Marcavage et al v. City of Winchester, Virginia et al, No. 5:2010cv00114 - Document 52 (W.D. Va. 2011)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 7/12/2011. (jat)

Download PDF
eL ERK. OFFI u. . :T K Uq' DE : Q4 . r 'VA , AT RQANQKS, - I TH E UN I N TED STATES D I STR I T C O U RT C FO R TH E W E STERN D I STRI OF VI G I A CT R NI H A RR I N BUR G DI I O N SO V SI J f/221 U 1E / IS 1 ; L 2 J ULI C. DUD s; D p v Eu , CLERK iz + R y+ x M I AEL M A R CA V A G E,e a . CH t l, C i lA c i n N o.5: 0- vvi t o 1 c 0011 4 Pl ntf ai ifs, M EM O M N D U M O PI I N N O C I O F W I H E STER ,VI G I , TY NC R NA etal, . D efendant s. By:Sam ue G .W is l l on U nied St es Di tri Judge t at s ct Thi i a a tonpurua t 42U. C.j1 a saelw bypl ntfs Re s s n ci s nt o S. 983 nd tt a ai if, pent Am e i a,a s f s yl e rc el- t ed vange i tc a Chr s i n lbe tesor ni a i bas i Phiade phi ls i nd i ta i ri ga z ton ed n l l a, Pe yl ni a isdiecor M i ha lM a ca ge agans t Ciy ofW i hese , igi aa nns va a nd t r t , c e r va , i t he t nc t r V r ni nd t ofispolc of i e s K e n Sa e wo t i e f c r , vi nz nbac ra J. . a el on,a i i o oft alege he nd M D ni s rs ng ut he l d enf r e e ofW i o c m nt nchese ' noi e or na a W i hese ' 201 Appl B l s Fesi l t rs s di nce t nc t r s 0 e os om tva . Pl i if al get tW i he tr snoie o di nc i f cily i ld t rt Fis a antfs le ha nc se ' s r na e s a a l nva i mde he r t nd Fouree t Ame t nh ndme soft UniedSttsConsiuto Aril 1 j1 oft Vigni nt he t ae tt in, tce , 2 he r i a Co tt i a Vigi asRei ousFr dom Re t ai Ac, r ni Codej5 2. a nsiuton nd r ni' lgi ee sorton tVigi a 7- 02, nd t tt ofie si pe mi sbl a i t o di nc t M a c va .1 Pli if ha m o d f r ha he fc r m r s i y ppled he r na e o r a ge antfs ve ve o j me ont pl di unde Rul 1 c ont i f ca c le et t or na ;t udg nt he ea ngs r e 2() her a il halng o he di nce he i vi lde e nt ha m o d t dim isba e on quaii d i muniy;a W i hese has ndi dua f nda s ve ve o s s s d lfe m t nd nc tr m oved t dim i spl i if 'f ci lc le s t t o di nc b a e t c le s l c m e i o s s a ntf s a a ha l nge o he r na e ec us he ha l nge a k rt a be us pl i if l k sandi The cour fndst tSa enba hera D a el on a e nd ca e a ntf s ac t ng. t i ha nz c nd ni s r e il t qua ii d i m uniy f t i a tons a t r or di m i s spl i i f ' a c a m s ntted o lfe m t or he r c i nd he ef e s s e a ntf s dam ge l i a i tt m . H oweve , he c tfndsdiput d f c s m a e i t t que ton ofwhet rt ga ns he r t our i s e a t t ral o he s i he he 1 ec ut a fd rl u sinj rsito o e teplitfs fd rlcamsu d r28U. C. 1 31 a dt Th o r h s e ea q eto u idcin v rh anif' e ea li n e S. j 3 5 n he plitfsasr sp e na jrs it no e teplitfs Vignalw camsu d r28U. C. 1 6 () anif set u plme tlu idci v r h anif' rii a li n e o S. j 3 7a. pl i if ha sa ngt mot af cilc le t t W i he t ror na e a wilhol a antfs ve t ndi o mt a a ha lnge o he nc se di nc nd l d n e de i r he rng t de e m i t e f t . vi nta y a i o t r ne hos ac s 1. M a c vag a ot rmembe sofRe ntAme i ade de t a tnd W i hese ' Appl r a e nd he r pe rc ci d o te nc t rs e Bl s Fesi lo M a 1 201 i or rt e pr st rr i i bei f t f si l r fo os om tva n y , 0, n de o x es hei elg ous le s o e tvagoe s r m c r nc se ' publcsr e sa sde l usng a a plfe . M a c va c le Sa enba he , W i he t rs i te t nd i waks i n m ii r2 r a ge al d nz Chi ofPolc be o emaki t ti i or rt e ur hi plr d us oft a plfe woul ef i e, f r ng he rp n de o ns e s ame e he m ii r d notvi aeary ofW i se ' or nanc s Sa e c ri or d M ar vag t thi plnne olt l nche tr s di e . nz nba he nf me ca e ha s a d a tvii s a he ha des i t m , oul notvi a e a or na es c i te , s d crbed he w d ol t ny di nc . M a c va and ot rm e be sofRe tAm e i a t nde t Appl Bl s Fe tva r a ge he m r pen rca te d he e os om s i l a us d a a pltera t y ha pl nned. D a e s a oa he M a c va c a m i he ha nd e n m ii s he d n ni l on ppr c d r a ge l i ng d r eve ac ec i d ompl i a ant boutM ar a c vage sa tvii sa as d hi t ce s usngt a ii r ' ci te nd ke m o a e i he mplfe . M a c va pr r a ge oduce a copy ofW i he t r s noi e or na e,a a g t thi a tvii sw e e d nc s e ' s di nc nd r ued ha s c i te r ic n ompla . Da e s n r viwedt or na a i or M a c vaget tt f lowi ince nil o e e he di nce nd nf med r a ha he o l ng t e W i hese Ciy Code pr s onspr c i d M a c va sac i te ' hr e nc t r t ovi i os rbe r a ge' tvii s . ()I s lbeunlwf lf a pes t ma ,c i ,orca et bemad or a t hal a u or ny ron o ke ontnue us o e co i d a e es i ,unne es a y,orunus ly l noi e,o a noi e w hi h ntnue ny xc s ve c sr ua l oud s r ny s c u ra o a l a n y , itr s ij r s o e d n e st c mf r, at s ft wefr, n e s n b y n o s d su b ,nu e , r n a g r he o o the l aey, lae h, ore r e ofot r w ihi t c por t lm is oft Ciy. nvionm nt he s t n he or a e i t he t ( Acsde lrdunlwf byt ssci s li ude, no bee l i ylmie t b) t cae a ul hi e ton hal ncl but t xcusvel i td o, t f l i he olow ng: ( Toply,o rt,orpe tt o rto orplyngofa r o,t e son, 2) a peae nui he peain ai ny adi elvii p honog a t pe pl ye ,dr , us ca i t m e ,s r ph, a a r um m i l nsnz nt ound a plfe or sm ia de c m ii r i l r vi e w hi pr uc ,r pr ch od es e oduc s o a plfe s e , r m i i s ound i s h a m a m e a t c ea e a no s n uc r r so r t ie dit bance w ihi any near dw eli t i oracr a r pr s ur t n by lng m t oss eal opert boundar y y. 2Be a s teplitfs mo i nu de Rul 1 ( ) e u r stec u t oc n ie t ef c sp e d d i t ed fn a t ' c u e h an if ' to n r e 2 c r q ie h o r t o sd r h a t la e n h e e d n s a w e a welast et t pli if havepr de i t compli ,A. Abel Co. Bal. ns r s l hos hat he antfs ovi d n he ant S. l v. t Tvpogr ohi l a ca UninNo 1 3 8F.d 1 0 1 3( t Ci.l 6 ) tec ut eie tefcsalg di b t p ris pla ig . o . 2, 3 2 9 , 9 4h r 9 4,h o rrcts h a t l e n oh ate ' e dn s e W he et pa tes algai ae i onsitnt t c tnotst rdia e m e . r he ri ' le tons r nc se ,he our e hei s gr e nt ( )Th ma i b a yp ro o u ra o a l l u o u e e s r n iei cu i g b t 3 e kng y n e s n f n e s n by o d r mzc s ay os n ld n , u notlm iedt t tm a by t htm a voie i publcplc s ast n i t o, ha de he l n c n i a es o o nnoy orditzb slr unr s bl t c f t he t w e f r e r e , a ors f t ofpe s nsi a ea ona y he om or , alh, la e, nvionm nt pe ce a e y r o n ny of i ,dw e lng,hot orot t r i nce orofa pe s i t vi niy. fce li el her ype esde , ny r on n he ci t W i hese CiyCodeCh.1 jj1 6() ( ( -3 . nc tr t 7, 7- a, b)2)() The pa tesof e c lc i a ount ofw ha happe d ne . or ng t M a c vag s ri f r onf i tng cc s t ne xt Acc di o r a e' a fda t Da e s or r d M a c vaget c s a dess usng t n ii . Da e s fi vi, ni lon de e ra o ea e nd it i he mplter nilon cl i st the onl t d M a c vage t r duc t vol e oft nm plte . Af e t c nve s ton a m ha y ol ra o e e he um he ii r t r he o r a i wih Da elon, ar a t ni s M c vagecal d Sanz nbac rt c le e he o ompli a utDa e s si e pr t ton of an bo nil on' ntr e ai t or na e.M a ca ger cal t tSa e c ra fr e Da elon' o de t t he di nc r va e ls ha nz nba he fim d ni s s r r ha M a c vag sus oft a plfe vi a e t or nanc Sa e c rsat t thet d r a e' e he m ii r olt d he di e. nz nba he t es ha ol M a c va hec d c i t us t a ii , t ti a he ctze c r a ge oul ontnue o e he mplfer but ha f not r ii n ompl i abou aned t t vol e,a of i rw oul i pe nty a s s t r s na e soft vol e a i s a he um n fce d nde nde l s e s he ea o bl nes he um nd s ue ct ton i a pr it . Bot sde a e t tt pli if con i iai f p opra e h i s gr e ha he antfs tnued t us t a ii rf r o e he mplte o s ve a hour a t t e c e rl s fer hes onve s tonst plc a t tt pl i if di notr eve a r a i ook a e, nd ha he antfs d ec i ny ct i f vi a i t or na e.Thepl n if a lget tt pln t at nd t Appl iatons or oltng he di nc aitfs le ha hey a o te he e Bl s Fe tvali f t e yea s a onc aga n us a a plte t e es t i vi w s The a e os om s i n u ur r nd e i e n m ii r o xpr s he r e . y r se n aj d me t e lrn teo dn n et b iv ld a ij n to e j ii is e kig u g n d ca ig h r ia c o e n ai, n n u cin n onng t enf r m e ,a da a . o ce nt nd m ges ll . Sanz nbac ra Danilon hav move t dimi st damag c am sagans t m o e he nd es e d o s s he e li i t he n t g ound t tt ha quaii d i muniy f t i a tonsi e or ng t or na e The he r ha hey ve lfe m t or her c i n nf ci he di nc . courtagr and gr st rm ot on t di i s. eess ant hei i o sm s Clhe doc r ne of q lf e i m uniy pr e t go r m e of i al lr la lt f c vi iti ua ii d m t ot c s ve n nt fci s f om i biiy or i l dn a i of rast i conduc do notvi a e c ea l es a i he sa ut y orco tt i l m ges ns a he r t es ol t l ry t bls d t t or ns iutona rg sofwhih ar as bl pe s wo d ha known.' Pea s n v.Ca lha 1 S. .8 i ht c e ona e r on ul ve '' r o la n, 29 Ct 08, 81 - 6( 5 1 2009)( i Harow v.Fizg r l 457U. 800,81 ( 982) Polc ofiesae quotng l t e ad, S. 8 1 ). ie fc r r e ild t as umea va i y e c e lw i c tt tonalû i a unl s t a edeca ed ntte o s ldl na t d a s onsiu i d l nd e s hey r unt lr unc tt t o ,' e st tl w i i o g os l a fag a l unco tt i ons iu i nal' unl s ha a s t r sy nd l r nty s ns iutonalt a pe s n of hat ny r o r s bl pr ncewo d bebo t s e isfa . M i hi n v. ea ona e ude ul und o e t lws' c ca DeFilppo,443 U. 31 38 ' li S. , ( 979) s eas Swa onv. 1 ; e lo ns Powes 93 F. 965,9 ( hCi.1 )(û en e r or nay r, 7 2d 69 4t r 991 t Abs t xta di r c r um s a s w hi a e notpr e he e la lt w ilnota t c f e c i t s a ut y i c t nce , ch r es nt r , i biiy l ta h or xe utng he t t or dute one wa a is s ppoi e t pe f m .A . nt d o r or , 3 ) He e, heW i hese or na ehadnotbe n de l r d unc tt i lby a c t r t nc t r di nc e cae onsiutona ny our be or t 201 A ppl Bl s Fe tva . The pl i if not t tt V igi a Supr m e Cou t f e he 0 e os om s i l a ntf s e ha he r ni e r ha r ce l deca e asm ia or na e a edby t Ciy ofVigi aBea h unco tt i na, d e nty lr d i l r di nc dopt he t r ni c nsiuto l s eTa n rv. t o Va Be c 27 Va 4 2( 0 9 , n a g eta a r a o a l poie e n e Ciy f . a h, 7 . 3 2 0 )a d r u h t ny e s n be l c ofi e woul ha known t r f r t tt W i hese or na ewasunco tt i la we l tc r d ve he e o e ha he nc tr di nc nsiutona s l. H o e r t i a g e i est prnc pl t t( n a c t c w ve , he r r um nt gnor he i i e ha t whe iy ounc lhasdul ena t d a i y ce n or na e, i ofi r on t sr ta e o di rl e il d t r y on t a s pton t tt di nc polce tce s he tee r r na iy ntte o el he s um i ha he counc lm e be sha c i r d t vi w sofl ga cou e a c ude t tt or na e i i m r ve ons de e he e e l ns l nd oncl d ha he di nc s avai a c tt i le r ie o a hort ' Gr s n v.Ciy ofPorl nd,33 F. 1 ld nd onsiutona xe c s f ut iy. os ma ' t ta 3d 200, 1 9( t Ci.1 9 ) c . es n v Ra , 8 U. 5 7, 5 ( 9 7 (û p lc ma slt sn t o 20 9h r 9 4 , f Piro . v 3 6 S. 4 5 5 1 6 ) ç oie n' o i o s . A unhap t them us c py ha t hoos be w e n bei c r d w ih de elcton ofdu y i he doe nota r s e t e ng ha ge t r i i t f s ret whe heha pr bl c e a bengmultdi da ge i hedoes' .Poi ofiesaenot n s oba e aus , nd i ce n ma s f .) lce fc r r ' r ui e t a yz c s 1 w t di c r s l dif r e o s m iarte t tm a r nde eq r d o nal e a e a o s e n ubte f e enc s r i l ii s ha y e r 3Ote crut h v h l ta g lc of r aeette t q aiidi ni e e wh ne frigalw ta h s h r ic is a e ed h t oie fkes r ni d o u lfe mmu t v n e nocn a h t a l y b e pe iu l fu du c nsl t a, sln a ta 1w i siltnt b o s' n t ot rh sa oj ciey en rvo sy o n n o tt i la o g s h t a s tli he o k 'a d he f u on o ke a n be t l v r s bl beift tir m ai vai Am or ysNo ar, 2 F.d5 2 5 43 (dCi. 01 ) ea ona e le ha t e ns ld. e v ro 6 4 3 2 , 3 -5 2 r2 0 . - l il i n c nsiutona l i im .Thus Sa e eg sato o tt i ly nfr , nz nbac ra Da elon wer e ild t as ume he nd ni s e ntte o s t tt or na e w asvald att tm e oft e n s g vi r s t t s s t ha he di nc i he i he ve t i ng i e o hi ui. Eve i t ofi r we enote tte t r y ont pr umptvevaldiy oft o d na e, n f he fce s r n ild o el he es i i t he r i nc t pl i if ha notdemonsr t d t tt or na ei unc tt i na asa ma trofc e ry he antfs ve ta e ha he di nc s onsiuto l te lal e t bls f r l w . W hiet Ta rc ti ld t d a he ciy' or nmw e t t s a ihed ede al a l he nne our nva i a e not r t s di ha c ai d s m ia ora l ont ne i l r na ogousl ng ge ot r c t ha u l ar bl i s i uiha e a ua , he ours ve phe d gua y ndi tng s bl o di nc .Se e. ,As t v. t o Bea o t 1 F. 408( hCi.1 (i ngt tt r na es es c. puih Ciy f ufr, 39 3d 4t r 998) tndi ha he pli if c le ng anoieco r or nanc t tpr hi t d ûoud a uns e l noies' r antfs hal ngi s ntol di e ha o bie i l nd e m y s 'we e no lkel t s c dont me isoft i cai ,a va ai a ij tonor r dbyt t i y o uc ee he rt her l ms nd c tng n nunci de e he dititc tont rbe g.tofiil aeno la ef ba g s si gry ae ;he ae src our hei hal t fcas r t ibl or d uese n a ras t y r la ef ta grs i brghtlnes' M ar ailov.Sumne , F. 295,298( hCi.1 . ibl or rns e sng i i . ' cirel r 973 2d 4t r 992) H e e, he of i r t a gr s d no brghtlnesi e or ng t or nanc a a e t r f e r t fce s r ns es e i i n nf ci he di e, nd r he e or i m une. m Be us Sanz ca e enba hera D a el o d d no vi a e t pl i if 'cl a l e t bls c nd ni s n i t ol t he a ntf s e r y s a ihed rg si enf cngt or na e, he ar e ild t qua ii d i uniyf t i aci ns i ht n or i he di nc t y e ntte o lfe mm t or her to . A c or ngl , t cour di m i s t da age c ai sa i tt m . c di y he t s s es he m l m ga ns he 4 11 1. W i he t rhasm ove t dim i st pl i if 'c a m st tt or na e i nc s e d o s s he a ntf s l i ha he di nc s unc tt i onsiutonalon isf c bec us t or na i a na r l t ior ds en ne r t a e a e he di nce s r ow y a l e cont t utal r ti i on s ec whi h i no unc tt i ly vag orove br esrcton pe h c s t ons iutona l ue r oad. I r s n e pons ,t e he pl ntfsha mo df j me ont pl di , r ui t tt or na e' pr btonson ai if ve ve or udg nt he ea ngs a g ng ha he di nc s ohiii 4Thepl ntfsas m a nots k da a agans t i viualde e nt f rt rsae lw cl m s Vigi a ai if lo y ee m ges i t he ndi d f nda s o hei tt a ai . r ni Cod j5 -.2( po ii panif fo c l cigmo eayd ma e frvoain o ta scin F rh r e 720 D) r hbt litfs r m ol t s e n n tr a g s o ilto s f h t eto . u te, i vi lpolc ofie se gi i dice i r f nci ha s r gn i uniyf t raci i t ndi dua ie fc r nga ng n s rtona y u tons ve oveei mm t or hei tons n he a sn eof r s ne lg n e Cob v Bo d n 2 1Va 1 5 l 9( 9 ) a dtepanif h v n t h re b e c g os gie c , ly . v e , 4 . 2 , 2 1 91, n h litfs a e o c ag d Da elonandSa enba rw ih g os neglge no ha t y pla f css t i tt plusbl s ni s nz che t r s i nce r ve he e ded a t ufk en o a i y uppor s a t uch cam . li d i ce s r ' s ,ornoiewhi h E e ona y n ys'r nde i c tt i ly i im. unne s a y'noie s c % as bl nno r' e r t onsiutonal nfr umThe c ur tndsma e i lis off c a t whe he ,a at es d m a tr t pl ntfs ha o ti t ra s ues a t s o t r s hr hol te ,he ai if ' ve sa ng t c le t or na e,a t r or wilhol t s motonst ra s me a tndi o hal nge he di nc nd he ef e l d he e i mde dvie nt nd c onduc anevi nta yhe rng o t san ng is t de ir a i n he t di s ue. S tcello t eCo ttto c n ie tefd rl o rst a j dc tnga ta da e ' t il l f h nsi in o fn s h e ea c u t o d u iai cu l c s s Ar u andtontove ses''Ale v.W rc , U. 73 750( 984) l o de t etbls t ts h c r ri .' ln iht468 S. 7, 1 . n r r o sa ih ha uc ac s orc rves e ss t pl ntfsmus de nsrt t tt ha sandi t s L.a a e onto ry xit,he ai if t mo tae ha hey ve t ng o ue. ps t . 7 0 5 .Tod s ,h plitfsmu ts o ( ) h th ys fee f u frd a ij l i fc-n 5-1 o o te an if s h w: 1 t a te u frd s fee n n uy n a ta s ivai ofalgalypr e tdi ees whi i ()c rt a pa tc aie a ( acua o n son e l otce ntr t ch s a oncee nd riulrz d, nd b) t l r i n n , o c n e t a o h poh tc l'2 $ c u a c n e to b t e teij r a dte mmie t n t o j curl r y t eiai ( ) t a s l o n cin ewe n h nu y n h ' a co uc c ane of'and( t ti i Slkel a o e t meeys ultve,ha t nd t ompli d ; 3) ha t s si y, s ppos d o rl pec ai t t he ij r wil erd e s db afv rbl d cso . Lu a v. fnd r o W id ie 5 4U. 5 5 n u y l b e r se y a o a e e iin' in Dee es f llf, 0 S. 5 , ' 560- ( 992)(nt na ciainsandquoai maksomit .t-heei ... demi mi lve 61 1 i er l tto tton r ted) t- r s a l ni s e l ofi poston w ih w hi h t Cons iuton i no c e m ii t c he tt i s t onc nwd. l r ha v.W r g ,430 U . 651 ' na a m ' i ht S. , 674( 977 ;s ealoNew Cr ai Felows pofBufal v.Town ofChe kt ga 1 Fed. 1 ) e s e ton l hi fo e owa , 64 App' 5,7( Ci.2005)( di tatt dee ntspesse atmpt t e or atee x 2d r hol ng h he fnda ' ritnt te s o nf ce r pr s r ton or na ag ns t pl i tf ' p ope t c tt t d ( i i onve e es .. e e va i di nce ai t he a n if s r ry ons iu e d nor nc m ni nc . is fiin t stsyt eij r n fc r q ie n frAril llsa dng'; Cii n u fce t o aif h nu pi-a t e urme t o t e 1 tn i ' Am. v l c l Li ri Uni ofM d.l v. iomioCny.999F. 780,786n. ( h Ci.1 ( ion be tes on . nc. W c c t , 2d 6 4t r 993) prs ofk i l 'de i i n t w ihdr pr vi l gr nt prvie t a A CLU l w ye di no t a s c s o o t aw e ous y a ed i l ges o n a r d t c tt eac nia eij yunde t Fis Amend nt. onsiut og z bl n ur r he rt me ) A s s tf r h a e o t bove, he pa tesha pr vi d c lc i ver i ofw ha oc ur e a t t ri ve o de onfi tng s ons t c r d t he f tval Gi t es i . ven hese conti i account t courtfndst an evi i y heari i l ctng s, he i hat dentar ng s ne e s y t a s s t c edi lt oft w ines e a eva ua e whe hert pl i t fs s f r a c s ar o s e s he r biiy he t s s nd l t t he a n if uf e ed n ij r i fc s fce tt stsyter q ie nso Aril IIofheCo siui n F rte e nu y n a t ufiin o aif h e urme t f t e I t c n t to . o h s t ra o s tec u t l h l t emo int d s s a dtemo inf r u me to t epe dn s e s n ,h o r wil od h to o imis n h to o j dg n n h la ig u radv s m e un i a t rt c thashe d a e de i r he i t de i t i s of nde i e nt tl f e he our l n vi nta y arng o c de he s ue sa ng.5 tndi lV . Fort r as s a e t Cour di m i s spl i if 'da a c ai saga ns D a elon he e ons t t d, he t s s e a ntf s m ge l m i t ni s a Sa en c rba ed on t i qua ii d i nd nz ba he s her lfe mmuniy.Thec t dsW i he t rsm oto t t our hol nc se ' in o ds s t ep an if' e iigcamsa dt epanif ' to fr u g n o tepe d n s imis h litfs r mann li n h litfs moi n o j d me t n h la i g unde a s m e tt tlt c thol a e de ta y he i on t i s ofs a ng. r dvi e n m i he our ds n vi n i r arng he s ue t ndi 7 ENTER : ul 1 2011. J y 2, . X .z , v UW TED STATES DI CT J STRI UDGE 5As a a s ito , pe A m ei hassandi t brngacl m on be l ofism e be s e n whe t rca t ng o i ai haf t m r , ve n s oc ain Re nt n he as cainislh ss fee n ijr , oln a o eo i me esh ss fee s c a ijr .S eW a' v. so ito tef a ufrd o nu y s o g s n ft mb r a ufrd u h n nuy e lh s t S li 42 U. 4 0 51 (9 5 .Th s ted fn a t' to t ds s Re e tAmeiafrIc o sa dn wil edn, 2 S. 9 , 1 1 7 ) u ,h ee d ns moin o imis p n rc o a k f tn ig l nec s iy de nd ont s efcua deveopm e tr quie t a s s whet rM a c va hassa ngt s esarl pe he am a t l l n e rd o ses he r a ge tndi o ue. 7

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.