Savas v. District Court of Commonwealth of Virginia Augusta County et al, No. 5:2017cv00115 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2017)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/19/17. (mka)
Download PDF
o w soF l us Dlm * u ae Fce s r A RF D iv T oV K,A A v DE2 1S 2 1 û? I TH E U N I D STATE S D ISTRICT CO U RT N TE x . D , FO R TH E W ESTE RN D ISTRI O F VIRGI I B J CT N A H ARRI N BU RG D I SO VISION DE P L D AV I SAVA S, D Pettoner ii , ) ) ) ) ) DI TRI COURT OF S CT ) COM M ONW EALTH OF W RGI A, NI ) AUGUS COUNTY, 4Ak, TA 4 ) Re ponde s s nt . ) CaseN o.5:7c 1 v001 5 1 By:H on.M i haelY.U r c bans d l Chi fUnie S a e Di ti t udge e t d t t s s rc J M E M O RAN D U M O PI I N N O Pe ii rD a d Sa s pr eci pr K ,fld t spe don f T rtofEz orttone vi va , oce lng o le hi t or ' i W z . Or rt Re cndOr e -Vo dl g m e , c aln i a u p cfe o d ris d b de o si dr i ud e nt' h le gng n ns e iid r e sue y ' J d Ru n R. ha oft Ge e a Dit tCo tofAu saCo t . t g h as u . pe S h he n r l sdc ur ge gu t un y Al h e lo hou n m e Ator yl Ho , 1, n Da c D. rya d fnd nt,ti u la wha a s t ne ohn oe 11 a d r i Obe l s e e a s i s nce r t cnm s i a Sa salgesa i tt m . vass ksla t pr ee L f ' a a ei. li ,f ny, va le gans he Sa ee e ve o oc d q ot m u rs Be a ehe a r i gent t cour wilGR AN T Sa s m odon t pr ee L f m a c us ppea s ndi , he t l va ' o oc d q or a e i.H owe r afe z vi wi t c pli ,t cour wilD I ISS t sa ton u rs ve , t r e e ng he om ant he t l SM hi c i p rua t 28U. C. 1 1 ()2 7) u s nt o S. j 9 5e() . Un r2 U.. j1 1 ()2 ( , src c rsha ad t t sr e i i a fl g de 8 SC. 9 5 e()B) ditit ou t ve u y o c e n n é l tn s i a dinas a c pli fl d t f m a a e i a a tm ei t cour de e nlne t t nd s is om a nt le q or u rs t ny i f he t t r i s hat he Savas v. District Court of Commonwealth of Virginia Augusta County et al Doc. 3 a to fi i fiol o maii s $)fi t saeacqm o whc r l fma beg a td; cin <) s rv ous r lcou ; al o tt li n ih ei y r n e ( s e orti s e smo tr r l fa i tad fnd n whoi i i) e k nea y ei gans e e a t i e s mmunefo s h rle ' t s z m uc eif'I i unce rf om t f c oft com pl i whate cty Sa i a s r i i t sa i buti la r he a e he ant xa l vas s s e tng n hi cton, t a pe r hetk sis wiha o d tis d b J d eS h, c o d rheb l ve s ud b p a s a e sue t n r e sue y u g ha whih r e ei s ho l e e Dockets.Justia.com t ci d. es nde The c ti n i u ofisoblga i t c tuept . q f ngslbe al Etc on out s nndf l t i ton o onst o ûi i t l iks y. . v. z us 55 U. 8 , 4( 0 7 . vet ls, h sl z l o tu t t ql e ntdo s Pa d , 1 S. 9 9 2 0 ) Ne rhee s t i i a c nsr ci e lt me e be on i notm e n ta cot ca i e aclatfiuz t alge f ct s t f t acog z bl cqm . a le ut n gnot e al e o le a s e éng or h nia e li S eWelrv De 'ofS . .' 9 1F.d3 7 39 (t C..1 0 (Therpeilu ca e l . t oc Sev, 0 2 8 , 1 4h i 99 ) < s ca jdiil e r. r < s iiu 'wih whih a dit tc ts d vi w s h p q . c pl nt doesnot olct de t c sdc our houl e uc z & om ai s q - ta f m t c ti o a ad a e.O nl t equesi whi h a es r y pr ent t a r ns or he ouz nt n voc t y hos tons c r qua el es ed o c l ma bepz rya dts e ' < c mpli mus c ti s fkintfct l te, oyt y opel d e s d. T o ant t on an u f e a tz matr ). A a 'a ce e a tue,t Ct t acbi ofr left ti plusbl on isf e.' s r tv.I ba ,556 c pt d s r o sa e m ei ha s a i e t ac ' A hc of J l U.. 6 ,6 (0 9 (uo gBel lCo . Two ,5 0U..5 4, 7 (0 7)se S 6 2 78 2 0 ) q én lAt. v. mbl 5 S 4 5 0 2 0 ); e e rl ixa 6 4 8 (ul n pla i rq ie nt u e Rul 8ofteFe ea Rue of neal . t 8 -7 o ti g e dng e urme s nd r e d ni h d rl ls Cii Pr c du ef zT l cvla to 7 v l o e r o f l ii cins). a S va a srsn bai f t sfde a c u tsj idci o rt smatrlS e a s se t o ss or hi e r l o r' urs iton ve hi te . e Kok on nv. a d a LieI . ofAm.5 U. 3 5 3 7 ( 9 4 (f dea c rsa e k e Gu r in f ns Co. , 11 S. < , 7 1 9 ) d r l ou t r 7 Fe c ursofl tdjrs it Th yposesonyta po ra t rz db Co ttto a o t i e uidci mi on. e s s l h t we uhoie y nsi in nd v u sa e whc i nott bee pa e b j iild c e . (n e n lctéonsomitd ) s eas t mt, ih s o x nd d y ud ca e r e' i tr a ia ? te l; e lo Fe R. v. 8()( pla i t a saeacam f rr le ni tc nti as r apli d. Ci P. a a e dng h t t t li o eif us o an ho t nn sae nto t g o sf t c u tsjrs ci ) Thefc oft ec mpli alg sn ttme f he r und ot he o z' u iditon . a e h o ant l e o e c tt ons iuùona vi a i orvi a i off de a sa u e t woul gvers t f r lquesi l olton ol ton e r l t t t hat d i i e o ede a ton j rs ito u r2 U. C. 1 3 . ra et fw fc salg d s g e t ofa yot e u id ci n nde 8 S. j 3 1 No r he e a t l e u g si e ve n h r v a eczm f r l f t t e tntdvest jrs id ma bei er dund rj1 3 . ibl li or ei , o he x e i riy u idc on y nfre e e 32 1 ecvl o e s eth t co q isS v sc mpln ctsteb ssfrjrsit na T S Go en n, lni. Th ifc v r h e ta ac mp ne a a'o lit ie l ai o uidci s < . v rme tplitf' ' z o U. f' ECF N o.2 1. t U. G o m m e doe nota a t be a pa t t t sc s . - But he S. ve nt s ppe r o ry o hi a e 2 I a e ,Sa ha notalge a c m upon whi t lefca be gt ed.The n ny vent vas s le d bi ch ei n ant cour hasf w de al oft sa e c tot rwih wli h Sa t sis a i ha no t e t is he t t our de t lc vas ake s ue, nd t s i i wha s ve i o natle oft unde l ng s a ecout a nsght t oe r nt nr he ryi t t t céon i whi t tor rwas n ch ha de e e e How q ,ta Rooke - ll a doc tne ge t ly pr kbisl rf de a cours nt t d. vet le t Fecm n ti ne a l oli t owe e r l t fo r ve ngsaec ur de ii . id n' I . . nl , 9 F.d 1 ,1 6( . Ci. r m e iwi tt o t csons Fre ma s nc v Du a 2 0 3 91 9 4t r h 20) 0 2. Undert Rooke -Fedm an doczne l e f de a c t m a he r l ti , ow r e r l our s y notc i re t r T s ue ac u ly pr s nt d t a de i by onsde ihe f s s t a l e e e o nd c ded i a s a e c t' or fc tt i l c m s t ar i xti bl t t our' fons iutona bi hat e ne tca y i e t n d wih q e t r ld u b asae c ur. Fllr ntrwi e t u si ue pon y tt o t' ye ons ' v Mo e 1 9 F.d 7 8 7 n. ( t Ci. 1 9 ) ( e na . or , 2 3 2 , 31 6 4h t 9 71 i r l nt q tton ma k o ni e ) Fe e a c zt a e di se of uo ai r s r t d . d r l ot s r ve td t r jrs ci K r e e ti n t fde a c m s l be t u iditon f e ntranig he e rl bi houd he whe e va e of a a la e r viw of t sat c t or r' qui l nt n ppelt e e he t e our de .' I r h g De o r tcPa ofVaj 1 F.d ( 9 )a 2 2 (t o da l v. m c ai t . 22 3 1 2, t 0 4 h , Ci.1 9 1 (le ains a d i tr a q otto maks o nte ) r 9 7 atr to n n e n l u ai n r r itd . Rooker l a a is whe t f de a a ton f s -Fedm n pple n he e r l c i ç endal es ly a nt t n ln mo et a a atmp t s e r ve o g mou s o ot ig z h n n te t o e k e iw f t a he saec ur')d cso byalwe fdea c u t' 11 ,1 F.d tt o ts e iin o r e rl o r. 2. = 29 3 ' . p. a 733.Thus f n a pa t s i f de al diti c t t t ,c whe ry ues n e z s rct our o r a j iae t s me is e d cd d i t e sae c ur e dud c t he a su s e i e n h tt o t pr e lngs t ta ton i i e s nc a a t m ptt obt i diec oc eci , ha c i s n s e e n te o an t t r vi w of t sat c t dec son . . . i conta nton of e e he t e our ii n tve i Roo r l ma ' Br wn & Ro l I .v.Bz c n i g l 2 , ke-Fed n. o ' ot, nc e ke rd e, 11 F.d (9 , a 20 ( t Ci.2 0 ).The lb latc d t t e 3 1 4j t 1 ( h r 0 02 4 a e ta he o h f de a c t a i ' il r r l i e r be i pora , snc a e r l our cton w l a ey, f ve , m t nt i e pat t ti s e i i f d r lc r t r a j iae a is ry ha s e kng n e e a ou t o e dud c t n sue de i d i sat cotr i unlkey t s y s cde n t e zt s i l o a o. I Ad ii nal, l h na sT t ne J hn Hooe117 nd Da c D . ry a d. d to l whi e me f or y o y e At 17a r i Obe l s def nda s Sa ssa esno cam f r lefa i tt s i lvi l ore n m e i t m e nt , va tt li or ei ga ns he e nci dua s ve ntons he by na ei t body ofli c pl i . m n he ns om ant 3 A c di y,t cour fndsno gz cor ngl he ti ound upon wlih i cotl gr ntSa 'pe i a lc t zd a vas tdon nd, t r or ,dinls e tnsa ton.An a opra e Oz rwilbeent r d. he ef e s is s li c i ppr i t de l ee Ete: 1- / /no, ned J/ q . = r M i ha lF.Ur nsd c e ba l ChifUnt dStt sDitit ud e e ie ae src l g