Tawalbeh v. USA, No. 7:2000cv00858 - Document 28 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 07/24/2012. (kab)

Download PDF
rL ERKS OFFI U, Dt PGURT CE S. ST. A- FOAhCKE, r F J I VA (; pg ;$ r) I TH E U N I N TED STATE S D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R T H E W E STER N D I STR I O F VI G I I CT R N A ROANOKE DI I ON V SI FA H ED T.TA W AL BEH , UNITED STATE S O F A M ER I A C ) ) ) ) ) ) JUL - 2 1 22 JULA C t i' ( CL .' ERK , BY; D U'Y CLERK F C i lAc i N o.7: v00858 vi t on 00: M EM O R AN D U M O PI IO N N By:Sam uelG .W ison l U nie St e D i t i tJudge t d at s s r c Fa T.Tawabeh,af r i t pr ee ngpr s fl amoton ( ke No.27) hed l edeal nmae oc di o e, ied i Doc t purua tt Rul 60( oft Fe r lRul ofCi lPr ed e s ki t va ae t sc ts s n o e b) he de a es vi oc ur ee ng o c t hi our' Fe ua y 22,2002 or r de ng hi m o i t va a e s ta i or c r ts nt nc pur ua t br r de nyi s ton o c t , e s de, or ec e e e s nt o 28U. C.j2255.Thec ttndst tTa l h' i t n motoni,oralit nsa pur e , S. our i ha wabe s nsa t i s f l n e t nd poss a u a to ie s c e sv j2 5 mo ina d,h rf r , imis siwih u p eu ie n n uh rz d, u c s ie 2 5 to n t eeo e d s s e t t o t rj dc . I 1 98 a traj r til t e c u tc n itd Ta le o s v r lo sv r lo fn e n 9 , fe u y ra, h o r o vce wab h f e ea f e e a fe s s a ii outoft bum i ofa c rsng he ng ompeio ' so ewih a C ol ov Coc al' Ta abe a aed tt r s t r t d ot M kt i. w l h ppe l ' a t Unie St t s Cour of Appe s f t Foulh Cic t afimed hi c c i a nd he td ae t al or he ' t r ui fr s onviton nd s ntnc l 2000,Ta be fldaj2255moto whiht c tdimis d.Se Ci lAci e e e. n wal h ie in, c he our s se e vi ton No.7: v00858 ( s se Fe 22,2002 . l 2007,Ta l h fl amoto t rduc hi 00c dimisd b. ) n wabe ied in o e e s sntnc purua t 1 U. C.j 358 c ( ,whih t c tc tue a dimis d as a e e e s nt o 8 S. 2()2) c he our onsr d nd s se s c svej2255moton.Se Ci lAci No.7: v001 ( s s e Apr 9,2007) OnJ y uc esi i e vi ton 07c 45 dimis d . . ul 11 201 Ta be fl t i tntmoton i hi 2000 cl e j2255 a ton,agui t tt , 2, wal h ied he nsa i n s os d ci r ng ha he c ts dva t isor rdimisnghi j2255acin be us Ta l hhasdic rdnew our houl cae t de s si s to ca e wabe s ovee e denc a t r ha bee a s t ntve c ng i t l w . vi e nd he e s n ubsa i ha e n he a l I. TheFe a RulsofCi lPr edue,i l ngRul 60( ,goven cvi a tonsfld i derl e vi oc r ncudi e b) r i l ci ie n f r ldititcours t h r e ,desgne t gove n ltgai ofci la tons do nota ede a src t. d suc ul s i d o r ii ton vi c i , nd c n o p o ie a t rt f r atc i o o e tr ig a ci na j dg n . Uni d Sae v. n n t r vd uho i o ta kng r v ru nn y rmi l u me t' ' t tts e M e i a, os 5: r c N . 04CR 0001 5: 1 80375,2011 U . D i t LEXI 1 5, 1 CV S. s . S 44998,2011 W L 6325881 , a * ( . Va.De 1 2011 ,s as Unie Stt v.Ber e ,421F.App' 292,293 ( h t 2 W D. c. 6, ) ee lo td aes . nir x 4t Ci.2011 (t'e Fe r l Rul of Ci lPr e e do notpr de a vehi e by whih g r ) Cf -h de a es vi oc dur ovi cl c a deenda lma c le hi crmi j f nt y halnge s i naludgme .) Tot se aS e60( moi t ts e nt' . hi nd, k ' Rul b) ton ha e ks t rv staj d me tds si g a j 2 5 a to a wih u me i s o l b ds s e a a o e ii u g n imisn 2 5 cin s t o t rt h u d e imis d s s ce sve ha s pe ii t pr ven def nt f om usng s a m oton t cic ve tt r e uc s i bea tton o e t enda s r i uch i o r um n he ul a i ts c sve j2255 a tonsi j2255( . M eia,2011U. Dit LEXI 1 gans uc esi ci n h)' rc ' S. s. S 44998 2011 , W L 6325881 at*2 ( tng Go ae v.Cr by,545 U. 5 53132 ( , cii nz lz os S. 24, - 2005). ûsi lry,a ) t mial m oton whi h s ks t a i c ee o dvanc one orm or s t ntve c a m s a l gedl om it d fom t i ta e e ubs a i l i le y te r he nii l j2255moin ort s tne evi nc o a g n i s to o ubmi w de e r r ume t n uppor ofadam r ie i t prorj t i as d n he i 2255 moi mus as be c tued a dimis d a ane s c sve j 2255 moin. Lz ton t lo onsr nd s se s w, uc esi to ' 4 ' ( tngGonz e 545U. a 5 32) Howe r nota1Rul 60( motonsma bec tue a cii alz, S. t 31- . ve , 1 e b) i y onsr d s as ce svej2255moton. M o es i al whe aRul 60( moton atc t c ltrl uc si i r pecic ly, n e b) i ta ks he olaea r e pr es i a j2255 pr ee ng ( cvi pr e ng) a oppos d t t s tnceoft eviw oc s n oc di a i l oce di , s e o he ubsa he f de alc ts r s uton ofa c am on t m e is t n t m o i may notbe co tued a a e r our' e ol i li he rt, he he ton nsr s s ce sve j 2255 moton. Gonzaez,5 U. a 532.Unie Stt v.W i soc 340 F.d uc si i l 45 S. t , td aes ne t k, 3 200, ( hCi. ) 207 4t r 2003 . Ta l h ad nce t a gume si hi Rul 6 b)moi net rofwhih algea wabe va s wo r nt n s e 0( ton, ihe c le de e t i t ci lc l t a r vi w pr s . l t a bot of hi a gum e s e t r ad es t f c n he vi ola er l e e oce s ns e d, h s r nt ihe dr s he 2 meisofhi pro j 2255 camsorwee omitd fo hi prorj 2255 cli . Unde eihe rt s ir li r te rm s i ams r t r s nai a r r es ofSl hae rtteort s ( wal hlatc st hi c rntmoton,i ce ro, nd egadl s swl tve il wit Ta be ta he o s ure i t i ce rt a hi itn in i t o ti rle fo te ci n l ud me ta ans hi ' Me ia s la h t s n e to s o ban eif r m h rmia j g n g i t m. rc , ' 201lU. Dit LEXI 1 S. s. S 44998,2011W L 6325881 a * Ass Rul 60( oft Fe r , t 2. uch, e b) he deal Rul s of Ci lPr e e f is t s y hi w ih t a hort f t r m edy t t he s e i e vi oc dur a l o uppl m t he ut iy or he e ha e ks n t sci nala ton.Ta l h' Rul 60( moto mus,t eor bec tu byt sc t hi rmi ci wabe s e b) in t herf e, onsr ed hi our as as c svej2255moton. uc esi i Thi c tma c i ras ce svej2255motononl upons ci cc rii ton fom s our y onsde uc si i y pe t e ttcai r i t U nie St t Cour of Appe s f t Fourh Cicui t t c ai s i t m o i m e t he t d a es t al or he t r t hat he l m n he ton e c ti ciei 28 U. C.j 2255(9. AsTa l h ha nots te any e denc ofs h eran rtra. S. 1 wabe s ubmitd vi e uc cetfc ton by t Cour o Appe l, t c tmus dimist i tn j 2255 moi as riiai he tf as1 he our t s s he nsa t ton s uccessve. i 2 1 11. Fort r as saed,t c tc t esTa l h' moton a a j2255 moton a he e ons tt he our onsnl wabe s i s i nd N z.' s' di m i s s i ass ce s ve. s s e t uc s i ENTER: hs h d yo Jl, 0 2 'i r z/ a f uy 2 1 . n' St t D i ti J a es sr ct udge 'I f c , t scour r ceved notc on M ach 31 2008 t tt Unied Stt Cour ofAppeal deni Ta l s n a t hi te i ie r , ha he t aes t s ed wabeh' rq etfrp r sint fl as c esv j2 5moin.S eDo k t 2 e u s o emiso o ie u c sie 25 t o e c e No. 6. 2Peii ri he e a s oft pr dur f obt ni c tfc i fom t U nied St e Cour ofAppe s ttone s r by dvied he oce e or ai ng eriiaton r he t ats t al f t Fourh Cic tt havet scour r viw as e sve j2255 moton. Pe ii rmus s m i acopy oft or he t r ui o hi t e e ucc s i i ttone t ub t he s c esv j2 5 moint teCo r ofAp e l, ln wi amoinrq etn atrej d epa e c riiain u csie 2 5 to o h u t p as ao g t h to e u sig h e -u g n l e t cto f ta t dsrc c u tma rve tes c e sv j2 55moin S e2 U. C.j2 44 (sa n e ,1 9 ) A h t he itit o r y e iw h u c sie 2 to . e 8 S. 2 a me d d 9 6. Fourh Cic tf m and i tuci f flng t sm o i w ilbe i ude wih t snotc orae a lbl fo t t rui or nsr tons or ii hi ton l ncl d t hi ie r vaia e r m he Fourh Cic ta t f lw i addr s O fk eoft Clr Unied Stt Co tofAppe sf t Fourh Cic t t r ui t he olo ng es : f he e k, t aes ur al or he t r ui, 900 E. ai St, c ond,VA 232 1 M n . Ri hm 9.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.