Vaughan v. Sears Logistic Services, Inc., No. 6:2011cv00011 - Document 18 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Norman K. Moon on August 15, 2011. (jcf)

Download PDF
GL S OFF ERK' I U DI CE AL T YNCHB.S. SX COURT URQ FIED VA L ALp 15 2 1 21 I THE UNI N TED STATESD I STRI COURT CT FoR THE W ESTERN D I STRI OF V I NI CT RGI A J ,l :A . - ' ' ... ' B: Yk LYNCHBURG DI SI VI ON ' p$ C - ù y ct x gis ct aRx '. - .- .' .x.' CI L A CTI N O. l1- 0001l VI ON 6: CV- JONATHAN VAUGHAN Pl nt ai ff M EM OM NDUM O PI ON NI J UDGEN ORMAN K . OON M SEARSLOGI CSSERVI I STI CES, NC. Dee f ndant . Thi m a t ri be or t c tupo c i r to ofPl n if sm oton t s rk s te s f e he our n onsde a i n ai tf ' i o tie D ef endantsm oton t di m i ori t aler i t r and t scas t t Ci ui Courtfor ' i o s ss, n he t natve, o em hi e o he rc t t CiyofLyn hbur ( ke no.8 As1fndt tt c edoe notd rse und t he t c g. doc t ) i ha he as s t ill erhe a wor en' com pens i l s'oft Com m onwealh ofVigi a w ihi t m eani of28 km s aton aw ' he t r ni t n he ng U. C.j1 45() lwil nyt moto S. 4 c, lde he in. Plitf J t nVa ha (i ugha ' i actz no Vigi a.Dee ntSe r anif onaha ug n t va n' s iie f r ni fnda as ) Logitc Sevie ,nc.(û r' i aDeawaec portonwihisprnci eplc ofb ies sis r c s l , û s' s l r or ai t t i pl a e usn s sea ) i Iln s Va ha br htt sa to s e ng$500000.0 i da ge , usc t,i t e n lioi. ug n oug hi c in e ki , 0 n ma s pl oss n h Cic tCo tf t e Ciy ofLync r Thec r ui ur or h t hbu g. ompl italge t ton o ab Ocob rl 2 an le s ha r out t e , 009, V a ha pi ke up a ta l rl de w ih tr fom Sea sa a l a i i M i e o ug n c d r ie oa d t ies r r t oc ton n ddl t n, Penns vani A saleged,Sear w as neglgenti am ong ot t ngs,f lng t s e pr l yl a. l s i n, her hi aii o ecur opery t tr ,overoadi t t aier and f lng t w a n Vaughan oft r uli danger V a he ies l ng he r l , aii o r he es tng . ughan a s r st ta a r ul oft tne i nc whe he o ne t doo t t t a l ra a Se r A u o s e t ha s es t ha glge e, n pe d he r o he r ie t a s t Cent i W es m i t ,M ar and,t tr cas er n t nser yl he ies caded out cusnghi sve eij y. , a i m e r nur W hie t c e w a s ilpe n i s a e c q De e a fl d a m oton t dim i s l he as s tl ndi g n t t our f nd nt ie i o s s, ar ng t Pl ntf scl m i bar ed becaus t V igi a W or s'Com pens i A ct gui hat ai if' ai s r e he r ni ker aton povi sPlitf e usverme 1SeeV a Codej65. 3 r de anifs xcl i e dy. 2-07A.Spe fc l Se r ciialy, as . cont ended t ti f lw ihi t dno srangert t w or t t'ar i at i W hal v.D ean St ha t el t n he s t o he k es' tcul ed n en eel Co.3 S. 2 1 l ( 1 )(i ngcai bardwheedee nts bc rco t , 27 E.d 02, 05 Va. 985 fndi l m re r fnda u onta trt was nosrng t t woki whih g anifs e oye wa e a d ...' ;sealoFo e v ta ero he r n c plitf'l mpl r s ng ge .) e s wlr . ' I 'Clani Sv .53 S. 2d31 ( ) nt1 e ng c, 7 E. 2 2000 . Dee d n t e rmo e t eato t t i c u tiv kn tec u ts u idito u d r fn a t h n e v d h cin o hs o r,n o ig h o r'j rs cin n e 28U. C. 1 S. j 332.Acc di t Pl ntf , f nda tca otsmula ousy a gu t a Pl ntf s or ng o ai if De e n nn i tne l r e h t ai if cli i b r e a s ek r m oval t c s A lho t er i c pl t di r iy b t e t e a m s a r d, nd e e of he a e. t ugh h e s om e e ve st e we n h pate , ndt a ti c nto rye ee s$7 000 $a cvia i i a Stt c r ris a he moun n o rves xc d 5, ,( J i l cton n ny ae out I arsng u rt wor e sc pe a i n lw sofs h St t m a notbe r m ove t a dit it ii nde he km n' om ns to a uc a e y e d o ny sr c co toft Unie Stts' 28U. C.jl c.Pli ift rf eseksa o d rsrki ur he td ae . ' S. 445() antf heeor e n r e ti ng De e n ' m o i t dim i s ori t a t r tve r m a ng t sa ton t sa e c r . f nda t s ton o s s , n he le na i , e ndi hi c i o t t ou t Def da ha n fl d a m o i t di m is i t sc t and 1m a nOts rkea m oto en nt s ot ie ton o s s n hi our, y ti in t thasnotyetbeen fl N onet es Pl ntf r s a s i quesi ofwhet t scas i ha ied. hel s, ai if aies erous ton her hi e s 2 par pr e l be or t co t Re1 i on D elCarmen Es za v. Jo ak 391 F.Sup 2d 504 op ry f e he ur . y ng zwi , p. ( D. x.20 , ai ifar st ta ca eofaci ta r uiesi eprttono a E. Te 05)Pl ntf gue ha ny us ton h t eq r ntr eai f wokes c r r' ompe ain saut flswihi t pohi tonofjl () l t te e t ditit nsto tt e al t n he r bii 445c . n ha as,he src cour hel t tbecaus a neglgence cl m w asbar ed by Texasw or s'com pens i l , t d ha e i ai r ker aton aw r emovalwasi pr .391 F.Supp.2d at507. H owever 1am notbound t f l DelCar m oper . o olow men Es a,and i any eventi i i r undert gover ng 1 oft Fi Cicui. See Ehl parz n t s ncor ect he ni aw he hh r t er lThe e i s edi p e whe h Pe yl ni ,M ar a orVigi a lw a i . Ho e r t is e ne d notbe r s om s ut t er nns va a ylnd, r ni a pples w ve a he s u e r s ve a t ss a I a e t pr empton ofc e ol d t hi t ge. n ny ven , e i ommon lw r m e esi a unior f a ur ofwor r ' a e di s f m et e ke s c mp n ainsaue .S eArh rv E. Du n d Ne u st Co, 8F.d 1 ,1 5( t Ci. 9 5 . o e s t ttt s e t u . L po t e mo r o . 5 3 21 2 4h r 1 9 ) o 2 to g c ut h v h l ta j1 4 ()in tu idcin la darg t f e n ma b wave in t ru h Al u h o rs a e ed h t 4 5c s o jrs ito a, n ih o rma d y e i d f o bo g t h wihi 30da ofr tn ys emova,Plitf motoni tmel a me ist sc ur' c i r ton.Se 28U. C.j l an irs i s i y nd rt hi o ts onsde ai e S. l 4 () Wi y v Un tdpa c l v .l c, 1F. p' 1 6 1 8( t Ci. 0 )( n u ls e o ii ) 4 7c, l . i ' e e r e S c, n . 1 Ap x 7 , 7 4h r 2 01 u p b ih d pnon . v StPaulFiea M a i l .Co.6 F. 771 77 77 (t Ci.1 ) l Ehlr t Fit . . r nd rne ns , 6 3d , 2- 3 5h r 995 . n e ,he fh Cicui uphel t deni ofa m oton t r and,r r t d he al i o em easoni t alhough t pl ntf ' s tçm ay ng hat t he ai ifs ui t r r i e pr aton ofr ght orbeneft undert TexasW or s'Com pens i A c ,t A ct equie nt r et i i s is he ker aton t he isl do no pr defrt s cfcrg ofatonasre b ( antfl' 1 tef es t ovi o he pe ii iht ci se td y pli if. d. ' Co t ha ge rlyco ude t tt rsngunde'a us di j1 c ha t sme urs ve neal ncl d ha t ii a r' s e n 445() s he a me nn a i teco eyrltdfd rl u sinj rs it nsaue 2 U. C. 1 313Hape a ig s n h ls l eae e ea q e t u idci ttt, 8 S. j 3 . r r o o v Autali e1 ' I c.392F. l 202(t Ci.20 ; lr 66F. 771 772-73(t . o lanc ntl n , , 3d 95, 6h r 04)Ehe , 3d , 7 5h Ci.1 ;Humphryv. que i,I .58F.d 1 1 1 (t Ci.1 ; e alo r 995) e Se nta nc, 3 238, 245-246 8h r 995)s e s S a manv Ex CoalUS l . 1 F. 72 725(t Ci.1 ) Si lry,heSu e pe r . xon A, nc, 6 3d 2, 7h r 994 . mial t prme Cour hasdet ned t ûlnguitc cons sency' dem a t coursgi t s e m eani t t enni hat di s i it ' nds hat t ve he am ng o S rsngund r'i tej rs ci lsauefrpae cl ms 28U. C.j 1 38()an i t d ii a e' n h u iditona ttt o tnt ai , S. 3 a, d n he ge r j rs cinsaut 28U. C.j1 1 Home Gr p,I .v V n Ai Cic aton nealu idito tt e, S. 33 . l s ou nc . or ado r r ul i S .I .535U. 8 829- ( 02) l i welesa ihe t tunde t welpl de ys,nc, S. 26, 30 20 . t s l tbls d ha rhe l- ea d c ompl n r e, ç s tt rs s u r f r l w t nl whe t pl n if ss a e e tofhi own ai t ul û ui a i e nde ' ede al a o y a n he ai tf ' t t m n s ca s ofa to s wst tii b e upo (e er lw.' Vad nv. s ov rBank,l S. . u e cin ho ha ts asd n fd ala j' e Dic e 29 Ct 1 1 ( 9)(uotngLouivil ( Na hvleR. v. te 21 U. 1 9,1 2( 9 :. 262, 272 200 q i s le Q s il Co. Motly, l S. 4 5 1 08 Acc r ngl f ealurs ctonu rj1 31i no pr rbymeevit ofa l cu o odi y,ed r j idi i nde 3 s t ope r rue n s tal r a antci ed def e' based on f all . I i pat ens ' eder aw d Beca e t com pl nts us he ai ounds i neglgence,notwor s'com pens i l , i doesnot n i ker aton aw t t rse!un rt wokme sc mpenstonlws'frpupos sofj 1 c .S ei I i d il de he r n' o a ai a ' o r e 445() e d. ts 3 e t n 1 31p o d sfd r l itit o rswi Ku idc ino a1 i l cin a ii gu d r h Co si to S ci 3 rvie e ea d src c u t t j rs it f l cvia t s rsn n e t e n tt in o h o o u l ws orteai soft Unie St t .'' a , r te he t d a es , i t ra t tDe en ntha a s re ori lkey t a s r ade e ebas d on awor r ' mma e il ha f da s s e td, s i l o s e t f ns e ke s Co pe a i S a u e. Se I x m ns ton t t t e 'f d Fort f e ng r as , a ntf m o i w ilbe de e he or goi e ons Pl i ips ton l ni d. TheClr oft Cour i die td t s nd ac riid c y oft so nin a t e k he t s r ce o e e tfe op hi pi o nd he ac c ompa ng o de t a lc s lofr or nyi r r o 1 oun e ec d. E trdti / dyo Auut2 1. nee hs w a f g s 0 1 , NO K.M O U NI TED STATES DI TRI J S CT UDGE 41a s ob e vet tgr ntn t r i s ughtc d r s ti di s ntr i . Re l o s r ha a i g he elef o oul e ul n s ona ulngs mandi t ca ew o d r quie a ng he s ul e r d tr n t nt a Pan ifscam G rse ju d rt ewo k n' c mp n ain lws'2 U. . j 1 4 () eemiai h t litf' li é igs n e h r me s o e s to a , 8 SC. 4 5 c . o a ' Howe er t e sa e c tm i htt n det m i t tt V igi a W o ke s Compe a i Ac i i ppost v , h t t our g he er ne ha he r ni r r ' ns ton t s na i e. 4

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.