wal hlatc st hi c rntmoton,i ce ro, nd egadl s swl tve il wit Ta be ta he o s ure i t i ce rt a hi itn in i t o ti rle fo te ci n l ud me ta ans hi ' Me ia s la h t s n e to s o ban eif r m h rmia j g n g i t m. rc , ' 201lU. Dit LEXI 1 S. s. S 44998,2011W L 6325881 a * Ass Rul 60( oft Fe r , t 2. uch, e b) he deal Rul s of Ci lPr e e f is t s y hi w ih t a hort f t r m edy t t he s e i e vi oc dur a l o uppl m t he ut iy or he e ha e ks n t sci nala ton.Ta l h' Rul 60( moto mus,t eor bec tu byt sc t hi rmi ci wabe s e b) in t herf e, onsr ed hi our as as c svej2255moton. uc esi i Thi c tma c i ras ce svej2255motononl upons ci cc rii ton fom s our y onsde uc si i y pe t e ttcai r i t U nie St t Cour of Appe s f t Fourh Cicui t t c ai s i t m o i m e t he t d a es t al or he t r t hat he l m n he ton e c ti ciei 28 U. C.j 2255(9. AsTa l h ha nots te any e denc ofs h eran rtra. S. 1 wabe s ubmitd vi e uc cetfc ton by t Cour o Appe l, t c tmus dimist i tn j 2255 moi as riiai he tf as1 he our t s s he nsa t ton s uccessve. i 2 1 11. Fort r as saed,t c tc t esTa l h' moton a a j2255 moton a he e ons tt he our onsnl wabe s i s i nd N z.' s' di m i s s i ass ce s ve. s s e t uc s i ENTER: hs h d yo Jl, 0 2 'i r z/ a f uy 2 1 . n' St t D i ti J a es sr ct udge 'I f c , t scour r ceved notc on M ach 31 2008 t tt Unied Stt Cour ofAppeal deni Ta l s n a t hi te i ie r , ha he t aes t s ed wabeh' rq etfrp r sint fl as c esv j2 5moin.S eDo k t 2 e u s o emiso o ie u c sie 25 t o e c e No. 6. 2Peii ri he e a s oft pr dur f obt ni c tfc i fom t U nied St e Cour ofAppe s ttone s r by dvied he oce e or ai ng eriiaton r he t ats t al f t Fourh Cic tt havet scour r viw as e sve j2255 moton. Pe ii rmus s m i acopy oft or he t r ui o hi t e e ucc s i i ttone t ub t he s c esv j2 5 moint teCo r ofAp e l, ln wi amoinrq etn atrej d epa e c riiain u csie 2 5 to o h u t p as ao g t h to e u sig h e -u g n l e t cto f ta t dsrc c u tma rve tes c e sv j2 55moin S e2 U. C.j2 44 (sa n e ,1 9 ) A h t he itit o r y e iw h u c sie 2 to . e 8 S. 2 a me d d 9 6. Fourh Cic tf m and i tuci f flng t sm o i w ilbe i ude wih t snotc orae a lbl fo t t rui or nsr tons or ii hi ton l ncl d t hi ie r vaia e r m he Fourh Cic ta t f lw i addr s O fk eoft Clr Unied Stt Co tofAppe sf t Fourh Cic t t r ui t he olo ng es : f he e k, t aes ur al or he t r ui, 900 E. ai St, c ond,VA 232 1 M n . Ri hm 9.