Haven v. Social Security, No. 6:2010cv00003 - Document 28 (W.D. Va. 2011)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Norman K. Moon on July 5, 2011. (jcf)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OFFI U S CE .w,. A L ' T YNCHD.S. IX COUX DV URG S A FIED L IN THE UNI TED STATES DI STm CT COURT F oR THE W ESTERN D I STRI OF V I NI CT RGI A LYNCHBURG DI SI VI ON J 25 2 1 UL 21 JUL' - ( g ') ) q; ' N Y u cE L D. u < . . .. ow Cl L AcTl N o.6; 0- 00003 vl ox 1 cv- CHERYL HAVEN, Pl nt ai ff M EM O RAN DU M O PI ON NI Socl SECURI AL TY, M Dee nt J f nda . UDGE N ORMAN K . OON Thi m ateri bef e t cout on consi a i oft f l i .a m oton f s m ar s t s or he ' t der ton he olow ng' i or um y j me ( ke no.1 fld by t Co sine ofSoca Se trt (< udg nt doc t 3) ie he mmiso r il cliy t commisoney o si r' r ' S ee nt);t Re r a Re omme ton tAe f' ( ke no.22)ofUnie Stt r fnda ' he po t nd c ndai d pol l doc t td aes M a srt J M iha lF. ba ki;a d o jci ( ke no.26)t t Re r tldont gitae udge c e Ur ns l n be tons doc t o he po tie he pr s Pli irsbe l Fort ras sae heen,1wilsrket obe to ,ad t o e antf haf he e ons ttd ri l ti he jcins opt he Re r i t o, ndgrntt Co si rsmotonf s po tn ot a a he mmisone' i or ummayj gme . r ud nt 1 . l hi Re r,t ma srt j n s po t he gitae udgerc e omme t t1afr t Commisone ' tna nds ha fim he si rs i l deci i denyi Pl ntf ' cl m s f diabiiy i ur son ng ai i fs ai or s lt ns ance beneft and suppl ent sec iy is em al urt i omeunde t Soca Se urt Ac (he& c'. Obe to t t Re tweefld,whih nc r he il c iy t t W t' jcins o he por r ie ) c unde or na y c r um sa s w o d o i a e t c ur t und r a a #c nov r vi w of t e r di r ic t nce ul blg t he o t o e t ke o e e hos po to oft Re tt whiho j ci pr ryweema 28U. C.j6 1 ,Or anov rins he por o c b e tons opel r de. S. 36(9* pi . Joh on,68 F. 44,48 ( h Ci.1 2) ns 7 2d 4t r 98 .Theo jctonst tweefl i t scae howe r be i ha r ied n hi s, ve, lThePr i entnom i t J es d na ed udge Ur ns t t scour on Dec be 1,2010.J e Ur ns is d hi Re t ba ki o hi t em r udg ba ki s ue s por on J nuay 27,2011. Ther t r on M a l 2011 t Se t confr e t nom i ton, a J a l eafe , y 2, , he na e im d he na i nd udge Ur ns ba ki r c i e h s u i il o s i n o Ma 1 , 01 . e ev d i j d ca c mmiso n y 3 2 1 . w e e p e r d by s eo ot r t n Pl i if who ha e e t d t pr e d pr s Pl i if i r r pa e om ne he ha a ntf , s l c e o oc e o e. a ntf s f ee t s i tlngs and m otons pr ed by s eone ele i s so wi hes,but t per on r o ubm t ii i epar om s f he s hat s m us be a lce e a t ne a it d t pr c i e be or t s Cour a m us co pl w ih t t i ns d tor y dm te o a tc f e hi q nd t m y t he Fe r l Ru e of Ci l Pr e m e whe s m itng flngs t t s Cour . Ac or ngl t de a ls vi oc d n ub ti ii o hi tz c di y, he o j cin wi b src e . be t s l e tik n o l Il . ( orove,1 o e v t tte obe tons lc t rquiie s cfct a Iwo d M e r bsr e ha h j ci a k he e st pe iiiy, nd ul o r l t m we e t y not sr c n. Fe r l Rul of Ci l Pr e le 7 pe m is a pa t t ve nze he r he ti ke de a e vi oc dtr 2 r t ry o s to j ci t ama srt j ' r ln t t dititc twihi f te da oft ubmi b e tons o gitae udges uig o he src our t n oure n ys he or r Fe R.Ci P.721)2) s alo 28U. C.j 63 b) Thedititc ur c nducsade de . d. v. ( . ee s , S. 6( . src o t o t n v rve o to e p rinso ama itae srpo ta d rc mme d t n t wh c s c o o e iw f h s o t o f gsrt' e r n e o n ai o ih pe 6c o o jcin weema e Fe . Ci . 7 1)3 , pin ,6 7F.da 4 .Ge ea o j cin t be to s r d . d R. v P. 2 4 ) Or a o 8 2 t 8 n rl b e t s o . o a ma srt j ' rpor a rc gitae udges e t nd e omme ain,rieai agu nt ara p e e e lc nd to etrtng r me s le dy r sntd, ak t s i t rquie by Rul 72 a ha te smeefe ta a f lte t o e t Ve y v he pect y e rd ki e nd ve h a f c s aitr o bjc. ne . Asr e,5 F.Supp.2d 841 8 (008) Thos potonsoft ma srt j e' rpo ta tu 39 , 45 2 . e ri he gitae udg s e r nd rc mme to t whihnoo j ci aema wilbeuphedunl st ya ece rye o e o ndain o c b e ton r de l l es he r lal aone us o c rr t lw.Se Or ano,687F. a 47( tng We v Calfno,468F.Su 8 8 r ontay o a e pi 2d t cii bb . la pp. 25, 30 ( D.Ca.979) E. 11 ). 2 o j ci n saet a t e we ewrte b apat % i ytyn t s pp r E s sse , a dt a t pa t The b e to s tt h t h y r itn y ry l mpl r i g o u o t hi) itr' n h the ry s ' i t t a ne i l lorm edi alm a t r ' a wasnotE r ng t ac lke a ator y. The sgnam r pori of s t r i d n ega not c te s' nd l yi o t i n t ne ' t ' i e ton t eo j ci n idiaet a t spa t wr et eo j c ins b t ha Pli tf' d u h e sg e a d s bmitdt e h be to s n c t h thi ry ot h b e t , u t t an ifs a g t r in d n u t h o e o j c in . be t s o Theobe to fldonPli ifsbe l mosl saelga c ncl ins3a i opo ae jcins ie antf haf ty tt e l o uso , nd nc r rt a rpe tagume sara pr e e Ac or ngy,t obe to fi t s cfc lyo j c t nd e a r nt le dy esntd. c di l he j cins al o pe iial b e to t ma itaej e' rpor,a t yaeco l oya lc t s cfct rquie byRul 7 he gsrt udg s e t s he r ncus r nd ak he pe iiiy e rd e 2, a ha t smeefc asafiu et obe t Ve y,539F.Supp.2d a 8 Ia d t tmy nd ve he a fe t alr o jc. ne t 45. d ha rviw of t rcod i c t t t t ma sr e j e wa c rc i fndi t t t ee he e r ndiaes ha he gitat udg s ore t n i ng ha he Com m i s oner' tnal deci on i s si si si s upport by s t i evi ed ubs antal dence and t Pl ntf di not hat ai if d m eethe bur ofesabls ng t s wast aly diabl f om a1 f m sofs t i gai ul r den t ihi hat he ot l s ed r 1 or ubs antal nf enA oyr . pl nent 111 . Be a e1ha deemi dt tt o j cinsweei opel fl Iwile e a or r c us ve tr ne ha he b e to r mpr ry ied, l ntr n de srki Pli ifs o j ci ,a ptng t ma itae j ' Re t i t o,gr tng t ti ng antf' b e tons do i he gsrt udges por n ot ani he Commiso rsmoton frs mmayj me ,a dimisngt sa ton a srki i fo sine ' i o u r udg nt nd s si hi ci nd ti ng t ' m r t actve docketoft cour. he i he t The Cl k of t Courtw il be diect t s a cer ii copy of t s m emor er he l r ed o end tf ed hi andum opi ona t a c mpa ni nd he c o n/ng ode t a1c uns lofrc d a t Unie SttsDititJ ge r r o l o e e or nd o td ae src ud Mi chaelF.Ur ki bans . E neeti < % dyoJl,01 t dhs J' a fuy21. r > NO K.M OO UNI TED STATES DI STRI JUDGE CT 3M os oft l8- ge doc entcons s sofbl k quot s ofSoci lSec iy Rulngs. t he pa um it oc e a urt i
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
