Shelton v. Colvin, No. 5:2015cv00027 - Document 18 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 11/23/2016. (jat)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
I ! l 1 CLERK' OFFI U, Dî COURT S QE S. ST. AT Y OKE, VA FIED L I THE UNI S N TED TATESDI RI COURT V CT FORTHE WES TERN DI TRI OFW RGI A S CT NI H ARM S ONBURG DI SI XI ON I y2V 23 2 1 22 J u L V cu E EM BY: L RO N N I T .SH E LTO N , E Pl ntf, ai if Ci lA cuon N o.5:5- 0027 1 vi 1 CV1 I M. 2 I CARO LY N W .CO LVI , N Com m i i ss onetofSoci Securt al iy, By: M i chaelF.U r bansd l Unie S a e Diti t udge l d t t s s rc J : D ef endant . ! l M EM ORAN DUM oél oN Nl I Thimatri beo et c ur onpli ifRo : i S lon' rs lo 'f tonfr s te s fr he o t antf lne het s fhetn' T i o ) Mo ' ' lon ks he 't e t i r t pt m r 3 Rec i r éon. ECF N o.16.Shet as t coutio r consde isSe e be 1 , 2016 onsde a o d rds si t i c s f rlc ofs jc ma trJ tsl ton ( No. 5 . rt r e imisng h s a e o a k ub e t te l icc i ECF x i 1 ) Fo he r as t tf l Shet sm oton i D EN I D . e ons ha olow, lon' i s E 1. ' I ' . Shelon fld li c antonApdl23,2015. hec ai se fom as resof t ie ls ompli T ompl nt tms r ei s biiy ns a e nef , l a i donsShelon m ade f Soca Se iy I pplca t or il cutt ncom e! d D ia lt I ur nc Be hs al an I ofwhih we ede e lShet s c r nid. lon oughtt vi w oft Soc a SecziyA rm i sz don' e e he i l lrt l nita s ; I ds asa o l smos r c ntcnm f rbe û sonr sjdiaag ou .Caoln Covi t in isl f n i t e e li o ne t e u c t r nds t y l n,he I I Shelton v. Colvin Doc. 18 Co sine ofS ilS cuiy tcovn' f e amq t dimis a g i t tt c t mmiso r oca e t t f li ' û d f l don o s s, r ang ha he o ut I wa wih tjrsl d t c i e Sh lo sc mplI . No. . mo n wa s t ou u icc on o onsd r et n' o znt ECF 7 The éo s i I : I 1F 1 o ad ti dlso yo S et nsa miita v a djcca a p as seECFNo 1 , t r eal l tr f h lo ' d nsrd e n ul jl p e l,e e i i . 2 a 1 3. Dockets.Justia.com ng rfrdtMaireugleCHop,h iudareportzecom m endi the coutt eee o gttldeol. pew oseI z sa s g a Col n' m odon.ECF N o.12. t nt vi s l Th rpo tnotdt tj iil e iw i o cnsi p elde wheea a l a nf e e r e ha udca rve s rl tl rcu d r n ppi éo ot i Iy c 1 s i s ctrt be si din is on r ' caagr ocal e jiy neft s s ased es udi t ounds 1 at4.Howe r c t si . da ve , ours tl l i ha ejrsito t c i rc s ato lsue. d.1 rpo.i ntfe o s his : v uidcin o onsde on ét ina is sI The e' t de iid ne uc sue z ' t ! u rS r d rv. ri,6 F.d 2 7 (t Ci. 9 0 ,f he me a ine sp e lde apr nde h a e Ha rs 31 2 9 4 h z 1 8 ) fwl n ntll s r cu d o g l ' ' z cll a fom unde sa ng how t obt i a e dç ir he rng a t re pa t de a of t nm nt z t t ndl o an n vi nta y a i fe x r e nil . hi a i ton f beneft,77 (im is 1oft tc m a ' s e ntm oton f a hea on s pplca i ot is ls s a ha bi nts ubs que i or dng rsu iaago n s iltsted epo esca s o l eCo stt n J (u t gSl dt e dct zu d voae h u rcs lu e fh néa i .A q oi la e, t zo n t ' l 6 F.d a 3 0 . mpo tf und t tt el l adc ltdi Sla rcd n sveS lo s 31 2 t 0 ) The r o ha h ' e r u ae n l de l ot a het n' u , r i cli fom dinas a f t sm pl r a on t tShet 1 wa r pê ent by a a t ney sm r s is l or he i e e s ha lop s e es ed n tor I durng hi a i éon pr es .I at6. i s pplca oc s d. Thus dinas à ofhi cli doesnotvi a edue , s i sjl s lm olt pz s . d.a 7. oce s I t OnSe e t1 , 0 6 ti c t , fe X no rve ofS lo ssn l o e do ptmbe 3 2 1 ,hs outatr vo e iw hetn' ige bjc n I ( No 1 ) a op e J d Ho ' rpo ti iseliey a dimi s dt c s f rlc ECF . 3 , d t d u ge ppes e r n t rttt' nd s se he a e o a k , ofsbjc matrjrs cin. No 1 . OcoIr11 S lo fldhi mo fr u e t te uidito ECF . 5 On tse , het n i s éon o e r consde ai ECF N o.1 t whi Col n s e 'e l fl d ar s e i r ton, 6, o ch vi ubs qu nty ie e pons i opposton, en ii I ECF N o.17. II. M odonsf r onsde adon, l notunc m on i f a pr c ie,a enot or ec i r whie om n eder l a tc r I 2 t cogni d unde t Fe r Rul sofCii Pr ede e See Am bln M e ze r he de al e v l oc . i ' t Co. U ni . v. v. I ! Viw Pat r. e rnesLLC, . DQ-72 71 20 0WL 45 0 , t* n. ( M d Fe 3, 1 ) No W 0 -0 , 1 l75 8 a 1 3 D. . b. 20 04 I l Abo et Betl c v. l ha a Ro v he l n . Me Bo nn n ofn I .9 F. D. 9 1 0( D. . 9 3. nc, 9 R. 9 , 0 E. Va 1 8 ) N e r he e s c t ha hel t tt s m otonsc n pe f m avaua e f ve t l s , ours ve d ha he e i a r or l bl uncdon. Above l t Bet I ,99 F. D .a 1 Suc a m odon w oul bea opra ewhe e f e m pl, he l, nc. R. t 01. h d ' ppr i t r , or xa e I I t Cour ha pa e l r s r t he t s t nty niunde s ood a pa t or has m ade a ry, d cso ou sd t a ves ra is sp) sent t t Colr by e ii n tie he d r ailsue ;e ed o he zt t pa ée , or ha m a a e t not of r as ng but of he r s s de n r or e oni a e nson.A f t rbass f am ofon t t onsde woul ppr he i urhe i or i o ec i r d be a c t lng orsg fc ntc ngei ihe 1w orac ssncet ont oli inii a ha nt a t i he s ison oft i s t t Cot .Sûc pr e sr r l a ie ubnnsi he s ue o he ut I h obl m a ey ts a t m odon t r c i rs zd be'qual r r . nd he o e onsde hotl e ly a e ' f I I ed,be us oft i e es i fnaiy courss zd g a m odonsf d. nde ca e he ntr t n i lt , t hotl r nt ot I n. e r consde a s i y.Uni ofV a Pat Found. G e El c.Co.755 F.Supp. e i r éon parngl v. . ent v. , 2d 1 De Die o Co., l t ct 7 , 4 - ( D. . 01 )(uot Da o bv. n 38 7 3 44 W. Va 2 1 q i ng u Pe n636 , 9 F. up 2 0 S p. d j 6 7( D. 2 0 ); e Do i v. vc Dic fntDr Cts, 30 c 0 2 , 0 3 E. Pa 0 0) se wne Re o sou u r.No. :5 v0 0 1 2 06 W L 1 7 9 0 a * ( . Va Ma 1 20 6. moi t reconsdershoul notbeused t 1 1 6 , t 1 W D. . y , 0 )A tok o i d o , r ie a ea gum e spt vi l m a or<t a k t Cour t r t nk wha t Cour had et r t r nt e ousy de <o s he l t o e hi t he t 7 :he t nc. ar dy t lea houghtt ough- rghty orwr y. Above t Bel, I ,99 F. D .a 1 hr i l ongl : ; R. t 00. Puzu ntt t eFe e a Ruls apa t c nm o ef ane tilo t atro a n a s a o h d r l e , ry a i or w ra r o le r me d j g ntp s a t Rue5 , mov frrl ffo !aj g n oro d rpt sa tt Rue ud me uru nt o l 9 or e o ei r l ud me t ê e z u n o l e r 60. pa t m a ng a m oéon unde Rul 59 m us fl t em odon no lt rTt n 28 da afe A r y ki r e t lej h a e fha ys t r : t e t ofjdg nt' d. Ci P. 9 $. Fo hCic tha hedta c urss he nty u me . Fe R. v. 5 9 The #t tui s l h t o t hold ' ' ! c ns eapos j g ntmod frrc i rdo 'l dwi nt Rul 5 dedl a a o % tud me on o eonsdea njl t he e 9 a i s fe hi ne I moto t atro a nd aj g ntpu s n t RuI5 e . eDo v. i n o le r me ud me rua t o l 9() Se ve CODESCO, 6 e 59 I F. 8 7, 0 ( t Ci.1 78 rfj apos j d me r ini fldwihi tn d y oft 2d 0 8 9 4 h r 9 ) g f f t u g nt toto s t t n e a s he e I : e tyofj gne a c l i oq s nt c re t s oft tj g ntis l be nt ud i nt nd al nt uedo he orche s ha ud me t houd s ! I te t da amo und tRu e5 () ho ve i ma bef z l sye ') s eas MIC z ae s don e l 9e, we r t y o mal tld.2; e lo , y ' Aut , v. wno S Pi s 5 2F.d26 , 7 -7 j4hCi. 00 )( ngCODES o.LLC To f . ne, 3 3 9 2 7 8(t z 2 8 noé CO l c l st a y not t t ndi t a e ontnue o ppl wihs a ng he m ndm e oft e r lRul ofAppeEa ePr edur nt F de a e t oc e I 4. moint ti fldltri c ns e a aRul 6 mo frrle fom jd me )A to ha s l ae s o % d s e 0$) don o eif r u g nt e I o o d r l r Bltne , 8 F.d1 2 (t Ci. 9 2;Ambl M r r e. n e zl 9 8 2 , -3 4h r 1 9 ) l i n t Co.20 0W L . , 1 457508 a *1 n. ,t 3. I H e e,Shet f d hi m oton f r consde a r lon ze s i or e i r éon on O c obe 11,2016 e c l t r , xa ty I t nt eghtda a t rt cout dimi s d t c s Thus t cour wilconst l sm oton we y- i ys fe he t s s e he a e. , he t l tue n i i a amo t atrora ndund tRue5 e. s éon o le me e l 9() 1 1. 1 Alh t I ou hRue5 e do sn s tf t t esa dad un rwhih ad stc c r ma g l 9() e ot e orh h tp z de c itit ou t y a nda e rirJ g nt t eFot t Cic i ha ou!ne t e r a o f tdongs :cj me n al ud me , h l h z ut s ti d hr e e s ns o i o c ; e t l ( . 1 t acmmo aea itwe igc a g i c nrln lw;2 t ac u to n w eie c o co d t n ne nn h n e n o tol gl ()o co n fr e vd n e i a no a l bl a tilor()t c retace rer rof1w o prve ma fs i tc . t val e t ra; 3 o orc la ro i r e nt niett ie' ' a . jus ' I Hucl snv Sao ,9 F.d17,01(t Ci 19)Tkl5()mo o s yn t e tlno . ttn 94 2 0618 4h t j 3.fue 9e é n ma o b i .9 l us d ho ve, o r ieagu nt whih c ud ha eo e r ie Dro t t is a c o t e , we r t as t me s c o l v e n as d i r o he su n e f he ! ' k ' j g nt n rma t ybeus dt agu ac s u iano e lg lt or t tt pat ha ud me , o y he e o z e a e nde! v l e a he y ha he ty d I t a lt t a e si t Sr ti t nc ' Pa I .Cl. v. . a .FieI .Co. 1 F. he biiy o ddr s n he s nsa e.' c. ns o Am N t r ns , 48 3d I I 39 , 3 (t Ci. 9 ) Thepu pos ofaRu e5 e I o n i nott gved n u p 6 40 4 h r 1 98 . r e l 9()m éo s o i T nha py a l l ka to a di l ha et s yt ejdg . Dtl i v. l r 44 F. u 8 9 8 9 i n ne d éona c nc o wa h u e' zkn Ta o , 4 S pp. 7 , 8 t ' I J ( D. .1 77 . E. Va 9 ) 2 OMP CODESCO, l 5 e wasa ndedt alw t nt ihtdast fl sc amodon. l Rue 9() me o l we reg y o t u h o e S et d snots cf whihbai frs ncn t c t' e rirj g nt h l oe on peiy c ss o me l g he ou t al ud me i s e I a i i t sc e. c ehe ct sno c ngest t lw a pr e sno e de e t t pples n hi as Be aus ie ha o hel nd es nt a vi nc ha l pos- t t dim i s lor r t c twilas lm eShet s e r consde a i bàs d on tda es he s s a de , he our l sp lon e ks e i r ton e I ( < I acerer roflw o (ma fs ij d e'Huc ns ,9 4F. a 1 8 . la ro a r 1 nietnus c . thi on 9 2d t 0 1 ' i Shet put f wa d t eefiem s' n s lon s or r hz ft ' i uppor ofhi m oéon f r onsde a 3 t' s or ec i r éon. I I Fis,prottviwsofli c msf beneft we ec rt i e e ls bi or is r onzucedwih f e t t f manufcur cotr . r a t ed zt I e dence' at r ve sonsofdoc e a vi ' le ed r i um nt don.ECF N o.16,a 1.M or ove ,t Soca t e r he il i S cuiyAdni srdonrS A' fi dt p od es o lsme ia i o ma n.Z Tli, e t t t nita <S ' al o r uc oGe fl dc lnft do I l ) e i s i heag e, iltdhi d pr e srghs I . e on ,j lo srg sund rt Helh ru svoae s ue oc s i t. d S c d hetn' iht e he at l I ur nc Por a lt a A c ount biiyA c ,42 U . C. j1 2 d. . q- f PAA' we e ns a e t biiy nd c a lt t S.: 30 :t . < 1 q (H1 ' t ) 1 ' I vi a e i s ve a wa .I a 3.Spe ik a l c r nn S'ca Se iy pa r k wa l t olt d n e r l ys d. t c i ly, e t i p il cutt pe wor s ef bl l a , ndAdmi itai La u geMa kO' r wf g u l r l d on t tsi yofa nk a n sr t wl d ve r Ha a on f l ei y e he e t mon voca i le r .t aThid, ud eO,Ha ai ore tye auae S lon, nln a a d tona xpe t d. r J g r nc r cl: v l td het s e tj n . , 1 physc heat wli h Shet algesas vi a e hi duepr es rght .l a 4-5. ial lh, nc lon le lo olt d j oc s i s d. t , ec j y N oneoft s a gu e sJ éf t <<e r dm a yr m edy, oft onsaruéon. pa he e r m nt .us y he xtaor : r e c. I I .Co. 1 F. a 403. ns , 48 3d t The c tf our ound t t be ts Shet wasr pz e e by c ha , caie lon e es nt d ouns l e i ea le pr eelngs t hol ng ofShr tv.H a rI ci notpr vi a e epdon t t n rir oc ci : he di ade tl ld s o de n xc o he baei rz p el i j iile iw wheea a pl a nf s il eurt be eisi sl te rcudng udca zve ne l z n p i do or oca sc iy n ft s I c dimisd onr ' caagr s se es udi t ounds Shet smoton doesnot ngt s s t tde i ng . lon' i bi o ugge t ha cl ni l 3Th seiemsar notconceptmly dilnct and s efm esrear poi saleady ar d t t court e t e t l si om i i gue nt r gue o he . Co ae eg, h lo 'Obe t n ECFNo 1 , t C'heCo rcf ld dt tl be ki c mml iainb t e m r, ..S etns jci , o .3a 1 I ' ut d u e ha te ra n o l ct ewen nc z n o S etna d(i atrejddn t hag tefc ta (i atmeqh dt d yt a v c t a dpus eS etns h lo n hs ton y i o c n e h ath ths to y I he ut o d o ae n ru h l , a o itzss', t ECFNo 1 , t (1ddh v a alme ta wa h tp i . .h alr e cdno h v a a desfr neet. wi ) h . 6 a 5 f i a e n t y h t s o ad . te t n y l t a e n d rs o T o o i met fz r o c ntc me' l zc g io o S etn'p- sùt tec ut latmp t cs hsagz nsn o owad r o a t .) n eo nd n f h lo s -q . tlz h o zwi te to at i rt ti ' r q ts l me t m os m e iozouspos i e l . he t rt i sbl i ght l 1 t e e t hol ng ofShr rt c o xt nd he di ade o ouns ld ltga sr pz s s<acla e t oflw' or ee ii nt e e ent < e r t or a ' wo k T n fs i j tc . Mo e ve , bs n ac dt éo l sue t ec ut i wiho r s f ie t nusie' r o r a e t ons t na is , h o t s t ut ma ' I a I s bjc matrj icc n t he zt s n w agu n jhept s nt, we tc e i e To u e t te ursl éo o a he e e r me t i ; e e s ho ve r dbl. I t ext ntShelon now ate pt t a he e t t m s o dvancea ale na c tt n tr dve ons iudona is t woul l s ue hat d i j tf t c ur' sbjc matrjts c n, i smpyt lt. s aga n sc ud usiy he o ts u e t te lidiéo he s i Il oo ae Thee r me t o l l h I a be n r ie by Shet scouns lprort t ent' ofdim is l lon m a notnow ve e as d lon' e i o he r y s s a.Shet y I r-t tlscs.e Wo te v Vi '',6 F.u;p 3 8083( D. .06 elkaez aeSe otn . r a18 St .d 9,9'W. Va21) i i rtke onsdea oni no me n t z ltgat is saleady deci d,provi a paty t gjc i rd s t a t o e ii e s ue r l I de de t he - I c nc t c atne o i o dlg l ii s hg khtp e i usy a i b ef cs o ha e o r f w r mpz ve e a poston , ihl r v o l-val l a t, t a J di ts luga iûed i o he wiea r ap o r a.s c nd bt a t a e t a sa t r s wa d t vebilre o ie t he ppl:o s ntz . ). Eve i tzscour we e t r l t s rnge s j r gove ri m odii ton under n f li t r o eax he ti nt t nda ds p rzng fca i . R i ue5 e,ti hg yd btulha S lonha s c sfl rie ac ns u na is et a l 9()i s ihl ou f t t het s uce sul asd o dtéo lsu h t y i wo dpe mi j iil e iw. ss c ndie i e sl dipos d o :t z l alg sa ul r tud ca r ve Hi e o tm s ai s e f i meey le e y olto tm or iht n e ot mpi t ionsiu i a is . . vi c : Vi ain ofasa t yrg ,a d do sn i l aeac tt ton lsue Cf D a sv. Pas m a , s n 4 2U.. 2 , 41 42(9 9 4 S 2 8 2 - 1 7) . ' eCon ms ma d tr j gj whatm anner' g ;s y eem ne <a ét tona i s r o sa t o yrg saee or e f p e u t a ; tclb1 cons ui lrght aet be tt t r iht r nf c d,f r s me h tusii e z we p ' e o c d t ou h t ec zt. nf r e hr g h otrs7 ). Hi & s a tnr ie s m ea s t nd lid t m , nwhie, dentf Va deki ncesi t r vi w ofhi l i iy Igue f e i n he e e s c s / a ,n c l or f s i n, l g t a t yf l aeli d pr c s . Tli alg d ae nd i oncus y a l o al e h t he f lt 's ue o e s' ls l on, n e vi l ' e I I 1 4 orone,Shet alegest tcerti m edi alr cordswerepotproduced t t cour when Shelon frs fl a F I lon l ha an c e o he t t i t led c mpzntnteWetm Ditito Vignai 2 0 . tswo t n d gta, l o g u g Co rddda mita te o l i h se src f rii n 0 5 Ii rh o I h tat u hl d e n a i d th th n h SS ha r c dst twer notpr uc dwhiehewa rviwi S lon' a lcai heas f md t tnohefoft A d e or ha e od e l s e e ng heI s ppi ton, lo ol ha t f he m elc lz porsc ngewha wass i i t c tsopi on.' cia e t ha t a d n he our' ni ' ECF N o.16 1 a 9 -, t . Shet s ot ra lga lon' he le donsa em or cisc ztt pa s . r e lf tl o r e Hea1u st tl rc rsp o ie t u g O' r r e ha te e od rvd d ol d e Haa g z ' s l c we e fla e u a drp o ucd'a dfhol h v b e teea t o y notc nge lkem a ot rdoc l e s r f en d p n e r d e y n f td a e en h x cl p , c ha d i ny he lm nt ! l l wiho tmor, oe notc nfrsbjc matrjrsido ont c r.<ft mee t u e d s o e u e t te uidc n he ou tç he r l aeao oaeiodercscnsf eoetlhsbcmaejiiin.. lgdn f drlfupoesa uf t sbi ujt trtsco,. l l a k a s e- t udt l gl e ydia pontd cnma c l r ies h ad pt e scnmj hee u r niga ev r s p i e li nt oud as uc ue I s li t rby ndemi n oc I sam o ys he d sg dt l tudca rv e 'Holwa v. c i r 7 4 F.d 1 0 , tt z c me e inr o i j iil e im ' l y S hweke, 2 2 1 2 mi o i 1 0 (t Ci.1 8 ) seBel Hoo 3 7U. 6 8 6 2 3(9 )(( s ima 1 5 4h r 9 49e lv. d, 2 S. 7 , 8 -8 1 46 <Aj ut y < I s mei sbeds nse f rwa o j id c nwh r t alg dcnm un rt e o tme inis d o nt f urs ido e è he l e li de h e C I ons tdon ... e dy a étz cla ppea st be i m a e i la m a s el f t pur e of r o m t ra nd de ol y or he pos l o anigj idc ono wh r s hacnm i whol i u tnd la fiolus' bti n uts id r ee uc li s l :nsbsa a nd zv o . y ). I. V I . H a ng c t fzy r viwed Shet sM oton f Re onsde aton,t Com m lsone ' vi a e t e e lon' i oi c i r i he s i rs r pons t t tm oton,a t m a sr e' z por al r com m e ton,t c t es e o ha i nd he gitat s e t nd e nda i he our i concude t tat rng isor rofdimi s li t sc e i notne s a y t c r ta ce l s ha le i t de s s a n hi a? s ce s r o or ec lar ezro 1w o p e n ma fs ij t . hetn' bI nu rRue5 e i ahg o . ro f a r rve t niet nuske S lo s vde nde l 9() s ih ne ' TheFourh Cicztha sat d t a prorde ii dog notquaiy asce ty e r ousor t t ti s t e hat i c son ! s lf la l r one 1 wordng m anies i *usi <çby beng c*us m a bewr p orpt bl wr l f t nl tce i l t y otg oba y ong;i m us ...srke t t ti usaswr wih t f ce ofa fve- k- d,unr rge a ed de :s '7 ong t he or i wee ol efi r t ' ad h.'TFW S. I v. nc. Ftnc t 5 2F.d1 6 1 4( . Ci. 0 9 (lpssi orgna)(u igBelo h a ho, 7 3 8 , 9 4t r 2 0 ) el i l ii l q otn l ut h i i I s Te e ens v.I o.S s & N e wor Co .N os 92l s or nf . t ks , . 2355,922437,1995 W L 5 20978,a *5 t I : f om one c tt t ot rc t' ECF N o. ,a 2.O t r s , lon deci st go i o s c sc ,a wihout r our o he he ouz ' 16 t he wi e Shè t lne o nt pe i s nd, t i ' h'd i m or,t c ur c n ge nnor a o t beivead pr e svildop oc ure Shet stl tm , e nwhie e he o t a la e s n o le ue oc s oa c rd. lon r e m a l, I esn al ag e tal d eO.Haarah dtewr n c n l ina t hsme tl n p yia h at- ap i t t se dl ru s h t u g ) r ec e h o g o cus s o i na a d h scl el y o h ontha d e no e e u rs t prcs h wa afze . . t wsv X'rd e 4 4U.. 1 , 3 (9 6 (Th o s t v n ddeshe o es e s fo d d CfMahe . l ig, 2 S 3 9 3 3 1 7 ) < e d f f u I , , n a na rq ie n of u pzc s i teo potnt t b h ad. . ) S e e eal ECFNo. 6 a 4 5 d me tle urme t d e o es s h p ru i o e er . ,; e n rl y 1,t -. . j l hi zde i y uc s s n6 (t Ci. pt 5 1 9 ) Shelon hassm pl notm ett sblr n.A ss h,hi m odon i . 4 h r Se . , 9 5) t . . D NID E E l . An a oprat O r rwilbeent r d. ppz i e de l ee . ste:/ z g-a- / nd /t o g ! ' .J rim . f f' k ' 4J , . . - * ; I . . M iha F. ba ki c el Ur ns Unie S ae Ditit ud e id tt s stc l . g
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
