-BWC Elliott v. Commissioner of Social Security, No. 6:2010cv00032 - Document 27 (W.D. Va. 2011)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Norman K. Moon on July 14, 2011. (jcf)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OFFI U. DI COUA : CE ;. R . , 4A k ltq V . T YscbB lq A x u . w% Flun .. J I# 2 1 UL' 21 IN THE UNI TED STATESDI STRI C OURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN D I STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A . L f I 'LEY CL;D ' RK 5. . % . ' < LYNCHBURG D I SON VI I $ w t, . u t.-k . / . cuE% CAS N O.6:l cvE 0- 00032 CHRI TOPHER D .ELLI S OTT,JR. , Plit an f M EM OR AN DUM OPI ON NI COMM I ONER OF SOCI SECURI SSI AL TY, JUDGEN ORMAN K .M OON Dee nt f nda . ThimatribeoeteCouronPl ntf' lte fldo M ac 9, l(oc t 23.l s te s fr h t ai ifsetr ie n rh 201 d ke no. ) n t l te ,Pl i tf r que t t Cou tt r c i e is or rda e N ove be l 201 de n he e tr a n if e s s he r o e ons d r t de t d m r 2, 0, nyi g Pli ifsmoton f j gme a ns Dee ntSoci Se urt Admi srton f f lr t antf i or ud nt gai t fnda al c iy nitai or aiue o rs e pond t Pl i tf s c m pl i w ihi t 1 d y tm eperod a l a e f r s e. By or e o a n if o a nt t n he 20- a i i loc t d or e pons dr dat June20,2011,lcons r Pl ntf sl t asam oton f r ed t ued ai if' eter i or econsder i oft or dat i aton he der ed Nove be l 201 a alowe D e e nt ou te da t f l ar s e.D e e n fl da b i f m r 2, 0, nd l d f nda f re n ys o ie e pons f nda t ie re opposi Pl ntf sm oton on Jul 5,201l.Fort r onss f t bel ,lwildeny Pl ntf s ng ai if' i y he eas et orh ow l ai if' m oton. An or w ilf l . i der l olow Plit f s e kn aj d me t f ea la ant fn a t o f i r t fl atmeya s r ani i s e ig u g n o d fut g isDee d n fr al e o i i l n we f u e t hi c pl i t Und Lo l Rul 4, De e an m us r pond t Soci l Sec rt di a lt o s om a n . er ca e f nd t t es o a u iy s biiy c ompl n sw ihi l da a t r s r i e oft c pl i on t e U . Ator y. Pl i tf fl d a ai t t n 20 ys fe e v c he om a nt h S. t ne a n if ie compl ntonJune 14,201 The Cl k ofCourti ued as m onsast Def ai 0. er ss um o endantonJune 1 The 6. s m ons was s ved on t U . Ator on June 22,m aki t ans er due on Oct um er he S. t ney ng he w ober 20. .. . However t PACER dockets fedt tt ser cewasm adeon Jul 6,andt tt ans w as , he pecii ha he vi y ha he wer due on Novem ber3. D ef endantfl isans eron Novem ber3. Thatans erwasuntm el By ied t w w i y. lte dae Nove r5, ai ifrquetdt Co tt e e j etr td mbe Pl ntf e se he ur o ntrudgme a i tDee nt Afe nt gans fnda . tr t a m oto was d ni d,t e m a t r pr c ed on t m e is a cr s m otons f s m a y ht in e e h te o e ed he rt , nd os - i or um r j udgme tweeflda bree n r ie nd ifd. Dea tudgme ti a pr raewhe adee da tha f ldt pla orohewiedee te fulj n s p op it n fn n s aie o e d t r s fnd h ato .F d. Ci. 5 .Th d cso t e tr ea lj d me tis ti tesu ddsrt no cin e R. v P. 5 e e iin o ne d futu g n l wi n h o n icei f e h o t c t Brglev M ac a smih,75F. D .73 742( . Va.1 ) bu d fulj me he our, o i . ky- t R. 9, W D. 977 , t ea t udg nt g nealyi difvord, zc ,I . Dl.O 3co k r Co Pr gr ,8 F. 9 950 e r l s sa e Ta o nc v. ', f/c fWore s mp. o ams 95 2d 49, r ( hCi.1 90) TheUnie SttsCou t Appe l f t FourhCic tha e e sdaStong 4t r 9 . td ae r of as orhe t rui s xprse d r s p e e e et a , sage r m a t r def ulsbea de a t t a m sa de e e bedipos d of r f r nc h t a ne al te , a t voi d nd ha cl i nd f ns s s e o t i me is' Colet Prpar or a ,nc v Hoov rUnies ,nc, l F.d41 41 (t n her rt. l on e at yAc d.I . . e v ralI .6 6 3 3, 7 4h ' Ci. 0)( c tng i patdititc ur or rde ngmoto t s a i e r ofdea t.Th r 201 va ai n r src o t de nyi in o d sde nty ful) e difvori whihs hj sa n c uc udgme sar hedi epe alysrngi stai whee a i tei tn nt e l s s ci l to n iu tons r, s n h nsa t c s t dee n i t g r n. Se Fe R.Ci P.5 d)( o di t t$()d ful ae, he fnda t s he ovenme t e d. v. 5( prvi ng ha $a ea t j gme tma bee trda i tt Unie Stts isofier,o isa ncesonl itecai nt ud n y nee gans he td ae ,t fc s r t ge i y f h l ma esa ihe acam orrgh t r ifb e de et t aiGe t c fl; e t . tue 55 F. tbls s li i t o ele y vi nc ha s ts she oul Stwar vAsr , 2 3d 26,28( s Ci.20 ( c tngdititco to d rofd a tbe a e Commiso rofSoca 1t r 09) va ai src ur r e eful c us sine il Se urt d monsrtdwilngnest e gei f t rpr e di )He v Ap lNo. 11 c iy e tae li s o nga n urhe oc e ngs; ad . fe, 00- 74, 2000U. App. S. LEXI 31 ,t*4- 2000WL 1 23( 0hCi. c. 2000)(fimi ore S 221a 5, 7865 1 t r De 6, afr ng d r denyi m oton f def tw her gover ng i or aul e nmentr espondedt pl ntf ' m oton f def tw ihi t o o ai if s i or aul t n w we ks.W he t govenme tsdea ti du t af lr t pl d,y c lyteco twilet r e ) n he r n ' ful s e o aiue o ea tpial h ur l ihe r f et e eradef ul orwils ta i t de a t S eM as v. se ,5 F. 3 3 ( t e us o nt at l e sde he f ul. e on Litr 62 2d 43, 45 5 h Ci.1 7) r 97 . I o cu et a u d rh cru tn e h r , ea lj d me ts o a p o rae Dee d n c n ld h t n e te ic msa c s ee d futu g n in t p rp it. fn a t r pr e t t ti e r d i f lng isa we b a e i r le upon t e due da e ls e on t Cou ts e es n s ha t r e n ii t ns r ec us t e i d h t it d he r ' do ke , hih i or e ty s a e t de dlnef r po ngt t c pl i t De e n ' e r w a c t w c nc r c l t t d he a i or es ndi o he om a n . f nda ts ror s duet m it keori dve t nc no t ba f ih. Se H e 200 U . A pp. o sa na re e, t o d at e ad, 0 S. LEX I 31 , t*4S 221 a 5 (rdii go r ntsrprsnttont tisfiur t pla wa duet i d re f lr t noe ce tng venme ' e ee ai ha t al e o e d s o na ve tntaiue o t t a we du dae .M oro r isan we wa fl o y t we lt a wa fld b or he ns r e t) e ve ,t s r s ied nl wo eks ae nd s ie ef e Pl nifrquetddea tu n.Plitfha n be nprj di db t ssi tyd a dflng. aitf e se fulj dgme t anif s ot e eu ce y hi lghl elye ii Def endant s f lng of is ans er show s t Def ' ii t w hat endant pl anned t pl and ot wi def o ead her se end a i tt s t Thepa te ha ha t o ga ns he ui. r i s ve d he pporuniy t pr e t i r s ctve c s st t Co t t t o es nt he r e pe i a e o he ur on t s t i m eris,and t Cour i i a poston t deci t scas on t m erisconss ent he ubsantve t he ts n ii o de hi e he t it wih t Fo t Cic tspr e en t tde a t be a de t he urh r ui' ef r ce ha f uls voi d. The Cl k oft Cour i her diect t send a cerii copy oft s m e or er he t s eby r ed o tfed hi m andum opi on and t accom panyi or t al counselofr d. ni he ng der o l ecor Ent ed t s er hi / 4voJl201l. dy fu t. y a , N O AN K.M OO UNI TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
