Switzer v. Town of Stanley et al, No. 5:2011cv00021 - Document 125 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 11/19/2012. (jat)
Download PDF
e pv s o- l u. Dl cour cE s, sm AT * I TH E UN I N TED STA TES DI STR I C O U RT CT FO R TH E W EST ERN DI STRI T O F V I G I A C R NI H A RR ISO N BUR G D I ISIO N V 1 soNBuRa VA Fl Gn l 80V 18 2 1 22 JUL C. 't CL . F EM 2 TH O M A S SW ITZER , Pl ntf , ai if C i lA c i N o. 5: v021 vi t on : 11c V. TO W N O F STA N LEY ,e .al, t . By:H on.M i chaelF.U rbanski U nied St esD i t i tJudge t at src D e e nt f nda . M EM O R AND U M O PI O N NI Be or t c ti Pl i i fThom asSw ize ' M oton f Tr ns rpts e ng pa e of f e he our s a ntf t rs i or a c i e ki ym nt ta c i sa t g r ntsexpe e. ( kt N o 1 ) I t moton,pl ntf not t thei r nsrpt t he ovenme ' ns 1 D . 24. n he i ai if es ha s . pr ee ngm f mana rs s ntt Fe R. oc di i or upe i.Purua o d. App.P.2 a( ,pli ifnee nots kpror 4()3) antf d ee i a ovalt pr e L f mapa rsi hewaspe mitdt pr e L f mapa rsi t ppr o oce d q or upei f r te o oc ed q or upei n he dit i tc tac i unl st di t i tc tc rii s t tt a ali no t ke i good f t s rc our ton es he sr c our e tte ha he ppe s t a n n aih. S eF d R. v. 2 ()3 ( . e e . Ci P. 4 a ()A) (l t a enc ofs m e e den i pr rmotve t a iantsgood f ih i e t bls d tn he bs e o vi t m ope i , he pplc ' at s sa ihe by t pr s nt ton ofa i s t ti notpl i y fi ous ' Eli v.Unied St t s 356 U . he e e a i ny s ue ha s a nl r vol .' ls t ae, S. 67 67 (1 ) Frvol a l lc fa agua eba i et ri lw ori fct' SeeNeiz 4, 4 958 . i ous ppeas a k <n r bl ss ihe n a na . ' tke v.W iln ,490U. 319,3 ( 989) l ohe wor , a li no fi ousi i i v lims S. 25 1 . n t r ds an ppea s t rvol f t nvoles lgalis a gua eont i meis l ;s eas Ada v.Rie,40F. 72,74( h Ci. e sues r bl her rt. d. e lo ms c 3d 4t r 1 4) 99 . lPtr ua t 28 U .SC. l 5 c( )u o afn igta plitf i p o e dn . fr pa p rs tec ut y ls nt o . j 9l ()2, p n idn h t an i s r c e igt o ma u ei,h o rma f q die pa e byt Unied stt oft e r ct ym nt he t aes he xpens soft rntng t r co d onappe ...,i s prntng i r quied e ' i i he e r p al f uch i i s e r byt a l ec t' he ppelat our. ' Pli tf sprm a y cai i t thi Fourh Am e a n if i r l m s ha s t ndme rghtwasvi a e whe nt i ol t d n de e n e e ed hi hom e w iho a w a r nt On A ugus 1 201 t cour hel t t f nda t nt r s t ut ra . t 0, 2, he t d ha pl ntf ' Fourh A m e entr ght w e e notvi a e prm a iy be us pl i ifha be n ai i f s t ndm i s r ol t d i rl ca e a ntf d e l ly e l d fom t f l r i nc pu s tt asat cour pr t c i or r Ther f e egal xc ude r he amiy esde e r uan o t e- t o e tve de . e or , a t tme oft ares,pli tf wasil ly a wr ngf l i t r sde e i vi ai n ofs i t he i he r t a n if lega l nd o uly n he e i nc n ol to ad or ra ha noras bl e cai ofprva yi t f l r i nc ( . 1 ) de nd d e ona e xpe tton i c n he amiy esde e. Dkt No. 00. Addii ly, hecour not d t te n i pli ifc d e t bls acogni bl e caton of tonal t t e ha ve f antf oul sa ih za e xpe t i prvac i t prmie ,hi Fourh Ame ntrght weenotvi aedbe us ( )gi nt i y n he e s s s t ndme i s r olt ca e 1 ve he domesi a e st ton i t home,e de e by t pr t c i or ra ns pl ntf, tc bus iua i n he vi nc d he o e tve de gai t ai if de e f ndan ' w a r ntes e l i o t f m iy r s de i s t s r a l s nt' nt he n l e i nce s uppo t d by t Fourh Am e e ' y re he t ndm nt s e e i f e ge crumsa sa ( pl ntf swie, ngt aut iyt c e t xc pton or xi nt ic tnce nd 2) ai if f havi he hort o onsnt o e r i o t f m iy hom e, e l gave he vald co e t def nda . nty nt he a l cl ary r i ns nt o e nt Plitf a e l t i c u tso d rd n n s v r l o tj d me tmo in fldb anif pp as h s o r' r e e yig e ea p s-u g n to s ie y pl ntf t tt c tconsr e a moto f rconsdeai purua t Fe R.Ci P 59() ai if ha he our tu d s ins or e i rton s nt o d. v. e a d 6 () ( tNo. 1 . I te epo t u g n mo in , anifs ug tt o frn w n 0b . Dk . 1 9) n h s s- d me t to s plitf o h o fe e j e de e f o hi w ie a s e on t ta l ge y c r c e e de t tt M a sr t vi nc r m s f nd t ps ha le dl ontadi t d vi nce ha he gi ta e J udge r le upon w hen m aki hi r po ta r om m e ton. Pa tc a l pl i ifar ue e id ng s e r nd ec nda i r i ul r y, a ntf g d t thi s e on' s a e ent co a ne i t M a c 15, 2 a fda tw e e m ade unde dur s , ha s t ps s t t m s nt i d n he r h 201 f i vi r r es be us de e e c ca e f ns ouns lpr s ur d hi s e on t s g t afi vi .The or r de ng t pos e e s e s t ps o i n he f da t de nyi he t j udgme motonsnotd,howe r t tpl nifpr nt i e ve ,ha aitf oduce onl oneafda tfom hi se o d y fi vi r s tps n whi h di no hi m or t n co i t e s e e ofa s a e c tpr e tve or r The new c d t ng e ha nfnn he xit nc t t - our ot c i de . af i tf om t s epson doesnots fdavi r he t ugges t hi proraf i tw as coer and ot w i e t hat s i f davi ced her s f is t unde m i t l galc us on t tpl i ifha no r as na e e c a i ofprva i al o r ne he e oncl i ha a ntf d e o bl xpe t ton i cy n hi f m iy r i nc Ther i sm pl no is of1 w lf f r ol i on a a a t r o e s n l esde e. esi y s ue a e t or es uton ppe l nd he ef r , pl ntf sa a i f i ous A c or ngl t cour fndst tt a a s ul notbe c r ii d ai i f ppe l s rvol . c di y, he t i ha he ppe l ho d e tfe ast ken i good f t a pl i ifs M oton f Tr ns i b de e a n aih, nd a ntf i or a crpt e ni d. The Cl r i die ed t s nd co e oft sM e o andum Opi on a t ac om pa ng e k s r ct o e pi s hi m r ni nd he c nyi O r rt pl i if de o a ntf . Ent r d: N ove be 1 201 ee m r 9, 2 / - -im 4/.?,4 -4 J ' n 2 - . M i ha lF. r ns c e U ba ki Unie St t Di t i tJ t d a es s rc udge