Davis v. Astrue, No. 6:2010cv00018 - Document 19 (W.D. Va. 2011)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on July 6, 2011. (jcf)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' O S FFI U CE S ATL YNCHB .S. D1 T COURT .. FIED G V . , L UR A , I TH E U NI N TED STA TES DI STRI CO UR T CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STRICT O F VIRG I I N A LYN CH BU RG DI I N V SIO J 2s 2 1 UL 0 ' 4 /G.tu'. :H )' .k.w - . yC / .. po yv. r / t e G REG O RY R.DA VIS, Pl ntf , ai if Ci lA cton No.6: vi i 10cv00018 V. M ICH AEL J.A STR UE, Com m isi s oner ofSoci Securiy, al t By: M i chaelF.U rbanski Unied St esD itri Judge t at s ct Def endant . M EM O R AN DUM O PI ION N Pl nifGr r R. vi (d vi' brugh t sa tonf rviw oft Co sine aitf egoy Da s ( s' o t hi ci or e e Da ) he mmiso r ofSo alSe urt s(d ci c iy' dcommisone' de iint de yhi cli frs plme a s c iy si r' cso o n s am o up e ntl e urt ) ico und rt So a Se urt Ac (hed c'.Da srie t is sona pea:() n me e he cil c iy t t W t' vi as s wo sue ) p l 1 wh t rt Admi srtveLa J (ç ' erdbyno fndi t plitf sme a ehe he nitai w udge $ ' re ALJ) t i ng he anif ntl i ime ssveea se t oft sque ta e l tonpr s, d( whehe t ALJ mpar nt e r t tp wo he e nil vauai oces an 2) t r he er ed by notor i a cons t i m ent exam i ton. Upon r ew oft r d,i i cl r r derng ulatve al na i evi he ecor t s ea t t ALJ' deci on i suppored by subs antalevi hat he S si s t t i dence. Accor ngl t Com m isi di y, he s oner' s motonf s i or ummayj me t( k t# 1 i GRANTED, vi' moi f s mmay r udg n Doc e 4) s Da ss ton or u r j dgme t( ke # 1 i DENI a t d cii o t Commisone i AFFI ED. u n Doc t 2) s ED, nd he e son f he si r s RM I Se ton405g)ofTil 42oft Unie SttsCod a torz j cilrviw ofte ci ( te he td ae e uh ies udi a e e h Soci Securt Com m isi ' deni ofsoci s urt beneft M as r v.Apf ,270 F. al iy s oner s al al ec iy is. to el 3d - 1 ,1 ( hCi. ) Ei e t So a Se urt Ac,( rviwi c r)mus u dt 71 76 4t r2001. tund r he cil c iy t a e e ng ou t t phol he fcual i ngsoft e ( )i t y a es re by s tnta e de ea we er a he a t fndi h ALJ f he r uppo td ubsa il vi nc nd r e c d 1 & . r t o a i tonoft c rc,eg lsa r ''I (leaini orgi )( otngCri v. hrugh pplcai he ore tl a tndad-' d. atrto n i nal qu i ag Chae,7 F. 58 58 ( hCi.1 6:.E t ughwerviw t ( tr 6 3d 5, 9 4t r 99 ç ho Al e e he Commisone 'jfcua s i rs a t l fndi onl t esabls t t ar support by s t i evi i ngs y o t ih hat hey e ed ubsantal dence,we alo m us as ur s t s e t t( s uli t c cl i a elgal c rc. Mvesv. lfno,611F. 980, 2(t ha hil tmae on usons r e ly ore t' ' r Caia 2d 98 4h Ci.1 ) r 980 . Thec tma neihe un ra aJtno rviw oft Commisone ' de sonnor our y t r de tke . vo e e . he s i rs cii r- i t e de eofrc d.Hune v. lv n,993F. 31 34(t Ci.1 2) J ca ewegh he vi nc e or tr Sulia 2d , 4h r 99 . udiil r vi w ofdia lt ca esi lm ie t de e m i ng whe h rs bs a i le de e s e e s biiy s s i t d o t r ni t e u t nta vi nc upporst t he Comm isi s oner' concl on t t pl ntf f l t s if t A cts enttem entcondii s usi hat he ai if aied o ats y he ' il tons. Se La v. lbrz e 368F. 640, ( hCi.1 6) Evi nc i s tnta whe e ws Cee e z , 2d 642 4t r 96 . de e s ubsa il n, consderng t r d asa w hol i m i bedeem ed adequat t s i i he ecor e, t ght e o upporta concl i by a uson raona emi Rihads v.Peal ,40 U. 389, ( 971,orwhe iwoul bes fce t e s bl nd, c r on r es 2 S. 401 1 ) n t d ufiin t rf eadie tdvediti aj yti .Smihv. tr99F. 635 638( hCi.l ) o eus rce r c n ur ral t Chae, 3d , 4t r 996. Subsantalevi t i dence i nota dl ge orconsi abl am ountofevi s dar der e dence,'Pi cev.Under ' er wood, 48 U. 55 565( 988,bu i mor t nameesitlaan s wha l st na 7 S. 2, 1 ) t s e ha r cnil d ome tes ha pr eponder ance. Per es,402 U . at401. I t Com m isi al S. f he s oner' deci on i s s si s upport by ed s bsa ta e de e imus beafime 42U. C.j405g ;Peae,40 U. a 401 u tnil vi nc ,t t fr d. S. () rls 2 S. t . t i a lt ' st ( na lt t e ge i a y s t n i lgai ula tviy b r as ofa d s biiy' i he i biiy o nga n n ubs a ta nf c i t y e on ny D i m edi l de er i e physcalorm ent i rmentwhi can be expect t r ul i dea h caly t m nabl i al mpai ch ed o es t n t orw hi has l t orcan be expec ed t l tf a c i ch ased t o as or ontnuousperod ofnotl t 1 i ess han 2 mo hs' 42U. C.j423( ( )A) Thetl eemi tono ei biiyf s alsc iy nt . ' S. d)1( . çdltr nai f lgi lt or oci e urt beneft i vesa fve- t i r ' W als v. Ba nh q296F. 287, 90 ( t Ci. 02) is nvol i s ep nquiy.' l r ar 3d 2 4 h r 20 . Thi i r a kswhehe tecli nt( )i wor ng;2)hasasve ei ime ;( h sa s nquiy s t r h ama 1 s ki ( e r mpar nt 3) a n i ime tt tme t ore l t r uie nt ofalse i ime ;4)c nrt nt hi or mpar n ha es quas he eq rme s itd mpar nt( a eur o s he patrlva twor a i not()wheh rheo s c npefr ot rwok.He klrv. r s ee n k; nd f , 5 te r he a ro m he r ce Ca l, U. 458 460- (983 ; oh o v. r a t434F. 650, 4n. ( hCi. mpbel461 S. , 462 1 ) J ns n Banh r, 3d 65 1 4t r 200 ( tng20C. R.j40 1 ) l t Commisone c l i yfn t cai nt 5) cii F. 4.520 . fhe si r oncusvel ids he l ma tdiabl 'ortnotdi ed' atany poi i t fve- t pr s,he does notpr t s ed' E sabl ' nt n he i sep oces oceed t t next o he se 2 C. R.j41 920( ( .Onc t cai ntha esa ihe ap i f i c s f tp. 0 F. 6. a)4) e he l ma s tbls d rma ace a e or diabiiy,t bur t s ft t t Com m isi t es ablsh t tt cl m antm ai ai t s lt he den hen hi s o he s oner o t i ha he ai nt ns he rSdu f toni c pa iy($ ', c nsdei t caman' a ,e ai wor e i alunci ng a ct i RFC' 1 o i rng he li ts ge duc ton, k ) experence,and i pai nt t per or alem atve wor t exit i t I and natonal i m nne s, o f m t i k hat s s n he ocal i e ono es 42U. C.j423d)2( ;Ta orv. ei r r 51 F. 66 66 (t Ci.1 75) c mi . S. ( ()A) vl W nbeae, 2 2d 4, 6 4h r 9 . 11 D a swasbor i 1980 and i consder ayounger i vi undert Act 20 C .F. vi nn s i ed ndi dual he . R. j41 9 .Hegrduae fom hihshoolatratndi s cale c tonca sssnc t 6.63/) a td r g c fe te ng pe i du ai lse i e he t r orf t g a ( hid ourh r de. Admi sr tveRe or he ena tr$ 'a 25. Het Ria i a ac l nitai c d, r i fe d ' t ) ook t ln s hid R. ( 1 ,a dc ee voc tona tai n i a tmotveee tonisi 2003.( l ) R. 47) n ompltd ai lr nig n uo i lcr c n R. 8. Alho hec rnl lve wihhi pae s( 27,Da slve i arntdtaie wihhi t ugh ure ty i s t s rnt R. ) vi i d n e e r lr t s 1RFC i a m eas em entoft m os a cl mantcan do despie hi lm iatons. See 20 C. R. s ur he t ai t si ti F. j41 945( Ac or ngt t SocalSe urt Ad nitain: 6. *. c di o he i c iy mi srto RFC i a a s s e t of a i vi als a lt t do s t ne wor r a e s n s es m n n ndi du ' bii o y us ai d k-elt d physi and m ent actvii i a wor s tng on a r arand contnui bass. cal al i tes n k eti egul i ng i A Ee ul r a c i ng ba i 'm e ns 8 h s a da , f 5 days a w eek,or an r g a nd ontnui ss a our y or equi entw or s val k chedul e. Soca Se urt Re a i ( il c iy gulton SSR)96 8p.RFC i t bed t r ne b t ALJonl at rh s o e e mi d y he y fe e c ier alrlva e de eofacai n' i r nt a a rltds oms( g. onsd s l ee nt vi nc l ma ts mpaime s nd ny eae ympt e , p n .Se 20 C. R.j41 9294 . ai) e F. 6. * . 4 gilre i 200 ( 1 )Hehel c r frhi at e orf yea- dda e whol rfind n 6. R. 47. ps ae o s hre our rol ughtr i ves wihhe mot r ( 1 7. Prort t alge o e daei Augus,2006, vi wor da t r he. R. 0 ) i o he le d ns t t n t Da s ke t DolarGener ,W alM ar ,K eyst M aii Kr ,and Goodw il and coul notkeep t s e l al - t o lng, oger l, d he am j f a9 d ypei ( 207 0. Abou amont atrt aleg donstd t ofhi ob or 0 a rod. R. -1 ) t h fe he l e e ae s diabiii t vocatonalpr am assitng Davi i securi em pl entt m i ed hi cas s ltes, he i ogr si sn ng oym er nat s e. ( 209) Therc di c tst tDa sdi no atmptt r-pe hi c s .1 R. . e or ndiae ha vi d t te o eo n s a e d. The r c r doc e sD a s s difcu ty w ih de e son,a e y,a A te i De i i e o d um nt vi ' fi ll t pr s i nxi t nd t nton fc t Dio de C( s r r ADD' .Fr m J y,2 t J y,20 her ceve te t ntf t s c tonsa ' o ul 006, o ul 09, e i d r ame or he e ondii t ) t BleRi Me c Ce er ( 1 -38 1 -48 1 0 ,1 -7 1 -20 21 -1 ) Ove he u dge dial nt . R. 37 , 40 , 5 -51 72 5, 95 4, 5 8. r t cour ofhi viis w ih St he se s st t even Al f ,FN P,and Jule Fr ch,N P,he r ved couns i der er i os ecei elng a me c tont i ovehi f ctoni l Hi pr ci i weeaj tdove t ye s nd diai o mpr s un i ng. d. s esrptons r duse r he ar, and Davi r pea edl s opped t ng hi m edi i aspr cri us l f unknown r ons. se t y t aki s caton es bed, ualy or eas I W hen Davi wasatl poi sdurng hi viis,he show ed sgnsofdepr si anxi y,and d. s ow nt i s st i es on, et hihsr slvel,( 1 , ndrpo tdpoo or ni tona s ls s l-oahi difc t g tes e s R. 73)a e re r ga zai l kil, efl t ng, fiuly see ng,a dapoo a tt.( l 4-75,1 ) Theei onl onei tnc ofDa scli nghe l pi n r ppeie R. 7 99. r s y nsa e vi ami e peinc dob e svet nki t ttntreel wihc ei wor ' ( 1 )Ofe x re e s si hi ng ha i efr dl t ompltng k. R. 96. tn, i ' tucuainsi hi c ndiinc n d wihpe i wheeheha soppe tki me cain.( l t to n s o to oicied t rods r d t d a ng di to R. 1 1 ) Howe r Da sas h dpostvef l u ,wheehewa E n good' t hi 73, 96 . ve, vi lo a ii olow-ps r ss g doi 'wih s de e son, ndcame t thi t prsi a li d ha s t mooda f toni ( r sa e, ( 1 ,2l ) Aton nd unci ng wee) tbl ' R. 95 5. ' e f l upvii, vi di n felCi hene dgdl'oco i Cee ,hi prs rptonf olow- stDa s d ot e dke l e e 't ntnue lxa s e ci i or de r sonwiha ey.( 204. Dui t i fnalf l upc ti di t rc d, vi pesi t nxit R. ) rng her i olow- onane n he e or Da s c a m e t b S or i c t ol' a e re e ç i l i d o e d e n on r , nd xpe i nc d t mpul i o ag t t d be vi .' ( 21 ) m ' no s ve r ia e ha or ' R. 3. He a s di no f eld pr s ed, nd onl f l m idl a ousa tm es l . lo d t e e e s a y e t l y nxi yi . d 5 I Jul 2008,Fr ch not t he seem ed t tear ty wantt i pr hi pr n y, os ed hat o s nes l o m ove s oductviy it and f i ng,buts s t f s uck i a way t i dif ul t i e pr s ng t he i not unctoni eem o eel t n hat s fk t o nt r et eei hat s sveeyde ese a hi a ey i sa e' ( 202. Shedi noe ho ve,ha t ur yc e rl pr sd nd s nxit s tbl. R. ) ' d t, we rt tû ops h ne t tng woul be ver hel ul' butt D avi di nothavet f es i d y pf s' hat s d he undst pr o oceed. I d. Da sa ple frs pplme t sc iyi omeo J y26, vi p id o u e nal e urt nc n ul 2007.( 8. E. R. ) Hugh Tenion,PI. . a s.t agency ps s ID , t e a ychol s ,r ew ed t r d and f ogit evi he ecor ound t D avi w as hat s i ie duet ADD, no s v el ( 1 -67. f t rdeemi dt ti ufi en mpard o but t e er y. R. 55 )He urhe tr ne ha ns fci t i onnaton exit t eval e t degr oflm iaton f daiy lvi actvii and soci nf i s ed o uat he ee i t i or l i ng i tes al f i ng,and t D a shad no r unctoni hat vi epeat epi ed sodesofdecom pe aton and onl m id lm ia i ns i y l i t ton i mai ai ngc e tai pesse e o pa e.( 1 ) Da ssa iatonf dia ly n nt ni onc nrton, ritnc , r c R. 65. vi' pplc i or sbii t w asdeni i taly by t Comm i i . He t a i f r ed nii l he ssoner hen ppled or econsi aton,and Ri d J. der i char Mia Ph. ,a i rviwedt e d nc ( 1 -90. Mianf t tDa swa i ie ln, D. gan e e he vie e. R. 77 ) l ound ha vi s mpard du t bo h A DD a a e y,bu nots v r y. I W hie M ia di fnd t ts f c e t eo t nd nxi t t e e el d. l l n d s ha ufi i n e de e e s e t a s s t de e o lm ia i n i a l hr e f to lc ie i , onl f nd vi nc xi t d o s e s he gr e f i t to n 1 t e unc i na rt r a he y ou m id lm iaton i daiy lvi actvii ,mai ai ng soci f i ng,and m ai ai ng l i t i n l i ng i tes nt ni al unctoni nt ni c e rton, ritnc ,o pa e,a df ndnode o ns i ( 1 ) Da s' a iai onc ntai pesse e r c n ou c mpe aton. R. 87. vi s pplc ton wa a i de e uponr o i r ton.( 8. A he rngwa he dbe or t ALJo Aprl22, s gan nid ec nsde a i R. ) ai s l f e he n i 200 l TheA LJ f 9. d. ound t a Da shasa no s ve e i pa r e ,s 20 C. .R. 41 9 , nd h t vi n- e r m im nt ee F j 6.21 a t ended r ew a s ep t o oft sequentaleval ton pr hus evi t t w he i ua i ocess 20 C. .R . . F j41 920()4)i) Th Appe l Coun lde edDa ssrquetf rviw,a t saton 6. a( (i. e as ci ni vi' e s or e e nd hi ci f lwe ( 1 ) olo d. R. -4. 6 II I To qualf as ds e,'a i pai iy éever ' n m nnentorcom bi i ofi r ent m us si fcanty naton mpaim s t gnii l lm i a cl m a ' physi orm ent abiii t do basc wor actvii 20 C. R. i t ai nts cal al ltes o i k i tes. F. j41 9 c.Bascwor a tviisi l ec rai physc f to ( g. ki sti 6.20() i k ci te ncud e t n ialuncins e. wal ng, itng, sa n ;sei he rng,ors a ng;u rtndi c ngou, ndrme rngsmpl tndig) e ng, a i pe ki ndesa ng, anyi ta e mbei i e i tuci ; eofj me t rs n a oprael t us lwokst to ;a de lng nsr tons us udg n; epondig ppr it y o ua r iuains nd ai wihc ngesi ar i woksti 20C. R.j41 9 .l r nt mus as l torb t ha n outne r etng. F. 6.21 mpaime s t lo as e e xpect t l tf a contnuousperod ofatl tt ve mont t qualf ass e. 20 C. R. ed o as or i i eas wel hs o iy ever F. j41 920a( (i;s as 42U. C.j423( ()A) 6. ()4)i) ee lo S. d)1( . Davi fr tcont s is endst hi m edi l det m i e i pai hat s caly er nabl m nnent ofA DD ,depr i s esson, and anxi y,coupl w ih hi difculy i m ai ai ng em pl ent pr de cl evi nce t et ed t s fi t n nt ni oym , ovi ear de hat hi menali ime t aesvee.( ke #1 a 6 ) W hieii undipue t tDa s s t mpar ns r e r Doc t 3, t -7. l t s s td ha vi suf er f om m ent i paim ent and hashad difculy m ai ai ng em pl ent i doesnot f sr al m r s fi t nt ni oym , t necess iy f l t t f m eri t causeoft I t . Davi poi st evi arl olow hat he or s he he ater s nt o dence i t n he r d fom hi s si w ih Fr ch t i cat hi desiet i ove hi f i ng s he ecor r s es ons t os hat ndi es s r o mpr s unctoni o c nmaiti g nul mplyme .( ke # 1 a 7. Bu Fr c t nureprciinerwho a nan aif e o nt Doc t 3, t ) t osh,he s a tto a c unt f t bul ofD a s sm e ca r o ds f und hi de e s on t be non- e r hi c o s or he k vi ' di l ec r , o s pr s i o s ve e, s a xit und rc r ,a hi ADD sa eatradusi hi me c ton.( 20 21 6. n ey e ontol nd s tbl fe j tng s diai R. 2, 3-1 ) D es t t f t Fr ch not neur ych t tng woul be hel ult pr de beteri i pie he act hat os ed ops es i d pf o ovi t nsght it hi me i r ns( 20 ,s ne rrfre Da st as ecals ove t e ye sof no s ntlmpaime t R. 2) he ve eerd vi o p i it r hre ar r arteat ent Beyond m edi i Fr ch si y counsel D a son hi s r s egul r m . caton, os mpl ed vi s t es m a g m e , e f c r r l tons ps a w o r ng, nd a vie t the s o s oki a be n na e nt s l- a e, e a i hi , nd r yi a d s d ha t p m ng nd gi e r ii r gulry.( 1 -7 20 21 ) xe c sng e a l R. 74 5, 2, 7. Davi t tfed t the hastoubl dsayi f ed,m ai ai ng concentaton,and has s es ii ha r e dt ng ocus nt ni r i e te difc t c ei ts a f lwi i tu tons' ( ke 1 a 1 )Heas xrme fiuly ompltng aks nd olo ng nsrci . Doc t 3, t -2. ' lo cai t ha pa catc onc ort c amonh,Doc tl a 2) a alge t thi a ey l ms o ve ni ta ks e wie t ( ke 3, t , nd le s ha s nxit iaboutbei unabl t keep up w ih hi co- ker and t dem andsofem pl e caus hi i ng eo t s wor s he oym nt e m t devel di r and he t hast cal i si f work.' I Butwhie t r o op arhea hen o l n ck or ' d. l he ecord i cat ndi es t Davi once t d Fr hat s ol osch t hi obs i t nki had i hat s essve hi ng mpeded hi abiiy t com pl e wor s lt o et k, ( 1 ) ido no a pe t tDa sboug a ot rwor r ltdc ai st Fr c R. 96,t es t p ar ha vi r ht ny he k-eae ompl nt o osh durng hi t year ofr arvi t l i s hree s egul sis. ndeed,t r d suggest t e wer ot r onsf he ecor s her e her eas or hi i biiyt k paj De rme to Re biiai Sevie (û 'rc dss ggett t s na lt o ee ob. pat n f ha lttve r c s ûDRS' e or u s ha ) lzi s a hi e blngmohe a gilre aelkel t blme.( 207 0. I patc a, a ne s nd s na i t r nd rfind r i y o a R. -1 ) n riulr t DRSc uns oropi st tt r i ta oltl n raonfr( vilt ke pl i obs' he o el ne ha hee s ûbs uey o e s o Da s o e osngj , ' and t m uch oft pr em ti t he i s l and know she w ilbe t hat he obl ds hat s poied l aken car ofeve i he e nf i n wor ng. ( 209. Fori t c Da swa Grdfom Go lduet t f ofprpe t s ot ki ' R. ) ' nsan e, vi s e r odwil o het o ry. ( 2 )Beoeteici n,rc r s w ta hi pefr nc wa E wf 'i t thetl d R. 08. fr h n de t e ods ho h t s roma e s t ul n ha ake a ' on t phone atwor di nots he k, d how f wor w ihoutcali and once l hi s f earl as s or k t lng eft s hit y oon ast m anagerl tt pr i es. l Folowi t posii D RS pl he ef he em s d. l ng hat ton, aced hi w ih Ol m t d Dom i on asa s pa ke ,o y t s ehi fr d a i afe he f ie t s w f w o k w i t ni hoe c r nl o e m ie ga n tr a l d o ho or r t hou c li A fe Ol Dom i on,Da sw o ke a a lne pa ke a Thom a vil Fur t e but a lng. t r d ni vi r d s i c rt s le niur , t tfed t he el ed t l es ii hat ect o eave t posii due t %s aldr a,'and Epoltcalt ngs.' ( hat ton o çoci am ' s ii hi ' R. 22. ) Ot re d nce i t r c d alo s porst ALJ Sde e m i tonst tD a s s he vi e n he e or s up t he ' t r na i ha vi ' i r enti nots e. Fore pl D a sadm ist bei abl t car f hi own pers mpaim s ever xam e, vi t o ng e o e or s onal needs pr e m eal ,s , epar s hop,drve,l t house, c untc nge a a tnd c ur h.( 1 ) i eave he o ha , nd te h c R. 03. 8 Bo h s a e a nc phys c a Te s and M ia f d hi i paim e t t be no s ve e, c t t t ge y i i ns nion l n oun s m r n s o n- e r whih contadi s Davi st tm ony oft i ensiy,per sence,and lm ii ef ect ofhi s pt s r ct s' es i he nt t sit i tng f s s ym om . ( l -1 ) R. 1 2. A sa cl i a t Da sbe r t bur e ofesa i hi hi diab l y. B l l k v. a m n , vi a s he d n t bls ng s s ii t a oç Rihads 48 F. 77 775(t Ci.1 2) c r on, 3 2d 3, 4h r 97 .Whiet rc ddo c ai me c e d nc l he e or es ont n dial vie e o hi i ime s ii de dofo jci me c le de cet ts f s mpar nt,t s voi be tve dia vi n ha howst ei r nt hos mpaime s sgniia tylmihi a lt t pef m ba i wor a tvii .4 U. C.j423( () A i fc nl i t s biiy o ror sc k ci tes 2 S. d)1. di agnoss al i i uf ci t es ablsh diabiiy. Gr sv.Heckl 785 F. 1163,11665 i one s ns fi ent o t i s lt os er, 2d -66 ( hCi.1 6) Furhemor teALJi n rquiedt a ce tDa sss e nt rgadi t 4t r 98 . t r e,h s ot e r o c p vi' otme s e r ng he efecthi m ent i paim ent haveon hi abiiy t per or basi wor actvii These f s al m r s s lt o f m c k i tes. sbeci s o - hi alge mont ypa catc , fiulymaiti ngfc , fkuly u j tve ymptms s le d hl ni ta ks difc t nani o us dit t com pltng t ksand f l i i tuctons anxit i e i as olow ng nsr i , e y nduced di r - m us be s ar hea t upport by an ed obe tveme c rc d.Se Cri v.Chae,76F.d585, 2( hCi.1 96)( ngt t j ci diale or e ae tr 3 59 4t r 9 fndi ha ale ainso panoroters j ci s mpt alnedonotetbls dia lt a c nno lg to f i h ube tve y oms o sa ih sbiiy, nd a t tkeprc de c o robe tveme c le de eo lc t rog ( tngFose v. c e,78 a e e n e ve j ci dia vi nc r a k hee cii tr He klr 0 F. 1 25,11 (t Ci.986) Nos c rc de sshee 2d 1 29 4h r1 ). u h e or xit r. TheALJmus t rf ema ce biiyd tr nai ofDa s' s b etves t t heeor ke rdi lt eemi tons vi s u j ci ympoms i lg ofteenierc d.Gi nteic itntra o whyDa sc dno ke paj b,a n iht h tr e or ve h n onsse e s ns vi oul t e o nd t dif i account oft se t and ext ofhi m ent i paim ent , t ALJ f he ferng s he veriy ent s al m r s he ound t he cama tssae nst l kcrdi lt ( 1 ) Suc d tr nai aes eyi t pr nc li n' ttme t o ac e biiy. R. 2. h eemi tons r oll n he ovi e oft ALJ,and t cour s d noti erer w ih t he he t houl nt f e t hosedet m i i . Hat er natons cherv.Sec' of v He lh & Huma Se v . 8 F. 21 23( hCi.1 ) Ac r ngl s t nta e de e at n r s, 98 2d , 4t r 989 . co di y, ubsa i l vi nc e ss i t r d t s xit n he ecor o upportt A LJ' fndi . he S i ng 9 IV Davi alo ar s s guest t A LJer ed by notor i a cons t i e m i ton of hat he r derng ulatve xa na i Davi sm ent i paim ent and t ri s' al m r s hei mpacton hi abiiy t engage i s t i gai ul s lt o n ubsantal nf e oymen.( ke # 1 a 7. S iial hes esstatt ALJ' cii ofDa ss mpl t Doc t 3, t ) pecfc ly, ugg t h he S tng vi' çrltveylmie 'te t nt( 1 !2 a a idiai o onl midi ime ts wst t çeai l i td'rame R. 2, ) s n n cton f y l mpar n ho ha t r d cont ned i ufk i m edi evi he ecor ai ns f ent cal dence. l D avi cont d. s endst by denyi hi a hat ng m c ns ttvee mi ton,t ALJfie i hi duyt f l d velpt r or ( ke # 1 a o ulai xa nai he ald n s t o uly e o he ec d. Doc t 3, t 8. W hiei ufi intme ca e de ei oneoft elm ie r s a ALJc n c i rf ) l ns fce di l vi nc s h i t d ea ons n a onsde or or rngaco ulai e m, C. R.j41 91 ()t i ufiinc ofme c le de ei dei ns ttve xa 20 F. 6. 9a,he ns fce y dia vi nc n t sc e trfr t t deemiai oft t r(hecli nt i diabld, andno whehe hi ontx ees o he tr n ton t he t ama l s s e ' whe ' t tr t cama c ridhi bur no pr fi etbls nghi diabiiy.20C. R.j41 91 s he li nt are s de f oo n sa ihi s s lt F. 6. 7;ee Lo f hol v. tu No.C09- 0 201 WL 48 efel z Asre, 1 43, 0 23665, t* ( D.o No 22, 0 a 3 N. lwa v. 201 ) CdA) ALJma or rme c e nai a tsswhe temedia rc dsprs ne t ( n y de dial xami tons nd et n h c l e or e e td o hi orhercons iut i fci m edi evi m tt e nsufi ent cal dence t det m i whet t cl manti o er ne her he ai s diabe ' (mpha i a d)(ii Bartv. l a 38F. 1 9,1 23(t Ci.99 s ld.) e ' ss dde ctng re' Shaal, 3d 01 0 8h rl 4) t (i i omitd) seas Woodsv. l a No. 51 1 WL 1 33 a *1( 0hCi. cttons te l; e lo Shaal, 93- 80, 994 61 4, t 1 t r M a 2,1 4)(( e Se r t r ma or rac ulai e mi ton whe t r c d c nt ns y 99 ç Th c e ay y de ons ttve xa nai n he e or o ai i ufiin me c le de et mak adiabii d emi ton.)(mpha i a d) ns fce t dia vi nc o e s lt etr nai ' e y ' ss dde . Davi may nothave pr ded m edi evi s ovi cal dence f abl t a fndi ofs e avor e o i ng ever i ime t ( 1 , t saeps hol c lrporsfo DrTe s a DrM ia c upld mpar n, R. 2)buthe tt yc ogia e t rm . nion nd . ln, o e wih Fr ch' t eat entnot do pr de s fci m edi evi t os s r m es, ovi uf i ent cal dence t m ake a diabiiy o s lt d tr n to ( 1 -67,1 -90. Be us s t e obe tveme ca e de eoft eemiain. R. 55. 77 ) ca e ufkint j ci di l vi nc he s ve iy ofhi m e t li paim en se s si t r c d, vi ' cl i t tt e A LJ f l d t f l e rt s n a m r t xit n he e or Da s s a m ha h aie o uly devel t r d f l op he ecor ais. V. Att end oft day,i i nott pr nce oft r ewi courtt make adiabiiy he he ts he ovi he evi ng o s lt det m i ton. l i t cour' r e t det m i whet t Com m isi ' deci on i er na i t s he ts ol o er ne her he s oner s si s s uppored by s antalevi t ubst i dence and,i t s cas i i I af im i t fnaldeci on oft n hi e, t s. n fr ng he i si he Com m i i ,t courtdoes nots ssoner he ugges t pl ntf i t aly f ee ofm ent i r ent The t hat ai if s ot l r al mpaim . obe tveme c lrc dsmpl f l t do me t e se eofasveei r n ta jci dia e or i y ais o cu nthe xitnc e r mpaime t h t woul r as na y be e c e t r s ti t t ldia lt f a lf m sofs t nta ga nf d e o bl xpe t d o e ul n o a s biiy or 1 or ubsa i l i ul e oyme t I a a st tteALJprpel c i rdaloft obe tvea s j tve mpl n. t ppe r ha h o ry onsdee l he j ci nd ubeci e d nc i a j c tngpl nifscai f b neis l f lwst talfc t oft vie e n dudiai aitf' l m or e ft. t olo ha l a es he Com m i si s oner' deci on i t s case ar s s si n hi e uppored by subs antale dence.A ccor ngl t t t i vi di y, he de iinofteCommiso ri AFFI ED,heplitf' motonf s cso h sine s RM t anifs i or ummayj gme i r ud nts DENI a ddee ntsmoto f s ED, n fnda ' in or ummayj r udgme i GRANTED. nt s The Cl k oft Cour her i diect t s aceris copy oft sM em or er he t eby s r ed o end tted hi andum Opi on t al counselofr d. ni o l ecor Ent ed: J y 6,2011 er ul / /. 4 J / X A + m A Mi chaelF.Ur ki bans U nied St esD i rctJudge t at sti
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
