STaSIS, Inc. v. Schurtz et al, No. 5:2011cv00117 - Document 15 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 1/25/2012. (jat)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
- **Š: e# u $, :T eouv '*: QI A T- le : q V . û oq Fl k:n I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I CO UR T CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I U CT O F V I G I I STI R N A H A RR ISO NBU R G D I ISIO N V J 2 21 Aï 02 JULI A D DE STaSIS,I C . N , ,GL ERK RK ) ) Ci lA cton N o.5:11cv117 vi i ) ) ) ) By: M ihae F.Ur ki c l bans ) Unie St e DititJudge td ats src ) Pl ntff ai i , V. JO EL SC H U RT Z,e al, t . D ef endant . s M EM O R AND U M O PINIO N Thi matri bef et co tont moto ofpli ifSTaSI l (i Sl ',f a s te s or he ur he in antf S,nc.$STa S' or ) Te por r Resr i ng Or rnec s r t pr e tt i t grt ofis c i nta busne s m ay t a ni de es a y o ot c he n e iy t onf de i l i s i or a i A V e i i M oto f Te po a y Re ta ni O r ra Su nf m ton. r fed i n or m r r s r i ng de nd ppori M e or ndum tng m a ( t # 11 wa fl onJ nuay 1 201 a a e de ir heai wa hedonJ nuay20, Dk . ) s ied a r 9s 2, nd n vi ntay rng s l a r 201 2. Fort r as s a e i ope cour a s m a i d he ei t c tw ilgr nta he e ons t t d n n t nd um rze r n, he our l a Te mpor r Re tai ng Or (; ' pr bii dee nt fom a us ofSTaSI S ay sr ni der d TRO' ohi tng fnda s r ny e ) S' c n ie ta if r to u tla e p di d P ei n r lj n to h ai c nb h l . Th o fd n iln o mai n n i n x e t rlmiay nu cin e rng a e ed 1 e e TRO a s pr bisde enda s o a lo ohi t f nt , r nyonei a tveco e t pa tcpai w ih t m , r n ci nc r or ri i ton t he fom a r i i m ar tng,s li o of e i f s l a pr dve ts ng, ke i e lng, r f rng or a e ny oduc des g d, ne r d,or t i ne engi e e ma acur by me ofi or a i t n by de e nt fom STaSI nuf t ed ans nf m ton ake f nda s r S. 1. Thi diput ars soutoft 2011ac stonbySTaSI ofaloft a s t ofEurj t s s e ie he quiii S l he s es oe De opmen,I Cç oe ) Dee nt aef r rofi r a ore oyee ofEurjt l vel t nc. Eurj f'. fnda s r ome fces nd/ mpl s oe. n lti a tcp tdta t eP ei nayIj n to h aigwil eh l b t e F bu l 8 1 , 0l l s niiae h t h rlmi r nu cin ern lb ed ewe n e ra' - 0 2 2. y as cain wiht Eu oe a s t u c s , ee a t weee ly db S SI a d sg e so ito t he rj t s e p rha e d fnd n s r mpo e y Ta S n in d em pl e and orco i t a iy ag ee e s D ef nt l tt e pl ofSTa S i t f l oym nt / nfden i lt r m nt . enda s ef he m oy SI n he a l of201l a STa S a s t t t y t STaSI S c i ntalbus nes i onna i w ih t m , nd SI s ers hat he ook S' onfde i i s nf ton t he i vi a i n oft 1 w a t i a ee e sw ih STa S.2 ST aSl a r t tdef nda s n ol to he a nd he r gr m nt t SI S ve s ha e nt r c ntyha be e e l ve comeempl dwihaCa dinco ny, 9- Que c,l d/ a oye t na a mpa 913 0575 be nc. b/ Unir cchi dCt toni- ppe '. toni- ppe unir cchi d' ) STa S as e t i is m oton t tUnir c chi d, hi he e of e ha bee i ve SI s r s n t i ha toni - ppe w ch r t or d n nvol d i t s t r bus ne s r ce l a n he of wa e i s , e nty nnounce isi e i t s la c r a n pe f m anc d t nt nton o el e t i r or e a tmoieh r waec mpo e t e lc tn aS S Sp o uc,h Eu oe M o ua V- n e u o t ad r o n n r piaig Ta I r d tt e rj t d lr Ba d d v D o npi STa S a s r s t tt de i oft s M odul rV - a d D ow npi be ng m a ke e w pe. SI s e t ha he s gn hi a B nde pe i r td by U nir c- ppe i pr i t r t i a c d o y be a l bl a t s tm e t Unir c t oni chi d s opre a y o t nd oul nl vaia e t hi i o toni Chi d t oug t us ofispr i t r i onnaton t ke by de e ppe hr h he e t opr e a y nf i a n f ndant . I s t STaSI s n hor , S c e t tt tm i ofde enda s de rur t m i a opra i n ofSTaSI Scontde i l ont nds ha he i ng f nt ' pa t e, he s ppr i t o S' i nta i or a i a t t m i oft a nf m ton, nd he i ng he nnounc e oft U nir ni - ppe M odul rV - nde em nt he t o c chi d a Ba d D ownpi c pe st c l i t ti w a t pr pe om l he onc uson ha t s he oduc ofc m e c alt f ,r t t n t om r i he t a her ha l tm a e i egii t nnova i a com pe ii ton nd tton. I 1. Att TRO he i Li W a r ac he arng, nda gne , omputrc ula f STaSI t tfe t ta e ons tnt or S, esii d ha s t nta qua iy of STaSI S t hni a da a w asr m o f om a S'asl ow ne l pt ubs a i l ntt S' ec c l t e ved r r sd a op as i d t de e ntR onni J c on. The da a r ova t pl c o ra w ee nd s gne o f nda e a ks t em l ook a e ve ke i e a ey prort de e mm dit l i o f ndantJ ks n' de rur fom STa S.W a ac o s pa t e r SI gnerwa a e t i ntf s bl o de iy t da a r m ove by u e ofc put r f e i t s Exhi t i r ce att TR O he r ng he t e d s om e or ns c ool . bis ntodu d he ai 2De e ntJ lSc r z a s r st tSTa S br ac d is o i tonsunde hi em pl f nda oe hu t s e t ha SI e he t blga i r s oymentagr m e ,gi ng rs ee nt vi i e t hi de s on t l a is e pl o s cii o e ve t m oy. esa ih t tt da at ke wast c c i na ur a ce ti ofi c t bls ha he t a n e hni al n t e nd ra n t once nedt M odulrVr he a Ba d Dow npi . W a r a s t tted t tf l w i t t lng oft s t s e m i d a SD nde pe gne l o es ii ha olo ng he i i he ui, he xa ne ca d i ntted t hera bei pr ded by de e ntJ c on. She f t rt s i i d t t sca d r de ii o s ng ovi f nda a ks ur he e tf e hat hi r co a ne a copy ofs m e,butnotal,oft da a r m ove f om J ks s STaSI l pt p nt i d o l he t e d r ac on' S a o i m edi t l be or hi de r ur f om STa S. m a e y f e s pa t e r SI Pa La be t STaSI S CEO ,a s t s ii a t TRO he i La be te ai d t t ul m r , S' l o e tted t he arng. m r xpl ne ha S SI a q ie a1o t ea s t o Eu o e i J n 2 1 a dta d fn a t, o mel Ta S c ur d l f h s es f rj t n u e 01 , n h t e e d n s f r ry a s cae wi Eu oe, e a STa I e o e sa de c tdc ntd n ily a re n s so itd t r jt b c me S S mply e n xe ue o i e tai g e me t h t wihSTa I De e d n J e Sc u t, o mel t eP e ie to Eu o e,e in dfo S S S t S S. fn a t o l h rz f r ry h r sd n f rj tr sg e r m Ta I on Oc obe l 2011. Tw o da a t rSc t sde rur f om STaSI de enda Ja ks n l f t r 4, ys f e hurz' pa t e r S, f nt c o e t STa S. Exa i ton ofdef nda J c on' l pt p 1 d t co e nsa SI m na i e nt a ks s a o e o nc r boutt m i a op i ton he s ppr r a i ofSTa S' c i nta bus nes i or a i Thi l w s tens d. SI S onf de i l i s nf m ton. s a ui ue La be t e tte t tSTaSI i i t bus ne sofe ne i a m anuf c urng m r t s ii d ha S s n he i s ngi erng nd at i pe f m a e aut otve ha d ar f A udive c e , nd t ti had a c os r l tons p w ih r or nc om i r w e or hi l s a ha t l e e a i hi t Au i l wigispr d cst b s be t oAu imane a ea wa rn ypr g a .La e t d al n t o u t o e u j c t d itn nc nd ra t o rms mb r o t s ii d t tiscl e r a i hi w ih A udiw a i e tf e ha t os el tons p t s nnova i i t pe f m a e a om o i tve n he r or nc ut tve co pone i ty a c ii lt t s ce sofhi compa STaSI wasi e ese i m nt ndusr nd rtca o he uc s s ny. S ntr t d n expa ng ispr tlne a deve o ng t ss me s tofr a i hi wih Vol wa n, nd ndi t oduc i nd l pi hi a or eltons p t ks ge a t Eurj taseswe eac r dt f iiat s har ltons p.La r tsiidt tis he o e s t r quie o aclt e uc eai hi mbet e tfe ha t pl nned busne sr a i hi w ih V ol wage w a a a c ii als ag a t tt en r nc i o a i s el tons p t ks n s t r tc t e nd ha he t a e nt t m a ke by U nir c chi d,s li pe f m a e a om otve ha dw a e f t fr ttm e he r t t oni - ppe e lng r or nc ut i r r or he is i , a s c fc l a M odul r Vnd pe i i aly a Bande D ownpi t ta d pe ha ppea s t be i ntca i de i t t r o de i l n s gn o he pr i aypr cts d b Euzj ta now owne bySTaSI woul ir paabl ij et opretr odu ol y o e nd d S, d re r y n ur he pr pe tofisr a i hi wih Vol wa n i am a ne t twoul be dit ul t qua iy. os c t eltons p t ks ge n n r ha d fk t o ntf La mber t tfedt tt M odulrVt esii ha he a Bande Do d wnpi c d no ha be r e ne r i t pe oul t ve en e ngi e ed n he b ifpe i snc de e nt l f STa S,a t ti wo d t ker re rod i e f nda s e t SI nd ha t ul a oughl ayea f hi e i e s y r or s ng ne r t do s La be t e tfe t twhie o he c pa esm ar tû pi ce ofa c pl t puzz e ' o o. m r t s ii d ha l t r om ni ke s one e om e e l, ' hi c pan sdow npi s a e a compl e m od a s t m t tm a be c i e i a va i t of s om y' pe r et ul r ys e ha y onf gur d n rey ma nner . Thi m odul rconc pt La be te ai d,i uni ue La be ta s t tte t tt s s a e , m r xpl ne s q . m r l o es ii d ha he STa S docum e sm i s ng on t SD c r r t ne by def ntJ c on di no a SI nt s i he a d e ur d enda a ks d t ppea t be ro r ndom 'r t r t r l t t a Audipr a , a he , hey e a ed o n oduc he under t w a goi t be r ea ed by t s ood s ng o el s U nir c- pped i t nea f ur toni chi n he r ut e. D e e nt of e ed no t tm on a t TRO hea i The a gue t tSTa S di no f nda s f r es i y t he r ng. y r d ha SI d t o t eEu o e if r to b c u eSTa I ha b e c e ise l y n a r e n wi wn h rj t n o mai n e a s S S d ra h d t mp o me t g e me t t h de e f ndan Sc t t tt r w a no e s i r l tons p be w e n STa S a V ol wag t hur z; ha he e s xi tng e a i hi t e SI nd ks en w hi h co d be i r pa a y ha m e , ha U nir ni - ppe ha m a no a c ul r e r bl r d' t t o c chi d d de t nnounce en ofa m t n e r i ot Audilne;a t tSTa Shadno e t ihe a irpaa eij ywarntng nty nt he i nd ha SI t sabls d ny re rbl nur ra i t ext aor nar rem edy ofa TRO . Unir c- pped,nota part t t case,w as notpr ent he r di y toni chi y o he es a t TRO he rng. t he ai 111. Ba e on t e de i r sd he vi nce nt oduc att TRO he r ng,STaSI ha e t bls t ed he ai S s s a i hed he f l i f t: olow ng ac s 1 l medit l prort de e ntJ cks sr sgna i fom STaSI c ran ofis . m a e y i o f nda a on' e i ton r S, e ti t c i nta bus ne s i or a i n,i l ng t c c da a, asr m ove fom t onf de i l i s nf m to nc udi e hni al t w e d r he STaSI l pt J cks us whie i STaSI S e pl S a op a on ed l n S' m oy. A c ofs opy ome,butno a l oft daar t l, he t emove fom de e ntJ c on' STa S d r f nda a ks s SI l pt w a r t e t STa S on a SD c r f l i f lng oft l w s t a op s e um d o SI a d olow ng ii he a ui. De e nt Sc t a J ks cure l a ee oyed a Unir c chi . f nda s hurz nd ac on r nty r mpl t toni - pped 4. Unir c- ppe ha be i t s t ebusne s a untlr c ty, d not toni chi d s en n he ofwar i s , nd i e en l ha m a ke e a pe f m a e a om o i ha dwa e. r t d ny ror nc ut tve r r U nir ni - pped am ounce t r l as o a e l i m odul rha dwa e lne o t o c chi l d he e e e f n xc us ve a r r i n Januar 19,2012. y 6. The announce e i c t d t tt fr tha dw a e iem t hi t m a ketw a a m nt ndi a e ha he is r r t o t he r s M odul r 3' V - nded Dow npi a ' Ba pe. Thi M odulr3'V- nde Do pea a st bevit lyi ntc t aEurj t s a ' Ba d wnpi ppe r o rual de ialo oe pr oduc owned by STaSI t S. 8 A Eu o e p o u ti vsb ea tetp o t ewe st pa ea n u cn terlaeo . rj t r d c s iil t h o f h b ie g n o n ig h ee s f t Unir c- ppe M odulr3' Ba he toni chi d a 'V- nded Downpi . Se TRO H e r ng Exhi t pe e ai bi 5A . 9. STa SpurhasdEurj tt e ndispr duc lnea de l asr t c SI c e o e o xpa t o t i nd veop taegi r l tons p w ih V ol w a n. STaSI i i nego i i nsw ih V ol wage a t e a i hi t ks ge Ssn tato t ks n, nd he co pe ii us ofispr i t r i or a i pos s a t e tt t e neg i tons m ttve e t opr e a y nf m ton e hr a o hos ota i . 1V . $ p ei n r ij ncini a e ta r n r rme yn v ra r e a o rg t' W itr k r l a y n u to s n xr odiay e d e e wad d s f ih . n e A mi ' v. t a Res Def Counci,555U. 7,24( Naurl . . l S. 2008) Rea Tr hAbo Oba sI v.Fed. ; l ut ut ma nc. El tonComm' 575F. 342,345( hCi. ) va ae onot rgr eci n, 3d 4t r2009 , c td he oundsa r nded, nd ema 1 S.Ct 2371( 0) r f' i pa t ndrma d,607F. 355(t Ci.201 .l i a 30 . 201 ,eafd n r a e nde 3d 4h r 0) t s r m e t ti S a e onl s rng y a i lm ie cic sance .' M i r r t Ry.l .v. e dy ha s l nt d y pa i l nd n i t d r um t s ' c ost a e gr nc 5 M otr a I , F. 335,339( h Ci.2001.Thus tg pli ifs ki aprlmi r ool, nc.245 3d 4t r ) ,ial antf ee ng ei nay ij n to mu te tb iht a h i l eyt s c e o temeis ta h i lk l t s fe n u cin s sa ls h t e s i l o uc e d n h rt,h t e s i ey o u fr k ir r bl ha m i t abs nc ofpr lm i r r i , ha t baa eofequii tpsi hi f vor repa a e r n he e e ei nay elef t t he lnc tes i n s a , a t tanij toni i t publcitr t' i e,555U. a 20.A pr lmi r ij on nd ha nunci s n he i nees. ntr 'W S. t ei nay nundi c n o b is e u e sa1 o ro t s ee n sa eme.I .Prlmi ayij n to saeme n a n t e su d nls l f u f he e lme t r t d ei n r nu cin r a t t d otc t sausquo a t pr ve ir par bl ha m durngt pe nc ofal ws t o t e t he t t pr nd o e nt re a e r i he nde y a ui u maeyt p e evet c u tsa lt t r n e ame nngulu me to t meis' I r hi tl o rs r he o r' bi y o e d r a i f j dg n n he rt. n e i ' M ir of Cor Anttus Lii ,333F. 51 525( hCi. cos t p. ir t tg. 3d 7, 4t r 2003) . A lho h t Foul h Cicui' r i i Re Tr h AboutOba a f us d on pr lm i r t ug he ' r t s ulng n al ut t m oc e e i na y ij n to s i rd fn d a ay i as a pl st t is a c o atmp r r r sr ii o d r nu cin ,t e e ie n lss lo p i o he s u n e f e o ay e tanng r e . s e Se Hoec tDif lCo. NanYaPlsisCop.17 F. 411, ( hCi.999 (ppl ng e hs aoi v. a tc r , 4 3d 422 4t r1 ) a yi t es mefco st atmpo ayr sr ii go d ra dap ei n r ij nci n ; mp n v. h a a tr o e r r e tan n r e n r l ay nu to l Si kis mi Gr s te 495F.Supp.1 1 ( S. 1 (a l s as Nes eset, 075, 079 D. C. 980) sme ; ee lo iwende v. nkofAm. r Ba , No.09 -2595,2009W L 1 834406,a *1( D. l J 23,2009)(ulngonatmporr t N. Ca. une ri e ay r sr i ng or rby a yi t s met tadop e i W i e a apple i Re lTr h Abou e tani de ppl ng he a es t d n nt r nd i d n a ut t Oba ) ma . Ba ed on t e de pr e e att TRO hea i t c r beleve t STaSI has s he vi nce es nt d he rng, he ou t i s hat S s ts i d a lf r quie e s f r a TR O. The e de e s a i fe 1 our e r m nt o vi nc ugge t t def nda J c on s s hat e nt a ks m ia o i t d c i talbus nes i or a i upo hi de r ur f om STaSI A co of s ppr pra e onfden i i s nf m ton n s pa t e r S. py s e bu nota l oft si or a i w asr t ne t STaSI a t rt s l w s twast l d. Shorl om , t l, hi nf m ton e ur d o S f e hi a ui ie ty a trl a ng STa S, f nda sJ cks and Sc t beg wor ng f Unir c- ppe fe e vi SI de e nt a on hurz an ki or toni chi d. W ihi a f m ont ofdef t n ew hs endant com i t w or f i,U nironi s ng o k or t t c-chi pped,t heret or a of e s t a e c pa a ofw r om ny, nnounce is e r i o t pe f m a e au om o i ha dw a e m a ke . The d t nty nt he r or nc t tve r r r t 6 frtp o u t ee s db Unto i- ip da pe r t b vru l i e tc l oaEu o e p o u t is r d c r la e y ir nc chp e p as o e ital d n ia t y rj t r d c, a t we iepa a nd he bst ge nnounci isrl s c anedavii ei geofaEurj tpr t Thi ng t eea e onti sbl ma oe oduc. s r l as com esata crtc tm e i STaSI S e f t t f ge a r l i ns p w ih Vol w a n ee e ii al i n S' f ors o or e ato hi t ks ge s m ia t w ha i ha wih A udi La be tt s ii t tt de l e oft sr l tons p w ih i lr o tt s t . m r e tted ha he ve opm nt hi e a i hi t V ol w a n i via t STa S' busne sa c e nsove m i a opr a i ofis c i nta ks ge s t l o SI S i s nd onc r r s ppr i ton t onfde i l t c c da a w o d ha m t tr a i hi A s s h, ed on t e de e a l bl t t e hni al t ul r ha el tons p. uc bas he vi nc vaia e o he c t tt TRO he r ng,STa S a a s lke y t s ce d on t m e is ofisl ga c ai s our a he ai SI ppe r i l o uc e he rt t e llm a i i outoft r ovalofis i onna i fom de e ntJ c on' l t rs ng he em t nf ton r f nda a ks s ap op. TheFourh Cic thasexpl ned,sher quie lre r bl har 'mus be t t r t r ui ai çt e r d ir pa a e m t neihe r m ot nors ul tve, a t a i m i nt'' D ie l r l Lt v. r a hr e e pec a i but c ual nd m ne .' r x s ae s d. B e kt ouch M e d. Cor ,952F. 8 81 ( h Ci.1 )(ii ECRIv. cGrw--ill ,809F. 223,226 p. 2d 02, 2 4t r 991 ctng M a l l.nc. l 2d ( - Ci.1 Cl tbls ngars orirpaa eham i no e h.A pli ifhast 31 r 987) Esa ihi ik re rbl r s t noug d antf he bur nofpr ngaûlars ngofi dit irpaa eij y'') s eas l r M i os de ovi ce howi mme ae re rbl n ur '), e lo n e cr oh ' Com . ir tLii ,333 F. a 5 Antt us t g. 3d t 25. On t sr or STaSI ha e t i he t t hi ec d, S s s abls d ha : ( )c i nta busne si or tonownedbySTa Swasrmo dfom alptpasi t 1 onfde il i s nf mai SI e ve r a o sgned o dee ntJ c onaf w da prort hi rsgnai i Oco r2011;( t si or ton fnda a ks e ys i o s e i ton n tbe 2) hi nf mai i ldedtchniali or i ont M odul V- nde Downpi ( deenda sSc t a ncu e c nf maton he ar Ba d pe; 3) f nt hurz nd J ks be n wor ng f Unir ni chi d,as t r c ac on ga ki or to c- ppe ofwa e ompa whih pr vi l hadnot ny c e ousy be ni t pe f nc aut i hadwaebusnes ;( wihi as r pe i oftme e n he ronna e omotve r r i s 4) t n ho t rod i , U nir c chi d a toni - ppe nnounc d is e r i o t pe f m anc a om otve ha d a e m a ke w ih e t nt y nt he r or e ut i rw r r t t t s e ofa M odul rV - nde D ownpi ,w hi h a a st be vi t ly i ntc li de i t he al a Ba d pe c ppe r o r ua l de i a n s gn o t Eurj tpr townedbySTa S;a ( t Unir c- ppedwe iepag a he o e oduc SI nd 5) he toni chi bst e nnouncng i t ne pr tcont nsavii ei geofaEurj tpr uc.Thi i notac ewhe et he w oduc ai sbl ma oe od t s s as r he a quiii ofco i ntalbusnes i o m ai n a isus by a c c ston nfde i i s nf r to nd t e ompe iora a ss c ai tt ppe r pe ul tve orr ot O n t srecord i appearslkel As s em e. hi t i y. uch,t har t STaSI appear bot act and he m o S s h ual i m i nt m ne . The ba ance ofe te tpsi STa S' f vorbec us t r i no e t i def nda s l quii s i n SI S a a e he e s quiy n e nt ' us ofi or a i pr i t r t STa S i vi a i oft i s at o y,c m on l w , nd e nf m ton opr e a y o SI n ol ton he r t ut r om a a conta ua oblg i . l s t i i i pe m i s bl f rde e nt t s l t as e soft r r ct l i atons n hor , t s m r s i e o f nda s o e l he s t hei com pa t STaSI go t wor atSTaSI f a s r pe i oftm e underc i nta iy ny o S, o k S or ho t r od i onf de i lt a e m e s a t n l ave STaSI t w or f a new c pe ior t ki w ih t m a usng gr e nt , nd he e So k or om tt , a ng t he nd i STa S' c i nta bus ne s i or aton t de l a pr SI S onf de i l i s nf m i o ve op oduc t ta t ha ppea s t be vi t l r o rualy i ntc t t ts d by STaSI The publc i e es i s r d by pr bii t de i al o ha ol S. i nt r t s e ve ohi tng he m i a opr a i ofa he ' c i nta busnes i or a i a a TR O i nec s a y t s ppr i ton not r s ontde i l i s nf m ton, nd s esr o pr s ve t s a usquo and pr entany f dhe us of STaSI ' c i nta bus ne s e er he t t ev u r e S s onf de i l i s i or to pendi t s he i ofa e die Pr i naylj tonhe rng. nf main ng he c dulng n xpe td elmi r n unci ai A ss at d att TR O hea i i i notl ton t cour t tU nir c- pped wasnot te he r ng, t s os he t ha t oni chi pr e a t hea i l ed,by t sTRO , he c t es nt t he rng. nde hi t our doesnotpr cl Unir c chi e ude toni - pped or , f t tm at ,def nt ,fom e gi i a lgii ae a l wf busnes . The TRO i or ha ter enda s r nga ng n ny e tm t nd a ul i s s narowl tiordonl t e j ndeenda s a a onei aci c r a pali pai wih r y al e y o noi f nt, nd ny n tve once t nd -ci ton t t t m ,f o us ng a confde i lbusne si o m a i m i a opra e f om STaSI he r m i ny i nta i s nf r ton s ppr i t d r S. V. Fo t r s s a ed i o n c ta s m m a i e her i de e nt a e ENJO I r he ea ons t t n pe our nd u r z d e n, f nda s r NED fom t us ofany c i nta i or aton m i a opra e f om STaSI untla e die r he e onf de i l nf m i s ppr i t d r S i n xpe t d Prlmi r Ij tonhe rngca behel TheTRO as pr bisdeenda s ora ei nay nunci a i n d. lo ohi t f nt, nyonei n a tve co e to pa tc pa i w ih t m ,f om a r i i m a ke i s lng,orof e i f ci nc r r r i i ton t he r dve ts ng, r tng, eli f rng or 8 s e a pr al ny oduc des g d,engi r d, m a a t e by m e ns ofi o m a i t ke by t i ne nee e or nuf c ur d a nf r ton a n def endant f om STaSIS. sr Purua t Fe r lRul o Ci lPr dur 65() adititco tmus fxabo s nt o de a e f vi oce e c, src ur t i nd w he veri g a s a t m por r r t a ni or r The dit i tc thasdi er ton i f xi t ne t r nt e a y es r i ng de . s rc our s e i n i ng he a mountf t s c iy bond,a isa or he e urt nd t mountor na iy de ndson t gr t oft pot nta di rl pe he aviy he e i l ham t t e j nedpa t Na YaPl tc ,1 F.da 421n. Bas ont e si rc d, r o he n oi ry. n asis 74 3 t 3. ed he xitng e or i a pe r t tSTaSI i lke y t pr va lo is c ai t tdef nda sm i a opra e t p a s ha S s i l o e i n t l m ha e nt s ppr i t d c i ntalbus nes i or a i Furhe , he TRO i na r i s t ntve s ope a i onl ontde i i s nf m ton. t r t s r ow n ubs a i c st y pr bisus ofconfde i lbusne si or ton tken fom STaSI Alo, heTRO i s rohi t e i nta i s nf ma i a r S. s t s ho t l d a t ePrlmiay Ij n to h ai wil eh adt we ksfo n w.Ass c ,h i , s h ei n r n u cin e rng l b e r wo e r m o ve u h te c ti t tabond of$50, 00 i a opra el rt s cii cr um sa esoft sca e our tnds ha 000. s ppr it mde he pe tc ic t nc hi s . A n a opra e Or w ilbe e e e ppr i t der l nt r d. Ent ed: Januar er y 5f Z .# . VN ,2012 #- r ' - *- M iha lF. ba ki c e Ur ns U nie St t s Di t i tJ t d a e sr c udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
