Deane v. Marshalls, Inc. et al, No. 5:2011cv00135 - Document 42 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/18/2012. (jat)
Download PDF
- * - o- l U. DI . cE s, sT cour AT- I TH E U NI N TED STA TES DI STR I CO UR T CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STR I O F W RG I I CT N A H AM SON BURG DIW SION I SONBUR? VA FIED L D 3 1 2 JUL C. U R ICE M .DEA NE, Pl ntf , ai if C i lActon N o. 5: vi i : 11cv135 V. M ARSHALLS, NC.M 1 , I , By:H on.M i chaelF.U rbanski U ni St esD it ctJudge ted at s ri D ef endant . M EM ORANDUM OPI ON M Beoetec utsplit psp s-u g n moinfrrc n ieain ( tNo 3 . fr h o r i ani o t d me t t o e o sd rto . Dk . . 8) f j o Pl n ifbe ivest tt c tha f ied t a qu t l a r she c ai sa t tt ai tf le ha he our s a l o de a e y dd es r l m nd ha he def endant have f l t ans erherSdi cover m otons.'The Cour i r r t constue pr s aied o w ts y i ' t s equied o r o K docum ent lber l and s docum ent ar hel t a l ssti ntsandar t n t e s i aly, uch s e d o es rnge t d ha hos da t byat ne .Erc onv. r ,5 U. 89, ( )(ii Esel v. mbl 429 rfed tor ys iks Padus 51 S. 94 2007 ctng tle Ga e, U. 97,1 (976) Th ,hec r wilc tuet pe n moi a motont rco i r S. 06 1 ). ust ou t l onsr he ndig ton s i o e nsde fldu rbohRul 59e a Rul 60()oft Fe rlRulsofCi lPr e e. ie nde t e () nd e b he dea e vi oc dur TheFo t Cic th sae çha amotonsldu rb hRul 59e a Rul 60b) urh r ui as ttd t t t i e nde ot e () nd e ( s dbea l e onl unde Rul 5 e i iwa fldn ltrt n( ) da sa tre r o t houl nayz d y r e 9() ft s ie o ae ha 28 1 y fe nty f he a ve s j me a se t corc t t ud nt' Ro ns nv. i FitainCor , d re udg nt nd e ks o re t haj gme . bi o W x lrto ' p.599 F. 403, 2( hCi.201 .TheCo t ope t M a srt J ' rpo ta 3d 41 4t r 0) ur ad td he gitae udges e r nd rcomme to a e eedfnalud n i t c s onNove e 3 201 ( tNos 3 & e ndain nd ntr i j gme t n he ae mb r 0, 2. Dk. . 6 3 )Pli iffl he moi f rc i rto o Dec mbe 5 201 wihi t t ny- g 7. antf ied r ton or e onsdeain n e r , 2, t n he we t eiht 1I Dec m b r2009,atrh fl go temoinb fr tec utnRobno . l 5 ()wa a n e t e e d n e e fe te in fh t eoe h o ri isn Rue 9e s me d d o xtn i o t rlva tm epei fo t da t t t ei tda . he ee nt i rod rm en ys o wenp gh ys , t RK x ( )d ytmelmi.Theeor, rmoi s lbea l e a amotont rc nsde undt 28 a i i t rf e he ton hal nayz d s i o eo i r r Rul 59e oft Fed a Rul ofCi l o e e e () he erl es viPrc dur. M otons underRul 59 ar nott be m ade lghty. See Pac.I Co.v.A m ercan N atl i e e o i l ns. i ' Fiel . ,1 F. 3 403( hCi.998)(ntr lquoai omitd (çng neal r ns Co. 48 3d 96, 4t r1 i ena ttons tt ) ç e r , l rc n ieaino a u g n atri e tyi a e ta r iayrme ywhc s o l b u e e o sd rto f j d me t fe t n r s n xr odn r e d ih h ud e s d s s rngl ' Rul 59( alowsaco toga amotonfrrc i rto i t e i tnc : pai y.). e e) l urt rnt i o e onsdeain n hre nsa es :4)t a o :1 o cc mmodaea i e v ni c ngei c toli lw;2)t a o f ne e d nc ( t n ntr e ng ha n onr lng a ( o cc unt or w vie e no a ia ea tilor()t c rec ace rerroflw ort prve ma fs ij tc . t valbl t ra; 3 o or t la ro a o e nt niet nusie' ' Huthi onv.Sttn,99 F. 1 1 ( hCi.l ) Plitf do no ale ac an i c ns ao 4 2d 076, 081 4t r 993 . anif es t lge h ge n c toli lw.l d sa art tplitf atc dfve()pa sofme c lrc dspeha onr lng a t oe ppe ha anif ta he i 5 ge dia e or r ps s ugge tng t tne e d nc notc i r d pr vi us y by t c ur e ss A ddii na l s i ha w vi e e onsde e e o l he o t xi t . to ly, pl ntf guest tt e i a t lctofwhatconstt esa compensabl diabiiy,'apossbl ai ifar ha her s ç conf i iut e s lt ' ie al i t acla er oflw o ma f tij tc Ha ngrviwe t pla ngst co t luson o e r ror a r nies nusie. vi e e d he e di ,he ur concl udest pl ntf addii evi hat ai ifs tonal dence i duplca i and cumul tve,and t lm ied s i tve ai he i t a gu e pr s n e i t m oto doe no de onsr t t ta c ea e r ofl w ha oc u r d o r m nt e e t d n he i n s t m ta e ha l r r or a s c re r t trves i ne e sr t prve tma fs ij tc ha e rals c say o e n nietnusie. l a ptng t M a sr t J e' r por a r c m e ton, he c r he d t ti n do i he gita e udg s e t nd e om nda i t ou t l ha t lc ds j c matr urs ci o rt sc ebe a epli iffie t e us he a ke ube t te j iditon ve hi as c us antf ald o xha t r adm i sr i r nitatve emedi l hercom pl nt pl ntf cl m st def es. n ai , ai if ai hat endantM ar hals s l dic i i t d a ai the i J y 2 s rm na e g ns r n ul 004. She d d no fl a c a m sw ih t Equa Em pl ym e i t ie ny l i t he l o nt OpporuniyCommiso (( t t sin $ EEOC' uni2006, lbe ndt 30 da flngpei l h r ' tl ) wel yo he 0 y i rod. n e mo in f r c nsde ai pli ifi l edfve( pa so me c lr c ds Not ng i t s to or e o i rton, antf ncud i 5) ge f dia e or . hi n he e r or , ec ds howe r s ve , ugge t t tpl i iftmel il d a cl i f rt ale d J y 20 s s ha a ntf i y e a m o he l ge ul 04 2 di c i i ton w ih t EEO C. The r c dsm e el i di a et tpl i ifs f r f o am yra s rm na i t he e or r y n c t ha a ntf uf e s r m id ofa l e sf rwhih s e w a uli a e y a a de Soc a Se urt di a lt be eft i Augus im nt o c h s tm t l w r d i l c iy s biiy n is n t 2011 U li a el pl i ipsm oto s e onl t r ha h i s st tt sco tha a r a h r . tm t y, a ntf i n e ks y o e s s ue ha hi ur s le dy ea d a de i d.Theeor,heei nobasst prviepl nifwihrle fo fnalud n i nd cde rf e t r s i o o d aitf t eif rm i j gme t n t sc s purua t Rul 59e. hi ae s nto e () Ac or ngl ii ORDERED t t antf Moto f Re onsdeain,DktNo.38, c di y,t s ha pli ifs in or c i rto ( . ) s lbeD ENI f t r onssetf h above. hal ED or he eas ort En e e D e t be 1 201 t r d: c m r 8, 2 / J A J f Aw +/. m c Mi chaelF.U r ki bans Unied St t D it ctJ t a es sri udge 3