Diamond v. Mohawk Ind., No. 6:2012cv00057 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Norman K. Moon on October 19, 2012. (sfc)
Download PDF
c>' .. .. I THE U NI N TED STATESD I STRI C OURT CT FoR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF V I NI CT RGI A LYNCHBURG D I SI VI ON 4 OFFI U e >< oeuRr G: A L si v Tw k q A FI kEQ 0CT 1b 2 1 12 J LI-'Dub . L RK U Ar. . E BY; Epu CAS N O.6: 2- vE 1 c 00057 PHI LI BRENT D I L P AMOND, Pl it f an f M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI M OHAW K I NDUS ES, TRI De n a t # d n. JUDGE N ORMAN K .M OON Pe d n beo et e c u ti Plitf smoin t p o e d i f r pa pe i ( o k tn . n i g f r h o r s anif to o r c e n o ma u rs d c e o 1, ihlwil rn .Ho v r f rr a o sstf rh b lw, wild s s Plitf sc mpan , ) wh c l g a t we e , o e s n e o t eo I l imis an if o lit p ru n t 2 U. C. 1 5 e( )B) u s a t o 8 S. j 91 ()2 ( . A dsrc c u tmu te lae a c mplitfld i f r pa pe i a d ds s i i i itit o r s vau t o an ie n o ma u rs n imis t f t d tnuie ta th a to o a p a ()i fio o o maiiu ;(i fist sae acam o ee n s h t ç e cin r p e l i s rv lus r l o s i al o tt li n t c ) whih rle ma be gant ,or(i)s e moneay r le agans adefnda who i i c eif y r ed' ii e ks tr eif i t e nt s mmune fo s c rle . 2 U. C.j 1 5 e( )B)i-i) s eas Erln Co S. v J h s n, 40 r m u h eif' 8 S. ' 91 ()2 ( ()(i ' e lo iie . A. . o n o 4 i, F. 6 656(t Ci.2006)Ctse tonj1 pe misdititco t t i pe nty a s st 3d 48, 4h r g ci 915 r t src urs o nde nde l ses he meiso i o mapa pe i c mplit, n t e cud s t ta h ven a g a ebai i 1w o rt f nf r u rs o ans a d o x l e ui h t a o r u bl ss n a r s f c.)(i to a itr a q oain o te ) a t' ct in nd ne n l u tto s mitd . ' a A pr s lt g nts pl di a e ç o be lbe a l c t u .' Erck on v Par ,551U . o e ii a ' ea ngs r i t i r ly ons r ed ' i s . dus S. 89,94 ( ) Stl,t fcsalege mus tas arghtt rlefa 2007 . il he a t l d t ç ie i o ei bove t s ultvelvel'' r he pec ai e , a t co ai mus c an t no h f c s t sa e a c am t r i ft ti plusbl o is nd he mpl nt t ont i ç ug a t o t t e l i o ele ha s a i e n t f c ' Bel At.Cor v. Twom bl , 550 U. 544,555,570 ( a e. ' l l p. y S. 2007) Thus t sCour ma no . , hi t y t RK dimis a a ton unde Se i 1 5 ( es a t ac ptng al wel- ea d alega i i t s s n ci r cton 91 t s fer ce i unl l lpl de l tons n he pl ntf scompl ntastue a dr wi a lr s bl f c ua i e enc fom t e f c si t ai if ai r nd a ng 1 ea ona e a t l nf r es r hos a t n he pl i ifsf vor i a antf a , t ppea sce t n t tt pli ifca r rai ha he antf nnotpr a s toff c si s ove ny e a t n uppor ofhi t s cam e ttigh m t r l f' Defo t v An l n ,3 0F.d6 0, 3 ( t Ci. 0 )(iain li n il i o ei . ' na . geo e 3 3 3 6 3 4 h r 20 3 ctto n e ' a itr lquottonsomitd) Heei t sc e,Plitf sOcober11 201 Complitfis nd nena ai te . r n hi as anif t , 2 an al t s a e a c ai u o t t l m pon whi h r le ca b g a e c e i f n e r nt d. I l. Pl i ifbrngs t s a ton unde Til V l oft Equa Em pl e Oppo t te Ac , a ntf i hi c i r te 1 he l oym nt runii s t a nt antf tts ha 42 U. C. j 2000e et s q. I hi Com pl i , Pli if sae t t he s ted sveal S. e 1 n s ubmit e r a i to t wor f M oha l ti ,whih has a br nch whe e Pl ntf r i s i pplcai ns o k or wk ndusres c a r ai if esde n Gls ow,VA.Se Com pl 3. Pl ntf al ge t tt huma r s c de t e t r (et r ag e . ai if le s ha he n e our es parm nt he e tihe ls, a ee wiho j s s o e g i a piai n jt t eb c oft pl. I P an ifsae o t tmp r d t r u t h v d h s p l to s o h a k he i ' d litf tt s c e' t ta e oye i Def nda ' hum a r s c de rme ç id co i ly a ha n mpl e n e nts n e our es pa t nt d e ntnual boutt hii l he rng g r c s )a d wa v r r d a dse p cf l' 1 . F rh r Plitf alg st a te sme p o e s n s ey u e nd irs e tu . d u te , an if le e h t h a ' e ly eéod ( i o o eo c so t t( fn a t o l hr sas lc g o pofp o l. I mpo e t l hmj n n c a in ha Dee d nq ny ie ee t r u t e p e' d ' Pli ifs ksda a sf &2 % ye r ofltl orno wor ' a wel a f çe i sr s . I antf ee m ge or t a s ite k, s l s or lmotonal te s' d ' ' Though Pli tf doe not r er nc Til VI or dic i i ton i hi Co pl it i a n if s ef e e te l s rm na i n s m an , t a p a sh i algngt a h fc ddici n to d rn t ej b a p iai n sa e To p o ea p e r e s le i h t e a e s rmiain u ig h o p lc to tg . rv prm af ci c s ofdic i naor f iur t hie unde Til V1,t bur n i on t pli ift i a e ae s rmi t y a l e o r r te l he de s he antf o s o ta h wa te t dls fv r byt nasmi ry stae j ba pl a tfo o tieo t h w h t e s rae e s a o a l ha i l l-i td o p i n r m u sd f he a u c 1Pl ntf i tal fl a complitwih t Eq Empl ai if niily ied an t he ual oyme Opporunii Commison,whih dim is d hi nt t tes si c s se s aci a i or hi ofhi rght t s Plitf di no dicos t daeoft ti ta llng, t ton nd nf med m s i s o ue. an if d t s l e he t ha niil i hough Pl ntf ai if sae t the fl t i t Compl n wih t Cour wihi 90 da ofr cevi notc fom t Commison. tts ha ied he nsant ait t he t tn ys e i ng ie r he si Se Compl 12. e .- p an if p oe tdTi eV1 ca s Br wnv Ru y n, 9 W L 8 41 , t* (t Ci.1 9 F b. litf s r tce t 1 ls . o . n o 1 98 l 5 4 a 1 4h r 9 8 e 27,1 )(ii M c 998 ctng DonnelDou asCor v Gr e 411U. 792,802 ( 97 ) Spe iial l gl p. . e n, S. 1 3). cfc ly, unde t Mc r he DonnelDougl fa wok,Pli ifmus s t the ()i a me r ofa l as rme r antf t how ha i s mbe pr tce ca s (i t th a pl da wa q aiid fraj bf rwh c M o a l d sre wa oe td ls; i) ha e p i nd s u lte o o o ih h wk n u tis s e s e ig a pia t;(i)t a,d s ie hsq ai to s h wa rj ce a (v ta,al rh s e kn p lc n s ii h t e p t i u lkain , e s ee td; nd i) h t fe i t rj cin,hep iin rman d o e a d M o a I du tisc ni u d t s e a p ia t fo ee t t ost e i e p n n o o h wk n sre o tn e e e k p lc ns r m p ro so Plitf sq aiiain .S eAla a o v Bo r o T u te o o to r Co ny, e s n f an if u lfc to s e v r d . a d f r se s fM ng mey u t 928F. 11 1 ( h Ci.1 )(ii Mc 2d 8, 21 4t r 991 ctng DonnelDou asCor ,411U. a 802) l gl p. S. t . Pl i if does not alege t t he i a me be of a pr e t cl s i hi Co ant antf l ha s m r ot c ed as n s mpli . Furhe , Pl i tf f is t de c i t poston f w hi h he a i d, or whe he t e w e e t r a n if a l o s rbe he ii or c pple t r her r s e ii j bo e i g .Plitf d sno alg t a h wa q ai e f rt epo iin, n h d e p cfc o p n n s an if oe t le e h t e s u li d o h sto a d e o s t not sa e t t De e nt contnue t s e a i a s wih smia qualtc tons afe hi tt ha f nda i d o e k pplc nt t i l r ii a i tr s rjcin. l ta ,Pli tf sae t th wa te tdr d l b Dee d n ' e ly e a d ta ee to nse d anif tts ha e s rae u ey y f n a ts mp o e , n h t hewast dç oneoc asont t( fnda t onl hiel)as e tgr ofpe e.' Compla ol d on c i ha Dee nl y r s elc oup opl 'z .t W hie Pl i if may be a l ng t wha he per e ve t be dic i nai eve whe l antf ludi o t ci d o s rmi ton, n n lbe aly c tu ng hi Co pl i ,Pli ifha notpl d s fc e f c s f ç he c tt dr w i r l onsr i s m ant antf s e ufi i nt a t or t our o a t t r a o bl i e e t t def nda i la e f rt miconduc al ged, ort tt e i he e s na e nf r nce hat he e nt s ibl o he s t le ' ha her s ' i r t n as e rp s iii ta (h ld fn a tha a tduna u l ' As c o t . q a,5 6 l e ha h e o sblt h t t e ee d n s ce lwf ly. h rj v I b l 5 mo y ' U. 6 2 6 8( 0 9 (iain o te ) S. 6 , 7 2 0 ) ctto mi d . t 2AS Saed,Pl ntf doesnotale t the i a memberofapr e e ca s and i i uncl ratt spoi wha tt ai if lge ha s otctd ls t s ea hi nt t , Pl ntf beivesr ga di t potnta sgnikanc oft tale d saeme , gi n t f tt t Pl ntf alo ai if le e r ng he e il i t e ha lge tt nt ve he ac ha ai if s dicos st the i aç s l e ha s ç young man wih ar or 'a wihoutmuchr c wor expere . Com pl a 4. t ec d' nd t e ent k ince .t 11 1. Fort r as s a ed,t Cour conc udes t t Pl i if has f l t s a e a c ai upon he e ons t t he t l ha a nt f aied o t t lm whc rl fma be g a td. Th rf r ,p ru n t U. C.j 1 5 e( ( ,te Co r wi ih ei e y r ne e eo e u s a t o S. 91 ()2)B) h u t l l ds s t Co lit wih u prj ie i a Or e t f lo imis he mpan , t o t eudc , n n d r o ol w. The Cl k i dieced t s nd c rii co e of t s M e or ndum Opi on a t er s r t o e e tfed pis hi m a ni nd he a ompa ng Or rt a1 couns lofr or a t t Pl ntf. cc nyi de o 1 e ec d, nd o he ai if Etets ) dyfcbr21. nr h R aoOte 02 ed i o, NO AN K. OO M UNI TED STATES DI STRI JUDGE CT 4