Hancox v. Augusta General District Court, Judge William Goodwin, No. 5:2013cv00091 - Document 10 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 10/28/2013. (jat)

Download PDF
:' ! ' )G *.2% QFFI Et.e. sT couR' * C 8 ol . r ATM SONBURQ VA Flln l IN THE UN I TED STA TES DI STR I T CO UR T C FO R TH E W ESTERN DISTR ICT O F VIRG I I N A H ARR I SON BU RG DIW SI N O t ) 1 1 ) * BY: D JOH N LAM ER H AN CO X , Pl ntf , ai if Ci lActon No. 5: vi i : 13cv00091 V. A UG USTA G ENER AL D I STR I CO UR T, CT JU D GE W ILLIAM G O O DW I , N By:H on.M i chaelF.U rbanski Unied St esD i ri Judge t at st ct Def endant. M EM O M DUM O PI I N N O John Lam erHancox,pr s br o e, oughtt s ac i on Oct hi ton ober l,2013, agai tt ns he H onor e W ilam Goodw i a sti J abl li n, itng udge oft Augusa Gener Dit i Court f ac i he t al s rct , or tons tke b J dgeGood ni hi rl a aj oft tc l.S cfc ly, u Good nr e a nyu wi n s oe s udge ha ou' pe iial J dge t wi uld a i tttplitf i atafccae.Thi c r ds se t c s o t g o o j ca gans h anif n rfi s s ou t imisd he a e n he r unds f udiil i ni onOcobe 3, l ( eDk. 5) Plitf flda ton pla ngso Oco r mmu t y t r 20 3. Se tNo. . anif ie ddii al e di n tbe l ,201 a tec tc tue t epla ngsa moi f rc i rto ofudgme t 0 3, nd h our onsr d hos e di s ton or e onsdeain j n t ed hat i ( t No.6 purua t Fe R. vP.59 e . The cour deni t moton ( eDkt No. ) Dk . ) s nt o d Ci ( )1 Se . 8. . Pl ntf hasagai s it addii pl ngs A gai t cour w ilconsr t pl ngs ai if n ubm ted tonal eadi . n, he t l tue he eadi n, he l a a(e we )moi f rc i rtono j me .( . 9 .Agai t courtw ildeny s rne d ton or e onsdeai f udg nt DktNo. ) t m oton. hat i l() ap s-u g n moini tldwi i tnd ys ftee tyo j d me t n c l it q et ntec retes 'lf ot d me t to s ie t n e a o h nl fu g n a d al no u si h orcn s ' j h ' s o o t a j d me ti s o l bete td a amo inu d r l 5 () h we e i ma b fr l sy e . Do ev. f h t u g n t h ud rae s t n e Ru e 9 e, o v r t y e o mal t ld' v o y ' CODES 5 9F.d8 7 s 9(t Ci. 9 8; e as MLCAuo tv . v. wno S uh r Pie, 3 CO, 6 2 0 , 0 4h r 1 7 )se lo tmoie LLC To f o ten n s5 2 F.d2 9 2 7 7 (t Ci. 0 8 (oigCODES c niu st a pyn t tsa dn tea n me toFe ea 3 6 , 7 - 8 4h r2 0 ) n t n CO o t e o p l owi tn ig h me d n t d rl n h Ru eo Ap l t P o e u e4 . l f pel e r c d r ) a z Pl ntf frtct t Pe yl ni c es cinonj di a rviw oflc a e y ai if is ies he nns va a od e to u cile e o al g nc a ton.2Pa Cons SttAnn.j75 Thi i notaPe ns va asaeco t l i afdea c t ci . . a. 4. s s n yl ni tt ur. t s e rl our l a e i V igi a.N ori t Augus aCo y Ge r lD iti tCour a l a a nc of oc t d n r ni s he t unt ne a sr c t oc l ge y Pe yl ni orofa ot rs a e. l i c rai y nota a nc oft U nied St t s A st si nns va a ny he t t t s e t nl n ge y he t ae . hi s nota a a ofa Pe yl ni l a a nc ac i , t sc s c in i c mplt l ir e nt n ppe l nns va a oc l ge y ton hi ode e to s o e ey relva . Pl nifn xtquoe (lh hhedo no cie aporinofa Ameia Ba Asocai aitf e ts atoug es t t) to n rcn r s iton publc to e tte dW ha i t Rul ofLa ' Se Am e i n Ba A s oc a i n Di s on f i a i n n il d ç t s he e w? ' e rva r s i to vi i or PublcEd a i n,D i oa on t Rul of w 4 ( ) a i bl a h t /www.me ia r i uc to al ue he e La 2008, val e t tp:/ a a rc nba - or cont g/ enfda / m abim i a ed/ i f ur / nal i ogueRoLpDF. hc gr t publced/cat esFi D al aut heckdam .pdf. . The quot pass dicuss J esM adion' wrtngs i t Feder itPaper on s aton of ed age s es am s s ii n he als s epar i pow er and goeson t com par t Am ercan- t e s t ofs aton ofpower w ih t ofa s o e he i syl ysem epar i s t hat pari ent y s em ofgover ent k-'e key poi ,'t pas lam ar yst nm . k h f nt' he sage concl udes,di t ever ts hat y f m ofgover or nmenthast have some s t t ens e t no one i t gover enthasso o ysem o ur hat n he nm muc powe t y c n a ta tt e lw. J= Ce ti y,s ha s tm e ssi t sc s as h r he a c bou h a ' J . ranl uc yse xit n hi a e ' pl ntf had t abiiy t appealhi s at courtconvi i t t A ugus a Count Ci ui Court ai if he lt o ste cton o he t y rc t . Theprpe me nst c le asaej ' r i it a alhede iint ahihe sae o r a o halnge tt udges ulng s o ppe t cso o g r tt c t nots et saej dgei fd r co t ouru he tt u n e eal ur. Fi l pl i ifnot hi s tm e t t r t Si t A m e m e t i i a i naly, antf es s en i n s owa ds he x h nd nt he mplc ton bengt tt pl ntf feshewa de e hi rgh t aj l whe a pe rngf hi tafcc s i ha he ai if e l s nid s i t o u' n p a i or s rfi ae y i Ge r lDititCou twheenojre aee neld.Pl ntf sr d i o eag i n nea src r, r u is r mpa le ai if tme y s nc an fundi saelw.Vigi aCo jl 1 1 2pr de ta tl nypes co cedi aditit o n tt a r ni de 6.- 3 ovi s h ttal ron nvit n src courtofan of ens notf oni s lhave t rght atany tm e w ihi t da f such f e el ous hal he i , i t n en ys rom convi i ...t appealt t cicui cour .' On a cton, o o he r t t' ppealt cicui courtw oul heart cas de he r t d he e no a dhea c e g d)bee ildt tilb aj yi tesmema rasiheha be n vo nd t c usd woul t ntte o ra y ur n h a nne f d e i ct f t of ens i t cicui cour .' Va. deAnn.j 1 1 1 2 ndi ed or he f e n he r t t' Co 6.- 36. l s m ,pl i tf ' c pl i i w ih t V igi a s a e c ts t m . l i t r he s ul n u a n if s om a nt s t he r ni t t our ys e t s he e ho d s e r dr s The e be ng no m e i t t m o i , i s lbe deni by an appr at Or e k e es . r i rt o he ton t hal ed opri e der e er t s da nt ed hi y. The Cl r i diec ed t s a cerii copy oft sM em or e k s r t o end tfed hi andum Opi on t t pr s ni o he o e pl ntf . ai if Ent r d: O c o r28 2 3 ee t be , 01 / ' 4 J f Aw +/ m A c M ihaelF.Ur ns c ba ki Unied St es Dit i J t at s rct udge 2Plit fsCo lit ttsta tth Sa no Cic iCo rClr , o l a p i t fldmyp p r n v r ani ' mpan sae h ttle tu tn rut ut ek wh m h d ad o i f l e a es e e ma esr J d eWil m Go d nsg e tep pro S mmo st a p a i Cic iCo r. ( mp.Dk. . , d ue u g la o wi in d h a e f u n o p e rn rut u t' Co l tNo 3 i ' , a 5 ( ro si o i ia) l t i me n t a p aniffie t prp r a dt l p re t i a p a,t s b n td t ) er r n rgn l. f h s a s h t litf ald o o e l n i y ef c h s p e li mu t e o e y me t tt sc tha ne t t r s onsbiiy nort au hort t r s i s h a f l r . ha hi our s iher he e p i lt he t iy o e cnd uc aiu e 3

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.